• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Cleaning results are not just about surface noise. Results I listen for include: greater clarity, better low level detail, improvements in timbre, better micro-dynamics, improvement in soundstaging, increased sense of air around the instruments and the soundstage. The last is one of the big improvements I hear with ultrasonic cleaning with the chemical formulations we've been talking about. I can use the same formulations in a multi-step manual cleaning and rinse with great results. But when I ultrasonic clean I gain an openness and space to the sonic field that I don't get with my manual cleaning regimen.

What I listen for beyond just reduction in surface noise are the reasons I've been completely underwhelmed in the past with demonstrations of ultrasonic cleaning that did not use the chemicals we've been discussing and did not include a multiple rinse and vacuum dry step. Surface noise greatly reduced, yes. But otherwise just ho hum. These other US demos were missing much of the other aspects I listen for and that I got with my four step manual cleaning process. Now I'm getting better than my previous four step manual cleaning process and loving it.
I agree that the success of US cleaning is quite dependent on the chemicals used. In my trials I used the Terg blend being discussed here in quite high concentrations, but it wasn't until I separated the chems and treated the record with each individually that I was able to obtain outstanding results. Unfortunately, this method was even more time consuming, and like a PVA peel, would sometimes reveal a surface that was less than ideal.....sometimes it's better to leave well enough alone and just try to remove the big, noisy stuff.
 
How powerful is your vacuum source?

I read on another forum that a person with a VPI was having the same problem. It seems there were still some water droplets remaining in the trouble areas after the vacuuming was done. The fix was to dry these areas with a cloth.

Give it a shot to see if it helps.

The vacuum is strong enough that it pulls the record to the wand so I have enough vacuum. It is counter intuitive but I'm going to reduce the vacuum a little bit on the CanFab wand to see if it pulls the cleaning at the ends better. If that doesn't work I'll give the cloth suggestion a try.
 
Cleaning results are not just about surface noise. Results I listen for include: greater clarity, better low level detail, improvements in timbre, better micro-dynamics, improvement in soundstaging, increased sense of air around the instruments and the soundstage. The last is one of the big improvements I hear with ultrasonic cleaning with the chemical formulations we've been talking about. I can use the same formulations in a multi-step manual cleaning and rinse with great results. But when I ultrasonic clean I gain an openness and space to the sonic field that I don't get with my manual cleaning regimen.

What I listen for beyond just reduction in surface noise are the reasons I've been completely underwhelmed in the past with demonstrations of ultrasonic cleaning that did not use the chemicals we've been discussing and did not include a multiple rinse and vacuum dry step. Surface noise greatly reduced, yes. But otherwise just ho hum. These other US demos were missing much of the other aspects I listen for and that I got with my four step manual cleaning process. Now I'm getting better than my previous four step manual cleaning process and loving it.
Sorry, but can you provide some before and after needle drops to demonstrate this? Otherwise, it seems yet another example of hifi fiction.
 
If the wand is machined only over the grooved portion, I would take a little of the material off the wand so the opening covers from rim to almost the label.
 
Grottyash: Isn't the concept that when noise is reduced, the dynamic range is increased a fact, not fiction? I thought that was the very founding principle of DBX and Dolby.
 
Re-read Rushton's post, and you'll see his claims go way beyond that.
I see, but I don't know how you quantitate things like "soundstage" and "sense of air" (I have the same problem scoring wine!). I do know that reducing noise is critical. The vinyl medium to me, as a jazz and classical music lover, is inferior without lowering the noise floor. Nothing ruins the escape experience more than noise, and this "escape" is what I am after. I'm not sure how to describe it, but noise instantly brings me back to a reality that I'm playing something on the turntable. With proper cleaning, I now have records where I do not notice any noise whatsoever, and this in a system I have built that I consider to be a very revealing. But here lies the problem I think: the more sensitive the equipment becomes, the more can be heard so you either get a dreamy, intimate experience or one annoyingly distracted by deficiencies. I'll do whatever it takes to avoid the latter.
 
Ok. I just got my 500 ml of Triton X-100. Should I try to stabilize the entire 500 ml with 5% ISO and some Hepastat, or just keep to the formula making approx. 50 ml bottles that I'll dilute with about 450 ml of DH2O before use? And except the fact that most of the Triton will expire before I can use it. (By my calculations 500 ml of Triton X-100 can make over 7 gallons of concentrate, and I don't have that much room in the fridge.)
 
2channel, fwiw, I mix up 120 ml of base solution at a time. That's enough for mixing up four 10L US tanks of solution. I store the remainder in it's original container in my refrigerator. Following phantomrebel's suggestion, I draw from the original container only with disposable sterile pipettes, discarding the pipette after use. I suspect it can last for years this way regardless of any stated expiration date on the container. Perhaps phantomrebel can clear up any misunderstanding I may have about this.
 
Since we're 63 pages in, would someone post a thread for recipe ratios, and proper storage, and request that be made a sticky?

It would be easier on new folks, and some of us old folks too.

Thanks.
 
Since we're 63 pages in, would someone post a thread for recipe ratios, and proper storage, and request that be made a sticky?
In the interim, here's a link to an earlier post with the amounts and percentages for the formula I'm using based on all the accumulated advice from this thread:

http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....re-doing-it-wrong.689430/page-53#post-9967144

This formula is continuing to hold up well for me and I don't anticipate making any changes for my cleaning regimen. Note that the measurements assume use for ultrasonic cleaning in a 10L (2-gallon) tank, but the percentages hold true for any size tank. This same base solution works just fine for manual cleaning by using twice the amount of the base solution per volume of water.

As for storage:

The base solution recipe linked to above includes more than 50% alcohol so it is sterile and can sit at room temperature indefinitely. Because it has the Hepastat 256 in the solution, it is further protected by the anti-bacterial properties of the Hepastat.

The Hepastat 256 can be stored at room temperature.

The Triton/Tergitol is best stored in a refrigerator. And it will have much longer storage life if you draw from the original containers only with disposable sterile pipettes. Discard the pipette after use. Don't let anything else touch the throat of the container. The risk is introducing some protein loving bacteria that invades the Triton/Tergitol. I use these disposable sterile pipettes from Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01E16K7FG/
You'll also need a pipette pump: https://www.amazon.com/Karter-Scientific-PIPETTE-PUMP-25ml/dp/B00191HNKY/
 
Last edited:
Since I am only hand/vac washing, if I make 6 50 ml bottles of concentrate with alcohol and hepastat that would yield enough diluted fluid to clean at least 250 LPs (500 sides). That will probably last 2 years, since I am not buying in the volume I used to before I had my SACD player.
 
Since I am only hand/vac washing, if I make 6 50 ml bottles of concentrate with alcohol and hepastat that would yield enough diluted fluid to clean at least 250 LPs (500 sides). That will probably last 2 years, since I am not buying in the volume I used to before I had my SACD player.
LOL, it's just a bit of a math problem, 2channel. How much cleaning solution would you estimate you use per LP side? I've seen some folks who just want to barely wet the surface of the record because the fluid they're using is so expensive. Me, I want to flood the surface and give the detergents some time to work on loosening the contaminants in the grooves - let the fluids do the work. So, at a wild guess, I suppose I'm use 5-7ml of cleaning solution per side. So, for 100 records, I'd expect to use 1,000-1,400ml of solution.

I'm recommending 29.5ml of base solution per 10L of water to make up the US tank solution, and twice that for manual cleaning. So we're talking 60ml per 10L of manual cleaning solution.

So, I'd say yes, you'll have enough base solution mixed up to do your 500 sides. :)
 
I knew I'd exhaust your patience at some point, Rushton. Even Saints have their limits, and I've worn down the holiest. ;^) My boss once called me an ulcer looking for a place to happen. Happy Holidays.
:rflmao: No, you're asking good questions. Keep thinking and keep asking. It's the only way we start figuring any of this out.
 
I've got too much time on my hands. We have a beloved but shedding visitor for the holidays and she sleeps in my cleaning/listening area, so all things LP are suspended until after cleaning.
 
:idea: ... you know ... one could read post #1 & 2 ... then just skip the other 63 pages. Just saying.

th
 
Last edited:
Ok, going to do this in my ultrasonic cleaner. Hopefully today. I want to run my calculation by anyone who would be nice enough to look. I want to pour in a gallon and then add the proper amounts of additives. I know people are removing fluid from a gallon then adding material back to be exact. I am going to have to go back and calculate to see how far off I am doing it this way but it seems a lot easier.

1 gallon = 3.79L or 3,785ml

Add:
.13% of Triton = 5ml but = 10% solution so = 50ml = 3.38tbsp or just round to 4 which is still under .2% which I think was the max
5% of 99% Isopropyl Alcohol = 189ml = 13tbsp = 0.8cup and could round that to a cup I think and still be under 10%

I don't have the Hepastat (sp?) 256 yet and will worry about that later.
 
Paully, 5ml of Triton per gallon of water should be about right, regardless of how you get to it. Be careful you don't end up with too much Triton in your US bath or you'll have a ton of suds, which you don't want. I recommend starting with less rather than more for your first tests. You can then increase the amount of Triton if you're looking from more cleaning action up until you start getting foam in your tank.

Remember to mix the Triton into some alcohol first so that it fully blends, then dump the Triton/alcohol into water. If you dump the Triton directly into water or you'll have some difficulty getting it to mix, at least this is the case with Tergitol and I suspect also the case with the Triton.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom