• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

M91ED or M97XE

M91 is the bees knees.

I got a M75 in the mail yesterday, just set it up with some extras from Needledaddy. Man, the M75 is a nice cart too. I believe it is related to the M91 almost to a T. These older Shures are incredible. I dont have a 97 as they are out of my pre-set price range but the 91s are very good.
 
Actually Pio1980 the tweeters of the large Advent were as carefully designed as the woofer. No oem anything in the large Advent.

Yes, the mid - tweeters were quite good in their day and OEM by Advent/ Kloss. By today's standards this driver and associated xover can be bettered while preserving the still - excellent mid-woofer.

Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk
 
Plus 1

It'll end up being a personal decision, but I much prefer the 91ED. Big bold sound, great tracker. The 97xE just didn't do it for me. Just not enough body, and not enough soul. That said, there are a lot of folks who really like it.

What is the turntable that your friend is going to use the cart on?

Had both too. The M91 blows the 97 away especially with a JICO elliptical stylus. The $35 one. Worked well on many of my Duals.

Eric
 
I have both cartridges and in my opinion it's no contest! The M97XE is one of the best trackers there is BUT it's also the most BORING cartridge I've ever heard. The roll off highs makes a lot of my records sound lifeless. Every time I've put it on it is usually a day before I take it off! The M91ED is a great little cartridge and I put it up there with my V15 III.
 
After failed attempts at finding a suitable replacement stylus for my vintage ADC XLM Type II Improved that I've had for 35 years, I ended up installing a new Shure M97-XE.

Not sure yet if I'm pleased or not. I'm guessing that the 0.0002 vs. 0.0003 tracing radius requires more precise alignment and the entire cartridge is a bit heavier, increasing the total arm mass.
 
Unfortunately for the M97xE, Catman isn't able to make its case heard in this thread. He'd tell you it's all about achieving the proper loading to bring it to life and make it sing to it's potential.

For those of you wanting to know about optimizing the M97xE, here's a good read. Scroll down to the section titled;

From an Ugly Duckling to an Elegant Swan - The Shure M97xE
http://www.mds975.co.uk/Content/vinyl07.html

Having said that, count me among the fans of the M91ED, I have 2 with a JICO on one and a NOS Shure Hi-Tracker on the other and I love them to death...
 
Last edited:
Man, the M75 is a nice cart too. I believe it is related to the M91 almost to a T.

Same guts, identical sound. The M91 was for those who preferred a removable stylus guard, while the M75 was for those who preferred a swing-down stylus guard integral with the stylus housing – that was the only difference. Personally, I prefer the M75 stylus guard - it can't get lost or dropped and trodden on!:tears:
 
fred soop said:
After failed attempts at finding a suitable replacement stylus for my vintage ADC XLM Type II Improved that I've had for 35 years....
Just a thought-- you can get an original ADC XT-III, roughly equivalent to an XLM Mk III, for $60. Still available on online auction sites. Designed to operate in the same body the XLM Mk II Improved uses.
.
 
Last edited:
How does the JICO stylus compare to the original M91ED stylus?

The SAS has a better tip profile and Boron rod cantilever, the HE JICO may not be as good as the original OEM Hi-Track but probably 2nd best now available. The EVG is an absolute steal for attentive pleasure and background listening but unsuitable for critical listening as it leaves too much unretrieved behind in the groove.
 
Same guts, identical sound. The M91 was for those who preferred a removable stylus guard, while the M75 was for those who preferred a swing-down stylus guard integral with the stylus housing – that was the only difference. Personally, I prefer the M75 stylus guard - it can't get lost or dropped and trodden on!:tears:

was looking at some pdfs on my phone earlier and I am going to conclude that the M75-G is the predecessor, the grand-pa-pa of the M44G. All of the specs are the same, even requiring the same color on the needle grip with same tracking weight and output voltage.
 
was looking at some pdfs on my phone earlier and I am going to conclude that the M75-G is the predecessor, the grand-pa-pa of the M44G. All of the specs are the same, even requiring the same color on the needle grip with same tracking weight and output voltage.

I think you'll find that the electrical specs for the M44, M70, M75 and M91 are all the same. They all use the same generator. All are rated at 630 ohms and 720mH. If you look through old cartridge specs, you'll see that.

I'm not really sure whether the M44 was introduced before the M75 but I think it was. I'm also pretty sure that the M70 came along before the M75. I do know that there were lots of different M44s before the M44G came along.

The "G" in both cases is just a stylus code a spherical stylus, like ED, EJ, HE, B, whatever. An M44G is the same as an M44-7 except for the stylus.

John
 
Just a thought-- you can get an original ADC XT-III, roughly equivalent to an XLM Mk III, for $75. Still available on online auction sites. Designed to operate in the same body the XLM Mk II Improved uses.

Ordered one today. Thank you. This will give me a backup in case I decide to abandon the M97XE.

I'm also listening with modified cables. The TT is on a shelf with the preamp and other electronics in a nearby tower cabinet, so the cable run is long. Originally, it was the 3 foot cable from the TT, coupled to a 12 foot cable to the preamp. A few months ago, I measured the capacitance of everything and that 12 foot cable was a ridiculous 1500 pf or more.

Since then, the TT cable was cut back to 2 feet (it needed new connectors anyway), the long cable was replaced with a 10 foot low C Blue Jeans cable, and the internal preamp capacitor was reduced from 130 pf to 100 pf. I'll change it to maybe a 47 pf as soon as I find a couple. So, I am now down to 135 pf (TT), 142 pf (long cable) and 100 pf (preamp) for a total of 377 pf.
 
Unfortunately for the M97xE, Catman isn't able to make its case heard in this thread. He'd tell you it's all about achieving the proper loading to bring it to life and make it sing to it's potential.

For those of you wanting to know about optimizing the M97xE, here's a good read. Scroll down to the section titled;

From an Ugly Duckling to an Elegant Swan - The Shure M97xE
http://www.mds975.co.uk/Content/vinyl07.html

Having said that, count me among the fans of the M91ED, I have 2 with a JICO on one and a NOS Shure Hi-Tracker on the other and I love them to death...

I will vouch for catman in his absence. I have a receiver that has a switch to change the loading from 47K to 100K. I replaced the 100K resister to a 62K and the Elegant Swan appeared. Best thing is with a flick of the switch you can tell the obvious difference. Next in line is the SAS needle and I expect it to soar like a eagle. Cable capacitance was adjusted to the 250pf that Shure M97xe likes to eat. This is not something most people can do to there receiver phono stages, but outboard stages would not be hard to do.
 
I think you'll find that the electrical specs for the M44, M70, M75 and M91 are all the same. They all use the same generator. All are rated at 630 ohms and 720mH. If you look through old cartridge specs, you'll see that.

I'm not really sure whether the M44 was introduced before the M75 but I think it was. I'm also pretty sure that the M70 came along before the M75. I do know that there were lots of different M44s before the M44G came along.

The "G" in both cases is just a stylus code a spherical stylus, like ED, EJ, HE, B, whatever. An M44G is the same as an M44-7 except for the stylus.

John

Banned with 10,000 posts? That sucks.

Yea I ll believe you there, there were some old M44s on eBay from the 1960s that almost sold for the new price. Apparently Brown was a popular color for Shure carts in the 60s.

I ll tell you this though, of all the needles I have which are compatible with the M44 and M91, the N44G is the best one. The N447 is very functional and I cant get good stereo imaging with the N44C(it appears to be a left channel centric needle). So if someone were asking for a good conical for a M91 or M75, I d say the N44G is a good choice.
 
Just a thought-- you can get an original ADC XT-III, roughly equivalent to an XLM Mk III, for $75. Still available on online auction sites. Designed to operate in the same body the XLM Mk II Improved uses.

So, the replacement arrived today. It is clearly marked as ADC XT-III, Made in USA, but is in a plain plastic case (and plain white envelope). While I have no reason to suspect that it is used or defective, I also have no proof that it is actually new. Any suggestions? I could probably take it to a shop and have it examined.
 
...I also have no proof that it is actually new. Any suggestions? I could probably take it to a shop and have it examined.
Bulk packaging is not unusual with online stylus vendors. I have never had problems with that seller or the genuine-ness of his merch (including some XT styli), but yes, if you have any doubts, and you have no good-quality magnifying optics of your own, take it to a shop. Doubt can really mess up a listening session.
 
Back
Top Bottom