• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks you for the response. I see the contamination pattern similar to the lower picture in used records quite often. I always assumed that it was due to poor care, until I saw it in this sealed record. I have not been able to successfully remove it.

Does it cause any surface noise?
 
A question about the Hepastat 256 32 oz bottle. Does anyone have experience with the bottle itself? I got the cap off and seen that it has the dilution system top. Before I tear it up, how do you remove this? I was able to get some product out, enough to use in the Spin Clean.

BTW, the bottle recommends 1/2 oz Hepastat to a gallon (128 oz) water which equals approx 15 ml Hepastat to 3781 ml water. For the 24 oz Spin Clean tank, I used a hair under 3 ml of Hepastat.
 
Can you exchange it for another copy?
I probably could. But, I have seen this on other records too. My interest, from record cleaning perspective, is to figure out what it is and how to remove it.

BTW, I am interested in digitizing/ripping some of my albums for portability reasons. This discussion does not belong to this thread, but, does anyone know of a thread/discussion on audiophile ways of digitizing your albums?
 
A question about the Hepastat 256 32 oz bottle. Does anyone have experience with the bottle itself? I got the cap off and seen that it has the dilution system top. Before I tear it up, how do you remove this? I was able to get some product out, enough to use in the Spin Clean.

BTW, the bottle recommends 1/2 oz Hepastat to a gallon (128 oz) water which equals approx 15 ml Hepastat to 3781 ml water. For the 24 oz Spin Clean tank, I used a hair under 3 ml of Hepastat.

You just pull the top out. I've mentioned this here several times, but the reason they call these solutions "256" is because that is the dilution factor for general cleaning (1 oz per gallon = 1:256. eg, the concentrate is 256X). We generally use it at 1:1000 dilution when combining it with a non-ionic detergent (e.g. Triton X100) for record cleaning.
 
We generally use it at 1:1000 dilution when combining it with a non-ionic detergent (e.g. Triton X100) for record cleaning.
Just a thought: if these quats are surfactants to begin with, why couldn't they be used in a higher concentration instead of mixing them with others? Seems to me the antistatic effect would be greater, even if the cleaning isn't as thorough.

Perhaps a solution of straight quats could be used as an antistatic treatment alone on an already cleaned but untreated record?
 
New to this whole scene, but it sounds promising. I need to gather up the chemicals and start mixing. I'm looking at going two directions -- either tracking down hepastat 256 (or clone) and use that with a distilled water/IPA mixture on it's own. Or going with Triton X-100+IPA+distilled water+quat. It sounds like either will work, and work well. Is one option better than the other or should I just take a path of least resistance?

Finally, would quat-based dish sanitizer tablets such as Steramine (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000W09SF6/) work as a quat source for my latter option?

Thanks!
 
You just pull the top out. I've mentioned this here several times, but the reason they call these solutions "256" is because that is the dilution factor for general cleaning (1 oz per gallon = 1:256. eg, the concentrate is 256X). We generally use it at 1:1000 dilution when combining it with a non-ionic detergent (e.g. Triton X100) for record cleaning.

Thanks - I just haven't read all of the 14xx posts. :)
 
Hepastat works well on it's own....I've done the experiment. Along with the quats, it does contain a non-ionic detergent and ethanol, albeit at lower concentrations. As a general rule, I don't like to introduce too many charged molecules into systems. Hence, I use mostly non-ionic detergent for cleaning with a smaller amount (10- to 100-fold less) of positively charged quats to control static and neutralize what is on the record surface. Does it matter? Not really, according to the Hepastat alone tests where there were no ill effects. I do know that there can be synergy when using surfactants of differing properties. You get mixed micelles that can solubilize things better that homo-micelles might. With all the surfactants in the Hepastat/Triton mix with the variety of head and tail structures, all the bases are pretty much covered.
And yes, the quat mix can be used as an antistat by itself. That is exactly what the commercial antistat treatments and sprays consist of. Many patents based on this, beginning in the 1930's with Dupont, continuing in the 60's with Bayer and Ciba, and in the 70's with BASF and DOW, through the 80's with Xerox and PPG. I could post a bunch of these if folks are interested. Controlling static has been a problem in industry since the beginning and great corporate scientists have solved the problem for us. We simply have to adapt it to our use, as it has also plagued many record collectors for no reason other than our own ignorance.
Hence, a 1:5000 to 1:10,000 dilution of Hepastat in 5% IPA put into a spray bottle makes a great antistat treatment. It also lubricates the record surface and prevents microbial growth. It isn't that great for cleaning at this concentration as it will be below the critical micelle concentration.
 
Last edited:
Hepastat works well on it's own....I've done the experiment.....<snip>
And yes, the quat mix can be used as an antistat by itself. That is exactly what the commercial antistat sprays consist of. Many patents based on this, beginning in the 1930's with Dupont, continuing in the 60's with Bayer and Ciba, and in the 70's with BASF and DOW, through the 80's with Xerox and PPG. I could post a bunch of these if folks are interested.

Great info, thanks. I actually have read all the posts in this thread. But in such a compressed time frame my head is spinning a little bit. ;-)

So in terms of expediency and simplification, I think I might just grab the Hepastat and give it a whirl. The fewer needed chemicals the better (unless it turns out my media library friends have a ready-source for Tergitol or Triton I can try out. BTW, I also have a small spray bottle of the premixed ACL Staticide (http://www.qsource.com/download/acl/20012003 SDS_0517.pdf). I've been using it sparingly as a damp wipe on some records and it seems to help, but I'm thinking that it should be more diluted, but used more generously, too. If you have any thoughts on dilution levels for antistat spray (edit: for Staticide, specifically, since it's already ~1:200 quat and IPA ) I'd love to hear them.

Cheers!
 
Last edited:
Steve, really. What in particular do you have an issue with? I do agree however, after 18 years running a research program at a medical school, two Ph.D. degrees, 100's of publications and patents, and as a member of the National Academy of Science, that I'm definitely "trying" to be a scientist!
I disagree, however, with your Purex solution. The use of SDS -containing solutions was discredited in one of the first posts of this thread. I highly recommend you read it. Furthermore, research has shown SDS is MORE dangerous and toxic than most quats. The FDA even considered banning it but were thwarted by industry (P&G). Your Purex also contains high amounts of propylene glycol, and this was addressed in discussions (in this thread and others) about Photoflo.
To be honest, your method is one of a common hack. Sorry, but that is the truth. The formulation was not meant for, nor is ideal for, cleaning carefully pressed plastics meant for sound reproduction. I apologize for being harsh, but read this thread in it's entirety and you will see where we are coming from before you crap on it. It isn't that your Purex won't clean stuff, rather, the thread is a search for perfection, not simplicity. There are many other threads on using household products and I encourage you to participate there and let us geeks be geeks. OTOH, if you want to present results comparing Purex vs. the formulations presented here, we welcome them with open minds! :)
 
Last edited:
Did you try it?

No worries, keep complicating things.

I challenge you, my method against yours any day....

Again, please follow the spirit of the thread. Please explain what particular ingredients in your solution bring something unique to the table or provide an advantage over others. Or present comparative results. Simply reaching under your kitchen or laundry sink, washing records, and stating that it is the best record cleaning solution ever is not going to cut it here.
We all agree it's only a cleaning process and there are many solutions. The question is what is most effective at removing contaminants, leaves no audible residues, controls static, does not harm the integrity of the vinyl, and allows for long term preservation.
 
Last edited:
Again, please follow the spirit of the thread. Please explain what particular ingredients in your solution bring something unique to the table or provide an advantage over others. Or present comparative results. Simply reaching under your kitchen or laundry sink, washing records, and stating that it is the best record cleaning solution ever is not going to cut it here.
We all agree it's only a cleaning process and there are many solutions. The question is what is most effective at removing contaminants, leaves no audible residues, controls static, does not harm the integrity of the vinyl, and allows for long term preservation.


Check for PM...non thread related.

Q
 
Thank GOD. There was one exclamation mark. I thought for one moment that I was going to be disappointed. It is a scientific reply after all. The ! makes it so...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom