What is key here is that there is an unavoidable residual molecular layer of the detergent that you use, no matter how much rinsing is done. The question is whether or not the molecular layer will be ionic or anionic (tending toward an affinity to accumulating a static charge, or tending to cancel out or prevent the accumulation of static charge), whether the detergent molecules in the residual molecular layer, oriented tails up to the vinyl, will have charged heads or neutral heads. Most common detergents, including dish soaps, are ionic, hence tending toward fostering static accumulation. Static discharges do damage the vinyl, leaving tiny pits.
Clean is clean, but there IS an unavoidable molecular layer of residue that cannot be removed by DIYer means. If you wish to propound your own views on record cleaning, I suggest that you stop throwing in monkey wrenches here, and start your own thread. This thread is shooting for better results than common methods produce. Granted, the improvements over common methods are incremental, but for the tuned ear, and detail oriented, the results are more than significant, and the pursuit of perfection is part of the fun.
All of us are completely familiar with the dish soap and rinsing methods. We are here to see if there can be more/better. If the dish soap rinse method was the best possible, this discussion would have been over in one page. We are here to see what may be possible, and there ARE better results available. That is why WE are here, participating in THIS thread.
Warning: The goals and points of a thread are stated, or implied, by the original poster and those that follow. If the topic is intentionally muddied by one or two contributors, the actions of those few is called thread crapping and is not tolerated on AK (see the rules). Unless you want a timeout, I would heed these words. You have a different opinion? You are welcome to it, but do start your own thread to propose and support it. Don't thread-crap here.
If you wish to learn, or have genuine questions...welcome. If you have a valid contribution to the discussion, as just stated...welcome. If you intend to short-circuit all of the work in this thread, negating most of its contents, you are not welcome. Participate, don't thread-crap, unless you are a troll. Trolls get sent on their way.
Rich P