• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

As Linkwitz once said, "It is difficult to screw up an open baffle speaker design to where it sounds worse than your typical box speaker".
Indeed he did say that, but his designs were far from being a single full-range driver in the middle of a rectangular board. His site goes into great detail about the uneven response from an OB and he went to great lengths to deal with the issue. His designs were extremely complex by any standards.
 
Indeed he did say that, but his designs were far from being a single full-range driver in the middle of a rectangular board. His site goes into great detail about the uneven response from an OB and he went to great lengths to deal with the issue. His designs were extremely complex by any standards.

I don't recall seeing any of Linkwitz complex multiple channel builds on this thread which has been going strong for some 8 years. The beauty of this thread is that it deals with open baffles that most of us can build with simple hand tools. Single full range drivers in the middle of a rectangular board can be game changers. You should give it a try and it may result in your praise rather than your criticism. It doesn't have to have the cosmetics of this Zen Master ZF15L or its $5000 price tag to have comparable performance. $399 for two drivers and a $35 sheet of MDF and you're 99% of the way there. :)

ZF15L525.jpg

 
Last edited:
You should give it a try and it may result in your praise rather than your criticism.
I have tried open baffles and was very impressed, particularly by the clarity in the bass. I don't have anything against the OB concept at all and I don't think you'll find a single post of mine on this thread where I say open baffles sound bad. It's only misinformation and denial of the laws of physics and acoustics that I have a problem with.
 
I have tried open baffles and was very impressed, particularly by the clarity in the bass. I don't have anything against the OB concept at all and I don't think you'll find a single post of mine on this thread where I say open baffles sound bad. It's only misinformation and denial of the laws of physics and acoustics that I have a problem with.

I recall some pictures you posted of those speakers you built that impressed you but this thread is too long to find them. Please repost them.
 
I would hope this thread will continue in the spirit of the original post which is reprinted here for those who may not have read it.


"So its -25 Celcius and the car wont start so of course I started messing around with my gear and came up with what I can only call an epiphany!

I took a pair of Foster (Fostex) FE103 alnicos with Planet-10-HIFI phase plugs that I had lying around and decided to cut up a left over cardboard box from xmas and create some crude open baffle speakers to see what the fuss is about...

WOW!:music:

Of course I have a sub hooked up for the bass.

Ive never heard anything like this in my life! I can hear the echo from the snare drum coming from BEHIND the speakers! Its like the whole front of me is the sound stage! Total open compared to my JBL decade 36, or any other speaker I've heard for that matter.

I like where this is going :D"



It's all about having fun with simple open baffles. It's not about being critical of others, finding fault or the need to prove one's audio prowess at the expense of others. If those things aren't important you're wasting your time on the wrong thread.
 
As someone who has had the open baffle epiphany I have also been puzzled by the enjoyment I’ve had with cheap drivers in an open baffle. So much so that I can’t enjoy multi thousand dollar box speakers anymore.

When I’m not being carried away to places sitting in front of them I’ve spent many hours reading trying to understand how these less than perfect designs can actually work. I’ve come to the conclusion that if the tonality is realistic, peaks and nulls in the frequency spectrum can be ignored because the auditory illusion is convincing. On the other hand a speaker which measures perfectly with box colouration and other artefacts is not convincing

I’ve got drivers which are obviously rolled off above 12k but they get so much right that I relax and don’t worry about what’s missing, sure the cymbals are quite but it’s just like being at a live venue in the back of the room rather than the front of the room where the cymbals are more prominent

A real test is reproducing applause, it so often sounds like rain or static rather than flesh on flesh but my imperfect open baffle full range drivers actually sound like I’m in the room

the other night I was testing my cheap drivers I’ve lived with for a while beside the tang band 1808, at first I was impressed by the extended top end but after a while I felt the tonality was off and things weren’t realistic, sure there was more sizzle to the cymbals and the trumpet had a little more crackle but I was thinking I preferred the more rolled off cheapies. Now here’s where anyone who values measurements and theory should stop reading

While switching back and forth between the two outputs on my amp I accidentally switch both sets of speakers on and I sat up in my chair as the realistic tone remained and the crackle and sizzle sat on top, the soundstage got deeper and it felt like I moved from the back of the venue to the front. But how? I mean the drivers were side by side? What about comb filtering? Why was the image still realistic? To be honest I don’t know the answer and from everything I’ve read it shouldn’t work but it did and I sat there for the next hour in the dark with Willie Nelson and Wynton Marsalis in my room.

I’ve heard $100k systems that do amazing things when it comes to imaging and rendering sound, it’s like a magic trick that is impressive but to me it doesn’t sound like being in a room with the musicians. I’ll take my crossover free full range open baffles with their dipole peaks, ragged frequency response and rolled off top end (bottom end goes to 30hz)

If you prefers the perfectly flat box speaker that extends to 40khz that’s fine, we listen to audio equipment for different reasons and it’s all good
 
As someone who has had the open baffle epiphany I have also been puzzled by the enjoyment I’ve had with cheap drivers in an open baffle. So much so that I can’t enjoy multi thousand dollar box speakers anymore.

When I’m not being carried away to places sitting in front of them I’ve spent many hours reading trying to understand how these less than perfect designs can actually work. I’ve come to the conclusion that if the tonality is realistic, peaks and nulls in the frequency spectrum can be ignored because the auditory illusion is convincing. On the other hand a speaker which measures perfectly with box colouration and other artefacts is not convincing

I’ve got drivers which are obviously rolled off above 12k but they get so much right that I relax and don’t worry about what’s missing, sure the cymbals are quite but it’s just like being at a live venue in the back of the room rather than the front of the room where the cymbals are more prominent

A real test is reproducing applause, it so often sounds like rain or static rather than flesh on flesh but my imperfect open baffle full range drivers actually sound like I’m in the room

the other night I was testing my cheap drivers I’ve lived with for a while beside the tang band 1808, at first I was impressed by the extended top end but after a while I felt the tonality was off and things weren’t realistic, sure there was more sizzle to the cymbals and the trumpet had a little more crackle but I was thinking I preferred the more rolled off cheapies. Now here’s where anyone who values measurements and theory should stop reading

While switching back and forth between the two outputs on my amp I accidentally switch both sets of speakers on and I sat up in my chair as the realistic tone remained and the crackle and sizzle sat on top, the soundstage got deeper and it felt like I moved from the back of the venue to the front. But how? I mean the drivers were side by side? What about comb filtering? Why was the image still realistic? To be honest I don’t know the answer and from everything I’ve read it shouldn’t work but it did and I sat there for the next hour in the dark with Willie Nelson and Wynton Marsalis in my room.

I’ve heard $100k systems that do amazing things when it comes to imaging and rendering sound, it’s like a magic trick that is impressive but to me it doesn’t sound like being in a room with the musicians. I’ll take my crossover free full range open baffles with their dipole peaks, ragged frequency response and rolled off top end (bottom end goes to 30hz)

If you prefers the perfectly flat box speaker that extends to 40khz that’s fine, we listen to audio equipment for different reasons and it’s all good

Good post!
 
I recall some pictures you posted of those speakers you built that impressed you but this thread is too long to find them. Please repost them.

I didn't take any pictures of the OBs I made. Maybe you're thinking of someone else.

You state you were very impressed with those OBs that you built with your own hands yet you didn't take a single picture????

No, I didn't. Why does that matter?

How convenient.

:needpics:
I'm not sure how pictures, or their lack, of my experiments with open baffles are relevant to anything. The laws of physics aren't dependent on the existence of any pictures I may or may not have taken.
I'm not sure what you're trying to imply but it appears to be some kind of veiled ad hominem attack.
 
I think you guys should let the back and forth go

yes dipole speakers are prone to peaks and nulls which much more knowledgeable guys like linkwitz have written about and incorporated into their designs

and yes many people find enjoyment listening to full range drivers in simple baffles which do have peaks and nulls but that doesn’t seem to bother them. The same goes for crossovers we could correct the frequency response of our full range drivers but we don’t want or need to so we don’t, other builders do and that’s fine

There’s nothing to be gained from arguing when you're both actually correct and to be honest it’s spoiling this thread

peace ✌️
 
Moderation Note:

There has recently been too much contention going on in this thread. The juicy bits have been deleted, so it won't help to go looking for them. Simply, there has been too many recent entries in our mod staff complaint queue about this thread. It is going to stop...forthwith

  • First, for any participant in this thread to dominate the conversation, and to act as the gate keeper of what information is posted here, expect resistance...by the mod staff.
  • For any member who wants to foster a single approach to the topic of open baffles, to the exclusion of all others. expect resistance...from the mod staff.
  • For any member who seeks to derail this thread with arguing, interpersonal back and forth, personal attacks, straw man arguments, etc., expect resistance...from the mod staff.
  • Those who enjoy offering up snark and insulting comments, expect resistance...from the mod staff.
  • For any participant who wants to state, or imply, that "everything you know is wrong," expect resistance...from the mod staff.
Jumping up and down and stomping your feet, picking sides, and other related actions will not earn credibility. If you have a contribution, make it. If it is not received, learn to live with it, let it lay, and move on; or respond in a friendly and respectful manner.

If this warning is not heeded, we will start by banning the violators and contenders from further participation in this thread. If that proves insufficient, the thread will simply be closed.

So...return to respectful, friendly dialog...Please. We don't like closing long-running threads, but we will if we have to.

Rich P

P.S. Commentary on moderation, and struggling with, or challenging, members of AudioKarma staff, who are trying to keep the peace, is guaranteed to not work in anyone's favor.
 
As someone who has had the open baffle epiphany I have also been puzzled by the enjoyment I’ve had with cheap drivers in an open baffle. So much so that I can’t enjoy multi thousand dollar box speakers anymore.

When I’m not being carried away to places sitting in front of them I’ve spent many hours reading trying to understand how these less than perfect designs can actually work. I’ve come to the conclusion that if the tonality is realistic, peaks and nulls in the frequency spectrum can be ignored because the auditory illusion is convincing. On the other hand a speaker which measures perfectly with box colouration and other artefacts is not convincing

I’ve got drivers which are obviously rolled off above 12k but they get so much right that I relax and don’t worry about what’s missing, sure the cymbals are quite but it’s just like being at a live venue in the back of the room rather than the front of the room where the cymbals are more prominent

A real test is reproducing applause, it so often sounds like rain or static rather than flesh on flesh but my imperfect open baffle full range drivers actually sound like I’m in the room

the other night I was testing my cheap drivers I’ve lived with for a while beside the tang band 1808, at first I was impressed by the extended top end but after a while I felt the tonality was off and things weren’t realistic, sure there was more sizzle to the cymbals and the trumpet had a little more crackle but I was thinking I preferred the more rolled off cheapies. Now here’s where anyone who values measurements and theory should stop reading

While switching back and forth between the two outputs on my amp I accidentally switch both sets of speakers on and I sat up in my chair as the realistic tone remained and the crackle and sizzle sat on top, the soundstage got deeper and it felt like I moved from the back of the venue to the front. But how? I mean the drivers were side by side? What about comb filtering? Why was the image still realistic? To be honest I don’t know the answer and from everything I’ve read it shouldn’t work but it did and I sat there for the next hour in the dark with Willie Nelson and Wynton Marsalis in my room.

I’ve heard $100k systems that do amazing things when it comes to imaging and rendering sound, it’s like a magic trick that is impressive but to me it doesn’t sound like being in a room with the musicians. I’ll take my crossover free full range open baffles with their dipole peaks, ragged frequency response and rolled off top end (bottom end goes to 30hz)

If you prefers the perfectly flat box speaker that extends to 40khz that’s fine, we listen to audio equipment for different reasons and it’s all good
I think you guys should let the back and forth go

yes dipole speakers are prone to peaks and nulls which much more knowledgeable guys like linkwitz have written about and incorporated into their designs

and yes many people find enjoyment listening to full range drivers in simple baffles which do have peaks and nulls but that doesn’t seem to bother them. The same goes for crossovers we could correct the frequency response of our full range drivers but we don’t want or need to so we don’t, other builders do and that’s fine

There’s nothing to be gained from arguing when you're both actually correct and to be honest it’s spoiling this thread

peace ✌️
........If your ass gets sore before your ears you know you’ve got good speakers.....the only other option I can imagine is that you might be eating too much:beerchug:
 
Way I see things is some people like being at the studio well others search out being there were nothing is perfect.....
 
I tried the F-15s sitting directly on the floor angled upwards but I like them better resting on top of the H-frame subs.

P1010003.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom