• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I couldn't remember the size container for rinse tank, so looked when I got home. It's rated for 6.5 gallons. As for draining, I have a siphon pump that attaches to my drill driver, and I just empty that into a five gallon bucket when I'm done. The remainder is light enough I simply lift that tank out of my frame and dump that.
 
Great stuff guys. Very impressive US set ups. My current US set up only does one LP at a time which is why I am most interested in the different batch systems presented here. My objective is to digitize every album as it comes into my collection, and there is a lot of volume to go through. I sometimes hand-wash and sometimes use the US bath. Whichever method I use, I always follow with a dH2O rinse on my RCM before air drying and packing into a new MoFi sleeve.
As a general side comment:
It's odd to me that people can feel (as a few of the comments posted in this thread have indicated) that the fastidious collectors here spend way too much time worrying about cleaning methods. If you've invested in a very revealing system, you surely desire the best reproduction you can achieve. If you are making a digital copy, you certainly want to archive completely free of artifacts. It really isn't that difficult: most of my collection has been deep cleaned only once in it's life with me and no further cleaning (not even brushing) has been required after the initial, careful wash. Once you hear perfectly silent background and clarity throughout the range, you get it. Arguments about the best cartridge or stylus to use are moot if the source material is dirty. My goal is to have accurate noise-free digital copies of my entire vinyl collection and then pass the good clean vinyl media on to someone else to enjoy. My kids are first in line and already receive 10-20 lps/week. Hence, I need to be very careful about how the records I collect are handled. Nothing but the best will do!
 
And it's not just surface noise. I can listen through a lot of surface noise. The big difference for me with a nicely cleaned LP is that the music comes through so much more realistically - timbre, harmonics, soundstaging, micro-dynamics - they are all better with a nicely cleaned surface.
 
This has been a great thread started by guest110 and continued by phantomrebel. I've learned a lot and I've hugely benefited from the sharing of everyone's experience. Thank you!

My focus has been to apply this information to ultrasonic record cleaning. And while all of my research (both here and in other forums) and experimentation is fresh on my mind, I decided to capture it in a letter to David Robinson at Positive Feedback in hopes he might find something of interest or value that he could apply and perhaps publish as a letter from a reader. David elected to publish it as a guest essay. I trust you will find that I've given appropriate credits to this thread and everyone who is contributing.

Rushton Paul: My DIY Approach to the Ultrasonic Cleaning of LPs - Positive Feedback

Writing this up also helped me clarify in my own mind this regimen and what's really making a difference. The essay summarizes what I am currently doing in my cleaning process. It is giving me the best sonic results I have been able to achieve in over 40 years of cleaning records.
 
Well I spent pretty much all day reading this thread front to back. Wow. Just wow.

Let me try to recap what I think I understand.

I buy the Triton X-100 in its full strength. I take a small amount of that and mix it into a 10% solution using distilled water and alcohol. If it's over 50% alcohol, this concentrate will last a long time.

Then I take that 10% concentrate and mix it into a 1:20 ratio with more distilled water/alcohol. Alcohol content being no more than 15%. I will go with 10%.

That final solution will be a .05% strength and can be used directly with a vacuum cleaning machine? Then follow up with a rinse of just distilled water, also on a RCM.

Did I get this right?
 
Danimal, you've got the general process. When I mix up my US tank solution, I'm shooting for a final Tergitol/Triton concentration in the US tank of around 0.13% and isopropyl at around 5.0-6.0%.

I'm also adding the Hepastat 256 to my US tank solution because I know some moisture will remain in the drain, pump and filter assembly. I want the antimicrobial benefit of the Hepastat in the solution to prevent bacteria from growing in those areas of my system. The antistat is a nice side benefit. The concentration of Hepastat 256 that I'm using is about 0.10%.
 
I couldn't remember the size container for rinse tank, so looked when I got home. It's rated for 6.5 gallons. As for draining, I have a siphon pump that attaches to my drill driver, and I just empty that into a five gallon bucket when I'm done. The remainder is light enough I simply lift that tank out of my frame and dump that.
Where are you? Why don't you offer record cleaning as a service for a fee? I'd pay a reasonable amount to catch up. I'm behind about 12 LPs.
 
Where are you? Why don't you offer record cleaning as a service for a fee? I'd pay a reasonable amount to catch up. I'm behind about 12 LPs.
Or, you might find a few kindred spirits near you who might join in assembling a "community" cleaning kit that can be rotated among you. This is what a few folks near me are considering.
 
This has been a great thread started by guest110 and continued by phantomrebel. I've learned a lot and I've hugely benefited from the sharing of everyone's experience. Thank you!

My focus has been to apply this information to ultrasonic record cleaning. And while all of my research (both here and in other forums) and experimentation is fresh on my mind, I decided to capture it in a letter to David Robinson at Positive Feedback in hopes he might find something of interest or value that he could apply and perhaps publish as a letter from a reader. David elected to publish it as a guest essay. I trust you will find that I've given appropriate credits to this thread and everyone who is contributing.

Rushton Paul: My DIY Approach to the Ultrasonic Cleaning of LPs - Positive Feedback

Writing this up also helped me clarify in my own mind this regimen and what's really making a difference. The essay summarizes what I am currently doing in my cleaning process. It is giving me the best sonic results I have been able to achieve in over 40 years of cleaning records.

Just saw this article. Great job, very detailed, particularly with regards to ultrasonic cleaning. Bookmarked it!
I think the Hepastat mix has been one of my best discoveries: an effective quat mix that anyone can easily obtain. Would be interested in hearing from anyone who has seen any negatives to it's use (other than the smell of the concentrate ;)).
 
Last edited:
Where are you? Why don't you offer record cleaning as a service for a fee? I'd pay a reasonable amount to catch up. I'm behind about 12 LPs.

From an economic standpoint, shipping LPs to be cleaned probably wouldn't make as much sense as having a local drop off service available.

What would make more sense is like was posted above. Not only would it cost about a buck a record round trip in shipping costs, but it would also take a week to two weeks in transit.
 
Just saw this article. Great job, very detailed, particularly with regards to ultrasonic cleaning. Bookmarked it!
I think the Hepastat mix has been one of my best discoveries: an effective quat mix that anyone can easily obtain. Would be interested in hearing from anyone who has seen any negatives to it's use (other than the smell of the concentrate ;)).
Phantomrebel, thanks for your positive comment about the article. I was just trying to collect and consolidate a lot of information I've gathered from you and others. I can say that multiple people have now made the listening comparison with this ultrasonic cleaning regimen and they are all uniformly enthusiastic about the results.

I have not tried the solution without the Hepastat in the mix, so I can't offer a listening comparison of with and without. I have not found any negatives to the Hepastat given the low concentration used for ultrasonic cleaning and given the double rinsing that I do in my regimen. What I'm delighted about is the knowledge that this can help reduce any bacteria growth in my drain, tubing, pump and filter. Plus, as the air is getting dryer for this time of year, I'm not noticing any static on my cleaned vinyl. I usually do, but not this year. So, perhaps the antistatic properties really are adding a nice plus!

A further note, I'm not using the Hepastat on it's own. I've only used it IN ADDITION to Tergitol and isopropyl in the mix.
 
Last edited:
I've tested it alone, with Triton, with Triton/IPA, and various mixes with and without and I like it best as an additive. Something synergistic (mixed micelles) going on with the Triton I've found. Surface noise is as low as I have ever achieved, maximizing dynamics.
 
I've tested it alone, with Triton, with Triton/IPA, and various mixes with and without and I like it best as an additive. Something synergistic (mixed micelles) going on with the Triton I've found. Surface noise is as low as I have ever achieved, maximizing dynamics.
The Hepastat is certainly working great as an additive here! Given your summary, I won't bother taking the time to compare, I'm just going to continue cleaning records.

In fact, the results here have been SO POSITIVE that my wife is encouraging me to RE-CLEAN records that were previously cleaned in our earlier "gold standard" manual wet/vac cleaning process.
 
The Hepastat is certainly working great as an additive here! Given your summary, I won't bother taking the time to compare, I'm just going to continue cleaning records.

In fact, the results here have been SO POSITIVE that my wife is encouraging me to RE-CLEAN records that were previously cleaned in our earlier "gold standard" manual wet/vac cleaning process.

One minor point I noticed: your autocorrect substituted the word "quartz" for quats in the article ("formulated principally of quartz and is available from both Amazon and Staples"). We don't want folks putting quartz on their records! :thumbsup:
 
Does Hepastat have some other magical property other than killing mold & germs?
Nothing "magical", but the quats it contains are also powerful anti-stats. The same compounds you find in dryer sheets, Staticguard spray, hair conditioners, etc.. In fact, there is a spray that contains the exact ingredients found in Hepastat (except about 10-fold diluted) that is commercially marketed solely as an anti-static formulation. This property is, in fact, what first peaked my interest years ago in adding quats to cleaning solutions.
 
Nothing "magical", but the quats it contains are also powerful anti-stats. The same compounds you find in dryer sheets, Staticguard spray, hair conditioners, etc.. In fact, there is a spray that contains the exact ingredients found in Hepastat (except about 10-fold diluted) that is commercially marketed solely as an anti-static formulation. This property is, in fact, what first peaked my interest years ago in adding quats to cleaning solutions.

Thanks. Good to know.
 
One might ask about quats...How do they work?
As antimicrobials, they integrate into cell membranes and disrupt them, causing the cells to lyse. Hence, they are active against a wide spectrum of microorganisms.
As antistats, they not only neutralize negative charges, they form a molecular layer on hard surfaces, allowing them to retain water molecules. As you know from humidity levels, water is a great conductor and prevents static build up. Furthermore, this molecular layer of long carbon chains and water helps reduce frictional forces. This property is quite a bonus for record playing and is why the compounds are often referred to as record "conditioners".
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom