• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
l read here of a member that fried a microchip in their turntable using a gun, I don't recall who posted it but it was recently.
I recently locked horns with Vince1 over this on another forum as his assertion is that these guns are dangerous. Let me just point out that assembly work of statically sensitive micro devices is performed under of flood of ionized air to prevent static discharge while the work is being performed. Because the gun emits ions from a fine point rather than a continuous flow of air the risk of sudden discharge resulting from a spark is real, however in order for that to happen the tip has to be within 1/2" of the object. In other words, the assertion that the gun can damage anything buried under a plinth is ridiculous to say the least. As to an ion field itself being dangerous, well....I'll take my cues from the industry that works with ESD sensitive devices, rather than hearsay and ignorant speculation.
 
I recently locked horns with Vince1 over this on another forum as his assertion is that these guns are dangerous. Let me just point out that assembly work of statically sensitive micro devices is performed under of flood of ionized air to prevent static discharge while the work is being performed. Because the gun emits ions from a fine point rather than a continuous flow of air the risk of sudden discharge resulting from a spark is real, however in order for that to happen the tip has to be within 1/2" of the object. In other words, the assertion that the gun can damage anything buried under a plinth is ridiculous to say the least. As to an ion field itself being dangerous, well....I'll take my cues from the industry that works with ESD sensitive devices, rather than hearsay and ignorant speculation.
Ripblade, I agree with you comments about the risks perhaps being overstated. I've had a Zerostat in my kit for decades and have always been prudent about where it pointed, but never anxious about it's damage potential. Still, as some others have reported, my experience is that my results with it are variable. Sometimes it seemed to add more charge that it successfully removed no matter how carefully I held the record away from other surfaces or squeezed and released the trigger. I eventually put it back in my audio toolbox and stopped using it.
 
Zerostats are pretty much ineffective if used on a record that is in place on a platter. This is because the ion stream sucks straight to any grounded metal, like the center spindle.

As an engineer, I can confidently state that there is little to no possibility of damage to electronics, unless the emission point is very close to a conductive equipment part that leads directly to sensitive electronics, such as metal control buttons or switches, or cartridge connections. "Very close" means closer than the 3/8" internal connections, where internal arcing will tend to take place (the snapping sound you hear if squeezing too fast). The internal arcing limits the voltage generated. If you purposely zap a button or connection, that is a different story.

Proof that the Zerostat works as desired, is seen in the statically charged LP clinging hard to a bit of debris, releasing that debris upon tipping and light blowing, after a shot or two from the Zerostat.

Remember, the Zerostat is essentially ineffective with the LP on the platter. The proper method is to hold the LP in one hand and squirt it with the Zerostat, one or twice, generally, before and after the brushing step. It doesn't hurt to squirt it once before inserting into its sleeve. In your hand, there is no possibility of damaging ANY sensitive electronics, PERIOD.

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
Sometimes it seemed to add more charge that it successfully removed no matter how carefully I held the record away from other surfaces or squeezed and released the trigger. I eventually put it back in my audio toolbox and stopped using it.
Yes, if you can afford it the Furutech deStat is a better option. Even better is the Panasonic ER-Q bench ionizer on a mic boom holding it over the record as it plays, but this is even more expensive and not without other risks.

For it's simplicity and relatively low cost the Zerostat has limited capabilities, but it's not useless or even dangerous if used by responsible, educated adults.
 
Last edited:
The issues lies not in the potential at the tip nor an accidental spark. The problem is, as Ruston and most Zerostat users experience, is that it is impossible to achieve an exact balance of charge. In an extreme example where ionization fails in one direction, there is the potential of creating an environment where you have momentary 1200 volts of charge. This charge will find a way to neutralize through a ground or conductor. This isn't a problem if the record is resting on your hand or on a countertop. But when it is on the turntable, it can go through something close like your cartridge when it is brought towards the record for playing. It is different than a bench ionizer where the air is ionized evenly throughout the environment. In more typical scenarios, the charge imbalance is mild but enough to attract dust.
 
there is the potential of creating an environment where you have momentary 1200 volts of charge. This charge will find a way to neutralize through a ground or conductor. This isn't a problem if the record is resting on your hand or on a countertop. But when it is on the turntable, it can go through something close like your cartridge when it is brought towards the record for playing.
Unlikely. It's never happened to me once in nearly 40 years of spinning vinyl. More likely the static will discharge through the spindle if the record is on the platter or through your body if you're holding the record.
 
Unlikely. It's never happened to me once in nearly 40 years of spinning vinyl. More likely the static will discharge through the spindle if the record is on the platter or through your body if you're holding the record.

I agree, highly unlikely, but it has been reported by a few people. I never experienced it as (when I did have one decades ago) I would use it away from the turntable on a countertop. I recall frequently experiencing spark-like pops if I wasn't super careful with the pull and release and I never achieved satisfactory (read consistent) results. Since then, my cleaning regimen has totally eliminated any issues with static whatsoever so such devices are obsolete.
 
I am glad I brought this up. And I have to admit I don't mind being somewhat ignorant about this subject as with this discussion I have learn how I have been using my gun incorrectly. I thought I was suppose to use it while on the table, and have many times done with while spinning a record in play. I also was led to be believe I should fire it at my turntable to discharge any static on the mat and table itself. Sometime I would hear it make popping noises thru my cartridge and I never thought of any damage to my turntable but worried about possible damage to my speakers, I am now more educated on the operation thanks to everybody's post.
 
While we're talking about anti-static solutions, I'll add one process that I've found consistent in improving the sound of my records: the Walker Talisman demagnitizer. For non-casual music listening, I use this on my LPs before each play and it always makes a consistent improvement in sound quality over not using it. I also use it on my cables and speaker drivers. Sounds crazy, but it works.

https://walkeraudio.com/?product=talisman-magnetic-optimizer

But this thing truly will do a bad number on your cartridge, so keep it away! It is a combination of several very strong magnets placed together in a particular combination of orientations.
 
While we're talking about anti-static solutions, I'll add one process that I've found consistent in improving the sound of my records: the Walker Talisman demagnitizer. ....Sounds crazy, but it works.
I am not doubting your experience with this demagnetizer, but am left wondering how a record gets significantly magnetized to begin with? To put it another way: PVC-PVA polymers are non-magnetic hence not significantly influenced by magnetic fields so I wonder what is really going on here?
 
Last edited:
I think the term "demagnetizer" may be a bit of a misnomer that is a holdover in my brain from years ago when it was first introduced. The record doesn't get magnetized. But, there apparently are electomagnetic fields (an example being static) that this composite magnet disrupts. The end result is a clearer, cleaner production of the LP. Same thing happens with cables and speaker cones. This is one of those "voodoo devices" everyone laughs about until they actually experience it.

The effect is not permanent. On cable and speaker cones, it only lasts the current listening session. On LPs, it's a "do it each play" part of the ritual of playing a record.
 
Sorry, my "magnetized" statement was ill-worded (which is why I rephrased it). Anyways, pretty interesting stuff there, and there must be an explanation. I do know that the PVA-PVC mix used in records also contains some heavy metal compounds. I wonder if the dipoles within these are being oriented by the applied field but how does this affect playback? Maybe the effect is rather on static as you suggest. In any event, thanks for bringing up yet another device to test!

Question: Can you detect a direct change in static charge when you treat an lp with this device? (e.g. charge up a record by rubbing and attract small pieces of lint or paper to it, then see if they fall off when treated.)
 
Last edited:
I think the term "demagnetizer" may be a bit of a misnomer that is a holdover in my brain from years ago when it was first introduced. The record doesn't get magnetized. But, there apparently are electomagnetic fields (an example being static) that this composite magnet disrupts. The end result is a clearer, cleaner production of the LP. Same thing happens with cables and speaker cones. This is one of those "voodoo devices" everyone laughs about until they actually experience it.

The effect is not permanent. On cable and speaker cones, it only lasts the current listening session. On LPs, it's a "do it each play" part of the ritual of playing a record.

Fremer had a similar experience with a demagnetizer. He looked genuinely surprised and had no explanation.

I'd probably wind up sticking the damn thing to my TV screen on accident, though...
 
This is just another example of how things can make a difference even when we don't completely understand the why of it. I love that people like @phantomrebel are always curiously searching for the science behind what we're exploring. I value the explanations when we have them. But, I've come to be a huge believer in "trust the ears" and in paying attention to what I'm hearing. Sure, I get tripped up by my own expectations into thinking I'm hearing what I expect. Happens to me many times. But that's why I have a listening partner who calls the question and keeps me straight. She has bat ears and knows in 10 seconds what I'm only beginning to figure out after 20 minutes or longer. ;)
 
This is just another example of how things can make a difference even when we don't completely understand the why of it. I love that people like @phantomrebel are always curiously searching for the science behind what we're exploring. I value the explanations when we have them. But, I've come to be a huge believer in "trust the ears" and in paying attention to what I'm hearing. Sure, I get tripped up by my own expectations into thinking I'm hearing what I expect. Happens to me many times. But that's why I have a listening partner who calls the question and keeps me straight. She has bat ears and knows in 10 seconds what I'm only beginning to figure out after 20 minutes or longer. ;)
LOL. My wife hears differences in cables that I simply cannot. She tends to always like the less expensive ones!
That said, Voodoo is simply an unsatisfactory explanation to me.
 
That said, Voodoo is simply an unsatisfactory explanation to me.
Me, too. There is always good science behind those tweaks or other improvements in our systems that are consistently and repeatedly observable through listening. We just may not yet have figured it out, and I love it when good, well grounded, explanations finally materialize.
 
Here's one example: silver contact enhancer pastes for electrical contacts. The results of these can be readily observed with the right test equipment measuring the effects of a material to material connection on the signal crossing it. There is always an energy spike. Before his time as an audio equipment designer, Lloyd Walker did final controls testing and final installation tweaking for nuclear and chemical plants. This was part of the work he did fine tuning the controls systems for higher accuracy and reliability before the plant was certified to go into operation. This experience led him to developing his E-SST Contact Enhancer (high purity silver, long crystal structure, suspension fluid decided upon through extensive trial and listening tests). Yet another "tweak" for which he was roundly ridiculed when he first released it nearly 20 years ago. But it is solidly grounded in good science and engineering. It is a staple in my system tool kit and his formulation far exceeds any alternate contact enhancer I've tried.
 
Sorry, my "magnetized" statement was ill-worded (which is why I rephrased it). Anyways, pretty interesting stuff there, and there must be an explanation. I do know that the PVA-PVC mix used in records also contains some heavy metal compounds. I wonder if the dipoles within these are being oriented by the applied field but how does this affect playback? Maybe the effect is rather on static as you suggest. In any event, thanks for bringing up yet another device to test!

Question: Can you detect a direct change in static charge when you treat an lp with this device? (e.g. charge up a record by rubbing and attract small pieces of lint or paper to it, then see if they fall off when treated.)
There is. It is complete and utter BS.

However, if it makes you happy, why not? What works for me is a glass of wine or similar, only one per session, mind. Really cleans up and clears the listening, not just of vinyl but digital files, too.
 
Zerostats are pretty much ineffective if used on a record that is in place on a platter. This is because the ion stream sucks straight to any grounded metal, like the center spindle.

As an engineer, I can confidently state that there is little to no possibility of damage to electronics, unless the emission point is very close to a conductive equipment part that leads directly to sensitive electronics, such as metal control buttons or switches, or cartridge connections. "Very close" means closer than the 3/8" internal connections, where internal arcing will tend to take place (the snapping sound you hear if squeezing too fast). The internal arcing limits the voltage generated. If you purposely zap a button or connection, that is a different story.

Proof that the Zerostat works as desired, is seen in the statically charged LP clinging hard to a bit of debris, releasing that debris upon tipping and light blowing, after a shot or two from the Zerostat.

Remember, the Zerostat is essentially ineffective with the LP on the platter. The proper method is to hold the LP in one hand and squirt it with the Zerostat, one or twice, generally, before and after the brushing step. It doesn't hurt to squirt it once before inserting into its sleeve. In your hand, there is no possibility of damaging ANY sensitive electronics, PERIOD.

Enjoy,
Rich P

Yes, record in one hand and the Zerostat in the other.

The best result you can get is when you also can control the humidity in your playing room!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom