• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Nicely done closet conversion. Now I don't feel so bad about my garage/shop space:View attachment 2586336
Prototype OB's of scrap ¼"x21"x36" ply, and positioned a bit close. The receiver stack is on the blue shelf. A sub would take the place of all the stuff on top of the three-drawer unit.

View attachment 2586337
I spend most of my time between the workbench, the table saw (which also serves as a backup bench) and my bandsaw, just out of view to the right. The OB's can be moved closer to the gable wall by adding a few 2x4's. Currently, they're 4' away, but the tilt adds distance, and kicks the rear sound the wrong way. The Sony's have their backs cut off, but can be restored. If I go with the Lii Audio F-15's, they would be face mounted on ¾" x 24"x 36" pine panels.


The F-15's are designed to move air in free space so they should sound much better than the Sony's. Less expensive options would be large wide band drivers from the 50's-60's pulled from tube consoles and organs. Brands like Zenith, Rola, Magnavox, Heppner, Conn, etc with alnico motors and ribbed cones are popular today used as guitar speakers in open back cabinets. A current 12" driver which performs well in OB's that I could envision hanging from your rafters is the Eminence Beta 12LTA. Its downside is it might need a tweeter depending on one's HF hearing.

I wouldn't buy the sub first as the OB bass might be acceptable for your tastes. Plus you can build a better sub for less money than you can buy. You certainly have the know how and tools to come up with something very interesting so keep us posted.
 
Last edited:
... A current 12" driver which performs well in OB's that I could envision hanging from your rafters is the Eminence Beta 12LTA. Its downside is it might need a tweeter depending on one's HF hearing...

At $100 each, I'll certainly take a hard look. I do have a serious hearing deficiency, which my ART15 band EQ corrects nicely without aids. As for needing a tweeter in addition to the woofer-driver, anything above 7-8KHz simply does not exist to me, EQ, aids, or not, but I don't feel I'm missing much.
Do you still think a subwoofer would be needed with the Eminence?
Before I get serious about a sub ($$$), my next step, prototype-wise, will be to move those OBs toward the end wall another foot (hanging from added 2x4's), and then place horizontal sheets of cardboard about a foot or two above them to test as "reflectors", if that's the right acoustical term. If successful, I'm thinking ¼" ply with rib stiffeners as a permanent reflector. Thanks again for your insight; this is a juicy project for me.
 
At $100 each, I'll certainly take a hard look. I do have a serious hearing deficiency, which my ART15 band EQ corrects nicely without aids. As for needing a tweeter in addition to the woofer-driver, anything above 7-8KHz simply does not exist to me, EQ, aids, or not, but I don't feel I'm missing much.
Do you still think a subwoofer would be needed with the Eminence?
Before I get serious about a sub ($$$), my next step, prototype-wise, will be to move those OBs toward the end wall another foot (hanging from added 2x4's), and then place horizontal sheets of cardboard about a foot or two above them to test as "reflectors", if that's the right acoustical term. If successful, I'm thinking ¼" ply with rib stiffeners as a permanent reflector. Thanks again for your insight; this is a juicy project for me.

Sounds like a good plan.
 
At $100 each, I'll certainly take a hard look. I do have a serious hearing deficiency, which my ART15 band EQ corrects nicely without aids. As for needing a tweeter in addition to the woofer-driver, anything above 7-8KHz simply does not exist to me, EQ, aids, or not, but I don't feel I'm missing much.
Do you still think a subwoofer would be needed with the Eminence?
Before I get serious about a sub ($$$), my next step, prototype-wise, will be to move those OBs toward the end wall another foot (hanging from added 2x4's), and then place horizontal sheets of cardboard about a foot or two above them to test as "reflectors", if that's the right acoustical term. If successful, I'm thinking ¼" ply with rib stiffeners as a permanent reflector. Thanks again for your insight; this is a juicy project for me.

Another candidate and even better value are the Betsy drivers from Wild Burro Audio Labs. Smaller than the Betas but a higher Qts they might be the way to go in your situation.

https://wildburroaudio.com/speakers/
 
Another candidate and even better value are the Betsy drivers from Wild Burro Audio Labs. Smaller than the Betas but a higher Qts they might be the way to go in your situation. https://wildburroaudio.com/speakers/

I've been looking at the 8" Betsy's also, very seriously. Although on a budget, I do not want to regret not spending a bit more. The elephant in the room is if my main driver choice still needed an active subwoofer. Even DIY, they are expensive. Ebay has a bunch, and I'm looking and learning.

But, a quick update: yesterday, leaving the Sony's mounted as shown in the photos (post 4882), I tossed some big cardboard scraps (from an old wide screen TV box) on top of the joists, to make a crude but even horizontal reflector for the back-tilted OBs. That essentially replaced the much higher (and slanted) roof and gable wall as the OB reflector. The change was, to quote someone that comes to mind, an EPIPHANY. So I cranked up the Tacoma, made the 10 mile trip to the local lumberyard, and plunked down $50 for a sheet of 15/32" CDX ply (remember, elegance is not an option). Today, I'll replace the cardboard with the entire 4'x8' sheet, and report the results. An added thought: If a sub is eventually added, why not from between the joists, 8' high?
 
OK the plywood has replaced the cardboard, with not much difference, if any, that my ears can tell. That says a lot to anyone out there that has doubts about using cardboard as a quick and "free" way to tune your OB's: it works!
 
Tried the Lii Audio F-15's on the big flat baffles without bass assist. I could immediately tell that I miss the H-frame Alphas. The wider baffles also seem to mask some of the back wave. So much for this experiment.

P1010011 3.jpeg
 
Well that's slightly discouraging. As you mentioned I would likely need a subwoofer with a pair of those '15's, which prices me out.

What would you say to a pair of Betsy OB's, with a DIY bucket sub? Use an 8" Peerless SLS subwoofer (why not 10"?), a Dayton SA-70 or SA-100 amp (it has to have a high level vs. low level input; and as an option to the 5 gal bucket, I have 6.6 gal, strong with screw-on lid. Yes I would be willing to spend more on noticeably better sound.
 
Well that's slightly discouraging. As you mentioned I would likely need a subwoofer with a pair of those '15's, which prices me out.

What would you say to a pair of Betsy OB's, with a DIY bucket sub? Use an 8" Peerless SLS subwoofer (why not 10"?), a Dayton SA-70 or SA-100 amp (it has to have a high level vs. low level input; and as an option to the 5 gal bucket, I have 6.6 gal, strong with screw-on lid. Yes I would be willing to spend more on noticeably better sound.

I’m not sure how this will fit in to the audiokarma protocol, but as a fellow sincere-but-broke audioholic, I have a pair of Betsy’s that I would like to send you (I replaced them with Betsy Alnico’s a few years ago). I would just ask that you pay the shipping - I’m in Mississippi - 39047. If you would like them, let me know.
 
Last edited:
Well that's slightly discouraging. As you mentioned I would likely need a subwoofer with a pair of those '15's, which prices me out.

What would you say to a pair of Betsy OB's, with a DIY bucket sub? Use an 8" Peerless SLS subwoofer (why not 10"?), a Dayton SA-70 or SA-100 amp (it has to have a high level vs. low level input; and as an option to the 5 gal bucket, I have 6.6 gal, strong with screw-on lid. Yes I would be willing to spend more on noticeably better sound.

I would stick with these plans. The only thing I did different is to cut a wooden ring which fits under the plastic baffle and gives a solid surface to screw the Peerless to.

https://www.transcendentsound.com/bucket-sub.html
 
Tried the Lii Audio F-15's on the big flat baffles without bass assist. I could immediately tell that I miss the H-frame Alphas. The wider baffles also seem to mask some of the back wave. So much for this experiment.

View attachment 2589046
So they don’t do as well in the bass department as advertised? If this is the case, seems like it would make little sense to use the 15, is bass support is needed anyways. The whole idea to the 15in full range is that it can be played stand alone.
 
So they don’t do as well in the bass department as advertised? If this is the case, seems like it would make little sense to use the 15, is bass support is needed anyways. The whole idea to the 15in full range is that it can be played stand alone.

Bass wise the F-15's used as single drivers are the best I've heard. No doubt many folks would be quite content with them as is. Adding additional woofers designed for open baffle use just adds so much more bass weight and presence to the music.
Poultry,

What size are the big flat baffles you use?

37" high by 30" wide represents sort of a compromise between the Decware Zens at 42 x 32 and Mr Glow-in-the-dark's which are 28 x 30.

One thing I learned is the cut out for the F-15 is not 14 inches. It's slightly larger. How much larger I don't know as I had to sand the cut out with a Dremel to make the F-15's fit.
 
Bass wise the F-15's used as single drivers are the best I've heard. No doubt many folks would be quite content with them as is. Adding additional woofers designed for open baffle use just adds so much more bass weight and presence to the music.


37" high by 30" wide represents sort of a compromise between the Decware Zens at 42 x 32 and Mr Glow-in-the-dark's which are 28 x 30.

One thing I learned is the cut out for the F-15 is not 14 inches. It's slightly larger. How much larger I don't know as I had to sand the cut out with a Dremel to make the F-15's fit.

What are you powering the F-15’s with? I’ve read several times in the last year or so, that they like a little more power, even though they are very efficient. Exactly how much, optimally, I don’t know.

Yep, Decwares biggest baffles are HUGE! I’ve always wondered how much that blocks the rear wave. I guess if the room is big enough to allow them to be pulled well out into the room, it wouldn’t be as much a factor.

When I had my baffles built, I just tried to scale them to fit my room. I made them as big as I thought my room would allow.
 
Back
Top Bottom