• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Is there no end!!!

But wait, there's more!!!......Isn't Episode 1 the first of the 3 prequels that Lucas threatened to redo in 3D? I saw a promotional poster at the local cineplex pretty much stating this a couple of weeks ago while buying tickets for Twilight-Breaking Wind-Part 1.

I can't wait for "Twilight-Oops, I Sharted #2"
 
Is it not a good thing that people who never saw the movie on the big screen will now be able to?

Gone With the Wind had several re-releases, you think Selznick was shameless (because of that I mean)?
I took my children to see the re-release of the original Trilogy. It was a magic moment for them to see these movies on the big screen.

"Gone with the Wind"? Are you kidding? How many times was it edited, modified, scene(s) altered to serve some other purpose. You're comparing apples rotten fruit.

If it weren't for the fact that other big Directors/Producers had a hand in Lucas's other works they'd be molested to no end as well. Thank goodness for their sanity and more importantly belief in what they did the first time was the right thing the first time. They offer no modified versions, they offer no altered stories or scenes, they don't insert footage that was never part of the original filming.

I'm perfectly happy with the originals. I'm perfectly comfortable with it's now dated special effects. I'm perfectly happy with ONLY Han shooting because after all "he is a scoundrel". Han was no saint and that was played on throughout the movie. Why try to change his image?
 
So, are we talking about something that was filmed 4:3 and then matted to get the proper aspect ratio, or a 4:3 pan and scan version?

The first Laser discs of Star Wars were pan and scan 4:3.

But, unmolested as far as childhood raping edits go.
 
The first Laser discs of Star Wars were pan and scan 4:3.

But, unmolested as far as childhood raping edits go.

That was my point. Pan and Scan is about the worst edit that can be done to a film, IMO. And I don't see the connection between butchering some movie edit, and "childhood raping", to be honest. I'm sure every Star Wars fan hates the Han/Greedo edit, but come on.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Lucas release the original versions on DVD about 5 years ago?
 
The only reason he does this crap is because buttnuts are willing to shell out their money for this poop.

And suddenly the pseudonym "Dukiedook" comes into focus.


Come on people, it's a fictional movie. It's a product. That's it. It's not some kind of historical record that has to be accurate. It's make believe.

I design speakers. If I design a set and then later make a revision that I think makes them better, I'm going to re-release them. They're a product. That's it.

If Lucas thinks that his CGI versions are better, who are we to argue? You may not like them as much as the original release. That's really too bad. Learn to deal with disappointment. I don't see why a theatrical re-release of something you don't like causes such a ruckus. Don't go see it. It's really that simple.
 
If Lucas thinks that his CGI versions are better, who are we to argue? You may not like them as much as the original release. That's really too bad. Learn to deal with disappointment. I don't see why a theatrical re-release of something you don't like causes such a ruckus. Don't go see it. It's really that simple.

This is a forum for discussion of movies. Some of that discussion is negative. If you dislike negative comments, no one is forcing you to read them. It's really that simple.


Vacuum tubes are where it's at!
 
Since Mr. Lucas created the series, he has the right to release, alter, re-release, or block the release of it, however he pleases.

We also have the right to buy or NOT buy what he offers, if we don't like it.

We can also go out and find the original versions, either on Laserdiscs or in the DVD release (I understand the originals WERE eventually released in that format, right?!), and project them at home via home theater gear, Mr. Lucas's preferences be damned!

Yes, it would be nice if he'd re-release the originals into theaters. I'd buy a ticket to see them again that way, even though I can watch the LDs at home any time I want. I'll bet a lot of other people would, too --probably even more (nostalgic boomers taking their kids!) than would go see a new/updated version. But it's Mr. Lucas's choice whether we have that option or not. Not our choice.

So if it bugs you that much, go find the LD or DVD release, and set up a home theater that'll allow you to experience it.

Personally, I'm happy to have BOTH versions. I like the originals for the nostalgia factor... but I don't hate the re-done ones; I can understand how and why Mr. Lucas wanted to re-visit them. As the originals clearly show, the film-making technology of that era was limited. I remember sitting in the theater back then and thinking, "WOW! How did they ever make this movie?" because we had only the older 50s-type sci-fi flicks with their hopelessly primitive effects for comparison. But today, the same once-impressive movies look relatively primitive. I don't blame Mr. Lucas for his decisions; if I had created these movies, I'd probably want to do the same thing. I prefer the originals, but ONLY because of the memories/nostalgia associated with them. They're not necessarily better, otherwise.
 
That was my point. Pan and Scan is about the worst edit that can be done to a film, IMO. And I don't see the connection between butchering some movie edit, and "childhood raping", to be honest. I'm sure every Star Wars fan hates the Han/Greedo edit, but come on.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Lucas release the original versions on DVD about 5 years ago?

No.

I got pan and scan version of Star Wars and Empire for free with a player I bought. I am just being wise about people complaining about Michael Bay, Lucas, Speilberg, et al. raping their childhoods with lame edits and such, I am not being serious. I need to be sure to use my sarcasm text for future reference. :yes:

Don't worry, I will not be seeing or buying any of these new versions. :no:

I thought complaining and whining was what Al Gore invented teh intarwebs for??
 
Given his need to reedit episode 4, what is to stop him from making changes to the prequels?

Could he make them any worse?

It'd be an even better thing if he released the original trilogy to theaters, you know...the ones people want to see, the ones that a large portion of the fanbase have never had a chance to see in theaters.

They were re-released as the Special Edition versions in 1997. Outside of the Han/Greedo thing, and the totally unnecessary re-insertion of the Jabba the Hutt scene, I like the SE versions and their improved F/X.

We can also go out and find the original versions, either on Laserdiscs or in the DVD release (I understand the originals WERE eventually released in that format, right?!), and project them at home via home theater gear, Mr. Lucas's preferences be damned!

VHS, too.
 
Since Mr. Lucas created the series, he has the right to release, alter, re-release, or block the release of it, however he pleases.

We also have the right to buy or NOT buy what he offers, if we don't like it.

We can also go out and find the original versions, either on Laserdiscs or in the DVD release (I understand the originals WERE eventually released in that format, right?!), and project them at home via home theater gear, Mr. Lucas's preferences be damned!

Yes, it would be nice if he'd re-release the originals into theaters. I'd buy a ticket to see them again that way, even though I can watch the LDs at home any time I want. I'll bet a lot of other people would, too --probably even more (nostalgic boomers taking their kids!) than would go see a new/updated version. But it's Mr. Lucas's choice whether we have that option or not. Not our choice.

So if it bugs you that much, go find the LD or DVD release, and set up a home theater that'll allow you to experience it.

Personally, I'm happy to have BOTH versions. I like the originals for the nostalgia factor... but I don't hate the re-done ones; I can understand how and why Mr. Lucas wanted to re-visit them. As the originals clearly show, the film-making technology of that era was limited. I remember sitting in the theater back then and thinking, "WOW! How did they ever make this movie?" because we had only the older 50s-type sci-fi flicks with their hopelessly primitive effects for comparison. But today, the same once-impressive movies look relatively primitive. I don't blame Mr. Lucas for his decisions; if I had created these movies, I'd probably want to do the same thing. I prefer the originals, but ONLY because of the memories/nostalgia associated with them. They're not necessarily better, otherwise.
More to the point, why can't we get cleaned up versions on BD? That really isn't asking a whole lot since they already mastered them that way. Most "fans" could care less about the edits or simply dismiss them as stupidity and would rather they weren't there. Look how many feature movies you can buy with a choice of Theatrical release or whatever version (Directors Cut, etc.) as an option.

Everybody wins with "your choice" and Lucas makes even more money. While denying us is his right, so is cutting your nose off should you choose to.

Lucas knows full well people not only want the "original" films, they're more than willing to pay. What kind of moron denies people something they are willing to pay for?

As for redone. Which one? Each has had more than one edit. Just goes on with every re-release. "Gone with the wind" was brought up earlier, how would someone like to see that with additional CGI edits? I sure as heck wouldn't. I own "Gone with the wind", like it just the way it is.
 
No.

I got pan and scan version of Star Wars and Empire for free with a player I bought. I am just being wise about people complaining about Michael Bay, Lucas, Speilberg, et al. raping their childhoods with lame edits and such, I am not being serious. I need to be sure to use my sarcasm text for future reference. :yes:

Don't worry, I will not be seeing or buying any of these new versions. :no:

I thought complaining and whining was what Al Gore invented teh intarwebs for??

No problem. Gore dropped the ball when he left out a sarcasm button on his design.:D

And Copa, just wait a while. If history has taught us anything, it is that Lucas will re-release these again on blu-ray, and then again on whatever comes after blu-ray, until he is no longer with us. I'm sure it's in his will to continue on with the practice forever, too.:D I bet the originals will be on blu-ray at some point. I think Lucas invented the term double-dipping, at least with video releases. I fell for it when I bought the 2004 DVD releases. I didn't re-buy the DVDs, but I should have waited for the next round. It won't happen with blu-ray, that's for sure.
 
He probably has it written in his will that corny, nonsensical changes be made to future version in the future formats until the end of time.

I would be willing to plunk down some bucks on the original three cleaned up, no goofy Greedo shoots first edits in Bluray if they came out. I doubt we will get that though.
I would have to buy a bluray player also to make this happen.
 
No problem. Gore dropped the ball when he left out a sarcasm button on his design.:D

And Copa, just wait a while. If history has taught us anything, it is that Lucas will re-release these again on blu-ray, and then again on whatever comes after blu-ray, until he is no longer with us. I'm sure it's in his will to continue on with the practice forever, too.:D I bet the originals will be on blu-ray at some point. I think Lucas invented the term double-dipping, at least with video releases. I fell for it when I bought the 2004 DVD releases. I didn't re-buy the DVDs, but I should have waited for the next round. It won't happen with blu-ray, that's for sure.
I hate when I get worked up on this stuff. It's from my generation, I remember standing in line for hours to see it. And while it is dated, it represents a new era in special effects, sound engineering and many other aspects.

The problem is that Lucas knows full well he can milk this because the buying public is so gullable and willing to buy anything that allows them to simply vegetate in front of their TV's that he's more than willing to oblige. But he throws a little wrinkle in the game by altering the product so that people will buy and buy until they get what they're looking for. I haven't bought the BD versions and likely won't. Recently acquired the LD "face cover" versions and received a LD player free. Watched them a while ago and found it cool to see what I saw for the first time.

Not holding my breath.

Any by the way, do any of you realize how many sleepless nights and gallons of coffee Gore consumed creating the internet. Give him a break will ya. ;-)
 
If any of you have the original releases that were THX certified on VHS, you should watch the interview Lucas gives on the tape. It is very prophetic. There is also a trailer for the movie on the tape where the announcer tells us to buy the movie now as we will never get to see it again in its original format. I didnt believe it at the time, but boy was it true. I do own the original releases on DVD as well. If any of you are waiting for the original release to come out on Blu-Ray, you are in for a loooooong wait. Actually, dont count on it because it will not happen. Ever. As stated earlier, Lucas had a 'vision' of what Star Wars should be. The technology of the time when the movies were made prevented that vision from becoming reality. Now that the technology is here, he is going to shape Star Wars into what he originally envisioned. He actually thinks the theatrical versions are garbage. Yes, these are his movies and he has the right to do with them as he pleases. We have the right to buy them or not give him our money. It is as simple as that. I personally think the retouched movies, including the 'prequels', are all garbage.
 

Now you are just being mean.:D

chris35745, I'm not holding my breath waiting for the originals on blu-ray, because I just don't care that much. But as much as Lucas dislikes the originals, he likes money, so I think he'll release them. It will just take some time. I'm just going by memory here, but I seem to recall when the first DVDs came out he said he wouldn't(or couldn't) release the originals on DVD. We all know how long that lasted.
 
Haven't you posted this link in another thread? I know I've seen it before. This is part of the issue. Those of us with any shred of common sense know full well that S.W. is dated. But so are movies like "Sinbad" with claymation, yet we enjoy them nevertheless.

I'm perfectly fine with film restoration, after all film deteriorates. I'm fine with improved audio if done with some restraint. Look at "The Wizard of OZ". Just incredible on B.D. And the audio sounds better than my Anniversary DVD issue.

The points made are good. He can do what he wants with them, we can choose to buy or not buy. But option three is giving buyers the option to choose which they want, which is a win win.

Eventually, if not already, S.W. is going to loose it's draw, so to speak, and will become nothing more than some movie from the 70's. The "cash cow" could have been milked sooner and better, but that's his choice.

As for a director looking back and saying "gee whiz we didn't have the technology back then...." yada yada yada (yoda yoda yoda?), well that's about as pathetic as one can get. Oh well.
 
Now you are just being mean.:D

chris35745, I'm not holding my breath waiting for the originals on blu-ray, because I just don't care that much. But as much as Lucas dislikes the originals, he likes money, so I think he'll release them. It will just take some time. I'm just going by memory here, but I seem to recall when the first DVDs came out he said he wouldn't(or couldn't) release the originals on DVD. We all know how long that lasted.

Actually, Lucas never intended the originals to ever grace a DVD. As far as he was concerned, VHS was the last time they would ever be released. Once he had the technology to do with them as he pleased, he didnt care what anybody wanted or thought. There was such a huge public outcry and backlash that he relented and released the originals on DVD. It was an act that was intended to get people to shut up. If you have a copy of the original release movies, look closely at them. They are exactly that, original releases. Crappy two channel stereo and VHS quality picture. It was a slap in the face to all the faithful. It was the re-releases and 'fakequels' that got the digital remastered picture and 5.1 sound. He has such a tight-fisted control over the works that he doesnt care what anybody thinks or says now about the originals. It is a matter of ego and will power for him. He has absolutely no intention, monetary not withstanding, to ever release the original three movies untouched on Blu-Ray.
 
If any of you have the original releases that were THX certified on VHS, you should watch the interview Lucas gives on the tape. It is very prophetic. There is also a trailer for the movie on the tape where the announcer tells us to buy the movie now as we will never get to see it again in its original format. I didnt believe it at the time, but boy was it true. I do own the original releases on DVD as well. If any of you are waiting for the original release to come out on Blu-Ray, you are in for a loooooong wait. Actually, dont count on it because it will not happen. Ever. As stated earlier, Lucas had a 'vision' of what Star Wars should be. The technology of the time when the movies were made prevented that vision from becoming reality. Now that the technology is here, he is going to shape Star Wars into what he originally envisioned. He actually thinks the theatrical versions are garbage. Yes, these are his movies and he has the right to do with them as he pleases. We have the right to buy them or not give him our money. It is as simple as that. I personally think the retouched movies, including the 'prequels', are all garbage.

So basically Lucas was a hack director of complete crap who was only saved by a low budget, which forced him to get creative. (I actually did a presentation on that theme in grad school, right after Episode 1 came out).
 
Back
Top Bottom