• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Are the Zenith's starting to get nervous about their position? It will be interesting to hear about the differences between the F-15
and the vintage sound. Was there any information about the new mentioned improvement in magnet in the F-15 now over the
previous version?

My 10 inch Zeniths have mellowed, and sounding more clear in their detail as compared to first hearing. Also got some new speaker cable,
Furez 14 AWG OFC that is sounding more detailed than the previous 12 AWG Monster type wire that I had. So far, it seems like a good value for .75 a foot.
 
Have a good number of open baffle (magnepans ) however I do keep going back to my cone systems. They just lack the dynamics of a good cone .

It's a sacrifice, as much as I love magnepans and I have even a Tympani (6 panels.6ft tall by 4ft wide per speaker) wonderful. But overall speaking ? My kappa 9 buries them all on dynamics.

Subs work great especially in a quad array which I have done. However I had 0 living room left, so those are all stored.

I would love.to hear a good dynamic open baffle system. I might sway towards that for my main listening room. But for now? I stick to my infinity kappa 9.

Pic is my magnepan mgIIIa with 60 inch true ribbon tweeters.

IMG_20220413_130437026~2.jpg
 
Are the Zenith's starting to get nervous about their position? It will be interesting to hear about the differences between the F-15
and the vintage sound. Was there any information about the new mentioned improvement in magnet in the F-15 now over the
previous version?

My 10 inch Zeniths have mellowed, and sounding more clear in their detail as compared to first hearing. Also got some new speaker cable,
Furez 14 AWG OFC that is sounding more detailed than the previous 12 AWG Monster type wire that I had. So far, it seems like a good value for .75 a foot.

Let me start by saying the F-15s, right out of the box are extremely engaging and they're not fully broken in yet. The sound stage and sense of scale is immense and the best of any full range driver I've heard. They just take over my room. Dynamic contrasts stand out as in their ability to suddenly go from very soft to very loud and then back again - it's an eye opening effect. The bass is there but the Alphas give it weight. I do think there's enough bass for most people to run them without augmentation. Scott Hamilton's tenor sax comes off amazing clear, meaty, and "in-the-room". Eddie Higgins' piano is as realistically reproduced as anyone would want. The upright bass is spot on and I'm enjoying the plucks, slaps, and fingers on the frets. I feel as though I'm hearing all the "wood" in that big doghouse. The instruments don't smear together like you hear from box speakers with crossovers and while that's a characteristic of open baffles in general it seems there's even more separation with the F-15s.

90% of my listening is with small group acoustic jazz in which both the F-15s and Zeniths OBs excel. I do enjoy "Chocolate Chip Trip" by Tool as the percussion hits hard and the electronic sounds really show off one's system. I highly recommend this song as a way to test speakers. The gong near the beginning is jaw dropping on the F-15s but a bit more thanks to the Zenith's shimmering highs.

The one slight negative is my need for a bit more sizzle on the top end which I think I can fix. The Zeniths have that with their front and rear firing tweeters. So in order to compare them I'll need to disconnect the tweeters on the Zeniths. I think the F-15s will come off the winner in most areas but I don't think they will have quite the sweeter tone.
 
I'm driving the F-15s with a Bottlehead Foreplay III pre and a pair of Bottlehead mono block 2a3's which make all of 3.5 watts and it's more than enough for the F-15s. 11 o'clock on the preamp's potentiometers is a loud as I can tolerate. The Alpha H-frame bass woofers are powered by a single 100 watt plate amp.

I tried the F-15s on the floor and angled toward me but I liked the sound better when sitting atop the H-frames.
 
Last edited:
Reading the Decware claims for the Lii Audio F-15 in open baffles while I wait on mine to be shipped is quite interesting:

50-17 kHz from one voice coil
100 dbs
Perfect point source
No crossover
No box
No shout
No peaks
Great bass

Not so sure about the last point but bass can be easily augmented. Notice I use the word "augment" which does not mean the same as to replace the bass provided by the F-15. Even a bit of overlap is no big deal.

1.jpg

I have asked you this question, multiple times....Never got a real answer.....
How can you run NO crossover, and have even reasonably flat response with a very small baffle?


ANY speaker mounted to a baffle where the radiation from the front, meets the back, will have a cancellation and a peaking frequency.

Cancellation will occur in the bass obviously where the wavelength from the front meeting the back wave are out of phase, and cancel each other out.

Peaking will occur at the wavelength where they are IN phase and cause an increase in volume, a 6 db increase in volume over a small band.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have asked you this question, multiple times....Never got a real answer.....
How can you run NO crossover, and have even reasonably flat response with a very small baffle?

Are you aware at all of "Baffle Peaking"? or simply hoping it does not exist??


ANY speaker mounted to a baffle where the radiation from the front, meets the back, will have a cancellation and a peaking frequency.

Cancellation will occur in the bass obviously where the wavelength from the front meeting the back wave are out of phase, and cancel each other out.

Peaking will occur at the wavelength where they are IN phase and cause an increase in volume, a 6 db increase in volume over a small band.

You Post all this stuff about speakers with open baffles, yet NEVER even mention of one of the biggest issues they have.
A few others have answered how they deal with the issue, but nothing from you??

The cornerstone of the OB sound is when the back wave wraps around and meets the front wave for a slightly out of phase sound which most of us find quite seductive. Conventional speakers attempt to minimize the back wave while open baffles embrace it. Can you posts pictures of the full range single driver open baffles you've built in which you've experienced baffle peaking?
 
The cornerstone of the OB sound is when the back wave wraps around and meets the front wave for a slightly out of phase sound which most of us find quite seductive.
"Slightly out of phase" is rather vague and misleading. When the difference in phase is 180 degrees the output is zero. Different amounts of phase shift produce different levels of cancellation.
Drivers aren't point sources, despite some claims, so the reality is more complicated than simple models which assume a point source would suggest, but the theory isn't useless.
An uneven output from OBs is a well-known phenomenon, not mere theory, but the issue can be addressed.
Of course, it's perfectly possible to accept an uneven response as a worthwhile trade-off for the other benefits of OBs.
 
Crossovers are a large ball of wax, with their pursuit of "Flat" response. Different drivers obviously have different pluses and minuses, and
therefore the use of filtering to try and minimize inherent driver irregularities, but does "Reality" absolutely guarantee absolute flatness?

Sound reproduced from speakers is not reality necessarily in the same way a photograph is not reality, but perhaps a suggestion of, or often
a means to create something completely different than what was photographed. There is physics, and then there is the way you prefer something to sound.
Deviations or not, preferences are the purview of individual subjectivity, and neither good or bad, at least as I look at it:)
 
@kevintomb

I think you missed the point @dfoulk was trying to make.
I also have not seen anyone in this thread asking for your help, I'm sure they could start a conversation with you if they wanted you to share your knowledge.
It was addressed, so maybe it is okay if we let it go now.
 
This has nothing to do with driver "Irregularities"....but has to do with a 6 db peak, that is literally INHERENT to any open baffle speaker, and the peak is the result of using an open baffle alone.

I have found, many are blissfully unaware of how it works, as I was years ago, and was hoping to help bring some information to help with some of the designs here. A few earlier did comment on how they design around the "Peaking frequency", and alas some seem to not be aware of what it is, nor how to deal with it.
It was my failure to verbally include baffles as a possible source of irregularities in the reproduced sound, surely they are, but my main emphasis was that the whole sound experience is some what subjective, and the diversity and characteristics of means employed (speakers, baffles, crossovers, etc.) whether seen as flawed or perfect, really is secondary to the point of how and if you enjoy your music. It wasn't meant to slight the inclusion of sound principles.:beerchug:
 
I have asked you this question, multiple times....Never got a real answer.....
How can you run NO crossover, and have even reasonably flat response with a very small baffle?

I don’t think anyone seeking a flat response goes with an OB set up.

A flat response is not the goal and I don’t think anyone suggested such.

People go OB for other reasons.
 
You Post all this stuff about speakers with open baffles, yet NEVER even mention of one of the biggest issues they have.
A few others have answered how they deal with the issue, but nothing from you??

I am always trying to learn and improve my ability to implement what I've learned from others. Whether or not PG addresses this issue or not is insignificant, in my opinion. The point is, what do we enjoy listening to and how do we get there. I'm always anxious to learn and improve my skills and what I've learned and implemented from PG has brought my enjoyment to a new level, and at a very reasonable cost. (Except for those who make a living at this, it is a hobby after all. The journey is the reward, as someone once said.) We all have different ways of achieving our goals. We should try to understand each other's approaches and respectfully banter about our thoughts, always willing to hear opinions without nastiness.

Just my opinion.
 
Last edited:
This thread has become a bit contensious, with report after report. The personal back and forth has to stop now or offending members will get banned from the thread or the thread gets closed.
Regards,
Jim
 
I was taken to task in drive by posts for not explaining something I've not experienced. If I have and don't know it I would certainly welcome more as the sound I'm getting puts box speakers I've owned from Zu and Aerial Acoustics to shame. As Linkwitz once said, "It is difficult to screw up an open baffle speaker design to where it sounds worse than your typical box speaker".

Andrew Robinson in his review of the Lii Audio F-15s calls them very neutral and I would agree. It takes some getting use to as the Zenith alnico's are more colored. I think some of the folks who sold their F-15s may not have allowed enough time to become conditioned to their neutrality.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It would be nice if you explained in plain English what or who you're referring to.
I don't remember you having moderate status last time I looked. Why is it that the new mods always seem to develop a case of HMS for no apparent reason?

I have been a moderator on AK for many years. after a series of 4 reports from two members about personal attacks another mod banned one of the parties from this thread and the other one got a pass. I left the message to bring the thread back on the rails as opposed to locking it. Questioning Moderation in the open forums is against AK rules. BTW If you have issues take it to PM in the future.
Regards,
ehoove
@valvenator
 
Back
Top Bottom