• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Pictures are always good for ideas so here is a few of my current experiments

I tend to like folded baffles or boffles as they can be called, my thinking is it keeps the baffle narrow for improved imaging but the wings long enough to keep the dipole peak lower and close to the crossover point

the sectional curved baffle with the Tang band 1808 is a new addition and on first listen it was obviously more extended in the top end and I thought better than the cheapies in the tower. But after listening for a while I found I preferred the imaging and tonal qualities of the cheapies even though it was obvious the top end was rolled off. Then in an accident I found running them both together seemed to provide the best qualities of both even though I know the there are reasons why it shouldn’t work.

I find I need to break up my critical listening with periods of relaxed listening to really pick up differences between
 

Attachments

  • 2122A6C6-7E7B-48C2-AFE2-4E9A07EDDEE4.jpeg
    2122A6C6-7E7B-48C2-AFE2-4E9A07EDDEE4.jpeg
    45.7 KB · Views: 40
  • DADC7F91-3EF8-4036-B64E-9AD1F154C8FB.jpeg
    DADC7F91-3EF8-4036-B64E-9AD1F154C8FB.jpeg
    79.9 KB · Views: 40
  • C7B79DE6-B373-4C67-A191-FCEF84AFA77C.jpeg
    C7B79DE6-B373-4C67-A191-FCEF84AFA77C.jpeg
    98.3 KB · Views: 38
  • 9660687F-B8A8-479F-AC87-598883FD81AB.jpeg
    9660687F-B8A8-479F-AC87-598883FD81AB.jpeg
    98.3 KB · Views: 37
So Andrew basically said if you can live with them 3 feet from the wall and add a “h” frame woofer you’ve got a speaker as good as anything out there
 
You can read thread after thread of discussions regarding wide vs narrow open baffles. I've tried both as well as all sorts of fixed and folding wings. Every design has its own advantages and disadvantages. The only thing written in stone is one's individual preference and that can be subject to change.. Folks just need to decide what works for them and be respectful of other's preference. It's all a compromise anyway and as in a good marriage "we give up some things to get other things". When someone says there's only one way to get X results my answer lies in the lyrics of the Cole Porter song, "Experiment". We may learn from reading but having the practical experience of "doing" goes a lot further.

Here is the F-15 used in a smaller baffle. My first thought might be that the baffle is too limiting but then I remembered playing with baffle-less speakers suspended by wires which really surprised me. I don't know anyone clairvoyant enough to know how an OB sounds without hearing it.

Redoak_natural_small.jpg
 
Last edited:
I tried open back boxes for mids/highs early in my Dark Star journey and found they ruined many of what I felt were the benefits of OB.
IME/O, YMMV, FWIW, etc.
 
Last edited:
Initial cutouts for OBs centered on a Zenith 1045, Eminence ASD 1001, and two Alphas per side.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20220514_2150121 (2).jpg
    IMG_20220514_2150121 (2).jpg
    101.4 KB · Views: 40
  • IMG_20220514_2149507.jpg
    IMG_20220514_2149507.jpg
    100.8 KB · Views: 41
Last night I went back and forth between the Zeniths and F-15's and could not declare a winner. They both have very endearing qualities. If I can figure out an easy way to A/B them I might could pick a favorite. Maybe I can try my old Marantz amp with each speaker on different channels. It has a balance slider but I'd have to account for different content from each channel? Very little difference it these speaker's sensitivity.
 
Last edited:
If I can figure out an easy way to A/B them I might could pick a favorite. Maybe I can try my old Marantz amp with each speaker on different channels. It has a balance slider but I'd have to account for different content from each channel?

Use the L or R channel of your source into both inputs on the Marantz.
 
Excellent! With that combination of drivers you should have years of enjoyment.
My current state of speakers, with the 10 inch Zenith 1043 Alnico on top, and my unknown 12 inch Alnico woofer on the bottom. The woofer is shiny from several thin coats
of water based poly, an experiment to lower Fs., and raise Qts. How much, can't tell you without equipment to measure, but from ear data, it seemed to add
some solidity and clarity compared to an uncoated comparison. The bottom woofer is separated from the top Zenith, but each enclosure is basically what I
would call a U-baffle, open to the back. The woofer-high midrange driver is full-range, but the Zenith has below 300 Hz. rolled off to let it focus on the mids and as
high as it can reproduce. Aimed out the back of the top part is a 1 inch cloth dome tweeter, with a 2.2uf blocking capacitor, and the tweeter is wired out of phase with
the front drivers.
The Zenith is padded down to match the woofer, but the arrangement is still very efficient. Currently I am using a restored vintage Kenwood single ended solid state
Ka-2002 amplifier, only 13 watts a channel, which has plenty of power beyond what is needed for listening. I have also used a Pass Amp Camp class A amp with only 8
watts max a channel, but with either, I am probably only using a 1 watt most of the time in a 20X18 room.
The speakers live behind protective screens because they live in Kitty territory:)
 

Attachments

  • S1.JPG
    S1.JPG
    107.4 KB · Views: 41
  • S2.JPG
    S2.JPG
    127.3 KB · Views: 39
I posted a link to Erin's Audio Corner youTube interview with Greg Timbers, former Chief engineer with JBL (through all the glory years - mid-70s to 4 years ago when SamSung let him go)
Its a 99 Minute interview, but at about 1:20, Erin asks him about open baffles and he smiles and talks positively about them, and electrostatics and some other non-JBL tech.
Might be interesting to you all - he's a really smart, friendly guy ...
https://audiokarma.org/forums/index...ormer-jbl-chief-engineer-greg-timbers.997521/
 
The speakers live behind protective screens because they live in Kitty territory

Still can't figure out why my cat hasn't touch any of my speakers, especially the grill cloth on the Bozaks and DQ10s. ...he's destroyed the dining room chairs, and a couch, no matter how many scratching posts I put out. When I'm in that room listening, even at high volume, he insists on sitting on my lap the entire time. A strange cat that likes music.
 
Still can't figure out why my cat hasn't touch any of my speakers, especially the grill cloth on the Bozaks and DQ10s. ...he's destroyed the dining room chairs, and a couch, no matter how many scratching posts I put out. When I'm in that room listening, even at high volume, he insists on sitting on my lap the entire time. A strange cat that likes music.
They are definitely individuals with different personalities! I used to have some tall transmission line speakers, and I had a cat I dearly loved, but she would
practice her Army Ranger training by climbing up the front grill cloth when she wanted to get my attention! She never bothered anything of my wife's, but she knew
stuff that I cared about, and that stuff was in jeopardy if she got hacked at me for telling her "No!" to something she was doing. Funny thing, I have never loved an animal
more than Miss Buddy. My wife told me that Bud and me were just too much alike:angel:
 
Question:

How do you guys approach baffle to driver decoupling?

I find that with the driver (high q bass driver in this case) tightly coupled to the baffle, the baffle resonates something fierce. That is not ideal. And in ob, it is no simple task to make the baffle inert. Much easier with a cabinet. Additionally, if there happens to be a full range driver on the same baffle with the bass driver, how is all that baffle vibration going to affect the response of said full range driver? Not sure sure, but it can’t be good. Of course these issues become more severe as spl goes up. And, the vibrating baffles I am describing are 3/4in pine plywood.

Sorbothane spacer between driver and baffle? Any other ideas? Or, is this a non issue?
 
Question:

How do you guys approach baffle to driver decoupling?

I find that with the driver (high q bass driver in this case) tightly coupled to the baffle, the baffle resonates something fierce. That is not ideal. And in ob, it is no simple task to make the baffle inert. Much easier with a cabinet. Additionally, if there happens to be a full range driver on the same baffle with the bass driver, how is all that baffle vibration going to affect the response of said full range driver? Not sure sure, but it can’t be good. Of course these issues become more severe as spl goes up. And, the vibrating baffles I am describing are 3/4in pine plywood.

Sorbothane spacer between driver and baffle? Any other ideas? Or, is this a non issue?
You have probably seen that some of the commercial designs make the baffles separate for the individual drivers. In my humble OB's, they started out as traditional
speaker cabinets that have had their backs removed, I guess that you would call them a U-Baffle? The bass 12 inch Alnico woofer baffle is actually a separate cabinet
that is bolted to the top cabinet with the smaller 10 inch full range Zenith, with felt tabs separating the 2 cabinets from having direct contact with each other even though the two are bolted together to minimize vibration. The original cabinet for the full range was a Klipsch Heresy. There is an additional baffle section that
is attached to both cabinets, but everything is 3/4 inch plywood. With the additional front plate, you have 1 1/2 inch thickness. The bottom woofer cabinet
is 3/4 and lined with an additional 3/4 inch of MDF. Whether this info is helpful, not sure, but I have not had any problems with vibration. I am a conservative listener,
but have you tried just adding thicker stiffeners to your baffle, or perhaps a double layer, or just an additional layer of MDF? That stuff is really dense. There are a couple photos in one of my posts above that show what my speakers look like.
 
I've tried decoupling with rubber feet between the H-frame subs and full range drivers. They might make a difference if played at high SPL's. Practice foam hokey pucks from Amazon are an option.

P8090028.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Question:

How do you guys approach baffle to driver decoupling?

I find that with the driver (high q bass driver in this case) tightly coupled to the baffle, the baffle resonates something fierce. That is not ideal. And in ob, it is no simple task to make the baffle inert. Much easier with a cabinet. Additionally, if there happens to be a full range driver on the same baffle with the bass driver, how is all that baffle vibration going to affect the response of said full range driver? Not sure sure, but it can’t be good. Of course these issues become more severe as spl goes up. And, the vibrating baffles I am describing are 3/4in pine plywood.

Sorbothane spacer between driver and baffle? Any other ideas? Or, is this a non issue?
One of the classic open baffle speakers is the Wharfedale SFB.
SFB_Brian_1.jpg

SFB stands for "sand-filled baffle". The construction (as I understand it) is two boards with a gap between them, filled with sand. The baffle has two shallow wings too, but they're more for rigidity and to act as a stand than to extend the baffle.
http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/SFB.htm
https://www.inner-magazines.com/audiophilia/wharfedale-sfb3/
You'll find plenty of results if you search for "Wharfedale SFB".
 
One of the classic open baffle speakers is the Wharfedale SFB.
SFB_Brian_1.jpg

SFB stands for "sand-filled baffle". The construction (as I understand it) is two boards with a gap between them, filled with sand. The baffle has two shallow wings too, but they're more for rigidity and to act as a stand than to extend the baffle.
http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/SFB.htm
https://www.inner-magazines.com/audiophilia/wharfedale-sfb3/
You'll find plenty of results if you search for "Wharfedale SFB".

Thanks for posting this. Enjoyed the articles. I’m a bit confused about the actual build. How thick are the pieces of wood and what is the overall dimension of the sand-filled gap - L x W x H ?
 
I don't know the details but clues can be gleaned from the pictures, and there are plenty of pictures online. I'd guess the centre part of the baffle is just solid wood and it's only the outer part which is sand-filled. I'd guess two pieces of wood about 1/2 inch to 3/4 inch thick with a similar size of gap for the sand, but that's just my guess.
 
One of the classic open baffle speakers is the Wharfedale SFB.
SFB_Brian_1.jpg

SFB stands for "sand-filled baffle". The construction (as I understand it) is two boards with a gap between them, filled with sand. The baffle has two shallow wings too, but they're more for rigidity and to act as a stand than to extend the baffle.
http://www.troelsgravesen.dk/SFB.htm
https://www.inner-magazines.com/audiophilia/wharfedale-sfb3/
You'll find plenty of results if you search for "Wharfedale SFB".
This is cool and all, but a bit outside of what I am up for. I seek driver to baffle isolation. It doesn’t have to be perfect.

The driver in question has 8 bolt holes. I was thinking about using only 4, to reduce driver to baffle contact, then use a rubber type washers between the 4 bolt holes that are used and the baffle. Use another rubber washer at the nut to baffle contact point was well to isolate the mounting bolts from the baffle.

I would love a sand filled baffle. I would love a several inch thick mdf baffle. But that’s not happening. I seek to get the most out of what I have that is currently up and running rather than take on large scale projects from the ground up.

My current idea is rubber or sorbothane washers. Not perfect, but should in theory give an improvement. Any other ideas? And is my idea worthwhile?
 
Back
Top Bottom