boreas
"If it sounds good, it IS good." E.K.E.
The generics seem to vary a bit ..i'll include some pics of a few i have.
That would be really helpful. Thanks!
John
The generics seem to vary a bit ..i'll include some pics of a few i have.
The originals I've seen all have the model number of the cartridge they belong to printed on the label. Certainly those for the YM-308 are so marked, Also, at least in my experience, the armatures on the original styli are fixed to the cantilever by a bright blue adhesive, visible with the naked eye.
As we say here in the States, daaang. The unbranded generic in the photos in post 123 is a moving-magnet Audio-Technica-looking version. You could check to make sure those little bars sticking out where they'd be in an Audio-Technica are really magnets, but I have little doubt they are. Might well work in the same body as the MI. A hybrid design, or just a cheap-out by the aftermarket? Are any genuine styli equipped with V-magnets, aside from one of the Spectrums?
And big fat heavy-looking magnets, at that.boreas said:...The "ears" for the X and Y poles are in fact magnets..
But you rightly pointed out that there's no soft-iron sleeve and plate to constitute the Z-axis on the [allegedly] MM stylus.boreas said:OOPS ! I see Walt beat me!
These are for the older Acutexan tripole 3 series bricks btw. The stylus all have the familiar curved side fitting and the cartridge has an unmistakable profile.
I don't think i've seen any Audio technica cartridge so far that cloned this particular cartridge shape, but please share a pic or link if you have one as it's still a mystery who else added a brand to this Piezo/Acutex design.
We know Akai , Acutex, Piezo , Hitachi and Eagle all have a varsion of this cartridge...it would be interesting to see other examples..I'll include a side profile picture of the 3 series brick just to avoid confusing y'all..![]()
The "ears" for the X and Y poles are in fact magnets, or so I believe, rather than "inducers" so this stylus is of the same design as the moving magnet Audio-Technica "V Magnet" styli.
Neither have I. That's why it was such a shock to see it in a MI-type stylus grip for Acutex. Maybe Audio-Technica was a silent partner in the Acutex venture. Dunno. But it is interesting that the tripole design looks very much like the IM analog of Audio-Technica's VM design, almost as if they'd been intended to be more or less interswappable from the start. Verrry interesting.melofelo said:..I don't think i've seen any Audio-Technica cartridge so far that cloned this particular cartridge shape...
I think you are correct, but I also think that, as I said, Acutex hedged their bets by making the designs sneakily similar.melofelo said:I fear that this last unbranded design..is probably just cost cutting...no z axis..no shielding...but it works well enough to sell in the older tri-pole stubby brick body.
I think the white body suggests a Piezo or Hitachi brand for the cartridge in your picture. The 300 series Acutex bricks had black, gray or blue bodies.
Thanks! Your "unbranded" one is a non tri-pole, non IM stylus, just like the one shown earlier in the thread. It even has the red dot on the cantilever. As you can see, it also lacks the metal "slug" that would sit below the magnet and the U-shaped shield that all the others have. The "ears" for the X and Y poles are in fact magnets, or so I believe, rather than "inducers" so this stylus is of the same design as the moving magnet Audio-Technica "V Magnet" styli.
John
OOPS ! I see Walt beat me!
Actually..this make sense ...if the induction plate behind the cantilever is missing. But...hm...wouldnt' that make the big barrel magnet in the body redundant ?:scratch2:
Yes, it would and inserting a pair of magnets into the body, bringing them in proximity to the coils would allow it to function. So, it would work but work as an MM, like an AT, and, of course, it would be "bi-polar".
John
There's only one possible problem, and you mentioned it just a few posts back: the sound is inferior. This has been the result anytime we've found someone has stuck a magnet (or two) on an ostensibly-MI cantilever assembly to make a universal hybrid. In some cases the level drops by ~10dB. In others there are tracking problems. In others the shape frequency response envelope alters for the worse. This I've always attributed, rightly or wrongly, to the presence of two (or three) interacting magnets.
Now, if you can find a stylus with the V magnets that sounds as good as an IM stylus....