• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Per the MSD sheet I found, it is Cyastat SN by another name, so definitely a quat, just not a simple tetra alkyl quat. If you found the ACL web site, you can see it comes in different concentrations which were not clear from the MSD sheet, I found elsewhere.
RE PVA. Are you speaking of Polyvinyl acetate(PVA) or Poly vinyl alcohol (PVOH) to differentiate? Re any effect on enzymatic cleaners, not my expertise.
Does anyone have a formula they could post using the ACL Staticide in place of the Cyastat?
 
Does anyone have a formula they could post using the ACL Staticide in place of the Cyastat?
If you are using the "general purpose" spray, it is <0.5% quat so I would dilute it 1:10 in your wash mix. ACL also makes their products in concentrates so we need to know what you have.

OT: Jimmy, Jimmy, Jimmy....tsk tsk!
 
I need to review one more time to make sure I get this correct (or within reason) from an operational standpoint for RCM use, because I have all my ingredients except the Triton X-100. I take it the ratios for RCM and US differ somewhat. To make a gallon of solution to spread on the surface of an LP I will:
Pre-dilute the Triton X-100 to 10% by mixing 5 ml with 25 ml Isopropyl alcohol (91%) and 20 ml DH2O. This is a stable solution. When I'm ready to make a gallon
Add the 50 ml solution above to a 1 gallon container. Add 3.8 ml Hepastat, 183 ml Isopropyl, and fill with DH20.

Is that OK?
If my calculations are correct, and that almost never happens, I'll have about 5.5% Iso
13.0% Triton X-100
0.1% Hepastat.

Then I'm opening a record cleaners store, just like those for clothes. No ticket, no Sheffields.
 
No, your math is off my friend. You are starting with a 10% solution of Triton and diluting it ~ 1:76 so that is 0.13% Triton (10 divided by 76) which is fine. You are starting with 20% quats (taking the high range given for Hepastat concentrate) and diluting it about 1:1000 which gives you 0.02% Quat (20 divided by 1000), which is also fine. If you use dilution factors, it makes it easier, I think. You did calculate your iso fairly well though! These are detergent concentrations that work well in an US bath, you may want to go 2X stronger for RCM or hand washing. You might also consider adding your Hepastat to the 10% Triton stock if you want to store it long term, but it looks like you make this just before using. Now, get going and let's see them clean records!
 
Last edited:
No, your math is off my friend. You are starting with a 10% solution of Triton and diluting it ~ 1:76 so that is 0.13% Triton (10 divided by 76) which is fine. You are starting with 20% quats (taking the high range given for Hepastat concentrate) and diluting it about 1:1000 which gives you 0.02% Quat (20 divided by 1000), which is also fine. If you use dilution factors, it makes it easier, I think. You did calculate your iso fairly well though! These are detergent concentrations that work well in an US bath, you may want to go 2X stronger for RCM or hand washing. You might also consider adding your Hepastat to the 10% Triton stock if you want to store it long term, but it looks like you make this just before using. Now, get going and let's see them clean records!

So I had the volume of Triton correct; I just had the decimal in the wrong place when I mistyped 13% instead of0.13%. If my Hepastat dilution is only 0.02% and I was shooting for 0.1%. I had the wrong target. I will revise my formula to 10 ml Triton/25 ml Iso/15 ml H20 to double the triton concentration. Can I add the 7.5 ml to that, or does that lower the alcohol concentration too much for storage? And you have the patience of a saint!
 
So I had the volume of Triton correct; I just had the decimal in the wrong place when I mistyped 13% instead of0.13%. If my Hepastat dilution is only 0.02% and I was shooting for 0.1%. I had the wrong target. I will revise my formula to 10 ml Triton/25 ml Iso/15 ml H20 to double the triton concentration. Can I add the 7.5 ml to that, or does that lower the alcohol concentration too much for storage? And you have the patience of a saint!
Yes, practice was correct, math was not. The key to storage is not the alcohol, but the quat. You actually need +50% alcohol for complete sterilization (due to the resilience of spores) while only sub-percentage concentrations of quat. This is why i recommended adding quat to the 10% stock if you choose to store it. Home brewers will confirm that even a 10% alcohol brew can spoil. The antimicrobial potency, and the antistat properties is what attracts me to quats. I might be simplifying too much technically, but I believe the alcohol is merely "drying out" the microbes, competing with stabilizing water, while the quats are actually disrupting the membranes and causing them to lyse (as if anyone is interested mechanisms of action!).
 
Last edited:
Yes, practice was correct, math was not. The key to storage is not the alcohol, but the quat. You actually need +50% alcohol for complete sterilization (due to the resilience of spores) while only sub-percentage concentrations of quat. This is why i recommended adding quat to the 10% stock if you choose to store it. Home brewers will confirm that even a 10% alcohol brew can spoil. The antimicrobial potency, and the antistat properties is what attracts me to quats. I might be simplifying too much technically, but I believe the alcohol is merely "drying out" the microbes, competing with stabilizing water, while the quats are actually disrupting the membranes and causing them to lyse (as if anyone is interested mechanisms of action!).
Having worked in hospitals most of my career, I can assure you that your lysing theory is accurate. But if quats are such good antistat agents, they should neither attract or repel you. (That's a bad joke. See what you get for helping?)
 
I've just bought the same bag. Did you just dissolve some in warm water? If so, how much of each did you use? Thanks!
Just going by memory as my cook book is at home (at work right now): I believe I used 5 mg Behentrimonium for 1 litre of my "special sauce" which is principally less than 10% of 99% IPA in a DH20 mix and 0.5% (or is it .05% - I can never remember which is why it is written down) Triton X-100 (all by weight vs volume). I find the Behentrimonium to be extremely difficult to fully dissolve so I had to filter out the jellyfish looking thingies using a coffee filter after about a week of letting the soup stew. Next time I mix a batch I will use hot water - practice and learn I guess....

Oh yeah, I also mix the Triton up front with the alcohol before adding to the DH20 as it dissolves well in IPA and subsequently makes it way easier for mixing into the DH20 as the X-100 doesn't then clump up as it does mixing into the distilled water on its own....

I mix a litre of final solution right away and don't do the intermediary concentrated solution - the less mixing crap up I do the better. That may change but so far so good...
:p
 
Last edited:
I find the Behentrimonium to be extremely difficult to fully dissolve so I had to filter out the jellyfish looking thingies using a coffee filter after about a week of letting the soup stew. Next time I mix a batch I will use hot water - practice and learn I guess....

You can also microwave heat the solution. Just be careful not to bring it to boil. 30 seconds, swirl, 30 seconds, swirl and it should go in ~ 180deg F. The pre-mix solutions of quat like Hepastat and others are far easier to use. Some Behen. preparations contain other ingredients that may leave a residue as they are prepped for cosmetic use (hair conditioner)...careful which one you get.
 
You can also microwave heat the solution. Just be careful not to bring it to boil. 30 seconds, swirl, 30 seconds, swirl and it should go in ~ 180deg F. The pre-mix solutions of quat like Hepastat and others are far easier to use. Some Behen. preparations contain other ingredients that may leave a residue as they are prepped for cosmetic use (hair conditioner)...careful which one you get.
Awesome, thank you - will try next time I mix up some home brew
 
Preferable choice: de-ionized or distilled H2O? Why? Sources for de-ionized?

Enjoy,
Rich P

Distilled - I use DI H2O vs DH2O to differentiate. I do have a source for Extremely pure De-Ionized water if I wanted as we just took delivery of a brand new state of the art DI Plant on the Base so getting a few liters wouldn't be hard. No point really though as DI water dies not stay DI water long as it starts to suck ions as soon as it leaves the process stream...
Besides this ain't rocket science and DH2O is good enough...
 
Preferable choice: de-ionized or distilled H2O? Why? Sources for de-ionized?

An excellent thread on water quality and the differences across distillation, reverse osmosis and deionization is to be found here:
https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/finding-pure-water-for-record-cleaning-very-long

Bottom line for me: buy the bulk dispensed DI water that is available in most Whole Foods Markets. It's DI stack is fed from the RO filtration for water that is very very pure. At $0.39 per gallon (provide your own container), it's my choice. And it's recommended by the author of the original post in the thread above as close to Type 1 Reagent Grade water.

I tracked down the company that installs and maintains these bulk water dispensers at the Whole Foods Markets in my area by calling Whole Foods Customer Service: National Water Services, Inc. trading as "Fresh Pure Waters". I recommend reading their Q&A on the water provided by their dispensers.
http://freshpure.com/your-questions-answered/

I see you're in Tucson and a Google search shows at least three Whole Foods stores in the Tucson area. You might give this water a try.
 
An excellent thread on water quality and the differences across distillation, reverse osmosis and deionization is to be found here:
https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/finding-pure-water-for-record-cleaning-very-long

Bottom line for me: buy the bulk dispensed DI water that is available in most Whole Foods Markets. It's DI stack is fed from the RO filtration for water that is very very pure. At $0.39 per gallon (provide your own container), it's my choice. And it's recommended by the author of the original post in the thread above as close to Type 1 Reagent Grade water.

I tracked down the company that installs and maintains these bulk water dispensers at the Whole Foods Markets in my area by calling Whole Foods Customer Service: National Water Services, Inc. trading as "Fresh Pure Waters". I recommend reading their Q&A on the water provided by their dispensers.
http://freshpure.com/your-questions-answered/

I see you're in Tucson and a Google search shows at least three Whole Foods stores in the Tucson area. You might give this water a try.


The store local to me has one, .37 a gallon. I contacted the dispenser company, and they routinely inspect the machines. 8ppb or less, is their standard.
 
All good science but DH2O suits my needs just fine - as you see in the treatise trade-offs abound as with all things. Quite frankly DH2O hits the majority of the requirements. that coupled with a fine RCM (love mine - review posted earlier in this thread) and given I am not working with Uber high-end audio anymore, my old Modded Thorens and sketchy Vinyl playing U-Turn Orbit seems to agree with what I am doing so will stick with what I have til this batch is used up. Will get a jug of military grade DI juice for my next batch and see if there really is a difference. While I doubt it, I will give it an honest try - then again my old pressure treated ears (Retired Navy diver) may not be capable of detecting a difference anymore so it may be an exercise in futilty????
 
Cleaning records isn't one of my favorite things to do but the results are absolutely worth it! Big thanks to ETLS for providing a manageable amount of Hepastat 256 and my one milliliter pipettes arrived today so I made up a new batch of cleaning fluid. My final mix in distilled water is: 0.1% Hepastat 256, 0.15% Triton X-100 and 5% isopropyl alcohol (91%). I use separate paint pads for the wash and two distilled water rinse cycles and vacuum between each step with my Canfab 3D RCM. I spin the record three or four times in both directions for wash and rinses with very little pressure applied to the paint pad. I can tell the cleaning fluid is mostly gone with the first rinse because the distilled water really beads up when I put it on for the second rinse. A new MOFI sleeve with today's date written on it completes the process.

Two of the albums (Doors, LA Woman and Eagles, The Long Run) I cleaned tonight I have owned since they were released and they had never been cleaned even though played regularly. As expected they sound much better with a quieter background. I will be curious to see how the antistat properties of the Hepastat work over time. Oh, and they look pretty amazing; shiny black evenly across the entire record.

Lastly, thanks to phantomrebel for continuing to share his expertise on this topic.
 
Here are some snaps of our Skookum new Fleet Maintenance Facility D.I. Water Plant (will take some better pics of the overall system as there is much more to it....):

IMG_20160808_132027.jpg


IMG_20160808_132022.jpg
 
Last edited:
Will get a jug of military grade DI juice for my next batch and see if there really is a difference. While I doubt it, I will give it an honest try - then again my old pressure treated ears (Retired Navy diver) may not be capable of detecting a difference anymore so it may be an exercise in futilty????
Since I can buy the RO/DI water for less than the cost of distilled water, that's my default choice. If comparing D to DI water, consider comparing at the RINSE stage rather than the cleaning stage where we've added all chemicals. It is in the rinse stage that I hear the difference that highly pure water can offer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom