• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

The Betsy is an 8" OB driver not a baffle type. They are sold by Wild Burro Audio Labs. When Randy at Caintuck Audio came up with the barrel shaped baffle he first used the Betsy driver so I guess that's how the guy in the video confused one with the other.

Yep. Steve Deckert is to blame for that. When he got involved scaling them up, he mistakenly referred to the setup, no matter the driver used, as a ‘Betsy’. Randy tried to get him to understand that it was the Wild Burro 8” that was called Betsy. As a matter of fact, there was a bit of a rift between Doug at Wild Burro and Deckert over this. But it was too late, since the setup had been called that on the forum for a while. Now, I see the barrel shaped baffles called ‘Betsy Baffles’ all over the internet.
 
The more I listen to bass heavy music the more I like pairing the F-15 with the H-frame Eminence Alphas. It's not that the F-15's don't play low enough but rather the Alphas give some nice weight to the bass. I would think the W-15's do the same.
 
The more I listen to bass heavy music the more I like pairing the F-15 with the H-frame Eminence Alphas. It's not that the F-15's don't play low enough but rather the Alphas give some nice weight to the bass. I would think the W-15's do the same.

I’ve never even heard the F-15’s. I had Randy’s original Betsy Baffles, then when all the hubbub on the Decware forum started, involving upscaling and the newly discovered Lii drivers, I ordered the Crystal 10’s, and then a bit later, the W-15’s. Others went with the F-15’s and loved them.

So, what I’ve had are the only open baffle setups I’ve heard. And the only amp/speaker configurations. So I have no frame of reference as far as what others describe as better or worse as comparisons.

The only thing I know for sure is that when I got my present system setup, I was very satisfied, and that has not changed for several years now. I’m a happy camper.

I would love to be able to get together with others, and talk shop, while listening to their open baffles. That is something I’ve wanted to do for quite sometime. I say talk ‘shop’, but I am not very technical at all. I trust my ears, but much had to be explained to me on the Decware forum, before I could understand how to even setup up what I now have.
 
Last edited:
Looks like the idea is to use the small driver for highs, rolling the lows off naturally. And….using the large driver for lows, rolling off the highs naturally. Between the two, there will be some overlap. By rolling the drivers off naturally and running them in parallel, you don’t need a passive crossover and you can get by with a single amplifier.

Sounds like a good way to minimize the amount of gear required to run the system. The downside is that the response of most drivers tends to get a bit erratic and distorted when they roll off at the end of their usable frequency range.

He is putting an 8 inch wideband driver next to a 15 inch wideband driver and they both produce basically the same frequencies, he may like it, but I know I wouldn't.
No different than putting 8 inch 2 way speakers next to 15 inch 2 ways and playing them together on one amplifier. :eek:
 
He is putting an 8 inch wideband driver next to a 15 inch wideband driver and they both produce basically the same frequencies, he may like it, but I know I wouldn't.
No different than putting 8 inch 2 way speakers next to 15 inch 2 ways and playing them together on one amplifier. :eek:

I have the same thoughts but am really surprised by all those youtube videos ( there are others I didn't link ) that praise that combination.
 
I have the same thoughts but am really surprised by all those youtube videos ( there are others I didn't link ) that praise that combination.
Looking at the response graphs, the 8 plays higher, the 15 plays lower. It’s an obvious attempt at getting the best of both worlds.
 
I have the same thoughts but am really surprised by all those youtube videos ( there are others I didn't link ) that praise that combination.

A lot of people like things I don't, as some say, to each their own.

When I was using 4 or 5 Visaton B 200s (one fullrange, the rest bass only), there was a discussion about comb filtering and whether it was really as much of a problem as measurements first type individuals claimed. IIRC one person felt that paralleling drivers vs series/parallel helped wrt comb filtering, so I tried 4 - B200s (6ohms) in parallel, all fullrange, because I had 2 amplifiers that could handle the load. At the time I could not hear any difference sitting in the sweet spot between one driver fullrange vs all the drivers fullrange. This was obviously with all identical drivers mounted vertically.
 
I hope a slight change of subject is OK. I followed a different path to add a measure of dipolar magic to my DIY fully horn loaded, triamplified horn speakers. The range from 200 Hz to 8 kHZ is provided by Oris 150 horns driven by AER BD3 drivers. The Oris horn designer, Bert Dopenberg, recommends a ported plywood cover for the back of the horn's back chamber. As an experiment I left the back off the back chamber so that the AER driver radiates sound out of both the front and the rear of the horn. I really liked the resulting sound, especially the improved depth of the image.
At 200 Hz the front wave is somewhere between six and ten dB louder than the back wave because of the boost provided by the horn. On up toward 1 kHz where the horn unloads the two are of equal volume all the way up to 8 kHz. As a former electrostat and Magnepan owner I really appreciate the dipole sound. My present arrangement gives me the great dynamics and sensitivity of horns with some of the benefits of open baffle.
 
I hope a slight change of subject is OK. I followed a different path to add a measure of dipolar magic to my DIY fully horn loaded, triamplified horn speakers. The range from 200 Hz to 8 kHZ is provided by Oris 150 horns driven by AER BD3 drivers. The Oris horn designer, Bert Dopenberg, recommends a ported plywood cover for the back of the horn's back chamber. As an experiment I left the back off the back chamber so that the AER driver radiates sound out of both the front and the rear of the horn. I really liked the resulting sound, especially the improved depth of the image.
At 200 Hz the front wave is somewhere between six and ten dB louder than the back wave because of the boost provided by the horn. On up toward 1 kHz where the horn unloads the two are of equal volume all the way up to 8 kHz. As a former electrostat and Magnepan owner I really appreciate the dipole sound. My present arrangement gives me the great dynamics and sensitivity of horns with some of the benefits of open baffle.

Pictures please…
 
auto
 
The first part of your reply is an oversimplification of what he is referring to.
The second part of your reply has not been my experience.
How's fact a oversimplification? It's physics, it's how it works .

Dipole speaker do suffer from cancellations, unless you think that out of phase back wave just "disappears" not how that works unfortunately.
 
This thread (maybe call it bridge suspension cable by now) has been gnawing on me, especially its recent emphasis on the Lii Audio F-15, which I'm looking at hard for my two-car garage/workshop. With no more floor space, I have to go vertical and use the open ceiling joists (21' long timbers, spaced 4' apart, 8' high) as mounting points. So, two OBs of about 2'h x 3'w, hinged under a joist, angled, with an average distance of 5' from their backs to a gable end wall. Elegance is not an option, only performance. I've recently tried a pair of Sony SS-MB300H's in this concept, but not enough oomph. They need not serve the whole shop, but about ⅓ of the floor space. I'm an old guy, raised building '50's vintage Karlson enclosures and dabbling with the Sweet Sixteen concept, wearing out a pair of Bose 901's, and determined to go out listening to good music. What I'm after here is opinions of those that have the F-15s, or other comparable full range drivers. Yes I can do the (ugly) photos, if really necessary.
 
This thread (maybe call it bridge suspension cable by now) has been gnawing on me, especially its recent emphasis on the Lii Audio F-15, which I'm looking at hard for my two-car garage/workshop. With no more floor space, I have to go vertical and use the open ceiling joists (21' long timbers, spaced 4' apart, 8' high) as mounting points. So, two OBs of about 2'h x 3'w, hinged under a joist, angled, with an average distance of 5' from their backs to a gable end wall. Elegance is not an option, only performance. I've recently tried a pair of Sony SS-MB300H's in this concept, but not enough oomph. They need not serve the whole shop, but about ⅓ of the floor space. I'm an old guy, raised building '50's vintage Karlson enclosures and dabbling with the Sweet Sixteen concept, wearing out a pair of Bose 901's, and determined to go out listening to good music. What I'm after here is opinions of those that have the F-15s, or other comparable full range drivers. Yes I can do the (ugly) photos, if really necessary.

Worth a try but you'll probably need a sub tucked away on the floor.
 
What exactly is your meaning here? What specifically do you mean when you say “depth of the image?”

When open baffle/dipole/bipole speakers are placed far enough away from the front wall the distance delayed reflection contributes to depth of the soundstage.
 
How's fact a oversimplification? It's physics, it's how it works .

Dipole speaker do suffer from cancellations, unless you think that out of phase back wave just "disappears" not how that works unfortunately.

You can only play the "fact" and "physics" cards when you know all (or at least most) of the facts and physics.
The post you originally quoted gave a clue, "dipole peak", all you had to do was some research.

http://musicanddesign.speakerdesign.net/Dipoles_and_open_baffles.html
 
Worth a try but you'll probably need a sub tucked away on the floor.

Well if I'm going to need a sub for the F-15's, then I may buy the sub first, to see how it goes with the existing Sony's. Zero floor space available for that, as mentioned before, but possibly on top of a 36" high storage unit, behind and centered on the speakers. Thanks for the suggestion. By the way, in an earlier post of yours, you mentioned a "2.2 rule" for the OB size. I couldn't find any such reference anywhere, but wonder if it's OB width = 2.2x speaker diameter?
 
bingow,

The 2.2 rule : "As a rule of thumb the baffle width should not exceed 2.2 times the cone diameter to keep the driver below the dipole peak."

I've never tried OB's hanging from the ceiling but I did try them hanging in a closet where they greatly outperformed box speakers. The bass was weak but subs made them quite listenable. Another option for a driver might be in-ceiling speakers which some folks use in open baffle builds.

P1010003 2.jpeg
 
Nicely done closet conversion. Now I don't feel so bad about my garage/shop space:DSCN4212.jpeg
Prototype OB's of scrap ¼"x21"x36" ply, and positioned a bit close. The receiver stack is on the blue shelf. A sub would take the place of all the stuff on top of the three-drawer unit.

DSCN4213.jpeg
I spend most of my time between the workbench, the table saw (which also serves as a backup bench) and my bandsaw, just out of view to the right. The OB's can be moved closer to the gable wall by adding a few 2x4's. Currently, they're 4' away, but the tilt adds distance, and kicks the rear sound the wrong way. The Sony's have their backs cut off, but can be restored. If I go with the Lii Audio F-15's, they would be face mounted on ¾" x 24"x 36" pine panels.
 
Back
Top Bottom