• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've only cleaned one LP in 55 years. I used beer. It didn't work.

Thanks for reminding me to check back on page 1, JJ. It looks like my last formula will have a problem. I'll substitute 100 proof gin for the beer.

On a more serious note, has anyone found a remedy for those pesky, stubborn little icky spots that normal cleaning leaves behind? I call them microboogers. When I look at some under magnification I can see a fiber or two stuck in them.
 
The OP was definitely ill-treated, and left, but could not stay away. Blessings be upon him. Part of the problem is the rather provocative thread title. That is all I will say on the matter...

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
What is key here is that there is an unavoidable residual molecular layer of the detergent that you use, no matter how much rinsing is done. The question is whether or not the molecular layer will be ionic or anionic (tending toward an affinity to accumulating a static charge, or tending to cancel out or prevent the accumulation of static charge), whether the detergent molecules in the residual molecular layer, oriented tails up to the vinyl, will have charged heads or neutral heads. Most common detergents, including dish soaps, are ionic, hence tending toward fostering static accumulation. Static discharges do damage the vinyl, leaving tiny pits.

Clean is clean, but there IS an unavoidable molecular layer of residue that cannot be removed by DIYer means. If you wish to propound your own views on record cleaning, I suggest that you stop throwing in monkey wrenches here, and start your own thread. This thread is shooting for better results than common methods produce. Granted, the improvements over common methods are incremental, but for the tuned ear, and detail oriented, the results are more than significant, and the pursuit of perfection is part of the fun.

All of us are completely familiar with the dish soap and rinsing methods. We are here to see if there can be more/better. If the dish soap rinse method was the best possible, this discussion would have been over in one page. We are here to see what may be possible, and there ARE better results available. That is why WE are here, participating in THIS thread.

Warning: The goals and points of a thread are stated, or implied, by the original poster and those that follow. If the topic is intentionally muddied by one or two contributors, the actions of those few is called thread crapping and is not tolerated on AK (see the rules). Unless you want a timeout, I would heed these words. You have a different opinion? You are welcome to it, but do start your own thread to propose and support it. Don't thread-crap here.

If you wish to learn, or have genuine questions...welcome. If you have a valid contribution to the discussion, as just stated...welcome. If you intend to short-circuit all of the work in this thread, negating most of its contents, you are not welcome. Participate, don't thread-crap, unless you are a troll. Trolls get sent on their way.

Rich P
You mischaracterize my method as dish soap imply I only using that NOT case
I asked couple of legitimate questions regarding TOPIC as you guys present so far NO answer only knee jerk defensive lecture on thread crap
Again not case
Why can not you just answer question and save blood pressure hostility?
MOST important to me is HOW HAS EFFICACY BEEN VERIFIED beyond I can hear it is better?
What is wrong with THAT very valid question?
This typical behavior though in all most all these threads where provincial mind set wins
You can take ball now and go home I will not try to join little game any more with questions
JJ
 
Last edited:
You mischaracterize my method as dish soap imply I only using that NOT case
I asked couple of legitimate questions regarding TOPIC as you guys present so far NO answer only knee jerk defensive lecture on thread crap
Again not case
Why can not you just answer question and save blood pressure hostility?
MOST important to me is HOW HAS EFFICACY BEEN VERIFIED beyond I can hear it is better
What is wrong with THAT very valid question?
This typical behavior though in all most all these threads where provincial mind set wins
You can take ball now and go home I will not try to join little game any more with questions
JJ
Easy Jimmy, we are all friends here and all are welcome. If you seek microscopic evidence, they have been posted before in this thread I believe. If you seek surface voltage measurement data, digitized audio files, or pH measurements, I can send you that as well. They provide dramatic evidence, but I still don't think they prove much as none of the tools match the ear, and this is what the media was meant for. It's good to be cynical, I know I am, but I never really know until I try something myself.
 
Careful clean and rinse matters more than soap dawn is fine but just very small amount like few drops
Can effect and does effect blown out of proportion
Too much over thinking on this subject and did not use to exist and people actually enjoy their Lp instead of worrying about the molecules on them!...
People worry same way over Lp like when they have first baby by third child realize babies are pretty durable same for Lp!...Just use common sense and do not drop baby or Lp no harm no foul!...

Kitchen sink do just fine to clean Lp if can not afford any machine. PLEASE STOP joining rank of people feel need to disparage apologoze for what they have that worse to my mind than people who feel need to remind forum of how great every thing is they have with almost EVERY post or like peacock signature lines I expect insecure from self important big ego needy for attention and braggarts just not like when has negative impact and create more insecure in self-deprecating way!

Mild soap and water little alcohol scrub with good brush GOOD rinse Repeat if need toRecord cleaning machine with vacuum ability best friend for this but NOT mandatory just make life easier and do job faster and record dry Lp ultimately just piece of plastic Cleaning Lp THOROUGHLY is not difficult or complex task requisite complicated chemistry process formula Too much anxiety for no measurable tangible audible advantage IF common sense method execute properly

Again...we all know about the merits of a good clean and rinse. This thread is not about that. It is about more than that, for those that like/want the additional effort and results. Shooting down all of the work done in this thread IS thread crapping. One does not have to go to the lengths propounded in this thread, to get excellent results, but we should be free to discuss how to take it to the next level without being disparaged by one with little interest in the topic at hand.

Each element of the developing cleaning solutions are more than adequately substantiated and justified at the times of their introduction. Denial of same is simply controversy without cause. Again, feel free to propound your theories, methods, their efficacy, and means of substantiation in your own thread. I, for one, would be interested to see what you have to offer, but do it in your own thread. In this thread, we are tryng to achieve specific goals, by specific means.

Your question was indeed answered two posts down from your question. If you disagree with the answer, substantiate your controversy or hold your peace.

Rich P
 
Last edited:
Hi folks. I asked this question before, but maybe I did not ask understandable, so let's try again from a different angle.

What are the pros and cons for using de-ionized water for washing and/or rinsing? How about the same question for distilled water?

Thanks,
Rich P
 
Hi folks. I asked this question before, but maybe I did not ask understandable, so let's try again from a different angle.

What are the pros and cons for using de-ionized water for washing and/or rinsing? How about the same question for distilled water?

Thanks,
Rich P
Hi Rich, I'm sorry for not more clearly answering your original question. Thanks for following up. Phantomrebel can give a better response, I'm sure, but for me using DI water in my rinse is about two things: 1) the DI process removes residual mineral content from the water being used in your cleaning solution or rinse and, assuming the DI stack is preceded by a good particle filtration step (e.g., RO) you have very pure water that won't leave anything behind; and 2) due to its purity, DI water will itself bind residual mineral contaminants from the surface of the record so they comes away in the vacuum drying step, it serves as an additional cleaning step all on its own.

I'd be okay using just RO water in mixing my cleaning solution since I'm adding Triton and Hepastat, but if I can get a good RO/DI water for the same cost I get the added benefit of something that will actively bind other minerals in the cleaning step.

Phantomrebel aludes to this in his comment a few posts above when he says:
...Really good RO/DI water of the type Ruston has found is actually a solvent for mineral ions and should sop them up without requiring EDTA.
 
And distilled water does none of those things? If not, why not?

Enjoy,
Rich P

Short answer is, yes it does.

People talk about distilled, or deionized, or RO water and for the purpose of cleaning and rinsing records they are essentially the same thing, purified water. There are several different processes for making high purity water including, distillation, demineralization and reverse Osmosis (RO), Sometimes water is treated by combining these methods and including a form of filtration. It depends on how pure the water needs to be. Ultra high purity water is required for semi-conductor manufacturing as a rinse agent. They would likely start with RO, then demineralization, followed by filtering to get to the purity level required.

Pure water you buy at the store is usually distilled or RO purified that has been filtered. Either is sufficient for rinsing records, or for use in making cleaning solutions, as long as they don't add minerals back into the water, as they do for some types of drinking water.

Contaminants in water are dissolved and/or suspended solids (minerals basically) and other chemical agents such as organic materials and other soluble chemicals. Cleaning solutions, once put on a record, will contain contaminants that need to be removed. I personally believe that rinsing with purified water is a good thing to do no matter how else you choose to remove the contaminated cleaning solution.

In chemistry, water is considered the universal solvent because so many things are dissolved/soluble in it.

I am not a chemist; however, I spent many years in the nuclear power industry in the chemistry field. Ultra pure water was needed to make high purity steam to turn a steam turbine. Thousands of pounds of water that contains even trace levels of contaminants, such as chloride ions, can corrode things rather quickly. Water chemistry was a very high priority

Jon
 
Last edited:
Water purity is an interesting question because for the cleaning stage, one would like some ions in the water as it is better for solubilization of certain contaminants. The problem is a lot of people have poor tap water that is acidic or high in minerals. For the final rinse stage(s), we want pure water that has few dissolved solids so that residues are not left behind. Some like deionized water, but this process does not remove uncharged contaminants (some organic molecules and microbes like bacteria). Some like distilled water, but certain contaminants can come off in the vapor with water so it is best when double distilled (a more expensive process). Reverse osmosis can create very pure water, but it's effectiveness depends on the pore size of the membrane used. Super pure water uses a combination of these methods. What really matters to us (and many industrial applications) is the amount of total dissolved solids in the water which we want as low as possible. It's not just the ions that need removal, but also the organics, bacteria, and colloids. Levels of contaminants less than 1 part per billion are desirable. Often we just use resistivity as a measurement of quality: 18 meg-ohm water is the target level for ultra-pure in the laboratory (sometimes referred to as ASTM Type 1). When you get water really pure, it has to be stored correctly as it can leach contaminants out of containers. We can take it as far as we want, but it comes down to what is available and distilled is often the easiest choice. Many store bought preparations now list the amount of total dissolved solids so you can search for the lowest possible.
 
Last edited:
I buy whatever is available at the supermarket. Sometimes it's deionized but more often it's steam distilled. Mineral salt content is usually listed as 0ppm. I can't tell the difference....maybe I just don't know what to listen for.
 
Good answers. Thanks to jnoyes and phantomrebel. And thanks to pustelniakr for continuing to move us to the next level "why".

I use the RO/DI water today in my cleaning solution because it is readily available to me at a fairly low cost. Previously I've used distilled water and looked for distilled with added filtration steps when I could find it. For my cleaning solution, I've never done any controlled listening tests to see if I can tell a difference. I've just tried to use the "best" water I could find at any given time for a modest cost. Today it's the Whole Foods bulk dispensed RO/DI water as maintained for them by Fresh Pure Waters.

Rinsing is another matter, however. For rinsing, I have done some very careful listening to see what differences I hear. And it's in the SECOND rinse step where I find the most consistently observable difference. When I use Type 1 Reagent Grade grade water for the SECOND rinse, I do hear an improvement over using just the RO/DI water, and the RO/DI water has given me better sounding results than the typical distilled water from the grocery store. When I add of a bit of ethyl alcohol (95% reagent grade ethanal in a 3% by volume mix) to the Type 1 Reagent grade water used in the second rinse, I hear another improvement.

But please note, I'm talking about subtle differences in results. It's just that the difference is audible and consistent. So I do it in my cleaning regimen.
 
I know I am now past the obsession stage and have entered a neurotic state; but where does one get type 1 Reagent water? Maybe I'll just buy SACDs and FLAC downloads from now on.
 
You can buy Type 1 Reagent Grade water from lab supply houses, but shipping is expensive. I manage to find some local labs who make up their own and by asking politely can often get a couple of gallons for free. Hospitals also filter their own. Since they use such large quantities, giving a couple of gallons to a polite but deserving audio nut is possible. Or make friends with your local chemistry or biology grad student over a beer. That's worked for me in the past.

Here's an example of a lab supply house seller that may or may not sell to individuals like us, but note the shipping cost:
http://www.dabossupplies.com/Thermo-Scientific-NERL-Reagent-Grade-Water-23249581

Thermo-Scientific packages their NERL brand water in both 5 gallon cubes and in 1 gallon plastic containers sold as a pallet of five. The set of five 1 gallon containers is how I've purchased mine in the past so that I only have 1 gallon unsealed and exposed to contamination at a time.
 
But please note, I'm talking about subtle differences in results. It's just that the difference is audible and consistent. So I do it in my cleaning regimen.
Thanks for that, but I'd like to know what differences you hear? For me, cleaning efficacy is judged by surface noise, usually through headphones as I find them much more revealing than speakers. Sometimes the continual noise (vinyl roar) is reduced but more often it's just the transient clicks and pops.
 
Cleaning results are not just about surface noise. Results I listen for include: greater clarity, better low level detail, improvements in timbre, better micro-dynamics, improvement in soundstaging, increased sense of air around the instruments and the soundstage. The last is one of the big improvements I hear with ultrasonic cleaning with the chemical formulations we've been talking about. I can use the same formulations in a multi-step manual cleaning and rinse with great results. But when I ultrasonic clean I gain an openness and space to the sonic field that I don't get with my manual cleaning regimen.

What I listen for beyond just reduction in surface noise are the reasons I've been completely underwhelmed in the past with demonstrations of ultrasonic cleaning that did not use the chemicals we've been discussing and did not include a multiple rinse and vacuum dry step. Surface noise greatly reduced, yes. But otherwise just ho hum. These other US demos were missing much of the other aspects I listen for and that I got with my four step manual cleaning process. Now I'm getting better than my previous four step manual cleaning process and loving it.
 
Last edited:
I'm getting pops/clicks at the beginning and end of the record after I clean them. It happened today with two new records that I cleaned before their first play. I wonder if the CanFab 3D vacuum wand, which covers just the grooved portion of the record, is as effective at its ends as it is in the middle. Anybody else have this experience?
 
I'm getting pops/clicks at the beginning and end of the record after I clean them. It happened today with two new records that I cleaned before their first play. I wonder if the CanFab 3D vacuum wand, which covers just the grooved portion of the record, is as effective at its ends as it is in the middle. Anybody else have this experience?
How powerful is your vacuum source?
 
You can buy Type 1 Reagent Grade water from lab supply houses, but shipping is expensive. I manage to find some local labs who make up their own and by asking politely can often get a couple of gallons for free. Hospitals also filter their own. Since they use such large quantities, giving a couple of gallons to a polite but deserving audio nut is possible. Or make friends with your local chemistry or biology grad student over a beer. That's worked for me in the past.

Here's an example of a lab supply house seller that may or may not sell to individuals like us, but note the shipping cost:
http://www.dabossupplies.com/Thermo-Scientific-NERL-Reagent-Grade-Water-23249581

Thermo-Scientific packages their NERL brand water in both 5 gallon cubes and in 1 gallon plastic containers sold as a pallet of five. The set of five 1 gallon containers is how I've purchased mine in the past so that I only have 1 gallon unsealed and exposed to contamination at a time.
Thanks again, Rushton. You reminded me that I know a guy in the renal dialysis field. I bet he has some good s#!t.
 
I'm getting pops/clicks at the beginning and end of the record after I clean them. It happened today with two new records that I cleaned before their first play. I wonder if the CanFab 3D vacuum wand, which covers just the grooved portion of the record, is as effective at its ends as it is in the middle. Anybody else have this experience?
I read on another forum that a person with a VPI was having the same problem. It seems there were still some water droplets remaining in the trouble areas after the vacuuming was done. The fix was to dry these areas with a cloth.

Give it a shot to see if it helps.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom