I could contact Dr. Charles .... who does work for PBS, and he could tell you some of the horror stories he has heard.
Secondly there are financial considerations, company against company. Thirdly, if you read back, I already mentioned
at least three reviewers who had their hand in the till.
The first, test pre, was hammered, inside and out, so shipping was not involved unless the shippers removed the cover to complete the job.
2nd, gent invited me to Mil to audition before an audio club. I did not wish reviewers and expressed so in my post. Night before I was to attend, the gent emails and tells me he is a reviewer. So what do I do?
I go, and the room is bare except for a small throw down rug and couch. Hardwood floor, walls, ceiling. Room is approx 18 x 30, from memory. Echoooooey is not the word.
Besides that the gain of the system is approx 45db before I added the tube pre. Pre is 20db. Noise was so loud that one could hear it easily at the other end of the room. Before I arrive home, a review is already posted on Audiogon by the reviewer. Never sold another pre in Wisconsin again.
That is what I get for trusting the reviewer.
3rd time different mag reviewer. Invited to St. Louis to audition at a reviewers house. He had a customer's 11A preamplifier for 3-4 days and emailed he wished to
do a review. I arrived, and around supper time, the reviewer asks me why I don't use clarity caps. I said because the
11A (10A was not there) is just how I want it to sound.
He did not leave it alone but kept pushing and pushing. Those caps aren't any good. I told him it depends upon how they are used. He pushed some more.
I told him that the 11A is so close to perfectly accurate (meaning output is exactly the same as input in every sonic parameter) that people cannot tell the difference when installed in their systems and when it is not (gain set, rigid setup conditions etc involved). Why would I wish to change someting that took decades to perfect.
He says that is impossible cause I use some Solen caps. Needless to say I never sold another pre in St. Louis. By the way, this reviewer is a weatherman, never had an electronics class in his life.
In 2009, I exhibited at the AKFest. I had standing room only almost all Saturday. A reviewer (St. Louis) from Positive Feedback stayed an
hour in my room (out of 9 hours he attended), and wished to do a review. Very impressed. Never heard from him again. Not one other magazine
announced themselves, took any pictures, nor posted even a sentence concerning my room. Yet, another
exhibitor visited us multiple times, and told us at least 4 times we had the best system there.
I think you can understand why I stay away from mags? Since I finally let the cat out of the bag, I bet the rags are really hacked at me.
Cheers.