• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is. It is complete and utter BS.

However, if it makes you happy, why not? What works for me is a glass of wine or similar, only one per session, mind. Really cleans up and clears the listening, not just of vinyl but digital files, too.

I hesitate to characterize something like that until I at least have tried it or have investigated the mechanism by which it may or may not work. I try to keep an open mind, no matter how ridiculous the claims appear.
Now, the glass of wine experiment I have tried and can say, without a doubt, it really works!
 
What works for me is a glass of wine or similar, only one per session, mind. Really cleans up and clears the listening, not just of vinyl but digital files, too.
I can subscribe to the wine! As to the other portion of your comment, I'll choose not to take offense but simply assume you've not taken the time to become better informed through some actual listening trials.
:beerchug:
 
Last edited:
I think of cleaning generally, whether it be removal of grime, static, or possible magnetic interference so find most comments here on devices relevant. That said, there are existing threads on the Zerostat and perhaps a separate thread on magnetic "rearrangers" would be useful (though I pity the poor soul who starts it!)
 
Forum threads seldom stick religiously to topic, put it down to inquiring minds, so why should this one be different? It will return to topic, if that is its destiny :)
 
I agree, highly unlikely, but it has been reported by a few people. I never experienced it as (when I did have one decades ago) I would use it away from the turntable on a countertop.
I suppose. A few people get struck by lightening so I guess we should all hide in the basement during electrical storms.

Actually, I've used my gun quite heavily on the platter while doing a PVA peel, squeezing the handle continuously as the peel progresses. The Zerostat is a great way of keeping the static buildup to a minimum during the peel.
 
So, continuing with on topic questions... I'm curious about the differences in quality/purity between 99%, 91% and 70% isoproply alcohol that we use in our cleaning solutions. I've looked at the MSDS from Vi-Jon who manufactures the Swan brand of 99% isopropanol many of us use and the ingredients listed are the same across all concentrations: Isopropanol and deionized water (or sometimes just "water"). This leads me to suspect that, at least in this case with Vi-Jon, all the concentrations are identical expect for the amount of dehydration they've taken the product through.

The reason I ask is that many of us may be purchasing 99% thinking about greater purity, then diluting it with R/O deionized water as we mix our solutions. If I want to end up with a Tertigol 10% base solution with 60% of the base solution being isopropyl, am I just as well off to start with a 70% Swan/Vi-Jon isopropyl?

See this Vi-Jon isopropyl alcohol MSDS posted at Office Depot for example: http://www.officedepot.com/pdf/msds/877218.pdf
 
Last edited:
A lot of this can be cleared up if you understand that alcohols are typically produced via distillation:
IPA is now mostly made via direct hydration of chemical grade (90-99%) propylene (The old way was to use sulphuric acid). Propylene and water are heated and the liquid-vapour mixture under pressure passes into a trickle flow reactor containing sulphonate polystyrene cation ion exchange resins. Alternatively, the reaction can be carried out in the gas phase over a phosphoric acid-based fixed bed catalyst. There is also a liquid phase route employing a soluble tungsten catalyst. In any case, the IPA is obtained from the aqueous solution by distillation. The first distillation pass produces 70% IPA. The higher % IPA mixes require additional heat energy (and cost) to come off or additional rounds of distilling. They are a higher grade as other products (and components in the starting propylene material or water that have similar boring points) can come off with the 70%. The presence of these co-distilling contaminants is why the 70% preparation is not considered "Hospital" or "Pharmaceutical" grade. It's very difficult to get 100% as the compound is hydroscopic and will pick up moisture from the air, so 99% is considered pure. The impurities are water soluble so unless you are using it in the final rinse before drying (where residues are a concern), 70% should be fine.

Similarly, the purity of water is increased when it is double or triple distilled.
 
Last edited:
I've been on a mission in recent weeks to figure out my sources for high purity water to use in my record cleaning. I really don't want to set up my own home filtration process; I'd rather leverage someone else's volume of high quality water production whether from the grocery store or otherwise. The best source I've come across is some of the bulk filtered water sold in natural food stores. Not all are the same, however.

In my area, there is a Whole Foods Market with a bulk water dispenser. In this store, the water dispenser is provided and maintained by National Water Services, Inc., operating under the tradename Fresh Pure Waters. According to their website, they provide bulk water dispensers in natural food stores in 38 states and Canada. Whole Foods kindly put me in touch with their general manager who graciously answered several questions I'd posed to Whole Foods. The information he provided to me by email about their filtration process is available on the Fresh Pure Waters website at: http://freshpure.com/why-drink-freshpure/125-2/

I was interested in the deionized water dispensed by their in-store dispensers. As described on their website, they start with the municipal water supply, then push that water through multiple stages of filtration: sediment filter, granular activated carbon filtration, reverse osmosis membrane, and activated carbon block filters (per email received). When selecting the DI water tap on their dispensers, the already filtered R/O water is further passed through a DI column and then to the activated carbon block filters. The final step as the water is dispensed it pass it to through high intensity ultra-violet light for sterilization.

While Fresh Pure Water's Deionized water is clearly ultra-high purity water, they answered that "We would not call it equivalent to Type 1 Reagent Water or 18 megohm-cm water because Type 1 reagent water is ultra high purity water that must meet certain physical parameters that we do not target or measure. Since our water is dispensed to the open air and not a controlled filtered air environment, we cannot guarantee the 18 meg ohm resistivity. I would say that our deionized water is comparable but not identical to type 1 Reagent Water or 18 Meg ohm Water." Seems reasonable.

So, if really high purity water is something you'd like to use in your cleaning regimen, consider exploring what natural food stores are in your area and whether they offer bulk dispensed water. Then check to see what company provides and maintains that equipment, how frequently the water is testing, and how frequently the filters are replaced.

At $0.39 per gallon, I'm willing to bring my own container and will be using this for mixing up my cleaning solution.
 
Last edited:
Interesting, but I question this source of water. The process of de-ionization effectively removes ions but is ineffective or is minimally effective at removing contaminants that are not charged (negatively or positively). Ions are generally not what contaminate records or lead to audible defects (unless one type is in excess significant enough to produce an electrostatic field or a mineral deposit). Audible contaminants on records are typically inorganic particles (like sand or dust fibers) or organic material (like proteins, fats, and microorganisms) and frequently a combination of both (e.g an oily fingerprint that has collected dust). Fact is, most organic contaminants, including bacteria and pathogens are not removed by de-ionization. Subsequent UV light exposure might kill the organisms, but what happens to the cellular material (dead cells)? Either the DI water has to be ultra micro filtered (or better yet nano-filtered) or it should be distilled. Reverse osmosis is the ultimate "filtration" method and properly prepared RO water should be more than sufficient for record cleaning/rinsing. If the correct pore size is used, RO water is pure and should not need further deionization, sterilization, or carbon filtration. Good RO water leaves no residue behind which is why it is used for cleaning windows and glass lenses. Hence, I'm puzzled by what Fresh Pure is producing. What pore size membrane are they using in their RO process that results in water needing further processing? How is it better than distilled water sold in the same aisle? The key determinant is not the amount of ions measured via resistance or conductivity, but rather the total dissolved solids (inorganic and organic) in the water that leave a residue upon evaporation/drying as these are what may be heard on the record surface (many of these being charge neutral). Sorry for the rant, and I admit I have no first hand experience with Fresh Pure, but there are many questions to be answered here and it appears the company is responsive so it may be worth inquiring.
 
Last edited:
The deionization stage comes only AFTER sediment filtering, granular activated carbon filtration and reverse osmosis.

At their dispensing station, you have the choice of selecting just RO water. in this case the water has gone through sediment filtering, granular activated carbon filtration and reverse osmosis. If you choose DI water, the RO water is then further run through the dionization column.

The final stage from either the RO tap or the DI tap is to take the water through a further activated carbon filter block and the UV.

At their website they say:
In the deionization process, water first passes through the pre-filtration and reverse osmosis systems (above). It is then filtered through a special deionization medium, which further “polishes” the FreshPure® Waters RO water by removing the 1-2% of trace minerals that may remain. This deionized water can exceed distilled bottled water in its purity. ​
And:
FreshPure® Waters RO Water contains only trace levels of minerals (typically 5-20ppm). FreshPure® Waters DI water has virtually no TDS at all.
​
No rant, just good questions on your part. I'm just trying to understand and to learn, so I value the further questions you raise.
 
FreshPure® Waters DI water has virtually no TDS at all.
.​
​
If this claim is accurately measured (via evaporation), this is some damn good water! I care less about mineral content, it is the TDS that matters more. Unfortunately, people use resistance or conductance as a means to measure TDS (using a subjective "factor") that has little relation to the amount of uncharged material dissolved in the preparation (Unfortunately I suspect this is what FreshPure is using). We do a final water rinse and let it dry on our records. It would be nice to have a consistent and comparative measurement that indicates how much total residue might be left behind by different preparations.
 
If this claim is accurately measured (via evaporation), this is some damn good water! I care less about mineral content, it is the TDS that matters more. Unfortunately, people use resistance or conductance as a means to measure TDS (using a subjective "factor") that has little relation to the amount of uncharged material dissolved in the preparation (Unfortunately I suspect this is what FreshPure is using). We do a final water rinse and let it dry on our records. It would be nice to have a consistent and comparative measurement that indicates how much total residue might be left behind by different preparations.
Good point about the testing. I'm reasonably sure they can't be doing an evaporation test. They must be relying on a conductance test when they run their periodic inspections of the equipment.

Questons about ultimate purity of this water is the reason I still plan to use Type I Reagent Grade water for my final rinse. I can obtain this from a local testing lab who's willing to give me a couple of gallons every now and again.

The bulk dispense water from the store is for the U/S tank to which I'll be adding a bit of the Tertigol 10% stock solution or for mixing a cleaning solution for manual wet vac cleaning. I'll also use it for any casual first step rinse of debris before putting the record into the U/S tank for cleaning. It's cheaper than the pre-packaged distilled or RO water I can buy off the shelf. With luck, it may even be better quality.
 
@phantomrebel, from what I'd read elsewhere, I was thinking that a digital conductance tester (like the HM Digital TDS-4TM Meter) would be an inexpensive tool to provide a bit of confidence about the relative changes in TDS in the U/S tank over the course of cleaning several batches of records. Given your comment above, I'm wondering if this will add any value. But, given my intended use of just checking on relative changes in the water over several cleaning batches, perhaps it's still a reasonable tool to have. Any thoughts?
 
I've noticed that atmospheric pressure has an impact on cleaning my records. On days with high pressure, the clezning process seems more in depth, if you know what I mean, and clicks/ rumble is reduced. On low pressure days, the records are still cleaned, if course, but, given low pressure usually means higher humidity, so they don't seem to dry as quickly. This seems to lead to a slower sound and higher inherent rumble.

I'm guessing that the slower drying times is allowing dust to settle into the groove, thus creating the higher rumble. That also adds weight to the record, meaning (I use belt drive exclusively) the records are heavier, put more strain on the motor which then turns them more slowly.

The only other explanation would be that higher humidity is contaminating the de-ionised water, but this seems far fetched. Anyway, I only clean my records on sunny days now, and only in the cold room I had installed as trmperature also has an impact.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom