• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for your input, Timothy. I do use a vacuum based RCM also, but, in my rinse cycles. I use both Nitty Gritty and Okki Nokki RCMs. I use a multi-step cleaning process. Admittedly, some steps might be unnecessary, but, until I better understand which steps, I will continue to use this process.

My process consists of:
- Last Power cleaner to clean Manufacturing Mold Release agent
- Scrub with Nitty Gritty Enzyme cleaner
- US cleaning using Rushton's formula
- Two rinse and vacuum cycles using DI water. I am about to order Type 1 reagent grade water to use in my second rinse cycle.
- I have also used Last Preservative on some of my records, until I read this thread. This step is now on hold pending further evaluation.

The questions that I have are about proper filtering of US solution and substitution of chemicals lost due to evaporation.

Best regards
Alex
 
Thank you for your input, Timothy. I do use a vacuum based RCM also, but, in my rinse cycles. I use both Nitty Gritty and Okki Nokki RCMs. I use a multi-step cleaning process. Admittedly, some steps might be unnecessary, but, until I better understand which steps, I will continue to use this process.

My process consists of:
- Last Power cleaner to clean Manufacturing Mold Release agent
- Scrub with Nitty Gritty Enzyme cleaner
- US cleaning using Rushton's formula
- Two rinse and vacuum cycles using DI water. I am about to order Type 1 reagent grade water to use in my second rinse cycle.
- I have also used Last Preservative on some of my records, until I read this thread. This step is now on hold pending further evaluation.

The questions that I have are about proper filtering of US solution and substitution of chemicals lost due to evaporation.

Best regards
Alex
I am actually hearing what you are laying down. The obvious question though: Doing all that, when do you find time to actually enjoy your records or is the actual cleaning process the enjoyment vs the tunes themselves (aka the space pen team)? Then again the NASA team made it to the moon and the Russians did not. But hey the Russians can put people into orbit now and NASA truly cannot (they are actually hitching rides with the Russians)...
To me there is always a point of diminishing returns and I have learned to just accept a little of life's imperfections to keep my tunes spinning on my turntable. Then again none of my records are so valuable that I feel they need to last longer than I will be alive so keep doing what you are doing.
;)
 
Last edited:
Yes, it is a lengthy process. But, cleaning a few records a week is a bit of a therapy and "me time" :). Also, not every record that I have goes thru "the works" process.
I think some steps may be duplicates, but, I am not sure which ones: eg. does the Rushton US solution also address manufacturing mold release agent, also?
 
Yes, it is a lengthy process. But, cleaning a few records a week is a bit of a therapy and "me time" :). Also, not every record that I have goes thru "the works" process.
I think some steps may be duplicates, but, I am not sure which ones: eg. does the Rushton US solution also address manufacturing mold release agent, also?

I believe it does, and since step 2 (Enzyme) is mostly for the other kind of mold and the Rushton Formula has Hepastat; I think I's skip # 2 also. But I've never done US. Does it remove big particles and hair?
 
Record manufacturers do not use a "mold release agent" per se. That is an old internet tale. The record is released via the steam generated during the heat pressing process. There are, however, compounds in the vinyl formulation that make the polymer release cleanly and retain its pressed form. These are integral to the vinyl and not something washed off. There is no oil, wax, or other "release agent" used in the pressing. That said, the vapor generated at pressing can be rather dirty and leave a residue behind.

I find an enzyme step is only necessary for really scummy thrift finds that have visible fingerprints and obvious contaminants (Cheetos dust is the worst!). In these cases, I simply make my own mix from enzyme tablets commonly found at the drugstore (the ones for digestive help, not the ones for cleaning contact lenses. The former has lipase, protease and amylase while the latter is usually just Papain, a protease).
 
I had said earlier I would show my pressure washing device and I am posting it now for people to look at. After pressure washing, the records get a distilled water rinse and a good vacuuming. I can now do a comparison between the Clear Audio Double Matrix, Ultra Sonic and pressure washing methods. Stay tuned.

Here is the link to the video
 
Last edited:
Record manufacturers do not use a "mold release agent" per se. That is an old internet tale. The record is released via the steam generated during the heat pressing process. There are, however, compounds in the vinyl formulation that make the polymer release cleanly and retain its pressed form. These are integral to the vinyl and not something washed off. There is no oil, wax, or other "release agent" used in the pressing. That said, the vapor generated at pressing can be rather dirty and leave a residue behind.
Based on what I've read, wax is added to the vinyl matrix for the purposes of facilitating ready release from the stampers. Heat and pressure causes the wax to liquify at the surface between the stamper and the vinyl puck.

There are patent abstracts on the internet that describe this. I think carnauba is included in one of the formulations. It is one of the hardest waxes and has the highest melting point of any wax.

The thinking is that this wax is somehow sticky and attracts dirt. The truth is, the dirt is in the air and static attracts the dirt and holds it to the vinyl, which is why we should wash the record after opening it. However, in washing the record we remove the wax and the beneficial lubrication it provides. So we gain one advantage at the expense of another.

I've never noticed a 'sticky' substance on new vinyl. A nice, glossy shine, on the other hand...
 
I had said earlier I would show my pressure washing device and I am posting it now for people to look at. After pressure washing, the records get a distilled water rinse and a good vacuuming. I can now do a comparison between the Clear Audio Double Matrix, Ultra Sonic and pressure washing methods. Stay tuned.

Something didn't work. What format should videos be in to download them on this site.
You don't post the media here, you link it in. For example my vid several posts above was actually uploaded to my YouTube channel and then linked in using the film icon in the post editor....
 
In other words, Left click to highlight the URL of the video. Right click to 'copy' the URL. Go to the post reply box at AudioKarma. Enter the URL into the reply box at AudioKarma by right click on 'paste'. Post reply.
 
Record manufacturers do not use a "mold release agent" per se. That is an old internet tale. The record is released via the steam generated during the heat pressing process. There are, however, compounds in the vinyl formulation that make the polymer release cleanly and retain its pressed form. These are integral to the vinyl and not something washed off. There is no oil, wax, or other "release agent" used in the pressing. That said, the vapor generated at pressing can be rather dirty and leave a residue behind.

I find an enzyme step is only necessary for really scummy thrift finds that have visible fingerprints and obvious contaminants (Cheetos dust is the worst!). In these cases, I simply make my own mix from enzyme tablets commonly found at the drugstore (the ones for digestive help, not the ones for cleaning contact lenses. The former has lipase, protease and amylase while the latter is usually just Papain, a protease).

You are a veritable bottomless pit of information!
 
Based on what I've read, wax is added to the vinyl matrix for the purposes of facilitating ready release from the stampers. Heat and pressure causes the wax to liquify at the surface between the stamper and the vinyl puck.

There are patent abstracts on the internet that describe this. I think carnauba is included in one of the formulations. It is one of the hardest waxes and has the highest melting point of any wax.

The thinking is that this wax is somehow sticky and attracts dirt. The truth is, the dirt is in the air and static attracts the dirt and holds it to the vinyl, which is why we should wash the record after opening it. However, in washing the record we remove the wax and the beneficial lubrication it provides. So we gain one advantage at the expense of another.

I've never noticed a 'sticky' substance on new vinyl. A nice, glossy shine, on the other hand...

Another bottomless pit! We are truly fortunate.
 
Based on what I've read, wax is added to the vinyl matrix for the purposes of facilitating ready release from the stampers. Heat and pressure causes the wax to liquify at the surface between the stamper and the vinyl puck.There are patent abstracts on the internet that describe this. I think carnauba is included in one of the formulations. It is one of the hardest waxes and has the highest melting point of any wax.
I think the standard lubricant is EBS (Ethylene bis stearamide). Either way, it's important to clarify that it is always part of the resin formulation, not something sprayed or wiped onto the stamper (a releasing oil stamper coating is something falsely perpetuated on the internet). They are necessary not just for separation but for improved flow of the resin (as a consequence, it lowers the melting temperature). It is very difficult to wash this out with aqueous solutions, though some on the immediate surface may be partially removed over time by detergents and alcohol mixtures. I assume they are replenished by some of the long chain surfactants I use however, and there are even patents (e.g. US4510187, US4351048 ) describing the benefits of adding quats for this purpose.

Car people will know that a hard wax finish can be washed with mild detergent without harm, but if you want to apply a decal or 3M taped body part, you wipe with alcohol to prepare the surface first (remove the wax). Hence, I cringe when I see people using straight IPA to clean their records.
 
Last edited:
I think the standard lubricant is EBS (Ethylene bis stearamide). Either way, it's important to clarify that it is always part of the resin formulation, not something sprayed or wiped onto the stamper (a releasing oil stamper coating is something falsely perpetuated on the internet).
Yes, what I was trying to say was that the mould release agent is in the vinyl, not on it, though some exists on the surface after pressing and can be washed off. One study (probably related to the patents you listed) showed that the friction coefficient of the vinyl increases after the record is washed. Hence, leaving some surfactant on the record is a good idea.
 
Yes, what I was trying to say was that the mould release agent is in the vinyl, not on it, though some exists on the surface after pressing and can be washed off. One study (probably related to the patents you listed) showed that the friction coefficient of the vinyl increases after the record is washed.
This is a very important point that is often overlooked. All the data show that slick record plays better and lasts longer. Another reason to stay away from strong commercial or solvent-based cleaners! As you stated, there is a balance between effective cleaning and removal of desirable compounds. Hopefully we can find the sweet spot.
 
Last edited:
I think the standard lubricant is EBS (Ethylene bis stearamide). ... Hence, I cringe when I see people using straight IPA to clean their records.

I have an acquaintance who owns a second-hand record store. He cleans his records with straight methylated spirits(denatured alcohol). I have told him that he is probably doing harm to the vinyl. He will not listen.
 
Also, I hold a soft bristle toothbrush at an angle to the vinyl with the solution on, and spin it by hand (as if the tb were the stylus, over the entire record and then reversed) anyone tell if a soft paint pad might be better? Less harmful?
/I actually feel kind of silly typing that, but I do have some dearly treasured records
I use a corner paint pad and it works well.
 
Hi Rushton
Thank you very much for your quick response. And, of course, many thanks for your article and the solution that I have been following.
- re: filter size, I just wanted to make sure that none of the chemicals in the solution (some are not water soluble) have molecules greater than 0.1 micron in size that could potentially get filtered out.
- I have noticed that I lose a bit of the solution after each session. Do you know if any of the other ingredient in the solution evaporate also or is the loss of solution volume only due to Alcohol evaporation? I have been topping off with mixed solution, but, if the loss is only due to alcohol, then, I will top off with Alcohol only.
Best regards
Alex
Alex, I don't see that anyone has yet addressed the question in your second bullet: "Do you know if any of the other ingredient in the solution evaporate also or is the loss of solution volume only due to Alcohol evaporation?" @phantomrebel is the best person to answer this but my guess is that only the alcohol is volatile enough to worry about evaporation over any modest period of time.

And, in regards to your first bullet, while the Tergitol S-15-3 is OIL soluble, in the presence of the S-15-9 I believe it does go into solution and is not just hanging around as a particulate that would be filtered out. Perhaps Phantomrebel will comment.
 
I've never analyzed or experienced evaporation of cleaning solutions containing small amounts of alcohol as I keep them well stoppered, but water/alcohol mixtures are a bit interesting as they are an azeotropic mixture so you are losing both in your case. In terms of filtration, you have no worries...the surfactants we are dealing form micelles that are in the 0.02-0.002 micron range.
 
Thank you very much Rushton and Phantomrebel for the great information. So, filtering the solution with 0.1 micron filter will not affect the chemicals in the solution and, I assume, is a good thing to do.

Interesting how both water and alcohol evaporate from the solution. So, topping off the lost solution with the same mixture is probably correct, although the proportion of water/alcohol that you add may be different from what is lost.

Phantomrebel, is your formula/process for making Enzyme solution something that you can share with us? If so, it will be greatly appreciated.

The discussion about mold release agent raises a question: earlier in this thread there was a discussion about Last record Preservative and soundgaurd - type solutions and how they are lubricants that we don't want on our records. Here we are talking about a layer of wax left on the record from the manufacturing process as a good lubricant to have on the record. So, what constitutes a desirable vs an undesirable lubricant? It is interesting that Last has a formula called Power Cleaner that is targeted at removing "mold release agent" but, you are supposed to add Last Preservative as a final step to preserve your records. Also, have you had experience with Stylast that helps protect and prolong the life of your stylus?
 
Looking at the commercial selection of quat cleaners, I found that Hepastat 256 is easily replaceable: Many manufacturers are producing a similar 256x quat concentrate (listed by Manufacturer, "Product name"):

Spartan, “Sparquat 256” or "GS High Dilution Disinfectant 256"
Brulin, “Maxima 256” or "Uniquat Neutral Disinfectant 256"
Stetson, “HBV Disinfectant 256”
Multi-clean, “Century Q 256”
Diverse, “Virex II 256”
National Chemical Lab, “Neutra-Cide 256”
US Chemical "Mixmate O" or "Sanitation System Disinfectant 256"

to name just a few. So no biggie that Quill left the market.

They must be back in the market. I just purchased a 64oz bottle of Brighton Professional™ Hepastat 256™ Restroom Cleaner; Handy Mix, Dilutable, 64 Oz. from Quill and it arrived yesterday. Pretty reasonable price of $31 shipped.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom