• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sam's Club also has a lemon scent version that is a littler higher on the quat concentration and contains edta and alcohol. Not sure if it would be better?
https://www.samsclub.com/sams/image...fectant-cleaner-safety.pdf?mobiledetect=false

I also found the msds for the sanitizer on Sam's website. It's here: https://www.samsclub.com/sams/images/pdf/proforce-sanitizer-safety.pdf
That's useful info as it shows the lemon fresh product, while containing a detergent (alcohol ethoxylate) and EDTA, is not preferable due to high pH (over 12). It also shows the regular version, while neutral, is higher in quats than I estimated: the stock is ~5 to 13% (they give a range as unfortunately is typical). I would use this in a "working solution" at 1:500 dilution (final 0.01%-0.026%) along with a 1:1000 dilution or Triton (0.1%) or even 1:2000 of Triton if you can get away with it. That would be a safe starting point for the quat as we don't know what the inactive ingredients are or what end of the range they actually put out. As stated many times, beware the Triton is slow to dissolve so give it time or dissolve it in your ISO first.
If static remains an issue, the quat could later be increased 5-fold but I would hold off at first as they are plenty powerful and you don't want to leave a cloudy film or residues behind.
Hence, the amounts of detergent and quat in your recipe above are way too high.
The amounts I am giving assume you are rinsing well with distilled water.
How great that your first LPs are getting a healthy wash from the beginning! Hopefully you have some fresh sleeves to place them in. Let us know how your cleaning goes.
 
Last edited:
Looking at the commercial selection of quat cleaners, I found that Hepastat 256 is easily replaceable: Many manufacturers are producing a similar 256x quat concentrate (listed by Manufacturer, "Product name"):

Spartan, “Sparquat 256” or "GS High Dilution Disinfectant 256"
Brulin, “Maxima 256” or "Uniquat Neutral Disinfectant 256"
Stetson, “HBV Disinfectant 256”
Multi-clean, “Century Q 256”
Diverse, “Virex II 256”
National Chemical Lab, “Neutra-Cide 256”
US Chemical "Mixmate O" or "Sanitation System Disinfectant 256"

to name just a few. So no biggie that Quill left the market.
 
Looking at the commercial selection of quat cleaners, I found that Hepastat 256 is easily replaceable: Many manufacturers are producing a similar 256x quat concentrate (listed by Manufacturer, "Product name"):

Spartan, “Sparquat 256” or "GS High Dilution Disinfectant 256"
Brulin, “Maxima 256” or "Uniquat Neutral Disinfectant 256"
Stetson, “HBV Disinfectant 256”
Multi-clean, “Century Q 256”
Diverse, “Virex II 256”
National Chemical Lab, “Neutra-Cide 256”
US Chemical "Mixmate O" or "Sanitation System Disinfectant 256"

to name just a few. So no biggie that Quill left the market.


Of these, which would be the best suited for cleaning records?
 
I am making a concentrate to be added with distilled water in 1 gallon jugs. Does my formula seem accurate for ultrasonic cleaning?

My concentrate to make 5 gallons of cleaning fluid would be:
Triton 5 Tablespoons
Quat 3.5 Tablespoons
95% Iso Alchohol 2 cups

Then for each gallon jug
95% Iso Alch. 6.5 Tablesoons
Concentrate 200 ML
1 gallon water

Does this give me the proper mixtures?
 
I am making a concentrate to be added with distilled water in 1 gallon jugs. Does my formula seem accurate for ultrasonic cleaning?

My concentrate to make 5 gallons of cleaning fluid would be:
Triton 5 Tablespoons
Quat 3.5 Tablespoons
95% Iso Alchohol 2 cups

Then for each gallon jug
95% Iso Alch. 6.5 Tablesoons
Concentrate 200 ML
1 gallon water

Does this give me the proper mixtures?
You need to specify your Triton concentration and type.

Enjoly,
Rich P
 
Just tried the shampoo/conditioner method with a little bit of Jet Dry using paint pad - It actually worked quite well. I try not to overthink these things
 
I am making a concentrate to be added with distilled water in 1 gallon jugs. Does my formula seem accurate for ultrasonic cleaning?

My concentrate to make 5 gallons of cleaning fluid would be:
Triton 5 Tablespoons
Quat 3.5 Tablespoons
95% Iso Alchohol 2 cups

Then for each gallon jug
95% Iso Alch. 6.5 Tablesoons
Concentrate 200 ML
1 gallon water

Does this give me the proper mixtures?


A little early for me to be doing math (pre-coffee), but It looks like your stock is 0.4% Triton, 0.03%Quat (assuming you are starting with a 10% commercial concentrate...you don't mention) and 2.3% IPA. And your 1 gal. working solution is about 0.02% Triton, 0.002% Quat and 4% IPA. This should work well for US cleaning. You could increase the IPA to half a cup to make it easier than measuring out 6.5 tablespoons (resulting in around 5%).
 
Last edited:
"Of these, which would be the best suited for cleaning records?"

I have not tried any of them, but they are all similar in composition so it may come down to price and availability.
 
"Of these, which would be the best suited for cleaning records?"

I have not tried any of them, but they are all similar in composition so it may come down to price and availability.


Several of those listed, have fragrance added. Any negative effects from those compounds?
 
Since Hepastat has been the approved disinfectant in hospitals for some years it will have to have a replacement. I've put out some feelers with former coworkers.
 
Several of those listed, have fragrance added. Any negative effects from those compounds?
It depends on what kind of fragrant compound they use but some can also be beneficial to cleaning (e.g. some terpenes). The quat preps also often contain dyes. Unfortunately, the nature of these included compounds is proprietary information. The good thing is that they are typically present in very small amounts and we are diluting 1000-fold or more. If you are looking for a commercial product, it's something you have to put up with, much like the people who use dish soaps or shampoo/conditioners. There are many suggestions for pure quats in this thread but they are difficult to find and work with. The best compromise is to find a commercial prep that minimizes dyes and perfumes.

EDIT: Please note I wasn't specifically recommending any of the commercial preparations I listed. I was merely pointing out that many manufacturers produce similar products. I would need to investigate each further before I could recommend them. To date, I've only tried the Hepastat and 3M's HB Quat.
 
Last edited:
I found the MSDS for Virex II 256 and diluted at 256:1 the pH is 8.8. Correct me if I'm wrong, but at the dilution levels we are using these quat based products in record cleaning solutions the ultimate pH is not an issue. I suspect it is very close to neutral 7. Also, most of the Hepastat 256 replacements listed above have some kind of fragrance in them. Are there any problems created by the fragrance?
 
I found the MSDS for Virex II 256 and diluted at 256:1 the pH is 8.8. Correct me if I'm wrong, but at the dilution levels we are using these quat based products in record cleaning solutions the ultimate pH is not an issue. I suspect it is very close to neutral 7. Also, most of the Hepastat 256 replacements listed above have some kind of fragrance in them. Are there any problems created by the fragrance?

Yes, you are correct: when you dilute this stock 1000-fold, you approach more neutral pH. Also, in general, high pH is better than low when it comes to solutions coming in contact with our records. We want to avoid encouraging the dehydrochlorination reaction that is autocatalytic and occurs as vinyl ages and breaks down (producing HCl). That's why we avoid acidic additives like wood glue or the Jet dry mentioned above.
See post above regarding the fragrance. Most of these are fairly inert and at super low concentrations. If there is a citrus or pine scented one, these are typically terpenes and can aid in the cleaning process (though insignificant). Most get caught up in the detergent micelles. Your nose will be the most sensitive detection instrument: a cleaned LP should have no detectable smell after final rinses.
 
Last edited:
I was able to buy 32oz of Virex II 256 from Amazon and for about $25 including shipping. I suspect this is a lifetime supply for record cleaning. We tried out the Hepastat 256 for household cleaning and it worked well so we'll also use the Virex II to clean bathrooms, floors, etc. 32 oz of that stuff will make 64 gallons of 256:1 cleaner! I'm also misting a very dilute (2000:1 or so) solution of Hepastat on my record brush before each play and on the turntable mat when I get some static. Seems to work well in this application too.
 
Let us know how the Virex works for you. Looks like between 10-20% quat in that concentrate.
In terms of household cleaning, the FDA banned a host of disinfectant ingredients last year (mostly used in antibacterial soaps) since they didn't do much good and they were deemed bad for the environment (and septic treatment plants). Interestingly, they withheld judgement on the quats we use and said they need more investigation as they seemed to be effective. Well duh, hospitals have been using them in place of bleach for years. My only caveat would be to not wash large amounts of them down the sink if you have a septic system at your house. You don't want to kill the bacteria in these systems that are essential for biodegradation of waste (in community sewer systems they are hugely diluted so not much of a problem). Instead, take the used solution from your US tank and wash down your driveway, roof, or sidewalk (it helps keep moss from growing and will break down with UV exposure to components microbes can process). Pool suppliers like HTH, Nava, and Kem-tek sell quat mixes as algaecide for pools and spas.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom