• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Is there no end!!!

Actually, Lucas never intended the originals to ever grace a DVD. As far as he was concerned, VHS was the last time they would ever be released. Once he had the technology to do with them as he pleased, he didnt care what anybody wanted or thought. There was such a huge public outcry and backlash that he relented and released the originals on DVD. It was an act that was intended to get people to shut up. If you have a copy of the original release movies, look closely at them. They are exactly that, original releases. Crappy two channel stereo and VHS quality picture. It was a slap in the face to all the faithful. It was the re-releases and 'fakequels' that got the digital remastered picture and 5.1 sound. He has such a tight-fisted control over the works that he doesnt care what anybody thinks or says now about the originals. It is a matter of ego and will power for him. He has absolutely no intention, monetary not withstanding, to ever release the original three movies untouched on Blu-Ray.

Are they(the DVDs) really that bad? I'm not arguing, just asking. Like I said earlier, I don't care that much, and I haven't seen them yet. I'm surprised that they would be considered "VHS quality".
 
Are they(the DVDs) really that bad? I'm not arguing, just asking. Like I said earlier, I don't care that much, and I haven't seen them yet. I'm surprised that they would be considered "VHS quality".
You have to have the correct DVD release, which had the corrected images (as in color and contrast fixed), but also had the additional footage. With that set came the original releases, but those who own them say they aren't much, if any, better than the VHS copies. I have all three (that I'm familiar with) VHS copies. I have the SE DVD release (bought with the idea they were original) and the "face" LD set. The LD set is the only set with the original movies intact. Image is better that VHS by a long shot, but not sure I'd say equal to or better than DVD, however, the player I have is entry level so that doesn't say much.
 
I have both, the boxed THX enhanced VHS originals and the original untouched release on DVD. The picture quality is about the same for both. The VHS copy blows away the DVD with much better sound. As far as Lucas being a hack director, as stated above, that couldnt be further from the truth. It is pretty simple really. His original vision of Star Wars could not be fully realized when it was made due to the technological barriers regarding special effects. The space scenes were made using models and glass plates with scenes painted on them and moved for each frame.

Being a fan of the original movies, and having been privileged to have seen them when they came out in theaters, I would love to own them on the latest media, with the best picture and sound. I have followed this story since the VHS days. I have seen numerous interviews that Lucas has given over the years regarding the original trilogy. The only reason he made them back then was to get into the film business. He wasnt satisfied with them then. Once the technology improved enough where he could go back and redo the movies to his liking, he did. What we are seeing now is his vision of what Star Wars should be. Dont get me wrong, I am not defending him or his actions. I dont like it any more than the rest of you, but there is nothing any of us can do about it. The best we can do is to get hold of the original movies in the few remaining formats that there are, and be happy about it.
 
Back
Top Bottom