• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Hi All. I just got home from picking up a pair of Carver Amazing Silver speakers in piano black and got them set up only to realize they are open baffle. We’re going to a MD picnic and we fire them up when I get back.
 
Green Glue is often used between layered baffles to dampen resonance. Magnet mounting is also a solution to decouple the driver from the baffle. Both are good choices if you enjoy music played at high SPL's.

green-glue-ul-certified-1.jpg
 
I seek driver to baffle isolation. It doesn’t have to be perfect.
Personally, I don't think that's feasible. The weight of a driver makes compliant mounting impractical in my opinion.
Since a flat board is unsupported at its edges, that's where a lot of movement occurs. Adding reinforcement at the edges, similar to what the SFB baffles have, would be an effective way to suppress unwanted movement.
 
Personally, I don't think that's feasible. The weight of a driver makes compliant mounting impractical in my opinion.
Since a flat board is unsupported at its edges, that's where a lot of movement occurs. Adding reinforcement at the edges, similar to what the SFB baffles have, would be an effective way to suppress unwanted movement.


I did mine exactly like this. The added reinforcement from the edges, Combined with the damping material, not only eliminated any resonance, but also aided in a more controlled baffle peaking frequency and lower baffle cutoff frequency.

I did a 3 component filter (Cap/Coil/Resistor Notch filter) to bring down the peaking that occurs and it sounded fantastic.
I would say the best of both worlds!Sunflower3.JPG
 
Last edited:
Here is an idea…

Currently full range and LF drivers are on the same baffle, as such the frames of all the drivers are coupled together.

The goal is to decouple the drivers so that the LF drivers are not rattling the full range drivers and do so without changing the physical location of any drivers.

What if I removed the LF drivers and put them on their own baffle. Then I located the new baffle in front of the original baffle (which still has the full ranger drivers), utilizing the original speaker cutouts, and maintaining a 1/4in gap between the new baffle and the original. This keeps LF driver to full range driver distance the same while eliminating driver to driver interaction. The new baffle would have its own structural support and would not be touching the original. This would also pull the LF drivers away from the original baffle a bit, which is good as that would put the voice coils of the LF drivers and full range drivers into alignment.

What do you think ?
 
Here is an idea…

Currently full range and LF drivers are on the same baffle, as such the frames of all the drivers are coupled together.

The goal is to decouple the drivers so that the LF drivers are not rattling the full range drivers and do so without changing the physical location of any drivers.

What if I removed the LF drivers and put them on their own baffle. Then I located the new baffle in front of the original baffle (which still has the full ranger drivers), utilizing the original speaker cutouts, and maintaining a 1/4in gap between the new baffle and the original. This keeps LF driver to full range driver distance the same while eliminating driver to driver interaction. The new baffle would have its own structural support and would not be touching the original. This would also pull the LF drivers away from the original baffle a bit, which is good as that would put the voice coils of the LF drivers and full range drivers into alignment.

What do you think ?

If using a true OB bass woofer there shouldn't be any rattling of the baffle. OB bass woofers have loose cones/suspension with high Qts ( .7 at a minimum but higher is better ) so they can move more air in free space. A low Qts woofer with tight cone/suspension needs a box and depends on the air in the box to function like a spring.
 
Last edited:
Here is an idea…

Currently full range and LF drivers are on the same baffle, as such the frames of all the drivers are coupled together.

The goal is to decouple the drivers so that the LF drivers are not rattling the full range drivers and do so without changing the physical location of any drivers.

What if I removed the LF drivers and put them on their own baffle. Then I located the new baffle in front of the original baffle (which still has the full ranger drivers), utilizing the original speaker cutouts, and maintaining a 1/4in gap between the new baffle and the original. This keeps LF driver to full range driver distance the same while eliminating driver to driver interaction. The new baffle would have its own structural support and would not be touching the original. This would also pull the LF drivers away from the original baffle a bit, which is good as that would put the voice coils of the LF drivers and full range drivers into alignment.

What do you think ?
That sounds like it would decouple the LF baffle perfectly! Also time aligning the speakers would never hurt. I say it is time to put down the coffee cup
and make a go of it:beerchug:!!!
 
If using a true OB bass woofer there shouldn't be any rattling of the baffle. OB bass woofers have loose cones/suspension with high Qts ( .7 at a minimum but higher is better ) so they can move more air in free space. A low Qts woofer with tight cone/suspension needs a box and depends on the air in the box to function like a spring.
The woofer in question would qualify as "true OB" then because the QTS = 1.1

And to be clear, the full range drivers are getting "vibrated". As in, remove power from the full range driver, keep power to the woofer, turn up volume a little, place your finger tips on the cone of the full range driver. In this case the cones are moving a decent amount and I seek to eliminate this as I am convinced that as is they do not sound as good as they would of the woofer was decoupled mechanically. Distortion has to be on the up and up as long as the woofer is vibrating them.
 
^ That isn't an OB, it's an NB. :rflmao:

Mounting a speaker with no baffle might solve one issue, but creates far larger issues with frequency response, cancellation frequency and the resultant peaking response, by having equal distance at all parts of the speakers back and front wave.

That is literally the most unforgiving type of response and why a speaker out on the open sounds horrible in most ways.

My very first speaker experiments at around age 10 were with car speakers mounted with no baffle on 2 Vises on my dads workbench. They were fun, but when he saw them, he helped me make a rudimentary baffle on some 1x8 pine board, and things progressed from there!
 
Last edited:
The woofer in question would qualify as "true OB" then because the QTS = 1.1

And to be clear, the full range drivers are getting "vibrated". As in, remove power from the full range driver, keep power to the woofer, turn up volume a little, place your finger tips on the cone of the full range driver. In this case the cones are moving a decent amount and I seek to eliminate this as I am convinced that as is they do not sound as good as they would of the woofer was decoupled mechanically. Distortion has to be on the up and up as long as the woofer is vibrating them.

A fellow in the Lii Audio Facebook group designed these. The full-ranger is not completely isolated from the bass driver, but only having a narrow connect point between top and bottom has to greatly reduce vibration.

EAA261BB-F3BC-4A56-B286-6B7C3F2AE9E4.jpeg 4A969994-CFB3-4E74-AC16-C21E6F23DA2D.png
 
The woofer in question would qualify as "true OB" then because the QTS = 1.1

And to be clear, the full range drivers are getting "vibrated". As in, remove power from the full range driver, keep power to the woofer, turn up volume a little, place your finger tips on the cone of the full range driver. In this case the cones are moving a decent amount and I seek to eliminate this as I am convinced that as is they do not sound as good as they would of the woofer was decoupled mechanically. Distortion has to be on the up and up as long as the woofer is vibrating them.
Not sure if this might be the cause but just some food for thought: did you short out the full range drivers when you disconnected them? The air pressure alone from the other speakers can cause a passive cone to vibrate. A simple wire between the two terminals of the fully disconnected full range is all it takes.
 
Not sure if this might be the cause but just some food for thought: did you short out the full range drivers when you disconnected them? The air pressure alone from the other speakers can cause a passive cone to vibrate. A simple wire between the two terminals of the fully disconnected full range is all it takes.
I did not short them out. I’ll try that next time I have them up and running.
 
Back
Top Bottom