• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Poultrygeist, I just noticed your profile picture and in there the OB FRD sitting atop of the WE bass bins ( I call them horn loaded OB or inverted box) That was my first iteration of 2 way OB with the rear of the bass driver open instead of sealed, to have true dipole bass. The bass was amazing with just one in a 2.1 mode but adding a second channel had serious room interaction problems.

These are OB H-frames ( an open ended cube with Eminence Alpha 15A's mounted in the center ) not WE bass bins. They are powered by a TPA3116 class D amp and I use an active crossover set at 700Hz on them but not on the big Zeniths which run unfiltered and full range. The tweeters use a 1.5uF cap to filter the LF and are powered by a single ended EL84 which also powers the Zeniths.

index.php
 
Ok, my bad. Did not notice that. I plan to play with different combos of FRD and FRD-tweeters by putting a slit between the FRD baffle and the bass driver. Easy change of upper baffle. I also happen to have a pair of those Zeniths 49CZ852 12" Alnico and I plan to top them with some tweeters of matching sensitivity. However am not sure if its fine to run the combo by the EL84 amp (only 8 ohm impedance terminal). (We do seem to have even similar toys.)
 
Hi everyone, just wanna ask, is there anybody owns a Harbeth speaker before, and currently enjoying the open baffle speakers?

I'm enjoying Harbeth, M30.1 in particular, but currently in a very serious consideration to sell it and fund this open baffle project, or opting for Spatial M4 speaker.

Thank you in advance.
 
Hi everyone, just wanna ask, is there anybody owns a Harbeth speaker before, and currently enjoying the open baffle speakers?

I'm enjoying Harbeth, M30.1 in particular, but currently in a very serious consideration to sell it and fund this open baffle project, or opting for Spatial M4 speaker.

Thank you in advance.

I would expect the Spatials to be an sonic upgrade. Even very inexpensive DIY OB's can offer a decided advantage over high end box speakers.
 
I would expect the Spatials to be an sonic upgrade. Even very inexpensive DIY OB's can offer a decided advantage over high end box speakers.

Thanks for the reply PG. I've been reading most of your comments and basically you are the reason I'm thinking of trying the open baffle speaker.

I might be going the diy route for this open baffle speaker then, looks like it's something that can be done although not easy. I'm thinking of following your design, fullrange driver on top of H-frame subwoofer, with active crossover. Another design looks tempting too, the slot loaded but I failed to find any info on the built.

Will be sending you PM later PG when I'm starting this project. Thanks again.
 
Thanks for the reply PG. I've been reading most of your comments and basically you are the reason I'm thinking of trying the open baffle speaker.

I might be going the diy route for this open baffle speaker then, looks like it's something that can be done although not easy. I'm thinking of following your design, fullrange driver on top of H-frame subwoofer, with active crossover. Another design looks tempting too, the slot loaded but I failed to find any info on the built.

Will be sending you PM later PG when I'm starting this project. Thanks again.

Sounds good and glad to help.
 
These are OB H-frames ( an open ended cube with Eminence Alpha 15A's mounted in the center ) not WE bass bins. They are powered by a TPA3116 class D amp and I use an active crossover set at 700Hz on them but not on the big Zeniths which run unfiltered and full range. The tweeters use a 1.5uF cap to filter the LF and are powered by a single ended EL84 which also powers the Zeniths.

index.php
Hi PG, I have really really really been enjoying my open baffle speakers! As you know it consists of the Eminence 12 LTA's and ASD 1001's driven by a pair of 45 tube SET amps with 1.33 uF on the + leg of the 1001's. And the Eminence 15 Alfa's driven by a Cary Rocket 88. Here is some of the fooling around I have done: First I tried Beringer CX2310 low outputs to the 15 A's and Beringer high outputs to 12 LTA's. I got a little more volume that way, but when I went direct from pre-amp to LTA's I thought it sounded more natural. I may try the first way again. Later I tried the subwoofer output to the Alphas, connecting both channels to one side of the amp and switching from the 8 ohm setting to the 4 ohm setting on the amp. This seemed to be an improvement. I tried turning the H-Frames sideways. I am back to having the drivers facing me now, but I feel like it works both ways (though sounds different each way). There have been times that I have thought I might want to attenuate the 1001's on some recordings, but the positioning of the speakers and listening position do effect the sound. I found that if I reverse the polarity on the LTA's (leaving the polarity correct on the 1001's) the symbols seem to sound overall farther back in the room. That I liked.

I will have to try one of those TPA amps that you mention. I have an old Sonic Impact amp that I will try swapping out with the Cary (maybe tomorrow). I know the Cary goes lower, but the Sonic Impact's bass sounding more tight with my other speakers.

I am writing all this for a couple reasons. First to thank you for your advice and encouragement which got me to do this. Second to see what you recommend that I try next. I do have a Sony receiver laying around that I could try on the 1001's (tri-amp) but I will have to get some a couple more XLR to RCA interconnects first.

Are you still using the 5 gallon bucket subs? I feel like I have enough bass, but it sounds like fun. And, maybe with them playing a little lower than the Alpha's I will get better bass on the recordings that happen to have information that low? Also, you say that your active crossover is set to 700Hz. Is that a mistype, or should I be doing something different? I am currently only using my active crossover for the summed mono sub connection going to one side of the Cary and then to both Alpha's. I have been running between 40 and 100Hz most of the time. I never have learned or had the wherewith to take measurements, except with my ears. However, it has always been something that I think and wonder about. Obviously, you like the Zenith's more than the 12 LTA's or you would not have sold the LTA's. I have been watching for them, but I usually see just one for sale (if any) and often with defects. I do love the LTA's, but I owe it to myself to make a baffle for my oval shaped Grundig speakers and try them with the H-Frames.
 
Bwebber,

Thanks for the kind words. I absolutely enjoyed the 12LTA's to no end but would have liked them even more had I paired them with the 1001 tweeters which I didn't have at the time. You've probably seen this blog but for others it bears repeating.

https://speakerprojects.wordpress.com/2016/08/29/eminence-beta-12lta-on-open-baffle/

I found the 1001's to be almost too good but a bit forward with my Zeniths so I balanced them with rear firing Realistic super tweeters. Perhaps their output is reduced I'm not sure. All four tweets do run off the same SE amp that drives the Zeniths ( but now from the Bottlehead 2a3 as the EL84 is now driving the Lowthers ). Tried tri-amping but way too complicated for me.

I really wanted to follow conventional wisdom which says the active x-over should be used to split the HF and LF but the single ended tube amps lost their magic and sounded like cheap solid states when I tried that. I use the LF active only with my LF Alpha woofers and the summed sub output connection for the subs ( bucket subs and 8" Dayton kit ). Subs are driven by plate amps. Depending on the type of music OB woofers can be all you need. Active crossover settings I think are personal and unlike passives ( thank goodness ) they can be changed with a flick of the dial. Yes mine is currently at 70hz.

The big SE powered Zeniths are a thing of beauty unfiltered/full range with nothing in the signal path to alter their natural sound. Desert island drivers and unlike the Lowthers they have some bass.

The wonderful thing about DIY OB's is that you can tweak to your heart's content and only you can say what sounds best to you. Buying off the shelf monkey coffins means you're locked in to someone else's sonic preference. I wouldn't be concerned about measurements because if it sounds right it is right. Measurements are most helpful for those who like to pass judgement without listening.

The lyrics from this song by Cole Porter are keys to DIY open baffles:

"Before you leave these portals
To meet less fortunate mortals,
There's just one final message
I would give to you.
You all have learned reliance
On the sacred teachings of science,
So I hope, through life, you never will decline
In spite of philistine
Definace
To do what all good scientists do.
Experiment.
Make it your motto day and night.
Experiment
And it will lead you to the light.
The apple on the top of the tree
Is never too high to achieve,
So take an example from Eve,
Experiment.
Be curious,
Though interfering friends may frown.
Get furious
At each attempt to hold you down.
If this advice you always employ
The future can offer you infinite joy
And merriment,
Experiment
And you'll see"
 
Bwebber,

Thanks for the kind words. I absolutely enjoyed the 12LTA's to no end but would have liked them even more had I paired them with the 1001 tweeters which I didn't have at the time. You've probably seen this blog but for others it bears repeating.

https://speakerprojects.wordpress.com/2016/08/29/eminence-beta-12lta-on-open-baffle/

I found the 1001's to be almost too good but a bit forward with my Zeniths so I balanced them with rear firing Realistic super tweeters. Perhaps their output is reduced I'm not sure. All four tweets do run off the same SE amp that drives the Zeniths ( but now from the Bottlehead 2a3 as the EL84 is now driving the Lowthers ). Tried tri-amping but way too complicated for me.

I really wanted to follow conventional wisdom which says the active x-over should be used to split the HF and LF but the single ended tube amps lost their magic and sounded like cheap solid states when I tried that. I use the LF active only with my LF Alpha woofers and the summed sub output connection for the subs ( bucket subs and 8" Dayton kit ). Subs are driven by plate amps. Depending on the type of music OB woofers can be all you need. Active crossover settings I think are personal and unlike passives ( thank goodness ) they can be changed with a flick of the dial. Yes mine is currently at 70hz.

The big SE powered Zeniths are a thing of beauty unfiltered/full range with nothing in the signal path to alter their natural sound. Desert island drivers and unlike the Lowthers they have some bass.

The wonderful thing about DIY OB's is that you can tweak to your heart's content and only you can say what sounds best to you. Buying off the shelf monkey coffins means you're locked in to someone else's sonic preference. I wouldn't be concerned about measurements because if it sounds right it is right. Measurements are most helpful for those who like to pass judgement without listening.

The lyrics from this song by Cole Porter are keys to DIY open baffles:

"Before you leave these portals
To meet less fortunate mortals,
There's just one final message
I would give to you.
You all have learned reliance
On the sacred teachings of science,
So I hope, through life, you never will decline
In spite of philistine
Definace
To do what all good scientists do.
Experiment.
Make it your motto day and night.
Experiment
And it will lead you to the light.
The apple on the top of the tree
Is never too high to achieve,
So take an example from Eve,
Experiment.
Be curious,
Though interfering friends may frown.
Get furious
At each attempt to hold you down.
If this advice you always employ
The future can offer you infinite joy
And merriment,
Experiment
And you'll see"
Thank you PG!
 
Hi PG, I have really really really been enjoying my open baffle speakers! As you know it consists of the Eminence 12 LTA's and ASD 1001's driven by a pair of 45 tube SET amps with 1.33 uF on the + leg of the 1001's. And the Eminence 15 Alfa's driven by a Cary Rocket 88. Here is some of the fooling around I have done: First I tried Beringer CX2310 low outputs to the 15 A's and Beringer high outputs to 12 LTA's. I got a little more volume that way, but when I went direct from pre-amp to LTA's I thought it sounded more natural. I may try the first way again. Later I tried the subwoofer output to the Alphas, connecting both channels to one side of the amp and switching from the 8 ohm setting to the 4 ohm setting on the amp. This seemed to be an improvement. I tried turning the H-Frames sideways. I am back to having the drivers facing me now, but I feel like it works both ways (though sounds different each way). There have been times that I have thought I might want to attenuate the 1001's on some recordings, but the positioning of the speakers and listening position do effect the sound. I found that if I reverse the polarity on the LTA's (leaving the polarity correct on the 1001's) the symbols seem to sound overall farther back in the room. That I liked.

I will have to try one of those TPA amps that you mention. I have an old Sonic Impact amp that I will try swapping out with the Cary (maybe tomorrow). I know the Cary goes lower, but the Sonic Impact's bass sounding more tight with my other speakers.

I am writing all this for a couple reasons. First to thank you for your advice and encouragement which got me to do this. Second to see what you recommend that I try next. I do have a Sony receiver laying around that I could try on the 1001's (tri-amp) but I will have to get some a couple more XLR to RCA interconnects first.

Are you still using the 5 gallon bucket subs? I feel like I have enough bass, but it sounds like fun. And, maybe with them playing a little lower than the Alpha's I will get better bass on the recordings that happen to have information that low? Also, you say that your active crossover is set to 700Hz. Is that a mistype, or should I be doing something different? I am currently only using my active crossover for the summed mono sub connection going to one side of the Cary and then to both Alpha's. I have been running between 40 and 100Hz most of the time. I never have learned or had the wherewith to take measurements, except with my ears. However, it has always been something that I think and wonder about. Obviously, you like the Zenith's more than the 12 LTA's or you would not have sold the LTA's. I have been watching for them, but I usually see just one for sale (if any) and often with defects. I do love the LTA's, but I owe it to myself to make a baffle for my oval shaped Grundig speakers and try them with the H-Frames.
I'm glad to see someone else enjoying the LTA's!
Mine have put the TB 1808 and Zenith's on the sideline's for now.View attachment 1105300
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1252.JPG
    IMG_1252.JPG
    87.4 KB · Views: 54
Last edited:
I'm glad to see someone else enjoying the LTA's!
Mine have put the TB 1808 and Zenith's on the sideline's for now.View attachment 1105300
Nice looking speakers! And, probably an exceptional tweeter?

Tonight I swapped the Cary Rocket 88 out for the Sonic Impact on the bass. I bought it for something like $28 years ago when they came out. I did put it in a larger case with 5 way binding speaker posts. I also replaced the bass limiting capacitors (one for each channel) and iliminated the volume/pre-amp part. I have not used it for years, however. I am glad I tried it, as it seems to do better on the bass than the Cary! I actually went back to the stereo bass in an effort to reduce the bass more. It's crazy! I imagine some of those TPA 3116 amps are even better?
 
I use one of these to drive my Alpha woofers. It's a dual chip TPA3116 class D amp velcro-ed to the top of it's power supply. The Astron is a linear regulated power supply popular with ham radio guys. With chip amps a good power supply can make all the difference.

P9240026.jpg
 
Nice looking speakers! And, probably an exceptional tweeter?

Tonight I swapped the Cary Rocket 88 out for the Sonic Impact on the bass. I bought it for something like $28 years ago when they came out. I did put it in a larger case with 5 way binding speaker posts. I also replaced the bass limiting capacitors (one for each channel) and iliminated the volume/pre-amp part. I have not used it for years, however. I am glad I tried it, as it seems to do better on the bass than the Cary! I actually went back to the stereo bass in an effort to reduce the bass more. It's crazy! I imagine some of those TPA 3116 amps are even better?

The Tweeter is nothing special, It is a "Hygeia" Planar I bought when it appeared that BG Radia would no longer produce the Neo 8's which I coveted.
When PE bought out the "right's" to the patent and began to manufacture the 8's again I had to indulge myself and these became surplus so to speak.
They were never a proper replacement for the BG's as they can't reproduce the same lower bandwidth , but happily can add some "air".
I xo @ 8.5k, where the LTA's start their rolloff. 12db LR reversed to protect the Planar.
 
I’ve been enjoying a set of Audio Artistry Beethoven Elite open baffle speakers for a couple of years now. They utilize eight 12” woofers, four 10” woofers and four 8” midrange drivers all in an open baffle arrangement the designer (Linkwitz) called active di-pole back in 1996 when they were created. All speakers are Scanspeak including the Revelator silk dome tweeters. Linkwitz is a pioneer in making speakers without a box and the Beethoven Elites have to be heard to be believed. The Elite’s use a proprietary four way active crossover which requires eight channels of amplification but I think this complication is well worth the result. Although I have not heard a lot of open baffle designs, I can’t say I have always been a strong supporter but these speakers sure have made me a believer it can be done very well.
 
Last edited:
I’ve been enjoying a set of Audio Artistry Beethoven Elite open baffle speakers for a couple of years now. They utilize eight 12” woofers, four 10” woofers and four 8” midrange drivers all in an open baffle arrangement the designer (Linkwitz) called bi-pole back in 1996 when they were created. All speakers are Scanspeak including the Revelator silk dome tweeters. Linkwitz is a pioneer in making speakers without a box and the Beethoven Elites have to be heard to be believed. The Elite’s use a proprietary four way active crossover which requires eight channels of amplification but I think this complication is well worth the result. Although I have not heard a lot of open baffle designs, I can’t say I have always been a strong supporter but these speakers sure have made me a believer it can be done very well.

Pictures would be so nice.
 
Back
Top Bottom