• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

I did not short them out. I’ll try that next time I have them up and running.
Might not be the problem you're experiencing at all but at the least it can take away part of the equation.
Though most any frequency can make the passive speaker vibrate I would think the main issue would lie with the resonant frequency of the speaker.
It's pretty surprising what resonant frequencies can do, and speaker cones like just about everything have a resonant frequency. It's the stuff that opera singers use to break glasses and what brings down huge bridges. Anytime I play my electric guitar and the acoustic is in the same room when I hit certain notes the strings on the acoustic will ring out loud like someone is banging on them.
edit: man I get long winded when I'm tired
 
The Kyron Gaia NB's sell for $249,000. The big OB bass woofers look like they are from Acoustic Elegance.

gaia-speaker-min.png
 
Last edited:
The woofer in question would qualify as "true OB" then because the QTS = 1.1

And to be clear, the full range drivers are getting "vibrated". As in, remove power from the full range driver, keep power to the woofer, turn up volume a little, place your finger tips on the cone of the full range driver. In this case the cones are moving a decent amount and I seek to eliminate this as I am convinced that as is they do not sound as good as they would of the woofer was decoupled mechanically. Distortion has to be on the up and up as long as the woofer is vibrating them.

I thought the white woofers were JBL's?
 
I thought the white woofers were JBL's?
The white woofers are indeed JBL.

I am not talking about those woofers though.

I am talking about decoupling drivers from each other and/or the baffle regardless of the woofers used.

If it helps, the woofer I am trying to decouple is a Goldwood 1858, 1.1qts.
 
The white woofers are indeed JBL.

I am not talking about those woofers though.

I am talking about decoupling drivers from each other and/or the baffle regardless of the woofers used.

If it helps, the woofer I am trying to decouple is a Goldwood 1858, 1.1qts.

I was going by the picture you posted at #4619 with JBL woofers on open baffles.
 
Take a look at Steve's video that I posted above. The baffles don't have to be that big, but thickness and a thick base on the bottom helps. And being solidly on the floor too - several of us on the Decware forums use bags of steel shot on the base too.

And you should experiment tilting the baffles back at different angles. This had the most positive impact of anything I've tried.

Geno, I really enjoy your videos on Youtube with the Fast 8's and W-15 woofers. Do you bi-amp and run the Fast 8's full range? I haven't spent much time on the Decware forum as I have a problem reading that white on black background. Is it common for members with Fast 8's and F-15's to power them from the same amp wired in parallel?
 
I have asked you this question, multiple times....Never got a real answer.....
How can you run NO crossover, and have even reasonably flat response with a very small baffle?


ANY speaker mounted to a baffle where the radiation from the front, meets the back, will have a cancellation and a peaking frequency.

Cancellation will occur in the bass obviously where the wavelength from the front meeting the back wave are out of phase, and cancel each other out.

Peaking will occur at the wavelength where they are IN phase and cause an increase in volume, a 6 db increase in volume over a small band.

Look up dipole radiation pattern, it will explain precisely what a open baffle does. Cancellation happens but not in the sweet spot. Most if not all open baffle dipole speakers (so not talking bipole) cancel off axis. Nobody cares ...you won't sit beside the speakers to listen to them.

Downside you get a really narrow sweet spot least that's how I understand it.
 
I can see how those JBL's would rattle the baffle.
As a matter of fact, the four 14in JBL woofers combined don’t vibrate the baffle nearly as much as the single 18in Goldwood.

The Goldwood is on a 36in x 36in baffle. The JBLs are on a 48in x 48in. Same materials, same construction.
 
Look up dipole radiation pattern, it will explain precisely what a open baffle does. Cancellation happens but not in the sweet spot. Most if not all open baffle dipole speakers (so not talking bipole) cancel off axis. Nobody cares ...you won't sit beside the speakers to listen to them.

Downside you get a really narrow sweet spot least that's how I understand it.

The first part of your reply is an oversimplification of what he is referring to.
The second part of your reply has not been my experience.
 
Geno, I really enjoy your videos on Youtube with the Fast 8's and W-15 woofers. Do you bi-amp and run the Fast 8's full range? I haven't spent much time on the Decware forum as I have a problem reading that white on black background. Is it common for members with Fast 8's and F-15's to power them from the same amp wired in parallel?

When Steve Deckert first took Caintuck Randy’s design, and scaled it up, there were a handful of folks that jumped on the F-15 bandwagon. They were using them alone with no other driver and no bass augmentation (and still are, I think).

A few of us used the Crystal 10, W-15 combo, using a Crown sub amp for the 15’s. (I had already been using Randy’s small baffles with the 8” Alnico Betsy’s with 12” Alpha bass drivers with a sub plate amp)

There has only been one Decware forum member (that I remember), that used a small and large full-ranger together in parallel. He raved about how great it worked, but I’ve not seen any others that posted about it. There are prolly others that have tried that, but they have not posted about it, that I’ve seen anyway.
 
There has only been one Decware forum member (that I remember), that used a small and large full-ranger together in parallel. He raved about how great it worked, but I’ve not seen any others that posted about it.

The same guy said to never use a solid state preamp with a tube amp because "solid state gear otherwise kills that beautiful spatial separation of the instruments being played". :rolleyes:
 
The same guy said to never use a solid state preamp with a tube amp because "solid state gear otherwise kills that beautiful spatial separation of the instruments being played". :rolleyes:

Ha! I’ve had a short discussion with him about that, as a lot of the time, I use a Sansui integrated amp. :cool:
 
There has only been one Decware forum member (that I remember), that used a small and large full-ranger together in parallel. He raved about how great it worked, but I’ve not seen any others that posted about it. There are prolly others that have tried that, but they have not posted about it, that I’ve seen anyway.

Looks like the idea is to use the small driver for highs, rolling the lows off naturally. And….using the large driver for lows, rolling off the highs naturally. Between the two, there will be some overlap. By rolling the drivers off naturally and running them in parallel, you don’t need a passive crossover and you can get by with a single amplifier.

Sounds like a good way to minimize the amount of gear required to run the system. The downside is that the response of most drivers tends to get a bit erratic and distorted when they roll off at the end of their usable frequency range.
 
This is the guy I was referring to. Goes by Dr.D on the Decware forum.

The Betsy is an 8" OB driver not a baffle type. They are sold by Wild Burro Audio Labs. When Randy at Caintuck Audio came up with the barrel shaped baffle he first used the Betsy driver so I guess that's how the guy in the video confused one with the other.
 
Back
Top Bottom