• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Since I can buy the RO/DI water for less than the cost of distilled water, that's my default choice. If comparing D to DI water, consider comparing at the RINSE stage rather than the cleaning stage where we've added all chemicals. It is in the rinse stage that I hear the difference that highly pure water can offer.

In this sprawling metropolis of mutts, squirrels, raccoons, and other vermin....myself included, where the heck would I locate some of this magic elixer of de-ionized, de-mineralized, de-militarized, water?
 
In this sprawling metropolis of mutts, squirrels, raccoons, and other vermin....myself included, where the heck would I locate some of this magic elixer of de-ionized, de-mineralized, de-militarized, water?
Hey there, ETLS! What part of the great state of Texas? Any organic food stores? Any saltwater fish/aquarium stores? Any Whole Foods Markets? How about a friendly lab assistant somewhere? These are the sources I seek out in places I've lived over the years.
 
Tyler or Lindale, I live betwixt the two. It's rumored the population of my town is 200, I highly suspect they counted everyone twice and added in the dogs too.
 
Just wanted to make a comment . I researched this thread and others, learning something about some of the formulas that people use. My initial formula consisted of Triton X-100 and distilled H2O. I've got probably 1000-1200 albums. Most of my collection was cleaned using this formula, and it was ok. Then, I added EDTA to the formula, and the remainder of my collection was cleaned with it. Have recently been playing some of the albums cleaned with the EDTA in the formula. I usually listen with headphones, and I have noticed a huge improvement in the low level noise since adding the EDTA. It's just amazing.
 
Just wanted to make a comment . I researched this thread and others, learning something about some of the formulas that people use. My initial formula consisted of Triton X-100 and distilled H2O. I've got probably 1000-1200 albums. Most of my collection was cleaned using this formula, and it was ok. Then, I added EDTA to the formula, and the remainder of my collection was cleaned with it. Have recently been playing some of the albums cleaned with the EDTA in the formula. I usually listen with headphones, and I have noticed a huge improvement in the low level noise since adding the EDTA. It's just amazing.

I know zilch about organic chemistry but a quick google search indicates EDTA's primary benefit is to bind metals ions and dissolve limescale. In medicine it is used to treat lead and mercury poisoning. That stuff stays in solution apparently and would be vacuumed and rinsed off the record. Since you have seen an improvement after adding it to your Triton mix it makes me wonder about the condition of your records before you initially cleaned them. Then again maybe I should wait for the experts to chime in....
 
Just wanted to make a comment . I researched this thread and others, learning something about some of the formulas that people use. My initial formula consisted of Triton X-100 and distilled H2O. I've got probably 1000-1200 albums. Most of my collection was cleaned using this formula, and it was ok. Then, I added EDTA to the formula, and the remainder of my collection was cleaned with it. Have recently been playing some of the albums cleaned with the EDTA in the formula. I usually listen with headphones, and I have noticed a huge improvement in the low level noise since adding the EDTA. It's just amazing.

As you know, EDTA is a chelating agent that binds divalent cations so it is possible the water you were using had some Calcium or Magnesium in it that was leaving a residue. I found that some of these mineral residues can't be seen, but can be heard, as the records often look perfect. Sometimes the minerals can also be on the glassware used, especially if containers out of an automatic dishwasher are used. It doesn't take much. Another possibility is that mineral ions were actually within the dirty records and weren't extracted by the Triton alone. Either way, glad to hear the EDTA is working for you. I used to add it to my cleaning solutions, but I'm adding the Hepastat now and it already contains some (4-8% in the concentrate). Really good RO/DI water of the type Ruston has found is actually a solvent for mineral ions and should sop them up without requiring EDTA.
I should add, that magnesium stearate became the lubricant/release agent of choice included in vinyl pellet mixes after lead stearates became unpopular. It is possible that there could be free magnesium around after breakdown (and stearic acid). I'm not sure whether there would be enough to be audible however, but it could stabilize interactions with other contaminants that get removed when the EDTA competes for their binding. We use EDTA in the lab for this purpose: it is included in extraction solutions to disrupt interactions that are stabilized by divalent cations.
 
Last edited:
2-3 hours, heck that's just scratching the surface of getting to know someone we've just met.

About the only traffic jam I see 'round here, is when the lazy dog suns himself in the middle of the road. Couple of taps on the truck's horn usually wakes him up. If he's really lazy I just toss 'em a Scooby snack off to the side of the road. He'll eventually saunter over there and fetch it.
 
No, your math is off my friend. You are starting with a 10% solution of Triton and diluting it ~ 1:76 so that is 0.13% Triton (10 divided by 76) which is fine. You are starting with 20% quats (taking the high range given for Hepastat concentrate) and diluting it about 1:1000 which gives you 0.02% Quat (20 divided by 1000), which is also fine. If you use dilution factors, it makes it easier, I think. You did calculate your iso fairly well though! These are detergent concentrations that work well in an US bath, you may want to go 2X stronger for RCM or hand washing. You might also consider adding your Hepastat to the 10% Triton stock if you want to store it long term, but it looks like you make this just before using. Now, get going and let's see them clean records!

First, let me add my thanks to Phantomrebel and all the chemists and empirical geniuses, and to ETL for the Triton.
Second let me apologize for being sooo obtuse. I am still not sure of the formula.
When you say go 2X stronger for RCM, Phantom, do you mean for just the quats; or all the additives? Also, if I'm going to make 10% stock, is there any reason I can't do that by mixing all 3 additives and just diluting with DH20 when ready?
 
When you say go 2X stronger for RCM, Phantom, do you mean for just the quats; or all the additives? Also, if I'm going to make 10% stock, is there any reason I can't do that by mixing all 3 additives and just diluting with DH20 when ready?
2channel, for what it's worth, that's what I do. I make up a 10% stock of all the chemicals except the extra isopropyl (so my 10% solution includes the final proportions of Triton/Tergitol, Hepastat 256 and enough isopropyl to get everything into solution. If not including the Hepastat 256, then I make sure my 10% solution includes more than 50% alcohol by volume to keep the 10% solution sterile. With the Hepastat, I don't worry about the percentage alcohol other than to know how much more alcohol I will need to add when mixing up a batch of "final" cleaning solution.

When I mix up a "final" cleaning solution batch from the premixed 10% solution, I add the water and whatever additional isopropyl is needed to meet the overall percentages of each ingredient that I'm aiming to achieve. If I'm mixing a cleaning solution batch for manual cleaning with my RCM, I use from the 10% stock 2X the amount I would use of that same 10% stock when mixing up for the ultrasonic tank.
 
^^What he said. It just makes it easier to have a 10x stock (containing the Triton and Tergitol) so that you don't have any issues getting the Triton to solubilize. Also the 10% mix is less viscous so measuring it out is easier. Alternatively, you skip the 10% stock all together and just mix the desired amount to Triton required for your working solution in some IPA to solubilize, then add it and the required about of Hepastat, alcohol, and dH2O. Either works.
When I mentioned going 2X more, I was suggesting maybe 0.26% Triton and 0.04% Hepastat for RCM or hand washing (always followed by a final dH2O of course).
 
Mild soap and water little alcohol scrub with good brush GOOD rinse
Repeat if need to
Record cleaning machine with vacuum ability best friend for this but NOT mandatory just make life easier and do job faster and record dry
Lp ultimately just piece of plastic
Cleaning Lp THOROUGHLY is not difficult or complex task requisite complicated chemistry process formula
Too much anxiety for no measurable tangible audible advantage IF common sense method execute properly
I wish it possible to put one I clean my method under microscope side beside one cleaned with all this make work method
Test in laboratory too for any residue
Fewer moving parts so to speak always make better result is the reality for all inanimate mechanical things
Lp cleaning not same thing as engineering motor oil or rocket fuel
Complexity here for simple task only creates new problems creates more work incidental contaminates being deliberately replaced with new chemical contaminates and extra steps to process make distance to ultimate goal even greater! : - (
I can not understand point
Please elucidate
JJ
 
Last edited:
Mild soap and water little alcohol scrub with good brush GOOD rinse
Repeat if need to
Record cleaning machine with vacuum ability best friend for this but NOT mandatory just make life easier and do job faster and record dry
Lp ultimately just piece of plastic
Cleaning Lp THOROUGHLY is not difficult or complex task requisite complicated chemistry process formula
Too much anxiety for no measurable tangible audible advantage IF common sense method execute properly
I wish it possible to put one I clean my method under microscope side beside one cleaned with all this make work method
Test in laboratory too for any residue
Fewer moving parts so to speak always make better result is the reality for all inanimate mechanical things
Lp cleaning not same thing as engineering motor oil or rocket fuel
Complexity here for simple task only creates new problems creates more work incidental contaminates being deliberately replaced with new chemical contaminates and extra steps to process make distance to ultimate goal even greater! : - (
I can not understand point
Please elucidate
JJ
Read the whole thread Jimmy. You keep fighting it, but you will discover that not all "soaps" are created equal. What is great for dishes and countertops is not the best choice for plastic discs with microscopic grooves that are designed for amplified sound reproduction. It isn't anywhere near rocket science to follow some basic principles and get the best results possible. This thread is for perfectionists and DIYers, not the satisfied or uninterested. If your method is working for you, and it sounds like it is, by all means keep at it! Everyone has their own methods and expectations and, despite the unfortunate title of the thread, nobody is necessarily "wrong". I do believe I can always do better however and this keeps the hobby fun for me.
 
Last edited:
Thanks again, Rushton and Phantom Rebel! I think I've got it now. I'll compromise with Jimmy's method and settle on this:
2 fingers IPA (India Pale Ale)
1 dram single malt
3.7 skosh cheap Chianti.
(no offense meant to anyone other than self. ;^)
 
Read the whole thread Jimmy. You keep fighting it, but you will discover that not all "soaps" are created equal. What is great for dishes and countertops is not the best choice for plastic discs with microscopic grooves that are designed for amplified sound reproduction. It isn't anywhere near rocket science to follow some basic principles and get the best results possible. This thread is for perfectionists and DIYers, not the satisfied or uninterested. If your method is working for you, and it sounds like it is, by all means keep at it! Everyone has their own methods and expectations and, despite the unfortunate title of the thread, nobody is necessarily "wrong". I do believe I can always do better however and this keeps the hobby fun for me.
That is true not all things created equal I agree but what IS true clean is clean
So now we first define clean and then we measure level of cleanliness as defined if this REALLY meet definition scientific method
Or is whole exercise just theory? How are all possible interactions addressed? Theory again?
I only ask because I DID read and every time new part introduced new issue or step to process comes too
Record cleaning work in progress?
Take away one foreign material add another so when whole process complete what is measurement taken to demonstrate our now agreed upon definition of clean?
For me clean in this instance means absence of all foreign material best as practically possible
Whole process just gaining momentum and growing in size
I just would like to see incontrovertible evidence that Lp cleaned with Frankenstein method make Lp any cleaner than simple method in any way other than in minds eye or in perceived subjective improvment audibly
I am just waiting for comparative test results more than I can hear difference
We all know how that one goes with wire capacitor resisters etc VERY subjective at best
I also asking because thread title implied one thing and you not even thread starter guest110 start thread and you now take in new tangent and that ok too dialog always fun so where is side track going with this?
My mind is open ALL WAYS for better method but I am not seeing reading here data test result to validate efficacy of a LOT of work and effort as well as introducing many chemicals on to Lp for which Lp never intended to see?
Proof of efficacy beside because I say so same scrutiny as any science effort
That was all I am asking you
JJ
 
...My mind is open ALL WAYS for better method but I am not seeing reading here data test result to validate efficacy of a LOT of work and effort as well as introducing many chemicals on to Lp for which Lp never intended to see?
Proof of efficacy beside because I say so same scrutiny as any science effort
That was all I am asking you
But Jimmy, your mind is not open. You have convinced yourself that none of this is necessary.

We have been experimenting and LISTENING to the results we can achieve. For me, what I HEAR is what is important and what I HEAR is the proof for what I need to be doing. What I HEAR is that doing what guest110 and phantomrebel have suggested actually makes an improvement, and the improvement actually enhances my listening enjoyment.

If what you hear meets your needs and allows you to find enjoyment, congratulations! It does not meet my expectations and I've tried it.

So, don't keep telling us that what we're doing is unnecessary. That is simply not true. Without what I am doing, I do not achieve the same listening enjoyment. That makes what I am doing very necessary.
 
What is key here is that there is an unavoidable residual molecular layer of the detergent that you use, no matter how much rinsing is done. The question is whether or not the molecular layer will be ionic or anionic (tending toward an affinity to accumulating a static charge, or tending to cancel out or prevent the accumulation of static charge), whether the detergent molecules in the residual molecular layer, oriented tails up to the vinyl, will have charged heads or neutral heads. Most common detergents, including dish soaps, are ionic, hence tending toward fostering static accumulation. Static discharges do damage the vinyl, leaving tiny pits.

Clean is clean, but there IS an unavoidable molecular layer of residue that cannot be removed by DIYer means. If you wish to propound your own views on record cleaning, I suggest that you stop throwing in monkey wrenches here, and start your own thread. This thread is shooting for better results than common methods produce. Granted, the improvements over common methods are incremental, but for the tuned ear, and detail oriented, the results are more than significant, and the pursuit of perfection is part of the fun.

All of us are completely familiar with the dish soap and rinsing methods. We are here to see if there can be more/better. If the dish soap rinse method was the best possible, this discussion would have been over in one page. We are here to see what may be possible, and there ARE better results available. That is why WE are here, participating in THIS thread.

Warning: The goals and points of a thread are stated, or implied, by the original poster and those that follow. If the topic is intentionally muddied by one or two contributors, the actions of those few is called thread crapping and is not tolerated on AK (see the rules). Unless you want a timeout, I would heed these words. You have a different opinion? You are welcome to it, but do start your own thread to propose and support it. Don't thread-crap here.

If you wish to learn, or have genuine questions...welcome. If you have a valid contribution to the discussion, as just stated...welcome. If you intend to short-circuit all of the work in this thread, negating most of its contents, you are not welcome. Participate, don't thread-crap, unless you are a troll. Trolls get sent on their way.

Rich P
 
Last edited:
My mind is open ALL WAYS for better method but I am not seeing reading here data test result to validate efficacy of a LOT of work and effort as well as introducing many chemicals on to Lp for which Lp never intended to see?
Proof of efficacy beside because I say so same scrutiny as any science effort
That was all I am asking you
JJ
You are correct Jimmy, a scientific approach is critical. I am in fact a scientist and test everything I do by habit. I analyze every mixture and method I use with chemical, microscopic, potentiometric, and (perhaps most important) acoustical analyses. I do this in a laboratory environment with sterile filtered solutions of pure reagents and controlled conditions. I have made recommendations on how folks might adapt the things I learned over the years to a home washing protocol. Everybody has their own conditions and equipment so I cannot say how they will perform, but the posts here appear to indicate people have achieved very satisfactory results. We all share our results, share new methods and ideas, and we all learn even more on how to refine our own washing protocols. You seem to have shown an interest...I encourage you to try some of our ideas (like a non-ionic detergent or a quat) and participate in the discussion.
 
I also asking because thread title implied one thing and you not even thread starter guest110 start thread and you now take in new tangent and that ok too dialog always fun so where is side track going with this?
JJ
I have it on good authority that the OP died a terrible death at the hands of a crazed maniac so it is left to us to continue what was started. If the ideas we share go along a different tangent, that is what we call progress!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom