• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
The problem with your methods is that you keep recirculating the contaminants without filtration and wonder why they still end up on the record.

This is true for those using Spinclean devices. Many here are using other devices (RCM, US, etc.), but this thread is about the solutions being used, not the methods. That said, several here use a pressure jet method similar to yours and it has always been said it is one of the best ways to dislodge contaminants. Member dfunghi posted that he uses a garden sprayer up to 45 psi. Others use the GEM-Dandy device. I would think it's a good idea to pre-filter the solution going into the pressure tank as any salt/mineral crystals or hard debris can damage the record surface. Most US users here filter their tank solutions.
I totally agree with your comment on spores. Microbes live on the label of improperly stored records and can cross-contaminate.

In addition to anionic surfactants, your Pyrex Free & Clear contains 10-30% glycerin and 5-15% propylene glycol. Both of these items are not very good to have on the record surface as they are inherently sticky (glycerine is also a good carbon source for microbial growth). One good thing is the detergent mix contains some enzymes, Subtilisin in particular (a protease), that help digest contaminants. The bad news is that your jetting method doesn't appear to include any incubation time for this activity to work. In your laundry (for what is was designed), it would sit on clothes for the entire soak and wash times. I know you are hell bent on using this detergent mix so I can offer some tips that may improve your results: 1) use more diluted, 2) let sit on the surface for 5-10 min before rinsing off, and 3) pre-warm the solution. Also, I would avoid using my bare hand to deflect the spray from the label. Oils and skin cells are extracted and dispersed on your record surface.

Got this off amazon for 20$!!
Best cleaner I've used. Worth it in every aspect

Great cleaner because it is simply Tergitol 15-S-7, one of our favorite non-ionics. To say it is "worth it" is not correct: The guy is charging you $20/oz for something we buy for 50-90 cents/oz. Quite the profit margin! Check out Talas as a source for example.
 
Last edited:
This is true for those using Spinclean devices. Many here are using other devices (RCM, US, etc.), but this thread is about the solutions being used, not the methods. That said, several here use a pressure jet method similar to yours and it has always been said it is one of the best ways to dislodge contaminants. Member dfunghi posted that he uses a garden sprayer up to 45 psi. Others use the GEM-Dandy device. I would think it's a good idea to pre-filter the solution going into the pressure tank as any salt/mineral crystals or hard debris can damage the record surface. Most US users here filter their tank solutions.

In addition to anionic surfactants, your Pyrex Free & Clear contains 10-30% glycerin and 5-15% propylene glycol. Both of these items are not very good to have on the record surface as they are inherently sticky. One good thing is the detergent mix contains some enzymes, Papain in particular (a protease), that help digest contaminants. The bad news is that your jetting method doesn't appear to include any incubation time for this activity to work. In your laundry (for what is was designed), it would sit on clothes for the entire soak and wash times. I know you are hell bent on using this detergent mix so I can offer some tips: 1) use more diluted, 2) let sit on the surface for 5-10 min before rinsing off, and 3) pre-warm the solution to improve your results.



Great cleaner because it is simply Tergitol 15-S-7, one of our favorite non-ionics. To say it is "worth it" is not correct: The guy is charging you $20/oz for something we buy for 50-90 cents/oz. Quite the profit margin! Check out Talas as a source for example.
Thanks! I'm new to this thread and the tergitol also! Thanks for the heads up! 20$ was worth it imo considering the cleaning I got out of it. Nice to know it's cheaper
 
Everyone has their own solution. The Triton I bought from @hi*ball has worked real well. I just mix it with distilled water and no alcohol, followed by a spritzed on distilled water rinse, and it has worked real well. I bought some Hepastat from @ETLS but have not used it yet. A quart of mixed solution lasts me about a year. After cleaning all new to me records, they simply get a distilled water rinse for many plays to come. IMO life is to short to be any more OCD about this, it just zaps the fun out of the hobby. YMMV
 
Last edited:
So are you done trolling now?

Yes and I have deleted all of my worthless input.

Sorry, I didn't realize I was trying to run with such "lofty" Intellectuals and my input was nothing but rubbish.

Now back to your nonsense and chemicals that are readily absorbed into your bloodstream and causing you headaches.
 
Last edited:
Hence, a 1:5000 to 1:10,000 dilution of Hepastat in 5% IPA put into a spray bottle makes a great antistat treatment. It also lubricates the record surface and prevents microbial growth. It isn't that great for cleaning at this concentration as it will be below the critical micelle concentration.
Good to know, thanks.

So, just to bring this diversion to it's logical conclusion, how would you apply this? Spritz onto a cosmetics wipe and buff the record? Or spray the record and buff dry with a cloth? Or....?
 
When I tried this, I used it in place of the D4 solution with a Discwasher, but I imagine a Groovewasher, cosmetic pad, or microfiber cloth would work. Just haven't tried those. I include the IPA simply to disperse the solution better. It beads up too much on clean records...YMMV.
 
Yes and I have deleted all of my worthless input.

Sorry, I didn't realize I was trying to run with such "lofty" Intellectuals and my input was nothing but rubbish.

Now back to your nonsense and chemicals that are readily absorbed into your bloodstream and causing you headaches.

Sorry this wasn't more welcoming Stevo, but I don't think all your input was "worthless". It is always useful to discuss what folks are using, what chemicals are in it, and the results achieved. But we need to discuss with facts, not just proclaim (at least in this thread) or views come off the wrong way. It's a tough sell to get record collectors excited about pouring glycerine on their beloved lps. There is little doubt that this thread is about the chemistry and this clearly isn't for everybody. That said, the chemicals we are using are less harmful than what is in many detergents. Just because it is something marketed to consumers does not mean it is harmless. You may remember the FDA did an intensive review of antimicrobials (completed last year) and this included many quat surfactants as they have this property. While they banned many ingredients in hand soaps and dish detergents (e.g. triclosan), they could find no evidence against using quat surfactants. This is one of the reasons they are replacing bleach in the sanitation field, especially in hospitals, food service areas, and schools. Finally, it is very difficult to absorb any of these detergents into your bloodstream. You are much more likely to ingest them. You'd be surprised to find how many consumer products include these quat surfactants. You pour high concentrations of them over your head every time you use hair conditioner. We are using dilute solutions on a plastic surface with only occasional exposure to our hands (not pouring over our head and having it run down our face!). As discussed earlier in this thread, there will always be people who have sensitivities to particular chemicals and headaches or allergic reactions would be a good reason to discontinue exposure.
 
Last edited:
I'm stranded at home and just put
Aerosmith on the TT and then I'm going to the beach and I don't care about record cleaning any more cause most all sound good now and if they don't out they go!

Just remember that if you play a dirty record it will just make things worse so no matter how we clean em', what matters is that we clean em'.

Man I feel young again but only for a few moments.

Some days you just need to relax and enjoy.

Have a great day folks and sorry for the thread jack.

Man that's a clean record!
IMG_3937.JPG

IMG_3936.JPG
 
Last edited:
I'm stranded at home and just put
Aerosmith on the TT and then I'm going to the beach and I don't care about record cleaning any more cause they all sound good now. ;-)"

Just remember that if you play a dirty record it will just make things worse so no matter how we clean em', what matters is that we clean em'.

Man I feel young again but only for a few moments.

Some days you just need to relax and enjoy.

Have a great day folks and sorry for the thread jack.

Man that's a clean record!

As has been said many times on this thread...if it is working for you and you are satisfied, more power to you! You definitely are cleaning. There are folks that use wood glue, Scrubbing bubbles, Windex, 2-n-1 shampoo, and all sorts of things to clean their records with great results. This thread is for the more anal types trying to discover what is going on. In the end, it's all about the music and you seem to have found a great zone to be in!
 
I did forget to mention one last step.

Give a final rinse with water that has been filtered with a Zero water filter or distilled but the Zero costs a lot less and you can feel free to use a lot.

Just a splash on each side just in case you can hear minerals. :D
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom