• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is an interesting one. The active component is a silahydrocarbon mixed with a small amount of tris(phenoxyphenyl)phosphate, a mixture first developed as a dry lubricant for aerospace. It was invented by the Ball Bros corporation (the very same one that makes those glass jars for preserving) and was originally called VacKote. Some great surface chemists worked on this invention, including Marion Fulk, and as a result, the Ball corp. quickly became a leader in the aerospace industry since the lube doesn't evaporate and lasts forever, even in a radiation rich environment. Hence, it was perfect for greasing metal parts on satellites and, in fact, was used to lube the wheels on the Apollo land rover!. They later re-packaged the lube for records and changed the name to Soundguard Record Preservative (they also made a cleaner and sold them together). Their patent expired a few years ago so I think the formula is now marketed by another group, but it has a fascinating history. Not something I think we need on our records though as, due to its incredible stability, you can never get rid of it. Chemically, it's more like GroOve lube than Last as a surface treatment.

I'm not sure why stability makes it something we wouldn't want on our records. The ones I treated with SG over 30 years ago have been played many, many times and still sound great, very quiet, and don't appear to need washing. Also, I still have the Shure V15 and original stylus that did so many of those playings. That is also in great shape after over 20 years. I would definitely use it again if I could.

Has anyone tried GroOve Lube? I've been tempted, but... Maybe I'll try it on a LP from my wife's old, poorly handled collection and examine the stylus after a few sides.

upload_2016-11-15_10-36-11.jpeg BTW. This is the first thing that popped up when I googled it. :^o
 
Has anyone tried GroOve Lube? I've been tempted, but... Maybe I'll try it on a LP from my wife's old, poorly handled collection and examine the stylus after a few sides.

The Grooove lube product is polydimethylsiloxone, a coating I wouldn't want on my records, though it is common in car shine products like Armorall and even in Jo clitoral cream (another place I would not recommend its use).
 
Washing piece of dirty vinyl not needing to be complicated or costing any real money
Watch film on how Lp gets made from beginning to end for decades
Soap and water LOTS of water maybe little alcohol and few drops of phot-flo
Little bit of mild soap safe for plastic and clean distilled water water water water
Record cleaning machine good too best way to go for efficiency
I wish I had penny for every word written on this subject! ; - )
JJ
 
Just found Guest110's posts and others experiences with GroOove Lube on the Gruv Lube thread. Interesting fact about the Jo clit cream! (see above). I guess I'll just go with doctoring my wash with Hepastat & Triton.
 
Washing piece of dirty vinyl not needing to be complicated or costing any real money
Watch film on how Lp gets made from beginning to end for decades
Soap and water LOTS of water maybe little alcohol and few drops of phot-flo
Little bit of mild soap safe for plastic and clean distilled water water water water
Record cleaning machine good too best way to go for efficiency
I wish I had penny for every word written on this subject! ; - )
JJ
As explained in this thread, the soap you use matters. Lots of products remove dirt, but we aren't washing dishes here, we are washing a piece of plastic carefully pressed with fine, varying microgrooves used to reproduce sound. Everything that touches it can effect the integrity of the sound. But yes, it doesn't have to be complicated. A little non-ionic detergent and distilled water and you're generally good to go.
It only get's complicated when specific contaminants need to be removed or particular issues need to be resolved.
 
Last edited:
Careful clean and rinse matters more than soap dawn is fine but just very small amount like few drops
Can effect and does effect blown out of proportion
Too much over thinking on this subject and did not use to exist and people actually enjoy their Lp instead of worrying about the molecules on them! ; - )
Back in old days all the popular photographs of record grooves before and after get this all started and still going today making bank for some people!
I briefly caught up with this worry too and one day said STOP!
Enjoy turntable more now
Every one should watch good film on record pressing plant and then may be not worry so much if they are hurting something
People worry same way over Lp like when they have first baby by third child realize babies are pretty durable same for Lp!
; - )
Just use common sense and do not drop baby or Lp no harm no foul!
No fried chicken during Lp listen session either! ; - )
My opinion view
JJ
 
Glad you're enjoying your turntable more now, JJ! Always good for us to each find the right balance of perfectionist attention to detail and just enjoying the music.

For me, the attention to the details is revitalizing my record collection and my listening enjoyment.
 
Careful clean and rinse matters more than soap dawn is fine but just very small amount like few drops

As always said in this thread, if you are happy with your results, then that's great! Some of us noticed Dawn gave us issues with static so we looked for something better and discuss our results. To each their own, there are no fouls here.
 
As always said in this thread, if you are happy with your results, then that's great! Some of us noticed Dawn gave us issues with static so we looked for something better and discuss our results. To each their own, there are no fouls here.
Dawn can not create static on plastic has to be something else but I hear what you say not the first time
So I am not going to argue with what any person say happens to them how can I know I am not there?
I tell truth I have not read whole thread but dawn is surfactant and kill static on plastic
Been used at aerospace missile facilities for same purpose static electricity control elimination
Plenty published papers on internet some by U.S. Navy on subject if interested in mechanism of action
Here is story just one consumer worker guy but same point
http://hingstssignpost.blogspot.com/2014/07/prepping-acrylic-sheet-prior-to.html
Plenty more consumer type stories a lot by hard core computer guys wanting to protect equipment in plastic cases
But NEVER use ones with hand softener that sort of junk just the soap
JJ
 
Dawn can not create static on plastic has to be something else but I hear what you say not the first time
So I am not going to argue with what any person say happens to them how can I know I am not there?
I tell truth I have not read whole thread but dawn is surfactant and kill static on plastic
Been used at aerospace missile facilities for same purpose static electricity control elimination
Plenty published papers on internet some by U.S. Navy on subject if interested in mechanism of action
Here is story just one consumer worker guy but same point
http://hingstssignpost.blogspot.com/2014/07/prepping-acrylic-sheet-prior-to.html
Plenty more consumer type stories a lot by hard core computer guys wanting to protect equipment in plastic cases
But NEVER use ones with hand softener that sort of junk just the soap
JJ
My son works at a NASA lab in Boulder. They use quats as antistats. So do all hospitals and chip makers. Dawn's main ingredient is SDS...an anionic detergent. Water alone kills the static charge when wet so any aqueous solution will do in that case. However, a micro layer of this charge is left behind after drying. This is what makes the record susceptible to static charge. I have verified this myself with an electrostatic voltmeter that I got from a friend at Xerox (where they also use quats as antistats).
Don't get me wrong, SDS is a great detergent...even stronger than the non-ionics we are discussing here so if it yielding the results you desire and you aren't having issues with static...keep using it.
 
Last edited:
Dawn can not create static on plastic has to be something else but I hear what you say not the first time
So I am not going to argue with what any person say happens to them how can I know I am not there?
I tell truth I have not read whole thread but dawn is surfactant and kill static on plastic
Been used at aerospace missile facilities for same purpose static electricity control elimination
Plenty published papers on internet some by U.S. Navy on subject if interested in mechanism of action
Here is story just one consumer worker guy but same point
http://hingstssignpost.blogspot.com/2014/07/prepping-acrylic-sheet-prior-to.html
Plenty more consumer type stories a lot by hard core computer guys wanting to protect equipment in plastic cases
But NEVER use ones with hand softener that sort of junk just the soap
JJ
Jimmy this thread has shone a light on the process of record cleaning. It has been a revelation and to my knowledge there is not another one like it in English anywhere else. You could expend your time in far worse ways than to take the time to read through it all. Take your time read a couple of pages at a time. In comparison you have leaped in with Dawn dishwashing liquid as if this is some Wonder product. Jimmy in the context of what is being discussed here, Dawn is not comparable.

Do yourself a favour Jimmy. Read the thread. Keep the Dawn for your dishes.
 
Jimmy this thread has shone a light on the process of record cleaning. It has been a revelation and to my knowledge there is not another one like it in English anywhere else. You could expend your time in far worse ways than to take the time to read through it all. Take your time read a couple of pages at a time. In comparison you have leaped in with Dawn dishwashing liquid as if this is some Wonder product. Jimmy in the context of what is being discussed here, Dawn is not comparable.

Do yourself a favour Jimmy. Read the thread. Keep the Dawn for your dishes.
You sound very condescending dawn just a well known example only reason I cite no wonder product
The rest of your post rude and just YOUR conjecture
You do not know me or any thing about me
My post was about cleaning Lp and fact that I disagreed with some claims made here what is wrong with that?
On other hand all you give is lecture
Save for self
JJ
 
My son works at a NASA lab in Boulder. They use quats as antistats. So do all hospitals and chip makers. Dawn's main ingredient is SDS...an anionic detergent. Water alone kills the static charge when wet so any aqueous solution will do in that case. However, a micro layer of this charge is left behind after drying. This is what makes the record susceptible to static charge. I have verified this myself with an electrostatic voltmeter that I got from a friend at Xerox (where they also use quats as antistats).
Don't get me wrong, SDS is a great detergent...even stronger than the non-ionics we are discussing here so if it yielding the results you desire and you aren't having issues with static...keep using it.
That is fine thank you for nice post! ; - )
Sincere I mean that
I do not like expression because usually said by wise guys but this time I do not mean it as wise guy but we are going to agree to disagree
Life is too short for this and I just believe in my heart AND from consistent results for decades and trying MANY approaches that the worrying over record cleaning EFFICACY if done with common sense and done WELL meaning rinse all one needs at the core of the matter is
SOAP and WATER + a tiny bit of seasoning! ; - ) And of course appropriate soap
AND a good record cleaning machine if buying lots of used Lps! ; - )
JJ
 
I used to use Dawn, until this thread came along and Vince helped us to see the advantage to replacing it with something like Triton X-100. I have to say that with the Dawn, there was some (not a lot) of static. With the Triton, NONE.

Just my experience.
 
As a chemist, what is your opinion of Kodak Photo-flo? (That is what I use as my surfactant)

That's what I've been using also, just 2-3 drops per 250ml. It tends to leave a tiny bit of residue behind, or so I thought until I swapped to new velvet "lips" for my Okki Nokki.

My mixture is 1/3 anhydrous isopropyl (99%) alcohol, 2/3 distilled mineral free water, and 2-3 drops of photo flo per unit. The bottles I use are 250ml so it's easy to pre-measure. The photo flo drops are from a small syringe. Seems like the big bottle of photo flo I bought is going to last a lifetime.
 
I like Illfotol much better than Photoflo. Photoflo has been discussed here and it is mostly propylene glycol with a little Triton. This will break surface tension of water, but photographers here have chimed in and said they find photoflo leaves a glycol film behind. Hence it's a no for me.
On the other hand, the primary component of Illfotol is a C12-15 Alcohol ethoxylate detergent (not defined due to propriety, but basically the same as Triton and Tergitol) along with a small amount of Methylisothiazolinone (which isn't all that good for you but is a pretty common preservative in household products). Hence, it is fairly similar to what many are using in this thread. So, if I had to use a product from the photography field, the choice is obvious.
 
Last edited:
Some one will have some thing negative to say about ANY thing
Here is good music on that fact!
Can REALLY see this today with internet
Does not matter what it is even if was free $20 bill
Just read reviews for any product at amazon
My favorite for good laugh is any kind of glue or adhesive
Then I go crazy when read WHY they do not like product
If think about every thing in life on this level then never eat drink take bath go out doors may be even try and figure out how not to breathe
Here we go again! ; - )
I not buying it Lps not this hard and to make any one happy this my last post to this one promise! ; - )
JJ

 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom