• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ratio is about 6 parts water to 1 part alcohol. (Just my preference)

You can buy 99% Isopropyl on Amazon fairly cheap. I used to be able to get it at Safeway, but not anymore.

What about dawn soap? I've heard people putting that in as well. Is there any benefit to that?
 
natitude, searching this thread is a great way to start on finding answers. Using Dawn has been discussed many times. See this earlier post by phantomrebel that answers your question as a starting point:
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....e-doing-it-wrong.689430/page-55#post-10067269

But, to answer your question, using Dawn is okay but there are better detergents for our purposes that are not as likely to create a static charge.
 
natitude, searching this thread is a great way to start on finding answers. Using Dawn has been discussed many times. See this earlier post by phantomrebel that answers your question as a starting point:
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....e-doing-it-wrong.689430/page-55#post-10067269

But, to answer your question, using Dawn is okay but there are better detergents for our purposes that are not as likely to create a static charge.

Thanks! I'll go back through this thread and check the link to the other one. Gives me something to do over the holiday weekend!
 
What about dawn soap? I've heard people putting that in as well. Is there any benefit to that?
Yes little soap remove break down material water or alcohol can not like greasy contamination
But need to ask dawn just argued talked about here and other places about one millon times you trolling? : - (
JJ
 
I've gone through quite a few pages on this thread, but not all... I do have to ask, for the average collector, what's wrong with just using a Spin Clean? Especially when I anticipate cleaning a used record once, then brushing it as I go.
 
Yes little soap remove break down material water or alcohol can not like greasy contamination
But need to ask dawn just argued talked about here and other places about one millon times you trolling? : - (
JJ

I'm not trolling... sorry if you thought that. I'm new to this and haven't even cleaned my first record. In fact, I just bought my first couple (used records) from thrift store yesterday. Just trying to learn. I'm taking Rushton's advice and I'm reading this thread from the start.
 
I've gone through quite a few pages on this thread, but not all... I do have to ask, for the average collector, what's wrong with just using a Spin Clean? Especially when I anticipate cleaning a used record once, then brushing it as I go.
Nothing wrong with it!
JJ
 
I've gone through quite a few pages on this thread, but not all... I do have to ask, for the average collector, what's wrong with just using a Spin Clean? Especially when I anticipate cleaning a used record once, then brushing it as I go.

This thread concerns itself more with the solution than the method. There is nothing wrong with a SpinClean per se. It's criticisms are that each subsequent record gets cleaned in the dirty solution of the previous records. I personally use a system of two SpinCleans (one with cleaning solution derived from this thread and another with rinse water) and a home made vacuum system after each.
 
This thread concerns itself more with the solution than the method. There is nothing wrong with a SpinClean per se. It's criticisms are that each subsequent record gets cleaned in the dirty solution of the previous records. I personally use a system of two SpinCleans (one with cleaning solution derived from this thread and another with rinse water) and a home made vacuum system after each.
You have invested enough money in TWO spin cleans to buy nice used16.5! ; - )
JJ
 
You presume too much and maybe should listen more than you talk. You have no idea how much I paid for anything I have.
Why angry?
I do not care what you have or spend I was making harm less joke
Sorry you can not take kidding
And I not presuming any thing you guy who said I use two spin cleans and vacuum cleaner
That IS lot of work
May be 16.5 make you feel better relief from all the stress fatigue after record cleaning! ; - )
JJ
 
One thing folks might consider when using a Spinclean is that the system is optimized for use with Spin-clean washer fluid, which contains a flocculant that aggregates contaminants and helps keep them at the bottom of the tank. Hence, a standard DIY fluid may not be the best choice for this device. In a hand-washing protocol, I have used the device filled with dH20 to aid in final rinsing, but not for actual cleaning. I could provide some flocculant info if folks want to make their own "Spin-clean specific" cleaning solutions.
 
Last edited:
Here we go again! ; - )
I not buying it Lps not this hard and to make any one happy this my last post to this one promise! ; - )
JJ

shm.

Some very knowledgeable folks have explained in great depth and detail why some detergents are better for record cleaning. Other folks have shared their first-hand experience with using different detergent, and have expressed their satisfaction for one over the other. Dawn is a good detergent, but it does have its drawbacks in regards to the dyes and perfumes noted in previous post and its propensity towards static charge. In my experience, I find the Triton detergent and hepastat 256 yields better results. If you haven't tried the Triton, you may be pleasantly surprised when you do.
 
I could provide some flocculant info if folks want to make their own "Spin-clean specific" cleaning solutions.

I would be interested in hearing about flocculants. I use a Spin Clean with my own formula, which was an attempt to copy the Spin Clean formula. I use Triton and EDTA.
 
I would be interested in hearing about flocculants. I use a Spin Clean with my own formula, which was an attempt to copy the Spin Clean formula. I use Triton and EDTA.
Hi Donal:
Most flocculants are multivalent cations, the most common being a polymer of aluminium chloride. If you imagine the contaminants within the Spinclean bath to be surrounded by the negatively charged detergent (SDS in their case), you can see how they can be disrupted and attracted to a positively charged polymer, forcing them to aggregate. The flocculant further reacts with water to form an insoluble hydroxide, creating gelatinous precipitates that settle to the bottom of the chamber. Though the length of the polymer can be dialed in as they are each effective at specific pH ranges, the most common is Al12Cl12(OH)24 and I assume this is what Spin-clean uses (though they will not say). It is also the main component of most pool/spa, pond, and tank water clarifiers (Some may be familiar with the shorter polymer Al2Cl(OH)5, which is what is in many deodorant/antiperspirants).

Pure chemical reagent polyaluminum sulfate (typically added to about 0.1mM) may be difficult to find for most DIY-ers, but one can look to the pool/spa chemical suppliers (like HTH) or aquarium suppliers (like Tetra) for their “water clarifiers” and use them as directed as they are, for the most part, the same thing. Cationic polyacrylamide is another flocculant that can be used and sometimes found at water treatment supply houses, but it breaks down with time and with mixing.
I have played with the polyaluminum sulfate for use in an Ultrasonic cleaner tank, but found it unnecessary.
 
Last edited:
Thanks phantomrebel. I think I saw that Walmart carries something along the lines you mention. I'll check it out and give it a go.
 
Most flocculants are multivalent cations, the most common being a polymer of aluminium chloride.

Ok. Went to Walmart and got small bottle of Tetra water clarifier. Says it clears cloudy aquarium water. Add 5ml per 10 gallons. So it must only take a couple drops per gallon. Looked on the bottle for a list of ingredients and found none. Went online and found it contains sulfuric acid and aluminum sulfate anhydrous. Hmm. Is this the stuff to use for record cleaning?
 
Ok. Went to Walmart and got small bottle of Tetra water clarifier. Says it clears cloudy aquarium water. Add 5ml per 10 gallons. So it must only take a couple drops per gallon. Looked on the bottle for a list of ingredients and found none. Went online and found it contains sulfuric acid and aluminum sulfate anhydrous. Hmm. Is this the stuff to use for record cleaning?
I'm not liking that if it is just the salt (more like alum vs. polyaluminum), maybe they have multiple formulas? They use the sulfate to keep the fish water chloride free, but you really want the polymer. Walmart also has HTH pool flocculant which is almost pure polyaluminum chloride (a.k.a. aluminum chlorohydrate): https://www.walmart.com/ip/HTH-Flocculant-32-oz/37569666
That is the one I would get, even though the bottle is enough for 10 life times.
I suggest you try some "backyard" chemistry before you use a flocculant: As stated in my previous post, the pH and the charge of components is critical for the precipitate to form. If you are using a neutral detergent or have quats in your mix, the game changes (for example, the quats will compete for binding to the aluminum polymer). So, the best thing to do is to take a glass of your detergent mix and add a little silted dirt from your garden (not much, maybe a screwdriver's blade worth per cup). Mix it well to get everything in solution, then add the flocculant to see if it works. You should try 3 different flocculant concentrations to see which works best and use the minimum (no sense having extra flocculent around). Also, try a separate cup of dish soap (e.g. Dawn) in water with dirt added as a comparison. This kind of experimentation is fun, informative, and worth the effort to make sure you are on the right track. Finally, while at Wally's, pick up some pH paper (likely in aquarium supplies section) so you know where your solutions are. Keep us updated on your findings!
 
Last edited:
Well, took the Tetra back to Walmart. Website showed they had two of the HTH in stock, but when I asked, was told all the pool stuff had been put up and is not available. So I'm done for awhile. Maybe sometime later, I'll check it out again. I just recently finished cleaning the main part of my collection. Only thing left to clean are a bunch of old box sets that I picked up, mostly at GW. I used the Spin Clean with their solution till it ran out. From reading this thread , mostly, I was able to concoct my own solution, and have a method that doesn't work too bad. Time to enjoy some music.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom