• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

I wonder if they make a D minor version? not that I could afford it...:(
Just curious, how big is your space anyway? That's a lot of firepower IMHO, though I'm sure that it sounds prettyfreakinawesome! (yes that is a word;)

...and BTW, question about the "subwoofers" - Are they open baffle (is that grill cloth on the back?) or are the top and bottom chambers connected?
 
I want to get into OB experimenting....I have heard that ElectroVoice Wolverines make good candidates. Is this true?
Many thanks :beerchug:
 
I’ve been enjoying a set of Audio Artistry Beethoven Elite open baffle speakers for a couple of years now. They utilize eight 12” woofers, four 10” woofers and four 8” midrange drivers all in an open baffle arrangement the designer (Linkwitz) called bi-pole back in 1996 when they were created. All speakers are Scanspeak including the Revelator silk dome tweeters. Linkwitz is a pioneer in making speakers without a box and the Beethoven Elites have to be heard to be believed. The Elite’s use a proprietary four way active crossover which requires eight channels of amplification but I think this complication is well worth the result. Although I have not heard a lot of open baffle designs, I can’t say I have always been a strong supporter but these speakers sure have made me a believer it can be done very well.

Are those ports on the rear? Does the fabric cover on the back allow for rear radiation? In my limited understanding bi-poles and di-poles are different in that the latter are usually wired in phase and allow full rear radiation.
 
I wonder if they make a D minor version? not that I could afford it...:(
Just curious, how big is your space anyway? That's a lot of firepower IMHO, though I'm sure that it sounds prettyfreakinawesome! (yes that is a word;)

...and BTW, question about the "subwoofers" - Are they open baffle (is that grill cloth on the back?) or are the top and bottom chambers connected?

Room in 22' x 14' with cathedral ceiling.

Audio Artistry made other more modest speakers using the same principles. http://www.audioartistry.com/products_legacy.htm The Dvorak in particular were popular back in the 90s at half the cost of the Beethovens.

Yes, the subs are open baffle (not loaded) with two 12" woofers firing into a forward facing wedge cavity and two firing into a rear facing wedge cavity. Like the whole system, they are absolutely amazing performers!

Here is a review of the non-elite version (passive crossover on main speakers) https://www.stereophile.com/floorloudspeakers/328/index.html I strongly support all the comments in this review. They were Stereophile speaker of the year in 98. I have never found a review of the elite versions like mine but they were offered in 1999 at additional cost. The elite is said to be greatly superior with the added control of the active crossover.

Linkwitz notes on elite http://www.linkwitzlab.com/B-Elite.htm

They also made Beethoven Grands but not sure how many? http://www.linkwitzlab.com/B-Grand.htm

Of course the hidden cost of the elite is the need for 8 channels of balanced amplification.

The transformer (Jensen) balanced active crossover for the elite has many internal adjustments. Trim for each channel and a few settings for LF crossover and phasing. It also has an external subsonic filter switch.

Are those ports on the rear? Does the fabric cover on the back allow for rear radiation? In my limited understanding bi-poles and di-poles are different in that the latter are usually wired in phase and allow full rear radiation.

Sorry, I was mistaken the speakers (except tweeter) are di-pole not bi-pole (fixed). The small ports in the rear are vents for the driver's voice coils. Yes, the rear fabric area is open to the back of the drivers (except tweeter is sealed). The size and shape of the rear open areas are said to be key parts of the unique tuning of these speakers.

One thing I was very surprised with these speakers is they are very, very forgiving to room acoustics and placement. As long as you give them some space, they work very well and magically disappear in the sound stage. They are "very" full range and quite amazing to experience.
 
Last edited:
I had four boxes waiting for me when I got home this evening. After unpacking the contents, here's what I have:

  1. Hawthorne Silver Iris with crossovers
  2. B&C DE10-8
  3. Eminence PSD 2000s-8
  4. Eminence Alpha 15a

I'm an OB rookie and would appreciate some advice from the seasoned vets here on how to get these setup properly. The two big questions I have are:
  1. What type/size baffle should I build and out of what type of material?
  2. I'd like to use the Eminence compression drivers:
    • I understand the crossover needs modification for use with this compression driver. Can anyone offer insight as to what modifications are required?
    • The Eminence drivers are currently mounted coaxially. Is this acceptable, or should I be building a baffle to accommodate a horn or waveguide?
I know these questions will lead to more questions, answers, discusion, etc., but it's a start and should get me going in the right direction.

Here's the haul:
IMG_20180321_194401.jpg IMG_20180321_194411.jpg IMG_20180321_194441.jpg IMG_20180321_194604.jpg IMG_20180321_194625.jpg IMG_20180321_202108.jpg
 
I want to get into OB experimenting....I have heard that ElectroVoice Wolverines make good candidates. Is this true?
Many thanks :beerchug:

I've come across some Wolverines before and listened to them... and found them not all that noteworthy... but not bad either. But I'm still quite a newbie with OBs. Others may have quite different assessments than I. I've tried several parts express 8" full range drivers, and again, not bad but didn't stick with them.

For what it's worth, I ended up with some vintage Heppner 8" drivers pulled from some vintage organs, likely from the 50s/60s. I found them to be unbelievable mounted in some small open baffles I built. I augment the lack of bass with a subwoofer.

But if you have some Wolverines, set them up in some quick-and-dirty OBs made from OSB/plywood/anything laying around... it doesn't much matter. See if you like what you hear, and if so, then build something perhaps a bit nicer. I had some 1/2" OSB around left over from some other project and quickly screwed them together and liked what I heard and went from there. It doesn't cost much to test/experment with OBs. Give it a try and let us know.

Hopefully, others will chime in, too, on your Wolverine question.

Cheers!
 
Thanks hnash! I have some big cardboard I might experiment with this weekend!

Got the Wolverines cheap at thrift store because they were in cheap crappy cabinets!
 
Matt0404,

I'm not that familiar with the well regarded Silver Iris but it looks like it has it's own compression tweeter mounted piggy back so I'm not sure why you would need the B&C tweeter? The crossover is for the Silver Iris and it compression tweeter. In any case I would drive the SI with one amp while powering the Alphas with a separate amp. For the Alpha amp you could use a low power plate amp and it's crossover for the LF or if you already have a second amp you could pick up a Behringer active for not much money. I've had great results using a cheap Behringer active on just the woofers while running the mains full range.

MJK's H-frames if you don't mind their complexity or 20" wide flat baffles if you want a simpler build. 3/4 inch plywood or MDF.
 
Last edited:
Matt0404,

I'm not that familiar with the well regarded Silver Iris but it looks like it has it's own compression tweeter mounted piggy back so I'm not sure why you would need the B&C tweeter? The crossover is for the Silver Iris and it compression tweeter. In any case I would drive the SI with one amp while powering the Alphas with a separate amp. For the Alpha amp you could use a low power plate amp and it's crossover for the LF or if you already have a second amp you could pick up a Behringer active for not much money. I've had great results using a cheap Behringer active on just the woofers while running the mains full range.

MJK's H-frames if you don't mind their complexity or 20" wide flat baffles if you want a simpler build. 3/4 inch plywood or MDF.
Thanks for the advice, PG! I should have clarified that the Hawthorne and its crossover are designed to be used with the B&C tweeter. The Eminence tweeters were included as an upgrade, but I was told the crossover would need tweaked for best results. I'm just not sure what tweaks are needed.

Thanks for the recommendations on the H-frame. I'll look into it!
 
That's the Sterling Silver Iris which is different from the standard Silver Iris.

In any case, I'm not sure either of the tweeters (B&C or Eminence) are original to the Hawthorne drivers.

Why would your Silver Iris/Eminence compression tweeters be wired up to the crossover if that's not the correct crossover?
 
Hawthorne Audio ( RIP ) sold several drivers and some were based on the Eminence 15" and 10" woofers. They started out as a DIY company and then later added their own complete OB's. They had a great forum to share experiences and folks commonly experimented with different tweeters, crossover tweaks, configurations etc.
 
Thanks hnash! I have some big cardboard I might experiment with this weekend!

Got the Wolverines cheap at thrift store because they were in cheap crappy cabinets!

Yes... some have set up their initial OBs using cardboard... but make sure it's stout enough.

Let us know how the Wolverines perform for you. And pics are always nice and generate more comments.
 
Speaking of Electro-Voice, I've just completed my DIY open baffles that use EV SP12C full range drivers. I re-coned them using an SP12B re-cone kit, and then modified them further, so they're far from stock.

IMG_0465.JPG IMG_0466.JPG

Sound-wise I'm quite impressed at how high the speakers play. They're not quite full-range, but at the same time, I don't think they need tweeter. I really like the coherent, time-aligned sound you get from single drivers.

The baffles are pretty simple, I tried to keep the drivers low to reinforce the bass response. They might need some form of baffle step correction, as they're pretty bright sounding. All in all though, for a $150 investment and a few hours of handy work, I'm really happy with their sound. I could listen to them all day!

Long live open baffle speakers!
 
The baffles are pretty simple, I tried to keep the drivers low to reinforce the bass response. They might need some form of baffle step correction, as they're pretty bright sounding. All in all though, for a $150 investment and a few hours of handy work, I'm really happy with their sound. I could listen to them all day!

Put some time on them and let your ears get used to them, the brightness will go away.
 
I picked up a pair of Zenith 49-1045 this weekend. Very similar to the 49CZ852s but with a whizzer cone. I've put about 10 hours them so far and I am pretty impressed. At first they sounded a bit sibilant and buzzy but that subsided after a couple of hours. Sound is very similar to the 852s, but the mids and highs have a touch more presence and impact. Soundstage is a tad smaller with less depth but still ample. I'll play them for about a month or so then switch back to the 852s before passing judgement, but for now they are putting a smile on my face.
 
Back
Top Bottom