• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

I'm new to OBs and have a question. if a driver show the start of a drop off at 100hz for example, if I put it in a vented cab, I will see the start to the drop off at, lets say, 60hz. does that apply to OBs as well,,,,when the cab pushes out the bass?
 
I'm new to OBs and have a question. if a driver show the start of a drop off at 100hz for example, if I put it in a vented cab, I will see the start to the drop off at, lets say, 60hz. does that apply to OBs as well,,,,when the cab pushes out the bass?
Well, since an OB is literally an open baffle, there is no "cab". You are then running a traditional enclosed speaker.
 
Ok, maybe I wasn't clear. I have drivers made for OBs. When I mount them on OBs will they have the same push of the low frequency down lower than a driver suited for a vented cabinet gets when installed in a vented cabinet? Am I making sense?
 
Ok, maybe I wasn't clear. I have drivers made for OBs. When I mount them on OBs will they have the same push of the low frequency down lower than a driver suited for a vented cabinet gets when installed in a vented cabinet? Am I making sense?

Im thinking the answer is no. The cabinet and port are used to Push Bass and lower the output from the driver. An OB driver said to roll off at 60 HZ will sound bass shy because it has no support (IE... cabinet & port) with that said many find the OB bass to be superior because while it lacks that boom kick you in the chest feeling it is much more articulate, accurate. OB bass is also not ONE NOTE as many Bass reflex designs and so much more engaging IMHO!!!!!
 
I guess I'll find out. I plan on mounting these on OBs and will take measurements. I'll post my findings. I have found over the years that one-note bass is more of a room issue than a speaker issue. I have bass traps in all four corners but not installed in my new room yet. I'll take measurements before and after bass traps.
 
40hz is about the lower limit for OB bass which pretty well covers the acoustic jazz I favor. Adding a box sub gets you lower with visceral impact but unlike OB bass the sound travels through walls. So much of the things we know and accept about box speakers don't necessarily apply to open baffles.
 
Last edited:
I do have 4 subs in my room but I am trying to get a real flavor for OBs so I don't want to include them right now.
 
I have bass traps in all four corners but not installed in my new room yet. I'll take measurements before and after bass traps.
Initially, I situated my small forest of cylindrical bass traps equilaterally about the room as well. After experimenting and measuring the results, I found the most neutral bass response was achieved by stuffing all the big ones behind the stats - which are are true boxless dipoles as well. My experience is that dipole bass linearity is also greatly affected by distance to front wall. I started with the Rule of Thirds and found that distance just about right.

Just a suggestion...
 
Please forgive me as I am new to OB and want to get started before spending for new traditional enclosed. If I want that low-end bass, do I get a sub or use a combination? I listen to mostly 60-70s rock & blues along with a little classical or jazz. Or is it possible to get the bass with a large driver?
 
I had a pair of OBs long ago and for rock and funk they needed subs. for Jazz and classical they didn't. I use Super Chunk bass traps in all four corners and four subs and my bass and sub bass is tight and I can hear every different note clearly. Also, where ever I am in the room the bass/sub bass is at the same volume. These new drivers start to roll off at 100hz so I ASSUME I will need to keep the subs in the system....but I'll listen to them without the subs just to know how they sound.
 
These new drivers start to roll off at 100hz so I ASSUME I will need to keep the subs in the system....but I'll listen to them without the subs just to know how they sound.
The roll-off will depend on the baffle dimensions as much as on the driver.
 
P1050703.jpg P1050707.jpg That is true. My first and only OB build was an OB-Line Array-eWave and the baffles where three feet wide and the line of 4" drivers were way off to one side. I modeled it in the EDGE program first and they had great bass.
 
Last edited:
My Lowthers are due for some service the only US rep for Lowther is David Dicks at Commonsense Audio. I asked him about repairs or trades his response was to tell me how bad my PM4a sounds and I should buy his AN 8" drivers as even his cheapest 275.00 driver sounds better than anything lowther offers. I pushed ahead with my request he tells me cones and surrounds will cost 1000. or he will give me 200.00 trade in for my 3000.00 drivers.

I contacted Lowther directly they will repair to as new and return my drivers for 1020.00 (thats new cones, coils, surrounds, spiders and frame if they deem it necessary) Looks like my lowthers are headed across the pond for some love. (David Dicks has lost me as a customer for life)

Finished my baffle project this am except for some trim temporarily using my tang bands till I get the lowthers taken care of, Wife & I are both happy with the look. Bass is plenty now what to do with a quad of goldwood 18's

OB today.PNG
 
My Lowthers are due for some service the only US rep for Lowther is David Dicks at Commonsense Audio. I asked him about repairs or trades his response was to tell me how bad my PM4a sounds and I should buy his AN 8" drivers as even his cheapest 275.00 driver sounds better than anything lowther offers. I pushed ahead with my request he tells me cones and surrounds will cost 1000. or he will give me 200.00 trade in for my 3000.00 drivers.

I contacted Lowther directly they will repair to as new and return my drivers for 1020.00 (thats new cones, coils, surrounds, spiders and frame if they deem it necessary) Looks like my lowthers are headed across the pond for some love. (David Dicks has lost me as a customer for life)

Finished my baffle project this am except for some trim temporarily using my tang bands till I get the lowthers taken care of, Wife & I are both happy with the look. Bass is plenty now what to do with a quad of goldwood 18's

View attachment 1690460
Have you mentioned to Lowther that their only US rep is trying to push his drivers, on people who are looking to service or replace theirs? They might rethink the arrangement.
 
My Lowthers are due for some service the only US rep for Lowther is David Dicks at Commonsense Audio. I asked him about repairs or trades his response was to tell me how bad my PM4a sounds and I should buy his AN 8" drivers as even his cheapest 275.00 driver sounds better than anything lowther offers. I pushed ahead with my request he tells me cones and surrounds will cost 1000. or he will give me 200.00 trade in for my 3000.00 drivers.

I contacted Lowther directly they will repair to as new and return my drivers for 1020.00 (thats new cones, coils, surrounds, spiders and frame if they deem it necessary) Looks like my lowthers are headed across the pond for some love. (David Dicks has lost me as a customer for life)

Finished my baffle project this am except for some trim temporarily using my tang bands till I get the lowthers taken care of, Wife & I are both happy with the look. Bass is plenty now what to do with a quad of goldwood 18's

View attachment 1690460

Every time I've talked to David he is always pushing his AN's. His website however seems very pro Lowther especially the DX3 which I have. He recommends a bass reflex design for the Lowthers which is contrary to what the experts say.
 
I had a pair of OBs long ago and for rock and funk they needed subs. for Jazz and classical they didn't. I use Super Chunk bass traps in all four corners and four subs and my bass and sub bass is tight and I can hear every different note clearly. Also, where ever I am in the room the bass/sub bass is at the same volume. These new drivers start to roll off at 100hz so I ASSUME I will need to keep the subs in the system....but I'll listen to them without the subs just to know how they sound.

What are bass traps? Used with OB systems?
 
Interesting and thank you. I’m using two big couches and a huge lazy boy chair for porous traps. Never knew they had a specific name.
 
The rear wave is what makes open baffles special and you want to make sure it's not absorbed.

The further out into the room they're placed the better they'll sound.
 
My first and only OB build was an OB-Line Array-eWave and the baffles where three feet wide and the line of 4" drivers were way off to one side. I modeled it in the EDGE program first and they had great bass.
Interesting. I haven't seen that software before. Do you have a link?
 
Back
Top Bottom