• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dissolving the Triton can be a tedious process, due to its high viscosity. I find that adding it very slowly to room temperature water + IPA works pretty well. Constant stirring seems to be the key.

Perhaps the small volumes that you are working with are impeding your ability to provide adequate and constant stirring during the dissolution process.

Maybe an inexpensive (used) magnetic stirring machine can do the work? A new one is about 70 bucks...
 
Yes, LOC recommended refrigeratation. But the MSDS for Tertigol does not, and I believe it may have been Vince1 who commented that the 100 percent concentrate would hang around for years.
It only remains for years if you use sterile pipettes to draw from it. It isn't a bad practice to keep it refrigerated to prevent mold growth (some can use the detergent as a carbon source and grow). Diluted solutions should be refrigerated or used at once since the vessels and water used at home for dilution is unlikely to be sterile. If quats are added, they can remain at room temperature. I always add quats if I'm filling a RCM chamber where the solution sits. Otherwise, it is an incubator for molds! IPA is not enough (you need over 50% to kill microorganisms and that could be too much for use on records).

There are 50 pages... is this solution only for mechanical cleaning or can it work for ultrasonic? Which I guess is also technically mechanical cleaning but hands off... Would this solution in an ultrasonic tank make suds all over the place or are the surfactants going to prevent suds?
Not sure which solution you are talking about, but solutions of 0.1% or less non-ionic detergent are fine in an US bath (they don't over-foam). I typically go even more dilute in the bath, around 0.02%Triton.


You don't need much stirring if you dissolve the Triton in a small volume of 90% IPA first, then dilute the mix down with water. Goes right in. If you are going IPA free, then mixing and time are needed...and a stir bar/plate really helps. Do NOT use heat...that will make matters worse.
 
Last edited:
Not sure which solution you are talking about, but solutions of 0.1% or less non-ionic detergent are fine in an US bath (they don't over-foam). I typically go even more dilute in the bath, around 0.02%Triton.


You don't need much stirring if you dissolve the Triton in a small volume of 90% IPA first, then dilute the mix down with water. Goes right in. If you are going IPA free, then mixing and time are needed...and a stir bar/plate really helps. Do NOT use heat...that will make matters worse.

Thanks! I wasn't referring to any one of them in particular, I've read about 10 pages so far, but didn't see any mention of using them in US cleaners. My winter projects include a DIY US cleaner, and one of the formulations in this thread will end up in the tub. Great thread! I like the sterile pipette advice. I brew beer and make mead, so I have all sorts of lab equipment in the meadery/brewery.
 
I would be very careful here. Temperature can affect the action of each component together or separately, so the trick is to find the temperature that gives the best results. I've assumed that 18 to 20 degrees celsius is about the best, and have a room where I can produce this temperature reliably.

I don't use tergitol, by the way, but I'm assuming the same would apply as it does to washing up liquid.
 
@MannyE
Glad to meet another member of this forum who setting up an ultrasonic record cleaner and looking at these formulations for ultrasonic cleaning purposes. After going through the entire thread twice, I came up with the process I'll be starting with for my ultrasonic tank experiments. I summarized what I plan to do in post #960 on page 48:
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....re-doing-it-wrong.689430/page-48#post-9903754

I look forward to hearing what you decide to do and how it works for you!
 
It only remains for years if you use sterile pipettes to draw from it. It isn't a bad practice to keep it refrigerated to prevent mold growth (some can use the detergent as a carbon source and grow). Diluted solutions should be refrigerated or used at once since the vessels and water used at home for dilution is unlikely to be sterile.

Hmmm, I can see that I will be taking up some refrigerator space from the household! And purchasing some disposable sterile pipettes.
 
@MannyE
Glad to meet another member of this forum who setting up an ultrasonic record cleaner and looking at these formulations for ultrasonic cleaning purposes. After going through the entire thread twice, I came up with the process I'll be starting with for my ultrasonic tank experiments. I summarized what I plan to do in post #960 on page 48:
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....re-doing-it-wrong.689430/page-48#post-9903754

I look forward to hearing what you decide to do and how it works for you!

I'll be posting a step by step of the build when it happens.
 
:beerchug: Looking forward to following what you do! For me, it's order parts and assemble rather than diy: Trusonik 10L tank, VinylStack spin kit, bbftx's filter design, lot's of help from this forum on the solution for the tank and for the ultrapure water rinse.
 
Getting back on track, the quat mix I have recently been working with is commercially sold as Hepastat 256. It is available in the US from Amazon or even Staples as a concentrate that contains 10-20% quat compounds*, 4-8% non-ionic detergent, 4-8% EDTA, 1-3% Ethanol, and 1-2% Sodium Metasilicate (along with some minor dye and fragrance). The product is marketed as a “one-step” disinfectant, cleaner, sanitizer, fungicide, mildewstat, bactericide and virucide. As known from this thread, the quats are also powerful anti-stats and the product performs very well in this regard. I am now using it on records at a 1:500 dilution which turns out to be about 5 cents/gallon of working solution. Though it works fine alone, I’ve been combining the 1:500 diluted Hepastat with 0.2% Triton and 5% IPA in a mixture that achieves great results. Note, this is for a wash step where the solution is scrubbed on with a paint pad then rinsed off with distilled water. I follow with a final distilled water rinse on an RCM. I have also used the solution at 1:1000 dilution in an ultrasonic cleaner where it also works very well (the low cost of the diluted product is an advantage when filling these large tanks). The pH of the diluted product is around 8.0, slightly basic, which is desirable to neutralize any acid breakdown within the PVA-PVC matrix. For those looking to add quats to their wash solutions, this product makes it easy. The solution can be stored at room temperature and even used around the house as a disinfectant (they use Hepastat in hospitals and food service facilities).


*Mix of Octyl decyl dimethyl ammonium chloride, Dioctyl dimethyl ammonium chloride, Didecyl dimethyl ammonium chloride, and Alkyl dimethyl benzyl ammonium chloride
So..., for those of us using a solution of Triton (or Tertigol) with IPA, would you recommend adding a dilution of Behentrimonium Chloride (as discussed earlier in this thread) or the Hepastat 256?

In my case, I am using a pump and filter with my ultrasonic tank, and have been concerned about having some of the ultrasonic bath solution remaining in the pump and filter canister in between batches of records. I have been thinking of adding a quat to the solution for it's anti-microbial properties, but also wondering if it will even make a difference at the very high dilution used in an ultrasonic cleaner. Thoughts?
 
So..., for those of us using a solution of Triton (or Tertigol) with IPA, would you recommend adding a dilution of Behentrimonium Chloride (as discussed earlier in this thread) or the Hepastat 256?

In my case, I am using a pump and filter with my ultrasonic tank, and have been concerned about having some of the ultrasonic bath solution remaining in the pump and filter canister in between batches of records. I have been thinking of adding a quat to the solution for it's anti-microbial properties, but also wondering if it will even make a difference at the very high dilution used in an ultrasonic cleaner. Thoughts?

If bacteria are really a concern, then you need to make sure you sanitize the pump before you use it, maybe by running some sort of higher strength antibacterial solution for a minute or so, then rinsing it with straight water. I'm just kind of jumping in the middle here, but I do that same exact thing with my pumps and filters when I'm bottling mead. I know it's very different from the pump in an US cleaner, but if you're concerned about contamination then the only way to be sure is to sanitize, rinse, then sanitize again after use. Even at high dilution, you're going to risk something funky growing in the inner workings of the pump over time (I think).

You didn't mention if you're heating the solution at any point though. If your cleaner has the ability to heat, then running straight water through at 160-165F will probably kill anything that's hiding in the pump. You might do this when you are done, then once again before you clean another batch.

Then again, you may be right about the tiny amounts...
 
Question for the chemists here: With such low concentrations of Triton or Tergitol, how is it that micelles can actually form? Without attaining cmc (critical micell concentration), I don't see how contaminant sequestering can occur.

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
Question for the chemists here: With such low concentrations of Triton or Tergitol, how is it that micelles can actually form? Without attaining cmc (critical micell concentration), I don't see how contaminant sequestering can occur.

Enjoy,
Rich P
That's a really good question Rich, but for Triton X-100, the CMC is about 0.013% and we are generally using 0.05% and above. The only dilute solution is in ultrasonic devices where we are at 0.02%. It should be pointed out that these values are for room temperature applications: the CMC of non-ionic detergents increases with temperature.The value also changes when other components are in the solution (e.g. quats will co-aggregate and IPA will lower the CMC) and the amount of foam produced (bubbles reduce the amount of detergent available to produce micelles). That said, even below the CMC detergents partition into the oil/water interface, they just won't break up the membranes or effectively solubilize soils (detergency). But they do dramatically break up the surface tension of the environment (which is why they are referred to as surfactants). So we like to use detergents above the CMC when cleaning but one could also use them below the CMC in rinsing solutions so as to reduce the surface tension of the aqueous solution and improve wetting. Hope this helps.

Edit: Tergitol is more complicated as each type has its own CMC. The different types were created for different applications (wetting, emulsifying, anti-foaming, etc.). More care is needed to select the appropriate type or mix of types for record cleaning.
 
Last edited:
Any inferences to be drawn for this formula (re CMC, base or resulting concentrations, etc.)? The specific Tergitols used are not specified (it is stated to be a proprietary blend), nor are any other components specified: https://www.amazon.com/Professional...=UTF8&qid=1473669017&sr=8-1&keywords=Tergitol The product appears to be a convenient quantity, in a convenient package, albeit a bit pricey. Considering the advertised capacity, the price is not distasteful to me.

Co-aggregate? What does that mean? Quats will form their own aggregates, or join with the non-ionic detergents in theirs?

Is stirring required, or will normal molecular agitation do the job over extended time? What I'm looking for is, can the required amount of concentrated non-ionic detergent be added to the distilled water and left to sit for a few days? Or, in the absence of stirring, or graduated introduction, will the Tergitol, or Triton, fail to mix or micellize?

For me, overly contaminated LPs are rejected, based upon visual inspection. I want a good formula for cleaning LPs that have been well cared for and are already essentially clean. I don't want the inconvenience of multiple rinse steps. I understand that a residual molecular layer is pretty much unavoidable, maybe even desirable, but will a single rinse with distilled water be sufficient with the above product, at the recommended concentration?

What about brushes and pads? Some are not changeable between steps (wash and rinse), with some machines (vacuum type). I don't want to use a formula that will counteract a rinse step by remaining in a fixed pad, after vacuuming.

What kind of time is required to solubize light contaminants? Can a proper concentration be applied, followed by immediate agitation (via brush or pad), followed by immediate vacuum removal? Or, must the solution be applied and distributed, followed by a waiting period, before agitation? It seems that wetting would be an important factor if a waiting period is required. I don't know why, but some LPs wet better than others (vinyl formulations, previous applications or residues, mold releases, etc?).

Will the use of the above product, or other non-ionic detergent, at the recommended concentrations, dislodge or displace the molecular layer, or residue, of previously used ionic detergents? If not, what steps must be added to ensure such?

How does the non-ionic detergent act (i.e. the molecular layer or residue) in the absence of the water that originally deposited it? Do they align in some way, (hydrophobic tails or hydrophilic heads all facing up), or what? I am guessing that the vinyl molecules will determine that , but I am unable to guess how.

Sorry for the extended queries, but it is time to get down to the nitty gritty, for me.

Enjoy,
Rich P

PS: Here is a page with lots of nice microscopic shots of vinyl grooves, so you can see what we are dealing with here: http://www.dak.com/reviews/3306story.cfm The good stuff is toward the bottom of the page. Please note that (unstated in the piece) for electron micro-graphs to work, the subjects must be conductive, so some kind of deposition of a conductive layer was required. This could account for the somewhat pock-marked groove walls. You are not looking at actual vinyl, but the conductive deposition layer (possibly vapor-deposited). The shots are quite good, however. BTW, there is no way that I believe that the level of post cleaning cleanliness resulted from wiping with the brush being advertised.
 
Last edited:
If bacteria are really a concern, then you need to make sure you sanitize the pump before you use it, maybe by running some sort of higher strength antibacterial solution for a minute or so, then rinsing it with straight water. I'm just kind of jumping in the middle here, but I do that same exact thing with my pumps and filters when I'm bottling mead. I know it's very different from the pump in an US cleaner, but if you're concerned about contamination then the only way to be sure is to sanitize, rinse, then sanitize again after use. Even at high dilution, you're going to risk something funky growing in the inner workings of the pump over time (I think).

You didn't mention if you're heating the solution at any point though. If your cleaner has the ability to heat, then running straight water through at 160-165F will probably kill anything that's hiding in the pump. You might do this when you are done, then once again before you clean another batch.

Then again, you may be right about the tiny amounts...
Thanks, MannyE!
 
Any inferences to be drawn for this formula (re CMC, base or resulting concentrations, etc.)? The specific Tergitols used are not specified (it is stated to be a proprietary blend), nor are any other components specified: https://www.amazon.com/Professional...=UTF8&qid=1473669017&sr=8-1&keywords=Tergitol The product appears to be a convenient quantity, in a convenient package, albeit a bit pricey. Considering the advertised capacity, the price is not distasteful to me.

Co-aggregate? What does that mean? Quats will form their own aggregates, or join with the non-ionic detergents in theirs?

Is stirring required, or will normal molecular agitation do the job over extended time? What I'm looking for is, can the required amount of concentrated non-ionic detergent be added to the distilled water and left to sit for a few days? Or, in the absence of stirring, or graduated introduction, will the Tergitol, or Triton, fail to mix or micellize?

For me, overly contaminated LPs are rejected, based upon visual inspection. I want a good formula for cleaning LPs that have been well cared for and are already essentially clean. I don't want the inconvenience of multiple rinse steps. I understand that a residual molecular layer is pretty much unavoidable, maybe even desirable, but will a single rinse with distilled water be sufficient with the above product, at the recommended concentration?

What about brushes and pads? Some are not changeable between steps (wash and rinse), with some machines (vacuum type). I don't want to use a formula that will counteract a rinse step by remaining in a fixed pad, after vacuuming.

What kind of time is required to solubize light contaminants? Can a proper concentration be applied, followed by immediate agitation (via brush or pad), followed by immediate vacuum removal? Or, must the solution be applied and distributed, followed by a waiting period, before agitation? It seems that wetting would be an important factor if a waiting period is required. I don't know why, but some LPs wet better than others (vinyl formulations, previous applications or residues, mold releases, etc?).

Will the use of the above product, or other non-ionic detergent, at the recommended concentrations, dislodge or displace the molecular layer, or residue, of previously used ionic detergents? If not, what steps must be added to ensure such?

How does the non-ionic detergent act (i.e. the molecular layer or residue) in the absence of the water that originally deposited it? Do they align in some way, (hydrophobic tails or hydrophilic heads all facing up), or what? I am guessing that the vinyl molecules will determine that , but I am unable to guess how.

Sorry for the extended queries, but it is time to get down to the nitty gritty, for me.

Enjoy,
Rich P

PS: Here is a page with lots of nice microscopic shots of vinyl grooves, so you can see what we are dealing with here: http://www.dak.com/reviews/3306story.cfm The good stuff is toward the bottom of the page. Please note that (unstated in the piece) for electron micro-graphs to work, the subjects must be conductive, so some kind of deposition of a conductive layer was required. This could account for the somewhat pock-marked groove walls. You are not looking at actual vinyl, but the conductive deposition layer (possibly vapor-deposited). The shots are quite good, however. BTW, there is no way that I believe that the level of post cleaning cleanliness resulted from wiping with the brush being advertised.

I may be able to address some of these questions. As for the product you linked, it is not disclosed which Tergitols are in their proprietary mix. However, it is likely 15-S-9, 15-S-7, or NP40 since these are water soluble and common. They also have low CMCs (0.006, 0.004, and 0.018 respectively).
Yes, detergents form mixed micelles when added together. These micelles will then have their own unique properties.
Stirring helps and is required for Triton if you are not using IPA unless you want to wait a long time. It doesnt have to be continuous, just swirl the flask frequently, but it still takes hours.
The surfactants are loosely bound (by hydrophobic interactions). Any subsequent detergent wash solubilizes them. Nobody knows how many molecules are bound, which components they are bound to, nor what happens as the needle is drawn across the surface. These experiments just have never been done yet they would be fairly easy (using radioactive tracer forms of detergent). Such studies have been done in the food industry to determine how much residual detergent remains on washed foods, processing equipment, and utensils. It is known that the hydrophobic tails are what determine surface binding. The polar heads are exposed, which is why we want to avoid charged ones.
Two things are needed for the detergent to work most efficiently: First there should be some mechanical force to help dislodge and solubilize the contaminants. This can be a soft pad or ultrasonic disruption. Second, time is required to allow for partitioning. Think how presoaking dirty dishes allows for better cleaning. So let the detergent sit for a few minutes, just avoid letting the surface dry out. I typically use a 10 min presoak when using the soft paint pad method on really dirty records (e.g. thrifty finds). I only soak for a minute or so on relatively clean records (e.g. having just a few fingerprints). Rinsing, if you are only doing one, is best done with lightly warmed solutions as temperature is your friend. One the molecular layer is deposited, future wetting occurs readily (polar heads facilitate interaction with water).
You don't need EM to examine record grooves to assess cleaning protocols. A simple USB microscope works very well and can be had for $20 (also useful for examining stylus condition).
 
Last edited:
Diluted solutions should be refrigerated or used at once since the vessels and water used at home for dilution is unlikely to be sterile. If quats are added, they can remain at room temperature. I always add quats if I'm filling a RCM chamber where the solution sits. Otherwise, it is an incubator for molds! IPA is not enough (you need over 50% to kill microorganisms and that could be too much for use on records).
Just to clarify: those of us mixing up a 10% base solution of Tertgol/Triton with more than 50% IPA should have a sterile solution for purposes of storing the base solution over time, correct? While this base solution would store for quite some time, once mixed into water to create the US tank solution or the RCM solution, that final use solution should be used quickly.

I've ordered my disposable sterile pipettes and an inexpensive pump to draw from my 100% Tertigol containers and now have those containers safely refrigerated. It's a huge gift to get this knowledgeable advice that the non-chemists among us can apply. Thank you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom