• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
The large voltage potential the device can produce could easily fry a cartridge or other electronics. I think the device was made to treat records while off the turntable, but I've read of people using them on the table. Furthermore, how does one get exactly the same ion balance on a pull vs. the release? It's difficult to imagine not introducing charge. I used the device back in the 70's, along with my Dishwasher and never really achieved satisfactory results.
"Easily fry a cartridge or other electronics"? Don't think so....it wouldn't still be around if that were so. At it worst it makes no difference...at it's best it helps at least marginally...or it wouldn't still be around after 40+ years.

Of course it all depends on the end user and how he interprets the instructions. I've had satisfactory results with it, but I do admit that came with a learning curve.
 
Well, I'm not skilled enough to handle a 4kV spark around my cartridge. That's like a mini lighting bolt, something my equipment doesn't need to be exposed to. Quats in my cleaning solution, a humidified house, and quality sleeves ensure I never have any static issues. A device delivering unequal charges to a surface cannot be good. The author of the quoted piece is one of the pioneers of the technology and admits it's use on records is ill advised. The longevity argument is moot: I guess cigarettes are still on the market 40+ years because they are considered safe? I'm sure there is a safe way to use the device, but why when there are plenty of permanent solutions to static issues.
 
Last edited:
I've never heard of one frying a cartridge with a Zerostat and Zerostat has been around a long time. I use the Zerostat at the record cleaning machine (VPI) which I suspect generates enough friction to charge the record during the drying stage. I then transfer the clean, discharged record to the turntable.
 
I've been using a Zerostat since they were first introduced (30+years). Mine came with a Neon bulb that illuminates when "zapped" at close range. Not once has it caused any problems with any cartridge I've ever had. That includes MM, MI, HOMC and LOMC cartridges. Since the late 70's I've used it on LP's that were on the platter of my TT's

Comparing it to cigarettes is ridiculous. I say this as a cancer survivor.
 
I've been using a Zerostat since they were first introduced (30+years). Mine came with a Neon bulb that illuminates when "zapped" at close range. Not once has it caused any problems with any cartridge I've ever had. That includes MM, MI, HOMC and LOMC cartridges. Since the late 70's I've used it on LP's that were on the platter of my TT's

Comparing it to cigarettes is ridiculous. I say this as a cancer survivor.

Sorry, I wasn't comparing the device to cigarettes. I was referring to the argument that because a product has been in use for a long time it should be considered safe. Apologies if that wasn't clear. I'm glad you have had success. Nevertheless, I'll take the advice of one of the pioneers in the field and keep it for fire starting purposes only.
 
Tried wood glue. Now I have a LP that won't play at all.
My best is a 22 oz. jug of tap water with 4 drops of 409 mixed in well. I mount the LP and start the TT. I wipe slowly with an almost wet clean rag. Then wait a minute and wipe dry with a clean dry rag. The rags I use are from WalMart for $5 a bundle. I change rags every day. My wife washes them and final rinse in a no additive spin dry.
Seems to work. Very quiet and never any dust bunnies on the stylus. All of my LP's are from GW and savers so it may take 3 cleanings to get the dirt and yellow stain off.
Even my old jazz stuff from the 50's and 60's that I bought new when I was a kid sound better.
 
Tried wood glue. Now I have a LP that won't play at all.
My best is a 22 oz. jug of tap water with 4 drops of 409 mixed in well. I mount the LP and start the TT. I wipe slowly with an almost wet clean rag. Then wait a minute and wipe dry with a clean dry rag. The rags I use are from WalMart for $5 a bundle. I change rags every day. My wife washes them and final rinse in a no additive spin dry.
Seems to work. Very quiet and never any dust bunnies on the stylus. All of my LP's are from GW and savers so it may take 3 cleanings to get the dirt and yellow stain off.
Even my old jazz stuff from the 50's and 60's that I bought new when I was a kid sound better.


409? I'm surprised you don't experience static. The two major surfactants in that formula carry negative charge. Also, pH is listed as 10.5, quite basic. Maybe the large dilution you are using it at minimizes negative effects? However, when very dilute, micelles (what make surfactants most effective at cleaning) can't form. Sounds like a simple protocol though.
 
10.5 pH is quite mild in this regard. You need to start to worry when you get above pH 12, and then only after extended contact.
 
Last edited:
10.5 pH is quite mild in this regard. You need to start to worry when you get above pH 12, and then only after extended contact.
I was referring to the effect of pH on the surfactants. They are deprotanated at this pH (e.g the amine oxide is a weak base with pKa around 5) and carry a charge. I'm not suggesting that this pH would damage the vinyl...I have no idea... I am more concerned with introducing an environment prone to static build up.

On the other topic, can you, or anyone else, suggest links where I can find info on effects of high pH on PVC-PVA polymer artifacts? I'm interested to do some research.
 
Last edited:
Ahhh...understood. Thanks for the clarification.

In regards to the high [OH-] issue, let me check my database in the AM to see what I might have on the topic.
 
Last edited:
Tried wood glue. Now I have a LP that won't play at all..

If you value it, send it to me. I'll make it right. Something went awry. Did you use Titebond Type II ??

I've glued hundreds. Aside from one oddball Zappa album that I suspect was made with something other than the usual ingredients, zero problems, and countless "basket case" albums saved.

I'm serious about fixing it for you. PM for my addy if you wish.
 
I'm experimenting with a very interesting commercial cleaner that is almost all quats and widely available in the U.S. It is sold as a disinfectant cleaner since it contains mostly quat compounds, but it also contains all our favorite compounds mentioned in this thread like non-ionic detergent, EDTA and alcohol.* In preliminary experiments, it really does do a number on the moldy old thrift store finds (including covers). I'm currently testing it by itself, and in combination with other reagents on vinyl record surfaces. It removes molds, dirt, oils, proteins, kills static, and leaves no residue although it does contain a mild perfume (no biggie). For pennies/gallon, it appears to be a real winner, but I am still in the process of analyzing digitized samples and micrographs of treated records before I can recommend the best mix ratio.
 
Last edited:
@guest110
@GPJeff
@Wildcat
I'd like to thank the many folks in this thread who have provided so much good information about their formulations and experiences. I've been a long time user of Walker Audio Prelude 4-Step record cleaning on a VPI HW-17, but with over 6,000 records to clean, I have to find a faster process. Otherwise, I find I'm listening to records without cleaning them, and that just makes me crazy. So, I'm shifting to experimenting with ultrasonic record cleaning and trying to find the right mix of ingredients to add to the tank.

As many have noted, Vince (guest110) provided outstanding technical guidance in a way all of us non-chemists could understand and apply. Particular thanks are due to Wildcat and GPJeff for their summaries and because they are also using ultrasonic cleaning and sharing their experiences applying the chemistry there.

My limited contribution is to share what I'll be starting with for my ultrasonic record cleaning experimentation:
  1. Create a 10% base solution of Tertigol and isopropyl and R/O deionized water for storage and ease of use.
    (I'll be using half-and-half Tertigol S-15-3 and S-15-9 from TALAS, then topping up with 70% isoprophyl to achieve a 10% Tertigol, 60% isopropyl, 30% water base solution. No quats because I'm assuming the dilution in the U/S will be too great to make any difference. I'll make this simple by using a 4-ounce/118ml storage bottle so I can mix my base solution directly into my storage container. Add 5ml of each type of Tertigol for 10ml total to a few ml of 70% isopropyl, then fill to the 100ml pre-marked line on the bottle with 70% isopropyl. I've decided to use 70% isopropyl because it will automatically give the the final 10/60/30 percentage blend I want for the base solution. I'm using 60% isopropyl because the information in this thread said that greater than 50% alcohol was needed to keep the mix sterile in storage. Disposable 5ml transfer pipettes should make this easy to measure and mix.)

  2. In the U/S tank (10 liter tank in my case), I will use R/O deionized water that I can get from a local Whole Foods Market in bulk for $0.39 per gallon.

  3. The base solution will be added to the 2 gallons of water in the tank using 10ml of the base solution for a concentration of 0.13%. (per the recap provided by GPJeff in post #285. Thanks GPJeff!)

  4. I will rinse and vacuum dry the records coming out of the U/S cleaner. My rinse solution will be Type 1 Reagent grade water sourced from a local testing laboratory that is kind enough to give me a couple of gallons from time to time as needed. To the Type 1 Reagent Grade water, I will add a small amount of 95% ethanol or ethyl alcohol (denautured with methanol) as a drying agent.
    (I have experimented with pure water rinsing over many years and have been convinced by my listening tests that it makes a big difference in the wet/vac cleaning process I've always done. Using Type 1 Reagent grade water makes a further improvement beyond distilled water. Adding the ethanol will be an experiment but one that is consistent with the ultrapure commercial rinse waters I've obtained elsewhere.)
So, this is my starting point for experimentation, both with ultrasonic cleaning and with the water solutions to use with it. In a month or so I should be able to report back on some results. Thanks to all!
 
Last edited:
Thanks to this thread I have marvelously clean records to listen to.

A few days ago I ran out of PhanStat RCF in the 4 oz spray bottle and thought of using the spray bottle in a new way. Rinsed the bottle with distilled water and filled with Hy-Vee Premium :biggrin: Distilled Water. For about the last 10 records that I know have been cleaned recently, I just squirted about 15 sprays from the bottle to give them a distilled water rinse. After drying on the VPI 16.5 these records are so quiet, the quietest they have ever been. These are records I listen to frequently, so I noticed the difference in the first 10 seconds.

Never have final rinsed much in the past. Now I am a believer. Of course, YMMV :music:
 
The large voltage potential the device can produce could easily fry a cartridge or other electronics. I think the device was made to treat records while off the turntable, but I've read of people using them on the table. Furthermore, how does one get exactly the same ion balance on a pull vs. the release? It's difficult to imagine not introducing charge. I used the device back in the 70's, along with my Dishwasher and never really achieved satisfactory results.
l read here of a member that fried a microchip in their turntable using a gun, I don't recall who posted it but it was recently.
 
l read here of a member that fried a microchip in their turntable using a gun, I don't recall who posted it but it was recently.
I also read that people are cleaning their records with 409, Tilex and Simple Green. Go figure.

Abraham Lincoln once said "Don't believe everything you read on the internet."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom