Cleaning results are not just about surface noise. Results I listen for include: greater clarity, better low level detail, improvements in timbre, better micro-dynamics, improvement in soundstaging, increased sense of air around the instruments and the soundstage. The last is one of the big improvements I hear with ultrasonic cleaning with the chemical formulations we've been talking about. I can use the same formulations in a multi-step manual cleaning and rinse with great results. But when I ultrasonic clean I gain an openness and space to the sonic field that I don't get with my manual cleaning regimen.
What I listen for beyond just reduction in surface noise are the reasons I've been completely underwhelmed in the past with demonstrations of ultrasonic cleaning that did not use the chemicals we've been discussing and did not include a multiple rinse and vacuum dry step. Surface noise greatly reduced, yes. But otherwise just ho hum. These other US demos were missing much of the other aspects I listen for and that I got with my four step manual cleaning process. Now I'm getting better than my previous four step manual cleaning process and loving it.