• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

I picked up a pair of Zenith 49-1045 this weekend. Very similar to the 49CZ852s but with a whizzer cone. I've put about 10 hours them so far and I am pretty impressed. At first they sounded a bit sibilant and buzzy but that subsided after a couple of hours. Sound is very similar to the 852s, but the mids and highs have a touch more presence and impact. Soundstage is a tad smaller with less depth but still ample. I'll play them for about a month or so then switch back to the 852s before passing judgement, but for now they are putting a smile on my face.

Since the subject of the Zenith 49CZ852s has come up again, I will mention something. I few weeks back I was very excited to pick up a pair of 12 inch speakers with no name on them that looked a lot like the Zeniths. I bought them because they were just $5.00 each and looked to be in good condition. I was very disappointed however, because one of them had bad cone rub, and the good one was not as efficient or anywhere near as good sounding as my Eminence LTA's. I tried some of what I saw on the net about fixing cone rub, but think I did more damage than good. I guess I would need to get the real thing. So, how do the Zenith 49CZ852s compare with the Eminence 12 LTA (efficiency, bass, mid-range, treble etc.)?
 
The Zenith 49CZ802 seems as efficient as the Beta 12LTA but they are more refined and their beautiful tone is the best I've heard. The Beta requires a tweeter but the Zenith plays high enough for most people that you can get by without one. Sometimes I forget to turn on my bass woofer amp and then don't discover it until later. So I'd say they would still be quite wonderful used as a single driver. I enjoyed the Betas for years and would still be doing so had I not discovered the Zeniths. I can't believe they sat unused on a shelf in my garage all that time.

You can read Mr. GITD latest updates on the Zeniths.

http://glowinthedarkaudio.com/zenith-49cz852.html
 
Look good for an Eminence Alpha 15a before I buy material and start cutting? Baffle size is 16"x16", front/rear to baffle depth is 7.5", woofer cutout is 13.77".

Back view:
Screen Shot 2018-03-24 at 10.03.40 AM.png

Front view:
Screen Shot 2018-03-24 at 10.09.11 AM.png
 
FWIW the inside measurements ( not the outside measurements ) of my H-frames are 17". That gives me about one inch from the Alpha lip to the baffle edge. You can go larger but much smaller might be a bit risky. Parts Express says the Alpha cut out is 13.87.
 
FWIW the inside measurements ( not the outside measurements ) of my H-frames are 17". That gives me about one inch from the Alpha lip to the baffle edge. You can go larger but much smaller might be a bit risky. Parts Express says the Alpha cut out is 13.87.
View attachment 1145613
Ditto............17"......you will need at least this size.
Hmmm...I thought MJK referenced internal cross-sectional dimensions of 16"x16" for the Eminence 15a. :dunno: In any case, my model allows clearance on all sides with a 16"x16" baffle with the driver mounted. The driver has an OD of 15.15" which leaves 0.425" clearance on all sides. I won't get away with solid mounting strips for the baffle, but I can run them up from the corners about 4" which should be enough. I'd re-do the model and cut list with a 17" baffle but.....I got anxious and cut everything already. :crazy:

And PE says 13.77" cutout, but Eminence says 13.87". Think I better stick with MFG recommendations. I'll measure before cutting to be sure.
 
PE gives the link to Eminence specs which states the cut out is 13.87 but it's not critical as either should work as there's wiggle room. The H-frames measurements are what I used after doing mocks up in luan. I felt the center baffle didn't appear to have enough strength ( material ) when I went less than 17 inches but maybe that's just me.
 
I took into consideration the way I would mount them on the baffle (rear- mount with Hurricane nuts).
I initially wanted 16", but PG suggested 17" and it worked out fine.
Good Luck and snap some pic's for us.
 
I have been a lurker of this thread for the past year or so. All of the positive feedback on the Zenith 48CZxxx driver convinced me that I wanted to give it a try on an open baffle. I was fortunate to have won a pair of 49CZ802 on ebay a couple of months ago . I currently have them mounted on a simple baffle measuring 40cm wide by 86cm high by 1.8cm thick.


Around the same time I received the Zeniths, I got back into tube audio with a Musical Paradise MP-301MKIII. I had a Decware SE84c+ that I really liked, but had to sell it a few years ago. The MP-301 isn’t my final destination, but is allowing me to enjoy the « tube » sound until more funds become available.


My Zenith 49CZ802s replace a BK-16 folded horn with Fostex FF165K drivers. Overall I am quite pleased with the sound I’m getting. The Zeniths really are fantastic drivers. They give substance to the music and make everything very engaging and a pleasure to listen to. I was afraid I’d be losing some detail in the switch, but the Zeniths are as detailed (possibly more detailed) than my Fostex speakers.


As of right now, there is no bass augmentation, only the single driver on each baffle. Even with the narrow baffle I am using, the sound is very pleasing, but I intrigued about bass augmentation with an Alpha 15A. I have read through the pages in this thread many times, but I am still not totally clear on a couple of things and hoping someone here could provide some guidance.

OB Speakers.jpg


Largely for aesthetic reasons, as well as the fact that I’m living in an apartment and don’t need thundering low end, I decided not to build an H-baffle like many here have done, but rather to mount one Alpha 15A under the Zenith driver on each baffle.


Before I invest in subwoofer amp(s) I would like to hear what passive subwoofer augmentation would sound like. I know this is something Caintuck Audio does with the Betsy driver, and thought it could work in my set-up as well. I have a feeling that a passive sub would be more than enough for my needs. I’ve never owned speakers that have any significant sub-50hz response and have always enjoyed the sound regardless.

So, now for the questions :

1) Can I use my integrated amp (Musical Paradise MP-301 MKIII) to power both the Zenith 49CZ802s and the Alpha 15As ? Will the 6.5 watts be enough to do this?

2) Could I do this without any crossovers ? (run both drivers full range)

3) If this is possible, I think I have to wire the speakers in parallel. My understanding is that this means I take the speaker output from the amp and run the wires into the Alpha 15A, and then run speaker wires from the Alpha 15A to the Zenith 49CZ802. Is this correct? Or should I run the wires out of the amp to the Zenith first and then to the Alpha 15A?

4) If this setup is possible, is there is a way, without a plate amp, to modulate the volume of the Alpha 15A so that I can dial in the amount of bass I want? My understanding is that because the sensitivity of the two drivers (Zenith and Alpha 15A) are roughly equivalent, perhaps I wouldn’t need to modulate the bass output. Nevertheless, I think it would be a nice option to have if there is a simple solution.

OK, thanks for reading, I realize this is a very long first post. Any help would be greatly appreciated.


All the best,

David
 
David, welcome to AK

Bi-amping your OB's is the key to good bass augmentation. You could come up with a passive crossover for the Zeniths and Alphas and power them from a single amp but I doubt your MP is powerful enough for the job. When using a passive crossover you lose some of the amp's power as it is converted into heat. I use a 20 watt amp just for the Alphas but I have used as much as 100 watts. The Zeniths as you know sound great running full range but the Alpha will require a filter to remove the HF.

If you decide to go with a plate amp it will have it's crossover built in for the Alphas. Since plate amps are mono you would normally wire the Alphas parallel ( doubling up on the two plate amp terminals ) which gives a 4 ohm load. Most plate amps love a 4 ohm load as it allows them to deliver their maximum power.
 
Hi Poultrygeist,
Thanks for the welcome and for all your contributions to this thread; they really helped me make my decision to take a chance with the Zenith drivers and have them shipped to France (not cheap).

I understand that there are advantages to an active system with a separate plate amp, but I was under the impression that there were people here who ran both the zenith and the Alpha 15A without any crossovers. Did I misread something? Is this not possible? I thought this was the preferred method for some as there were no added electronics between the amp and the drivers. Perhaps I just didn't understand correctly.

If anyone else has any thoughts on the matter I'd be grateful. Thanks again for your help Poultrygeist.
 
Can't imagine running the Alphas without some type of a low pass. They play pretty high for a woofer and would be competing with the Zeniths.

My first two way OB's were these with the Betsy's running full range ( nothing in the signal path ) from a small tube amp while the Alphas were driven from an old receiver. The crossover for the Alphas ( in the picture ) is a fixed 70hz passive which acts as a filter so that only the low frequencies come through. It worked pretty good and some folks use Fmods which do the same thing. This set up is not so cost effective because the passive crossovers end up costing about the same as a $70 Behringer CX2310 active. With an active you are free to change the crossover as well as having a host of other sound tweaks at your finger tips. I now use active crossovers only for the Alphas in two different systems while the full range speakers run unencumbered.

PB230008.jpg
 
Thanks. I guess I'll have to reassess.

If I got a single plate amp, for example a Dayton Audio SA100, what would the wiring look like?

Something like this?

- Two pairs of Speaker wires (+/- left channel & +/- left channel) from speaker output on MP-301 amp ⇒ into hi-level inputs "from amplifier" binding posts on the Dayton Audio SA100 ⇒ then 2 pairs of speaker wire (+/- left channel & +/- left channel) from "to speakers" binding posts on Dayton Audio SA100 ⇒ one set of speaker wires to Alpha 15A on left baffle and one set of speaker wires to Alpha 15A on right baffle

AND

- Two pairs of speaker wires (+/- left channel & +/- left channel) from speaker output on MP-301 amp ⇒ into Zenith drivers

Sorry if my questions seem rudimentary, but all this is new to me, just want to try to get it right the first time.

And one more thing, if I used the Dayton plate amp, would I need a Behringer CX2310?
 
FWIW I only use a plate amps RCA line in and line out connections and not the speaker level connections. Without a preamp to split the signal between two amps I often use Y cables from the source and feed both amps simultaneously.

Another option is to connect your source directly to the plate amp's line in RCA's and then line out to the MP's inputs. The signal to the MP would not be altered as the plate amp's line out is pass through.

An option to Y cable splitters would be this:

RCASplitterZOOM.jpg
 
If I got a single plate amp, for example a Dayton Audio SA100, what would the wiring look like?

Something like this?

- Two pairs of Speaker wires (+/- left channel & +/- left channel) from speaker output on MP-301 amp ⇒ into hi-level inputs "from amplifier" binding posts on the Dayton Audio SA100 ⇒ then 2 pairs of speaker wire (+/- left channel & +/- left channel) from "to speakers" binding posts on Dayton Audio SA100 ⇒ one set of speaker wires to Alpha 15A on left baffle and one set of speaker wires to Alpha 15A on right baffle

AND

- Two pairs of speaker wires (+/- left channel & +/- left channel) from speaker output on MP-301 amp ⇒ into Zenith drivers

Yes

And one more thing, if I used the Dayton plate amp, would I need a Behringer CX2310?

No
 
Thanks for the replies openly bafld.

It seems like there are a few different ways to skin the proverbial cat. Is it better to use the hi-level inputs or rca inputs of the Dayton plate amp? What are the relative advantages of each? I would like to keep things simple and have as little between the amp and the drivers as possible.
 
Speaker level works well for most applications. At least with line level I know the plate amp is not restricting the speaker's ability to run full range.
 
Back
Top Bottom