• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I did forget to mention one last step.

Give a final rinse with water that has been filtered with a Zero water filter.

Just a splash on each side just in case you can hear minerals. :D
That's a very important step we have been finding, no matter what wash solution is used.
Onwardjames has a sticky on record cleaning in the general topic section. You may want to post your procedure there as there would be much interest.
 
In my hunt for Hepastat 256, I ran across a few more potential options.

  • this IC Lysol (not the Lysol you remember but a Quaternary 256 Lysol). Cheaper per ounce than the Staples/Quill Hepastat, as it comes in a gallon bottle. I know I don't need this for much for records, but the more I read about it, it sounds a move to a gneral household quat cleaner instead of bleach might be a good option. ~$31/gal (vs. $24/ 1/2 gal for hepastat 256)
  • this "Top Performance" 256 -- this one (detailed info here at the Pesticide Action Network) looks to be marketed as a vet-focused cleaner but the actual forumlation is apparently registered with the EPA as Maquat by Mason Chemical and distributed under a huge list (61!) of product names, as pet, health, and janitorial-centric brands. $36/gal
  • this Simple Green Pro 5 Disinfectant Quat cleaner. It's less concentrated, but supposedly doesn't have any added color or fragrance, which may or may not be a good thing. MSDS here. $15.80/gal. Though this is more diluted than the 256 products, I'd like to get @phantomrebel's opinion if this is a decent cleaning option for vinyl. If so, it might open doors for people who can't find or don't want to search out the hospital/janitorial brand stuff. It's reasonably cheap, and because it's a Simple Green brand, it's probably orderable at many local hardware stores or the big box chains like Lowes or Home Depot.

    Update?edit: The Pesticide Action Network site I link to above is pretty interesting. Not because I'm overly worried about the chemicals themselves in properly diluted form, but because the site seemingly cross-references the different brands pretty well. For example, I'm shocked above about the 61 brand names the "Maquat" product is distributed under. But it turns out Hepastat 256 is distributed under 139 names, and the Lysol 256 I mention above is seen under a massive 401 names, including Virex 256, a product that's been mention on this thread before.

    Lysol 256 at PAN

    Hepastat 256 at PAN

    Needless to say, that's a whole lot of branding for just a few product formulations. This should open some doors for folks who can't find a product locally. The product may not be there, but the formulation may be available anyway -- just hiding under a different name!
 
Last edited:
In my hunt for Hepastat 256, I ran across a few more potential options.
Good info! Yes, there are hundreds of options. I like to use the ones with higher % levels of quats so that when we dilute them out, there is less of the non-quat components and the pH drops more towards neutral (some of these like the simple green are quite basic in pH). My understanding is that the bulk formulations are all made in China and companies buy and repackage with their own dyes, labels and bottling. Pretty standard practice nowadays. One gallon will last a lifetime so choose carefully!
 
Follow up question (and hopefully my last). Are all of these quats? And if so, are any of them better quats (or formulations) than the others? Or is it a toss up when you're looking at the 256 concentrations?
Hepastat 256 and the Maquat-made 256 solution contain very similar concentrations of the same active ingredients and some other differences. Lysol IC has fewer of these (quat?) ingredients at higher percentages, but I don't know if that means it has fewer quats and more junk or just less junk ;-) Or maybe it doesn't matter? At any rate if you wanna peak at these MSDS screen caps and give a thumbs up or down on them I'd be appreciative.

index.php


index.php


index.php
 
Any thoughts on adding a quat product (Hepastat 256) to the Spin Clean formula for use in the SC?
Should work fine, just keep the concentration low..maybe a 1:1000 - 1:2000 dilution so as not to disrupt the flocculant. Spin clean has mentioned issues with static using their system (on their website FAQ) so I think it would be a good add. Static issues seem to always arise when an anionic detergent wash is followed by a towel dry.
 
Follow up question (and hopefully my last). Are all of these quats? And if so, are any of them better quats (or formulations) than the others? Or is it a toss up when you're looking at the 256 concentrations?

Yes, those are all quaternary ammonium compounds. They differ with respect to their carbon chain "tails", but they all have a quat ammonium head group. I have not experimented with all of these particular quats individually so cannot comment on their comparative activities, but if a solution only has one or two of them it should work equally well if the goal is merely for use as an antistat. I have made solutions of just the Didecyl dimethyl ammonium chloride and they work fine. Earlier posts described the use of just Behentrimonium chloride as well. The only reason the 256 mixes were brought up is because they are MUCH easier to obtain for the average person as a source of quat surfactant.
The Marquat product looks intriguing, and superior to Hepastat if you choose the one with the non-ionic surfactant and no amine oxide. I don't like the NaOH in the Lysol. No wonder it has such high pH. And with the cyclic terpene, I would avoid it.
 
Last edited:
Yes, those are all quaternary ammonium compounds. They differ with respect to their carbon chain "tails", but they all have a quat ammonium head group. I have not experimented with all of these particular quats individually so cannot comment on their comparative activities, but if a solution only has one or two of them it should work equally well if the goal is merely for use as an antistat...

<snip> The Marquat product looks intriguing, and superior to Hepastat if you choose the one with the non-ionic surfactant and no amine oxide. I don't like the NaOH in the Lysol. No wonder it has such high pH. And with the cyclic terpene, I would avoid it.

Excellent. Of course, finding the the one with the no amine oxide is probably trick since they may not specify this either/or on the generic label. So unless I'm guaranteed the no-amine oxide version, it sounds like the Hepastat is the safer bet. As for the Lysol 256 -- that's good to know. According to the PAN site, it's supposedly the same make up as Virex 256 which has been listed here before as a potential product.

Thanks again!
 
Just a heads up, Lysol is really pushing their "Laundry Sanitizer" product (just saw another ad for it in fact). It consists of quats of course, most of the ones found in the 256 formulations, only it is diluted down to 2.5% quats. I haven't used it on records, nor would I buy it, as the 256 stuff at 10X higher quat is a much better value and I don't know what is in the the other 97.5% (mostly water, but what else? Surely perfumes as they come in flavors like "crisp linen"). Anyways, these bleach substitutes are really taking off now for home use. They claim it removes 99.9% of bacteria and many suggest its use with fabric softener. Clever marketing but we know fabric softener is also quat-based so they are trying to double sell folks.
Another use for all that excess 256 product I guess, if you find yourself in that situation.
 
Last edited:
Hi guys. New to the thread, vinyl cleaning, and analog in general. Well, "new" in the sense I've been carting records around with me since I was a teenager in the 80s but haven't owned a TT until last month. :crazy:

I'm looking at sources for Triton X-100, and I notice several sources identify the grade of X-100, but I've neither seen a recommended grade mentioned in vinyl cleaning threads nor have I found a listing of the grades of X-100 (apparently grades vary by chemical).

Can one of our chemist friends here explain the grades of X-100, which is the minimum grade recommended for vinyl cleaning, and whether there is any benefit to using a higher grade?

Many thanks!
hc
 
While not a chemist, the "grade" of Triton is relatively unimportant or even meaningless IMHO. The only time the grade would be important is in a solution that won't be rinsed off such as an alcohol based fluid. If you mix a decent grade surfactant in a liter of good quality water it will only be a ml in volume of which the vast majority will be 100% Triton or whatever you choose to use. I mix my surfactant and reagent grade IPA into reagent grade water from Amazon or Ebay. The if rinsed off with the same reagent grade water you will be left with a VERY clean record. Talas Online has the Triton X-100 although I ordered it through Amazon. Give them a call.
 
Hi guys. New to the thread, vinyl cleaning, and analog in general. Well, "new" in the sense I've been carting records around with me since I was a teenager in the 80s but haven't owned a TT until last month. :crazy:

I'm looking at sources for Triton X-100, and I notice several sources identify the grade of X-100, but I've neither seen a recommended grade mentioned in vinyl cleaning threads nor have I found a listing of the grades of X-100 (apparently grades vary by chemical).

Can one of our chemist friends here explain the grades of X-100, which is the minimum grade recommended for vinyl cleaning, and whether there is any benefit to using a higher grade?

Many thanks!
hc
If you go to post #70 you will see an explanation of what grades there are and the purpose of these grades.
 
I was able to buy 32oz of Virex II 256 from Amazon and for about $25 including shipping. I suspect this is a lifetime supply for record cleaning. We tried out the Hepastat 256 for household cleaning and it worked well so we'll also use the Virex II to clean bathrooms, floors, etc. 32 oz of that stuff will make 64 gallons of 256:1 cleaner! I'm also misting a very dilute (2000:1 or so) solution of Hepastat on my record brush before each play and on the turntable mat when I get some static. Seems to work well in this application too.
Let us know how the Virex works for you. Looks like between 10-20% quat in that concentrate.

So, how does the Virex II perform compared to the Hepastat 256 that I think you also tried? Any difference between the two for records (or household cleaning for that matter -- lord knows we'll have enough of it to spread around!). Now that I've started looking I'm finding these quats everywhere and instead of reinventing the wheel, I think I'm just going to grab the Virex II or Hepastat and call it done!
 
So, how does the Virex II perform compared to the Hepastat 256 that I think you also tried? Any difference between the two for records (or household cleaning for that matter -- lord knows we'll have enough of it to spread around!). Now that I've started looking I'm finding these quats everywhere and instead of reinventing the wheel, I think I'm just going to grab the Virex II or Hepastat and call it done!

I can't say there is any difference between the Hepastat and the Virex II for record cleaning. Both help with static for the first three or four plays then it seems the action of removing and inserting the record into the sleeve (MFSL in my case) causes some static. I still mist my velvet/carbon fiber brush with a really weak dilution of Hepastat and distilled water before each play and it is surprising how much dust is on the brush after about 10 clean records. We are using our AC now so maybe that accounts for the dust on the records. The misted brush takes care of static on the record for that one play.

The Virex II smells a little nicer to me than the Hepastat but neither are objectionable. We took a Hepastat mix in a spray bottle on board a cruise ship to clean up surfaces in our cabin but we still both got sick so I can't say if it helped or not. Maybe the lesson learned is I'm not all that thrilled with traveling by cruise ship given how easy it is to transmit "bugs" in confined quarters. These quat cleaners do a good job controlling mold/mildew in the shower. Just spray it on and let it soak for a bit, scrub lightly, then rinse. I don't use the Virex as a primary cleaner but a supplement on commonly touched surfaces when one of us has a cold or other ailment. I have a lifetime supply to be sure.
 
I can't say there is any difference between the Hepastat and the Virex II for record cleaning. Both help with static for the first three or four plays then it seems the action of removing and inserting the record into the sleeve (MFSL in my case) causes some static. I still mist my velvet/carbon fiber brush with a really weak dilution of Hepastat and distilled water before each play and it is surprising how much dust is on the brush after about 10 clean records. We are using our AC now so maybe that accounts for the dust on the records. The misted brush takes care of static on the record for that one play.

The Virex II smells a little nicer to me than the Hepastat but neither are objectionable. We took a Hepastat mix in a spray bottle on board a cruise ship to clean up surfaces in our cabin but we still both got sick so I can't say if it helped or not. Maybe the lesson learned is I'm not all that thrilled with traveling by cruise ship given how easy it is to transmit "bugs" in confined quarters. These quat cleaners do a good job controlling mold/mildew in the shower. Just spray it on and let it soak for a bit, scrub lightly, then rinse. I don't use the Virex as a primary cleaner but a supplement on commonly touched surfaces when one of us has a cold or other ailment. I have a lifetime supply to be sure.

Great info, thanks. It sounds like whichever is cheaper/easier to obtain is the way to go. 2qts of Hepastat is about $26 shipped w/tax; 3 quarts of Virex II is about $29. Sounds like either is going to work fine and while the Virastat is cheaper per ounce, do I really need that extra quart? I pick one out of the hat and move on to actually cleaning the records!

PS - sorry about getting sick on the cruise. Ick.
 
This is an embarrassingly stupid question, but before I start mixing I need to ask. Following the recipes found on AK and other sources, I intend to include Hepastat at 0.10%. As Hepastat comes in a concentrated form (.5 oz makes 1 gallon), is the volume of Hepastat required for the record cleaning solution straight from the concentrate, or after it has been diluted?

FYI - the cleaning solution (Hepastat, Terg 3&9, iso alcohol, and distilled h2o) will be used in a 40kHz ultrasonic machine.

Thank you. This thread is a terrific source of info.
 
This is an embarrassingly stupid question, but before I start mixing I need to ask. Following the recipes found on AK and other sources, I intend to include Hepastat at 0.10%. As Hepastat comes in a concentrated form (.5 oz makes 1 gallon), is the volume of Hepastat required for the record cleaning solution straight from the concentrate, or after it has been diluted?

So the standard concentrate is 21.7% Quat (I say "standard" as they also sell so ready to use preparations at a lower concentration). So to get to 0.1%, you need to do a 1:217 dilution, which is about 4.6 mls per liter. I think this is strong IMHO, particularly for US cleaning (even for household cleaning you do a 1:256 dilution). I like doing a 1:2000 dilution so you end up about 0.01% and include a non-ionic detergent (e.g. Triton X100) at 0.05 to 0.1%.
 
I can't say there is any difference between the Hepastat and the Virex II for record cleaning. Both help with static for the first three or four plays then it seems the action of removing and inserting the record into the sleeve (MFSL in my case) causes some static.

This is very interesting. I wonder if there is some static being generated by your system or environment? I say this because I have not generally experienced this. When I first experimented with quats back in the early 1990's, one of the albums I treated was Mozart Symphonies Nos. 25,26,&27 with James Levine on Deutsche Gramophone (purchased new). Back then I was using Cyastat 609 as the quat antistat based on RCA's patent (US3960790). This album became one of several I have used over the years to test my systems anytime something is added, removed, or a new cart is set-up as it has both highly dynamic and very quiet passages and I know every note by heart. Hence it has been played many dozens of times (it's actually one I've been able to document groove wear as I have a 2-track 15 IPS tape copy of it I made in 1996). It has only received that one initial quat treatment in it's lifetime, yet I never have been able to measure any static charge on it's surface. I would bet any quat in the grooves has long since been worn away, but the grooves are only a percent of the surface area so I'm thinking there is enough charge around to maintain a conductive environment. Every time I get an album that appears to have static issues, the sleeve is problematic. I too, use a lot of Mofi sleeves and on occasions have detected static on new bags of them, but this is not typical. So I don't think the quat only lasts for a few plays...rather, I believe there is excess charge being introduced in some way in what you are describing. Maybe try using higher % quat or treat the sleeves and playing surface as a test? It's a mystery though as I have heard this before from others. Some have reported static generation by their idler turntables. I really can't wrap my brain around how this can be, but observations speak for themselves. I guess there will be situations where a single treatment is enough and others where frequent treatments are required. I sure would like to know how static is continuously being produced in the latter case.
 
Last edited:
This is very interesting. I wonder if there is some static being generated by your system or environment? I say this because I have not generally experienced this.....I sure would like to know how static is continuously being produced in the latter case.

Me too! While I'm not exactly sure what effect static charge would have on the sound of record when played it certainly is annoying to have the static. I do notice the static when I lift the record off the turntable (most recently a Technics SP-25 but also my AR XB with a deer hide mat) so the idea the "system" is generating the static might be a place to look. I am certainly open to suggestions!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom