• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Indeed. Talas is an EXCELLENT source. They also carry Triton X100 and Ecosurf (which someday I will experiment around with).
Triton X-100 also has the advantage of being less than half the cost of purchasing both Tergitol S-15-3 and Tergitol S-15-9 for use in combination, as I have done. And, it appears to perhaps be a bit easier to handle. Nonetheless, I'd be curious to compare the results provided by Triton X-100 as compared to the results with the combination of S-15-3 and S-15-9. Has anyone made this comparison as part of your experimentation in solutions for record cleaning?
 
Last edited:
That's why I recommend Triton X-100. It just makes things simple.
Nothing wrong with simple, and the lower cost associated with using a single surfactant is a bonus, but there is some utility to having 2 very different kinds to experiment with. I've found the 15-S-3 to be a powerful solvent for hard, crusty fingerprints when it's mixed into mineral oil instead of being blended with the S-9 in water. Wash up afterwards is a real task though and the process really only lends itself to an hydraulic cleaning arrangement with good label protectors.

I suppose it's possible to experiment with blending different ratios of the 2 for different types of cleaning problems. For example, higher S-3 for heavy fingerprints followed by several rinses, and higher S-9 for lightly soiled or maintenance cleanings where less rinsing is desired.
 
If bacteria are really a concern, then you need to make sure you sanitize the pump before you use it, maybe by running some sort of higher strength antibacterial solution for a minute or so, then rinsing it with straight water. I'm just kind of jumping in the middle here, but I do that same exact thing with my pumps and filters when I'm bottling mead. I know it's very different from the pump in an US cleaner, but if you're concerned about contamination then the only way to be sure is to sanitize, rinse, then sanitize again after use. Even at high dilution, you're going to risk something funky growing in the inner workings of the pump over time (I think).

You didn't mention if you're heating the solution at any point though. If your cleaner has the ability to heat, then running straight water through at 160-165F will probably kill anything that's hiding in the pump. You might do this when you are done, then once again before you clean another batch.

Then again, you may be right about the tiny amounts...
@MannyE, following up on your recommendation for sanitizing the pump, I've obtained the Hepastat 256 recommended by @phantomrebel and will be starting this weekend to sanitize my pump, tubing, containers and tank using the Hepastat 256, some very thorough rinsing, and soaking in some 90% isopropyl alcohol. I'll also start by boiling all of my glassware containers even if I can't do so under pressure (no autoclave, no pressure cooker).

From that point, I'll mix up my first batch of 10% base solution to use in some initial ultrasonic cleaning trials. I'll include a bit of the Hepastat 256 in the 10% base solution per @phantomrebel's suggestion and using his concentration recommendation for US use.

Any cautions or suggestions from anyone? What have I missed?
 
I have tried all 3 Tergitols the S-3, S-9 and the S-7. I also have tried Triton X-100. All work about the same except the S-3 is oil soluble and clouds your mixture which I didn't like. I have the best results by not mixing them and following the final wash with two rinses each with a new cotton facial makeup removal pad. I am first doing a wash with the X-100 and follow that with the S-7, then the rinses. I have yet to see any accumulation of material on the stylus. Once in a great wile a tiny strand from the cotton pad is seen. That can be minimized by using "quilted" pads. I cut them in half or quarters to reduce consumption. Seems to work for me. No alcohol or quats added and the solutions remain clear for months. Oh, the Triton will dissolve over a few hours to overnight if you just put in the liter of water and let it sit.
 
@phantomrebel, I've followed your recommendation to try the Hepastat 256 to use in combination with the Tergitol and isopropyl for my ultrasonic tank cleaning and I'm very pleased with the results so far.

As a summary for those catching up with this thread, following phantomrebel's lead my current mix for ultrasonic record cleaning is:
  • 0.13% Tergitol S-15-3 and S-15-9 in a 50/50 proportion (or use Triton X-100 as a simpler alternative)
  • 0.10% Hepastat 256 (a 1:1000 dilution)
  • 5.00% isoprophyl alchohol (using 91% grade)
As phantomrebel has recommended, I'm finding it useful to premix the Tergitols with some alcohol and to make up enough in advance for several US tank refills. In my case, I'm making up a 4 oz bottle's worth of solution (about 118 ml) that will give me enough concentrated mix for four 2-gallon US tanks when I add the additional alcohol as part of setting up the tank. In case this helps anyone else, in milliliters this solution is:
  • 40.00 ml Tergitol
  • 30.00 ml Hepastat 256
  • 48.00 ml Isopropyl to top out the bottle at 118 ml
This combination neatly fits into one the those readily available 4 oz (118 ml) blue storage jars and is enough to mix up four 2-gallon US tanks using 29.5 ml of the combination per tank and then adding another 400 ml of 91% isopropyl to each tank to reach the 5% alcohol concentration.

Thanks for all of your guidance and sharing on these record cleaning formulations!
 
Last edited:
Thanks Rushton for listing what you are using in a simple to follow recipe. The last batch of records I cleaned were very dirty vintage soul albums I picked up at a thrift store. I hand washed them, using a Triton-Hepastat-IPA mix about 4 times more concentrated than what you use for UC cleaning and, after a final dH2O rinse on my RCM, they came out as clean as any records I have ever seen or heard. I think we are on to something here that is easy to put together and consistently yields great results.
 
Last edited:
I've now cleaned over 40 LPs using the cleaning fluid formulation described in post #1056 for my ultrasonic cleaning. The results are outstanding. Better than any other US tank cleaning fluid mix that I've tried before and far better than "isopropyl with a bit of clear dishwashing liquid" used in my earliest US trials. The key characteristics I'm hearing with this fluid and ultrasonic cleaning (using a 40khz tank, 35 degree celsius heating, approximately 3 revolutions in 10 minutes, double high purity water rinse and vacuum dry between rinses and filtering the tank water between each batch of LPs) are:
  1. Absolutely no audible damage to the grooves, no high frequency dulling or roll-off
  2. Dead silent background (on records not previously groove-damaged)
  3. Excellent reveal of transients, harmonic overtones and timbre
  4. A great sense of openness to the sonic image and soundstage
This weekend I'll do a careful comparison with my previous preferred 4-Step manual wet/vac cleaning regimen. The process with US and this detergent solution sounds like it is at least as good as my previous 4-Step regimen and perhaps better. Until I do a careful listening comparison, I won't know for sure.

What I do know for sure is that the sound quality result using the US and this detergent solution is very very good and it's significantly FASTER to clean a batch of records. With 6,000 records to clean, I look forward to the faster cleaning times with comparable results.
 
Rushton- Maybe I missed it - what US device are you using? Does it accommodate multiple LPs at once?
I'm using a 10L tank with records spaced 1" apart (like ETLS) using a Vinyl Stack Spin Kit rotation device. For a reasonably modest investment, this setup works really well, allows for variable rotation speeds, and provides easy on/off of the LP spindle with magnet attachment. With a 10L tank, I have the width to do 4 LPs at a time using their optional 4 record stack. For a 6L tank, use the 3 record spindle stacks shown in the picture below.


https://thevinylstack.com/view-cart/#!/ULTRA-Sonic-Spin-Kit/p/51658871/category=13505423

The Vinyl Stack folks are good folks to work with and very responsive.
 
Last edited:
I built mine to do 8 at one inch gap spacing per spindle.
ETLS, I like that you used 1" spacing between your records! Great job assembling your own diy rotation solution. That is a massive US tank to hold 8 records, but looks super efficient for getting a lot of records cleaned.
 
One concern I had is that the fluid from the US tank dries before I can get to the rinse stage. It worried me a bit at first, but I can't tell that it's causing a problem. I simply saturate the record on the first rinse cycle, which seems to successfully re-dissolve any of the detergent residue which then vacuums off. With the second rinse, I haven't been able to hear that any residue is remaining from the tank cleaning fluid initially having dried on the surface. I mention this because I was thinking I might need to move from the US tank to a rinse tank to keep the surface wet, and then to rinse and vac. But that doesn't seem necessary.
 
IMG_20160928_085526.jpg IMG_20160919_131838.jpg tWith the way I designed mine, I can simply slip the spindle out of the square drive rotisserie. Since my rinse station is immediately to the right, it only takes a matter of seconds to transfer the spindle, fully loaded, and let it spin in the rinse tank.

With having multiple spindles, each set up exactly the same, I can then simply insert the second into the ultrasonic cleaning tank.

While those two are working, I can load a third with records since I designed them for vertical loading and unloading.
 
With the way I designed mine, I can simply slip the spindle out of the square drive rotisserie. Since my rinse station is immediately to the right, it only takes a matter of seconds to transfer the spindle, fully loaded, and let it spin in the rinse tank.

With having multiple spindles, each set up exactly the same, I can then simply insert the second into the ultrasonic cleaning tank.

While those two are working, I can load a third with records since I designed them for vertical loading and unloading.
Outstanding! What do you do about re-freshing the rinse water? Do you simply dump and refill from time-to-time? Are you vacuum drying after the rinse?
 
Last edited:
Outstanding! What do you do about re-freshing the rinse water? Do you simply dump and refill from time-to-time? Are you vacuum drying after the rinse?


To the left of the rinse tank, you'll see the junker turntable I use for any vacuum process needed. Very rarely do I ever use it. As for the rinse tank, it has a large enough volume of water that any Triton remaining on the records, is well diluted.

I have an identical set up like the rinse station, with a hinged lid that covers the records which allows me to spin the records at just enough rpm to let the centrifugal force move the water off the records. Since the spindle has the sealed roller bearings on each end, and I don't try for maximum velocity on spinning, I've never had a problem with needing a long drying time, or for vacuum drying.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom