• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Greetings,

for 20 years I've been using my VPI HW-16.5 to clean my records and basically using their "concentrate formula" to make a cleaning solution. Just recently I've really been noticing how static charged brand new records are and this VPI solution does not seem to be helping reduce this. Newly cleaned records still just attracting dust from everywhere. This last year I noticed this thread, so I came back to it in December to make my own mix based on the suggestions of phantomrebel and this long discussion.

Ordered a 2 oz bottle of Hepstat256 from a forum member and just today received by 8 oz bottle of Triton X-100 from Talas.

phantomrebel posted this some pages back:
"I’ve been combining the 1:500 diluted Hepastat with 0.2% Triton and 5% IPA in a mixture that achieves great results. Note, this is for a wash step where the solution is scrubbed on with a paint pad then rinsed off with distilled water. I follow with a final distilled water rinse on an RCM."

so doing the math for the 1:500 diluted Hepastat with 0.2% Triton and 5% IPA , unless I've made a mistake:
for a 1000ml of cleaning solution, the mix would be:
2ml Hepstat 256
2ml Triton X-100
50ml 99% IPA
946 ml Distilled Water

Just dissolve the Triton X with the IPA first, then combine the Distilled Water with Helpstat 256, then clean and double rinse some records, ...This mix looks very similar to what 2channel just posted.

I saw some discussion about cleaning everything that comes in touch with the solution during the formula mixing process so as not to introduce a contaminant. Any suggestions on a process for that? I used to homebrew so I have some cleaners and sanitizers, would Star San be good enough to sanitize everything?
 
I swear by Star San for my beer brewing needs, but it isn't necessary for record cleaning. You can wash everything with the diluted Hepastat and be fine. No need for the strong acid (my bottle label pictured below) unless you are cleaning glassware that will contain a solution for long term storage. Your record cleaning mix looks similar to what most folks have been using. Let us know your results! :thumbsup:


IMG_4841.JPG
 
Now you did it...You mentioned brewing and records in the same post. I need a beer. My mix is similar to heavy rock's and I've found a bunch of uses for Hepastat 256. We took a small sprayer of the diluted stuff on a recent cruise to clean surfaces in our stateroom; the ship had a little trouble with the Norovirus on the previous trip. And it has killed off some mold that was just getting started in the grout of our shower. Pretty amazing stuff really. AK is full of surprises.

I've also used a quick spritz of 1:3000 diluted Hepastat spray on my record brush to help pull off any dust on the record. I don't soak the brush and the 1:3000 dilution shouldn't leave any residue on the record.
 
Haha, yes a good beer always goes good with a great record.

After my post above I was thinking, you know I can probably just clean this dusty glassware with the Hepastat 256...which is what I did.

Anyway I can report back on the results of cleaning my first 2 records. So far in one word, it is WOW! My records have never looked cleaner and these 2 albums are crystal clear sounding, and that is saying a lot since I've been using the VPI HW-16.5 for so long I just took it for granted it was doing the best it could, which is good. Now with this mix it is doing what it really should have been doing, and that is work great.

I'll give 2 very specific examples of the situation of the 2 records I chose to clean first. Both are Japanese pressings from the 70's bought in the last 2 months. Both of these records I had cleaned twice already, but they seemed to have some micro dust down in the grooves that the VPI was just not vacuuming up. I set them aside I was so frustrated with them.

One of the 2 was a really weird case. It is this lp: https://www.discogs.com/Joe-Flower-Travellin-Band-The-Times/release/1118253

One side played pretty well (and happened to have the best songs) but the other side sounded like a campfire and had some fairly quiet passages on a few songs, making the crackle seem even worse. This one side had micro dust down in the grooves too that did not come out, but it also sounded like maybe this side was played with a bad needle. I was pissed to say the least and figured I would have to try to buy another copy eventually. Anyway it cleaned up beautifully and I'm listening to it now, it sounds amazing. I have heard a few minor crackles on the side I thought would always sound like the campfire. Flower Travellin' Band "The Times" might get another cleaning, I took a look at the "previously dirtiest side" with a flashlight after listening and I still see a very light sprinkling of the micro dust. The stylus must have lifted that out of the groove during playback.

Taking the time to hunt down these 2 chemicals and making this mix has already paid for itself with the results on these 2 albums.
 
Really great to hear your success Heavyrock. I, too, have come across a couple examples where one side plays worse than the other. I haven't figured out how this occurs generally, but in one case it was on an lp that came with a turntable that I purchased. The record was stored on the table for a long period of time so one side was exposed to the elements. It never fully cleaned but it sounded better after a third cleaning where I incubated it in the solution (pre-warmed) for about 10 minutes. Something you might try.

Cool album you mentioned in your post: I never heard of it before but it looks interesting.:music:
 
That's one of the issues I considered when I decided to go ultrasonic. How effective would a horizontal cleaning system be, versus the vertical cleaning that the ultrasonic brings to the table.

Even with an excellent cleaning fluid, the gravitational pull would still allow the unwanted debris to rest on the playing surface, and even with a powerful suction, just how much of the debris would be removed. And after the cleaning cycle is completed, is there a small redeposit left where the leading velvet pad ends?

With the vertical cleaning cycle of the ultrasonic, it would seem gravitational pull is your friend as those fines are dislodged from the grooves. Since my rinse process also is done while the records are vertical, once again gravitational pull is my friend.

Since I have the sealed roller bearings on my spindles, I use centrifugal force to my advantage to spin a lot of excess rinse water off the records. I have yet to find any fine debris or dirt in the bottom of the spin tank. It also shortens the drying time of the records, not to mention far less water for the vacuum to deal with.
 
While I see your point ETLS, I would argue gravity has little effect in the fluid where the contaminants are solubilized. Once the fluid is removed via vacuum, anything suspended should come up along with it. Maybe unsuspended particles would be affected by gravity, but we are talking about a weak force of gravity vs. a very strong vacuum force. The distinct advantage of ultrasonic methods to me lies in the disruption method and that is very hard to beat. In this case, gravity would be useful as would vertical orientation (as in your system).

I guess what I'm saying is that anything left behind most likely was never solubilized. That is why I recommended increased time and temperature.
 
Last edited:
I, too, have come across a couple examples where one side plays worse than the other.
Same here, but quite often with records from my own collection, its the one side that gets cleaned and played frequently that sounds fine, while the flip side picks up dust from the mat but is never played or cleaned.

Interesting subject, I find, how records wind up in the condition they do. It seems one can't account for all the variables.
 
Last edited:
With the vertical cleaning cycle of the ultrasonic, it would seem gravitational pull is your friend as those fines are dislodged from the grooves. Since my rinse process also is done while the records are vertical, once again gravitational pull is my friend.
Gravitational pull is not that great in water, that's why Nasa astronauts train submerged in water. I suspect in many cases the dirt is not really any heavier than the water it displaces. The rinse is a big help though, but mostly by redundancy, I suspect.
 
Gravitational pull is not that great in water, that's why Nasa astronauts train submerged in water. I suspect in many cases the dirt is not really any heavier than the water it displaces. The rinse is a big help though, but mostly by redundancy, I suspect.


Yes, I understand what you're saying. What I was referring to is the propensity of particulates to separate and move away from the record surface more readily in a vertical orientation, as opposed to a horizontal orientation. On horizontal cleaning, suspended particulate can only remain in the cleaning fluids until the vacuum pulls that fluid from the record's surface. With almost 3 gallons of cleaning fluid surrounding the records in the ultrasonic tank, there's plenty of room for particulates to disperse.

Since I have all my cleaning stations set up to receive a fully loaded spindle, everything from the pre-rinse, wash, post-rinse, and drying are all accomplished vertically. The goal is to get the records as clean as is humanly possible, efficiently, and without damaging the vinyl surface.
 
Mt conscience has been torturing me and I must confess before the brotherhood and ask for my penance. I have used LAST record preservative through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault. (some may not understand the Davinci Code talk. ;^)
Is it safe to wash these LPs with the holy brew; or will some evil molecular interaction destroy the vinyl for all time?
P.s. I will never wash those that were treated with SoundGuard in the '70s and '80s. They still look and sound better than new. I wish I could get more of THAT stuff!
 
Mt conscience has been torturing me and I must confess before the brotherhood and ask for my penance. I have used LAST record preservative through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievous fault. (some may not understand the Davinci Code talk. ;^)
Is it safe to wash these LPs with the holy brew; or will some evil molecular interaction destroy the vinyl for all time?
P.s. I will never wash those that were treated with SoundGuard in the '70s and '80s. They still look and sound better than new. I wish I could get more of THAT stuff!

Their preservative is perfluoropolyether (see US patent # 5389281) to Walter Davies (Last's owner). It is an inert grease and very difficult to remove. The cleaning solutions in this thread will not remove it. Removal requires very strong solvents that are incompatible with PVC-PVA polymers.
The Soundguard is similarly a lubricant containing dialkanolamine derivatives (see US patent #4125668, #4071460, and #4096079) issued to Ball Brothers. It's basically N-octyl N,N-beta,beta'-diethanolamine at 0.02% in 1,1,1-trichloro-2,2,2-trifluoroethane, essentially a solvent containing quat. In today's world, there is no need to go to this extreme since many water soluble quats are available that also have similar lubricating and anti-stat properties.
 
Why should you be ashamed of using Last? I have records I treated with it 35 years ago that are still dead quiet, it has not harmed them in any way that I can see or hear.
 
Their preservative is perfluoropolyether (see US patent # 5389281) to Walter Davies (Last's owner). It is an inert grease and very difficult to remove. The cleaning solutions in this thread will not remove it. Removal requires very strong solvents that are incompatible with PVC-PVA polymers.
The Soundguard is similarly a lubricant containing dialkanolamine derivatives (see US patent #4125668, #4071460, and #4096079) issued to Ball Brothers. It's basically N-octyl N,N-beta,beta'-diethanolamine at 0.02% in 1,1,1-trichloro-2,2,2-trifluoroethane, essentially a solvent containing quat. In today's world, there is no need to go to this extreme since many water soluble quats are available that also have similar lubricating and anti-stat properties.

^^^ What he said!



:dunno: :confused: :D

(Seriously, thanks for the info!)
 
Why should you be ashamed of using Last? I have records I treated with it 35 years ago that are still dead quiet, it has not harmed them in any way that I can see or hear.
Just because I think THE BREW is better. The ashamed part was meant as humor. My wife doesn't get me either.
 
Their preservative is perfluoropolyether (see US patent # 5389281) to Walter Davies (Last's owner). It is an inert grease and very difficult to remove. The cleaning solutions in this thread will not remove it. Removal requires very strong solvents that are incompatible with PVC-PVA polymers.
The Soundguard is similarly a lubricant containing dialkanolamine derivatives (see US patent #4125668, #4071460, and #4096079) issued to Ball Brothers. It's basically N-octyl N,N-beta,beta'-diethanolamine at 0.02% in 1,1,1-trichloro-2,2,2-trifluoroethane, essentially a solvent containing quat. In today's world, there is no need to go to this extreme since many water soluble quats are available that also have similar lubricating and anti-stat properties.
Is there anything you don't know? Patent numbers no less!!!!
Would it be OK to wash the LPs treated with LAST, even though the LAST would not be removed, to provide the benefits of THE BREW? I suppose I could test on a junk LP.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom