• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just wanted to update you all. I've made a cleaning solution using the pro force sanitizer and triton. Used it on a couple of records I cleaned with the triton alone that remained static prone. It works great! Seems to rinse well, no noticeable film or residue to the naked eye. The records play great with greatly reduced surface noise. I wouldn't say they are perfect, but much better. These are older, well played records.

For the 500 ml of solution I mixed:
1 ml of proforce
.5 ml of triton 100
25 ml of 99% ISO
Balance distilled h20.
Using a mkiii squeaky clean, I use triton, rub it in a few rotations, let it sit a few minutes. Follow up with two rinses of h20.
Seems to work really good!

Thanks Phantomrebel!
 
A little early for me to be doing math (pre-coffee), but It looks like your stock is 0.4% Triton, 0.03%Quat (assuming you are starting with a 10% commercial concentrate...you don't mention) and 2.3% IPA. And your 1 gal. working solution is about 0.02% Triton, 0.002% Quat and 4% IPA. This should work well for US cleaning. You could increase the IPA to half a cup to make it easier than measuring out 6.5 tablespoons (resulting in around 5%).
Thanks for the reply. Dang, I can't even hardly remember my name before I've had my coffee!
Isn't the Triton100 recommended to be around .13% on the final solution? And the 10% Quat to be around .10%?
 
Thanks for the reply. Dang, I can't even hardly remember my name before I've had my coffee!
Isn't the Triton100 recommended to be around .13% on the final solution? And the 10% Quat to be around .10%?
Yes, that is Ruston's recipe. I use similar for hand cleaning but found I can get by with less reagent in my ultrasonic bath and this makes rinsing easier. Your mix is a little low but it should work. That said, for optimal results I would start with adding 8x more of the surfactant stocks so you end up with 0.16% Triton and 0.016% quat and give it a try. The quat can be increased further if you are finding issues with static or the records are moldy. That way you are above the CMC of Triton and have enough quat to be effective. You won't get excessive foaming with this mix, it just is about how you rinse and dry. Some just spray and drip dry, others wipe, others put on an RCM. Since there are so many variables, I prefer ranges and hesitate to recommend exact concentrations. Complicating the issue is that commercial manufacturers provide wide concentrations ranges (sometimes 10-fold!) in their products for propriety so it is impossible to know exactly how much quat we have. It's best to experiment: wash, look, and listen. You want to use the minimal amount that cleans and rinses well, leaves no residue, and yields a record free of non-structural noise.
 
Last edited:
I'm using a Squeaky Clean RCM and rinse twice after cleaning the record. I suspect that the first rinse (spray on distilled water and then apply with a paint pad) and subsequent vacuum get most, if not all, of the cleaning fluid off the record. When I spray on distilled water for the second rinse it beads up unlike the first rinse when the distilled spreads out across the record. So, do you think the second rinse is just insurance?
 
Hoping this thread isn't dead! I recently got a US rig up and running and I'm getting great results, but I feel like the fumes from the cleaning solution are giving me headaches/making me feel woozy. I'm using Rushton's formula -

0.13% Tergitol S-15-3 and S-15-9 in a 50/50 proportion

0.10% Hepastat 256 (a 1:1000 dilution)

5.00% isopropyl alcohol (using 91% grade)

The room where I do my cleaning is small and not well ventilated - when I have the cleaner running and the lid off there's a pretty strong chemical smell in there. That said, I haven't thus far been doing marathon sessions - half-hour at a time in there at most. I've also wondered if my Chinese US machine (the Trusonik sold on eBay) is offgassing because the smell is far and away the strongest when the machine is running. So... just wondering if anyone can't give me any advice on this. I'm starting to feel a little paranoid because in general I feel like I haven't investigated the safety of these substances and I'm worried that I've been a little too cavalier.
 
Hoping this thread isn't dead! I recently got a US rig up and running and I'm getting great results, but I feel like the fumes from the cleaning solution are giving me headaches/making me feel woozy. I'm using Rushton's formula -

0.13% Tergitol S-15-3 and S-15-9 in a 50/50 proportion

0.10% Hepastat 256 (a 1:1000 dilution)

5.00% isopropyl alcohol (using 91% grade)

The room where I do my cleaning is small and not well ventilated - when I have the cleaner running and the lid off there's a pretty strong chemical smell in there. That said, I haven't thus far been doing marathon sessions - half-hour at a time in there at most. I've also wondered if my Chinese US machine (the Trusonik sold on eBay) is offgassing because the smell is far and away the strongest when the machine is running. So... just wondering if anyone can't give me any advice on this. I'm starting to feel a little paranoid because in general I feel like I haven't investigated the safety of these substances and I'm worried that I've been a little too cavalier.

?? Triton has no smell. Hepastat concentrate has scent added, but you shouldn't smell much at 0.1% (The quats themselves have no odor and are definitely not volatile). The only volatile component is the IPA, but at 5%, I doubt you are smelling much and it's odor is distinct. My guess would be it is the US machine you are using. Chinese manufacturers use all kinds of noxious components. I can smell their rubber parts and oiled components from 20 ft away. They have no regulations there for off gassing, which is why we no longer import some of their products like plywood (though idiots like Lumber Liquidators occasionally do so). I'm actually convinced (and am not alone in this belief) that they put their industrial waste in products as a means of disposal. Do some research and you'll find some of the chemicals at high levels in Chinese products are known carcinogens, neurotoxins, endocrine disrupters, and renal toxins - many have been banned for use in the USA . There are efforts to prevent this toxic importation in some products ( for example see http://dynamics.org/Altenberg/CURRENT_AFFAIRS/CHINA_PLASTIC/)
You're not going to like this, but my recommendation would be to ditch the machine and get one made in the USA or Europe. You'll pay more, but what is your health worth?
Again, the detergents and quats have no odor. You are sensitive to something else in your cleaning environment.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for replying Phantom - I was suspecting as much myself. It's a very strong smell that doesn't seem to have anything to do with the detergents themselves. It is definitely giving me a terrible headache. I think I can still return the machine actually - was thinking about doing that anyway because it's having trouble getting to 35 degrees.
 
Which machine are you using btw? The results I've been getting I have to say are phenomenal so... well there's no turning back now.
 
As a test, run the US machine with distilled water only, and see what aromas manifest. If nothing, try running it with distilled water and IPA, to see if the IPA is acting as a solvent for something related to the internals of the US machine.

I'm curious to know if the US machine could atomize the fluids being used.

I have obtained a 10% concentration to be further diluted at time of use. There is a bit of aroma at the 10% concentration. It would be hard for me to believe that at concentrations for US cleaners that even aroma would be a strong in any way.

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
Last edited:
I was wondering about the atomization myself Rich because yesterday I felt like I had a strange acrid taste in the back of my throat after a cleaning session. But I am pretty convinced it's the cleaner - I noticed the chemical smell when I unboxed and it gets very intense when the machine is running. The solution itself in the tank, when the machine is off, has no odor at all. I'm going to drain it today and run it with just distilled to see, although I've already initiated the return. AS I said, the heating function doesn't work at all. Looking into a Sonix IV - seems like a machine that many have had good luck with and it's not a crippling price (btw saw that someone was selling an Audiodesk in BT for a very good price...)
 
Hoping this thread isn't dead! I recently got a US rig up and running and I'm getting great results, but I feel like the fumes from the cleaning solution are giving me headaches/making me feel woozy. I'm using Rushton's formula -
I noticed this as well. Peering in for a closer look it coated my eyeglasses in a thin fog. After that I started wearing a particle mask.

Don't know about the machine itself offgassing any more than any other piece of electrical equipment. Tergitol is used in latex paints and wax stripper, so if it smells anything like that then it's not the machine itself.
 
Well my machine definitely had an unpleasant offgassing smell fro the moment I took it out, but I can't really say if it's the machine itself or the agitation of the solution that causes the acrid stench when it's running. Earlier response stated that the only thing in the solution that really smells is the IPA - then again something doesn't need to smell to be toxic when inhaled. That said, the solution doesn't seem to have much of an odor when stagnant and given the dilution of the detergents and the IPA, it was hard for me to imagine that it was causing the smell or my headaches. The smell is strong and unpleasant but isn't really the issue for me - I can deal with it. It's the headache and accompanying feeling of wooziness which occurs for me after very little exposure, which is not only unpleasant but seems really unhealthy. I am really sensitive to these types of allergic reactions and also struggle with headaches. What's more I don't have any other option in terms of the room I have my rig in (for more space or ventilation), so if it is the solution causing my problem (which I suppose is possible if there's atomization happening) I'm going to have to go to another solution. Bottom line - first thing I need to do is run the tank with just distilled water and see if I get the smell. BTW - I haven't yet drained my tank. Are there any safety/health issues I need to think about with disposing the solution (tergitols/hepastat/IPA diluted in distilled water)?
 
I did read someone in one of these DIY threads posting that the Library of Congress recommends wearing safety goggles, gloves and respirator when working with 100% tergitols. Which gave me pause...
 
I did read someone in one of these DIY threads posting that the Library of Congress recommends wearing safety goggles, gloves and respirator when working with 100% tergitols. Which gave me pause...

The LOC recommends goggles and a lab coat when mixing and using the cleaning fluid, and undiluted Tergitol is an eye and skin irritant. I don't see any reference to respirators. The isopropyl alcohol in these formulas is also an eye irritant and flammable as well.

It's worth being careful when mixing up these fluids, but I think that applies also to mixing up any kind of cleaning solution whether it's for records or bathroom floors. Anybody who's mixed bleach and ammonia can testify to the hazards there.

Here's a link to the MSDS for the Library of Congress Record Cleaning Fluid: http://www.loc.gov/preservation/care/MSDSRecordcleaning.pdf
(This refers to the record cleaning fluid which contains less than 1% Tergitol).

HAZARDS IDENTIFICATION
3.1 Emergency Overview Not applicable.
Health Rating: 0 – None
Flammability Rating: 0 - None
Reactivity Rating: 1 - Slight
Contact Rating: 0 - None
Lab Protective Equip: GOGGLES; LAB COAT
Storage Color Code: Orange (General Storage)

3.2 Potential Health Effects
Water is non-hazardous.
Inhalation: Not applicable.
Ingestion: Not applicable.
Skin Contact: Not applicable.
Eye Contact: Not applicable.
Chronic Exposure: Not applicable.
Aggravation of Pre-existing Conditions: Not applicable.


The biggest safety concern seems to be when using the undiluted Tergitol to make up a batch of cleaning fluid.

Basically don't drink it, don't bathe in it and don't get it in your eyes.

Here's the Safety Data Sheet for Tergitol 15-S-9.: http://www.gccgz.com/down/MSDS-e/15-S-9.pdf

3.2 POTENTIAL HEALTH EFFECTS
Effects of Single Acute Overexposure
Inhalation Short-term harmful health effects are not expected from vapor generated at ambient temperature. Aerosol can be hazardous if inhaled.
Eye Contact Causes moderate to severe irritation, experienced as discomfort or pain, excess blinking and tear production, with marked excess redness and swelling of the conjunctiva. Corneal injury may occur.
Skin Contact Causes irritation with discomfort, local redness, and possible swelling. Prolonged contact may cause severe irritation, with local discomfort or pain, and local redness and swelling. Effects may be prolonged.
Skin Absorption Prolonged or widespread contact may result in the absorption of potentially harmful amounts of material.
Swallowing Moderately toxic. May cause irritation of the mouth and throat, abdominal discomfort, nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea.
Aspiration into the lungs may occur during ingestion or vomiting, resulting in lung injury.
 
Last edited:
I ran my Trusonik with just distilled water and there was still a nasty smell, though it didn't seem quite as strong. I'm returning it (heat function doesn't work anyway) and just ordered the Sonix IV 136. I'll see how that one treats me, seems like a much better machine overall, also 60khz. I admit I'm a little concerned though - having researched the chemicals now doesn't seem like Hepastat, Tergitol or IPA vapors should be giving me any problems, but I'm worried I might just be oversensitive. Wouldn't be the first time I've had this kind of problem. I suppose I can try a particle mask as well.
 
Well, the Tergitols and Tritons are WAY less toxic than SDS (using LD50 results in mice), and SDS is the go to detergent in almost all shampoos and dishwashing soaps so I'm not sure what people here are worrying about. Furthermore, Triton and Tergitols are sold in liquid form while SDS is in a powder that is incredibly noxious (removes the mucous coating from your lungs) so we prefer working with the former. The quats we are using are also in liquid form and they are approved for hospital and food surface use. They are not very toxic to humans and we are using them at concentrations less than your local restaurant or preschool does. This is why they have replaced bleach as preferred disinfectants in sensitive environments. Again, it is your US tank that is the problem. Take it out and shoot it. Than go back in the cleaning area with just your cleaning solution and hand wash a few records and see how you respond. There is a very rare chance that you are allergic to something, but I bet my best LP that you will no longer experience any noxious odors (in the case that your are sensitive, a particulate mask will do nothing...you will need a special filtered unit with protective clothing and also wear the same when you do laundry, dishes, or any other household cleaning unless you select particular products...It is an unfortunate condition, but it does exist and you would not be alone. You NEED to consult a doctor, preferably an experienced allergist, if this is the case).
Careful when interpreting safety sheets: Attorney's dictate what is in these and if you followed them, you'd never salt your food as NaCl is mutagenic and you need protective clothing to handle: http://www.sciencelab.com/msds.php?msdsId=9927593 !! Yet us contact lens wearers have no problem squirting 0.9% solutions of this salt directly in our eyes on a daily basis with no ill effects.

EDIT: This may be something not to be taken lightly. There are serious sensitivities out there we just don't understand. If you find yourself uncomfortable with a particular environment, avoid it immediately and find someone who can help you understand and deal with your sensitivity. Be confident that this is not a weakness or something to be ashamed of, rather, be proud of the fact that you have a unique sense that is greater than the average person!
 
Last edited:
I have been using Rushton's formula (Tergitol S-15-3 and S-15-9, Hepastat 256, 9a% IPA, and Whole Foods DI water) for my US tank with great results. I have come across a couple of issues that I wanted to get input from the knowledgeable members on this thread:

1 - My ultrasonic tank has a drain valve. After each batch of cleaning, I connect a hose and drain the solution into 1gallon containers, while passing it thru two layers of fabric for filtering (old T-shirts, really). This may not be the most effective filtering method, however. I found a compact inline water filter made by a company called Sawyer. Walmart sells them for $30. It is actually a 0.1 micron filter, which is great. The only question is if the filter is too fine and could potentially filter some of the needed chemicals from the solution.

- I drain and change the cleaning solution every 40-50 records. But, this could take a few weeks. Meanwhile, doesn't the alcohol in the solution evaporate? If so, how can you tell how much alcohol has evaporated so that you can add it back to the solution?
 
I have been using Rushton's formula (Tergitol S-15-3 and S-15-9, Hepastat 256, 9a% IPA, and Whole Foods DI water) for my US tank with great results. I have come across a couple of issues that I wanted to get input from the knowledgeable members on this thread:

1 - My ultrasonic tank has a drain valve. After each batch of cleaning, I connect a hose and drain the solution into 1gallon containers, while passing it thru two layers of fabric for filtering (old T-shirts, really). This may not be the most effective filtering method, however. I found a compact inline water filter made by a company called Sawyer. Walmart sells them for $30. It is actually a 0.1 micron filter, which is great. The only question is if the filter is too fine and could potentially filter some of the needed chemicals from the solution.

- I drain and change the cleaning solution every 40-50 records. But, this could take a few weeks. Meanwhile, doesn't the alcohol in the solution evaporate? If so, how can you tell how much alcohol has evaporated so that you can add it back to the solution?

Hi Alex,

Simply draining your US tank through a filter seems like a fine approach. Some people drain through paper coffee filters. The inline filter I use is a 1 micron filter (not familiar with a 0.1 micron filter), and it seems to work fine without adverse impact of the effectiveness of the mixed solution. The chemicals are in solution and a filter won't filter out the chemicals, only particulates.

You are correct to wonder about alcohol evaporation - this is sure to happen over time. I will usually add more as I use the mixed solution over several days, but I have no set amounts or recommendations - I just make a guess as I do it. I do keep my tank sealed by a cover when not in use precisely to minimize that alcohol evaporation over time.

Cheers,
Rush

P.S. I replied to your posting of this same question at Positive Feedback Online, but my reply has still not been approved for posting after 5 days! So, clearly this forum is a better place to ask questions and share information.
 
Hi Rushton
Thank you very much for your quick response. And, of course, many thanks for your article and the solution that I have been following.
- re: filter size, I just wanted to make sure that none of the chemicals in the solution (some are not water soluble) have molecules greater than 0.1 micron in size that could potentially get filtered out.
- I have noticed that I lose a bit of the solution after each session. Do you know if any of the other ingredient in the solution evaporate also or is the loss of solution volume only due to Alcohol evaporation? I have been topping off with mixed solution, but, if the loss is only due to alcohol, then, I will top off with Alcohol only.
Best regards
Alex
 
I have been using Rushton's formula (Tergitol S-15-3 and S-15-9, Hepastat 256, 9a% IPA, and Whole Foods DI water) for my US tank with great results. I have come across a couple of issues that I wanted to get input from the knowledgeable members on this thread:

1 - My ultrasonic tank has a drain valve. After each batch of cleaning, I connect a hose and drain the solution into 1gallon containers, while passing it thru two layers of fabric for filtering (old T-shirts, really). This may not be the most effective filtering method, however. I found a compact inline water filter made by a company called Sawyer. Walmart sells them for $30. It is actually a 0.1 micron filter, which is great. The only question is if the filter is too fine and could potentially filter some of the needed chemicals from the solution.

- I drain and change the cleaning solution every 40-50 records. But, this could take a few weeks. Meanwhile, doesn't the alcohol in the solution evaporate? If so, how can you tell how much alcohol has evaporated so that you can add it back to the solution?
Use a Squeaky Clean Mk III and you will be cleaning with fresh juice each time :rockon:
It's kinda akin to the super expensive NASA space pen development versus the Russians simply using a Pencil. They both write good in space....
:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom