• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not sure where I read this but I thought 80K was more likely to cause cavitation o vinyl, especially some of the softer formulations.
My understanding is that higher frequencies produce smaller bubbles which implode with less force, therefore are safer. 40kHz is a sort of GP frequency that is high enough to do the job safely but low enough to produce cheaper transducers.
 
As to using US running @ 80 I thought the subject was put to rest regarding damage occurring on records.

Is any of this ever really put to rest?

When I referred to "cavitation" I meant cavitation of the vinyl as in leaving pocks, I understand that cavitation is also the process of "breaking" the water to deep clean.

I guess it is and always will be a YMMV thing. I used a ton of trial and error before I landed where I did, forgoing automation for better cleaning results. Yes, I do a lot more manual labor but have seen (heard) LPs take several steps in the correct direction via this process.
 
I'm trying to gather the ingredients for the reg Williamson peel and does anyone know a source for Cyastat SN ?
Elvanol is on chemical store and everything else is amazon just can't find Cyastat SN
The Cyastat SN is just a quat surfactant (Stearamidopropyldimethyl-2-hydroxyethylammonium nitrate). We've discussed many of it's relatives in this thread that you can substitute. I've made hundreds of these PVA masks playing around with many different formulations and can say they just don't produce the results I am after.
 
I also use Rushton's formula. I have added an Enzyme step before US cleaning. I spray the Enzyme solution on the record, or get a fabric brush really wet, and use a lint and a bristle brush to scrub the record for about one minute. I think adding this mechanical scrubbing action to help loosen stuff in the grooves before US cleaning is a good thing. For Enzyme solution, I just switched to using a home made solution that I read about in a post. The solution is very simple: just mix the contents of one Nexazyme with one liter of water. You can get Nexazyme at Pharmacies or on Amazon.

The Nexazyme protocol was discussed early in this thread, post 61, but the link page was taken down. Anyways, it works well, just be sure to empty and discard the sticky capsule. Also, never let the solution dry on the record surface during incubation (which should be more like 15 min).
 
The Cyastat SN is just a quat surfactant (Stearamidopropyldimethyl-2-hydroxyethylammonium nitrate). We've discussed many of it's relatives in this thread that you can substitute. I've made hundreds of these PVA masks playing around with many different formulations and can say they just don't produce the results I am after.

thanks, i did use search for cyastat and most of the info i found was from a few years ago. i'll did through this specific thread some more.
 
The Nexazyme protocol was discussed early in this thread, post 61, but the link page was taken down. Anyways, it works well, just be sure to empty and discard the sticky capsule. Also, never let the solution dry on the record surface during incubation (which should be more like 15 min).

Thank you for the information PR. And for all your contributions to this thread.

I'd like to confirm that the contents of one capsule of Nexazyme in 1 Liter of RODI water (or better) is the correct ratio.

In the future, I'd like to find a liquid concentrate of pure enzymes instead of breaking apart capsules. Many enzyme cleaners contain other surfactants, detergents, alcohols, glycol, etc. which I'd like to avoid. Any thoughts on sources?

I've read that enzyme cleaners are most effective at slightly elevated temperatures like 98 Deg F. I'm planning on making a temperature controlled soaking tank as a pre-clean step.
 
I guess one question is if Nexazyme needs to be applied as a separate step (I actually use a brush to scrub during enzyme treatment), or can Nexazyme simply be added to the ultrasonic tank solution during the general cleaning process.
 
I am sure this has been discussed but finding it... I am thinking about getting one of the following ultrasonic cleaners to replace the super cheap $100 one I bought. Can anyone who knows anything about it let me know if these are good choices.

Sonix4 Mechanical Ultrasonic Cleaner (vs the digital) - https://www.sonix4.com/product-page/ultrasonic-cleaner-1-1-2-gallons-6-5l-with-heat-st136h

Trusonic - http://www.ebay.com/itm/New-Stainle...e=STRK:MEBIDX:IT&_trksid=p2055119.m1438.l2649

Thank you for any input!
 
I'd like to confirm that the contents of one capsule of Nexazyme in 1 Liter of RODI water (or better) is the correct ratio.In the future, I'd like to find a liquid concentrate of pure enzymes instead of breaking apart capsules. Many enzyme cleaners contain other surfactants, detergents, alcohols, glycol, etc. which I'd like to avoid. Any thoughts on sources?
I've read that enzyme cleaners are most effective at slightly elevated temperatures like 98 Deg F. I'm planning on making a temperature controlled soaking tank as a pre-clean step.
Yes, for convenience this works, but it is overkill and you can get by with one capsule powder per 5 liters, particularly when using at elevated temperatures where, as you have found, activity/efficiency is greater. Also, I use in tap water or specific buffer solutions, not distilled/de-ionized as the enzymes require ions for catalysis and stability. I haven't looked for pure liquid sources, but I have used Sporacidin and found the lipase and amylase activities to be very low in that mix. I assume this is because they aren't present in sufficient quantities and the protease (typically papain or pepsin) is quite active in solution and is digesting them. In any event, this is why I choose to stick with powered (dry) enzyme mixes. In the lab, we keep pure enzymes in solution in the fridge or freezer where activity is low and I would recommend only buying liquid enzymatic solutions that are stored this way.

I guess one question is if Nexazyme needs to be applied as a separate step (I actually use a brush to scrub during enzyme treatment), or can Nexazyme simply be added to the ultrasonic tank solution during the general cleaning process.
This is an interesting question. The short answer is yes, as some of the same enzymes (e.g. Papain protease) are used in laundry and other household cleaning solutions where they work in a detergent mixture. The long answer involves levels of activity in a situation where pH is not optimized and salts (ions) required for activity and stability are lacking (since tank solutions are typically made with DI water). Furthermore, I would suspect some denaturation of enzymes (killing their activity) in a solution of cavitation bubbles, but I have never looked into this. Maybe give it a try and see what happens?
 
Last edited:
Yes, for convenience this works, but it is overkill and you can get by with one capsule powder per 5 liters, particularly when using at elevated temperatures where, as you have found, activity/efficiency is greater. Also, I use in tap water or specific buffer solutions, not distilled/de-ionized as the enzymes require ions for catalysis and stability. I haven't looked for pure liquid sources, but I have used Sporacidin and found the lipase and amylase activities to be very low in that mix. I assume this is because they aren't present in sufficient quantities and the protease (typically papain or pepsin) is quite active in solution and is digesting them. In any event, this is why I choose to stick with powered (dry) enzyme mixes. In the lab, we keep pure enzymes in solution in the fridge or freezer where activity is low and I would recommend only buying liquid enzymatic solutions that are stored this way.


This is an interesting question. The short answer is yes, as some of the same enzymes (e.g. Papain protease) are used in laundry and other household cleaning solutions where they work in a detergent mixture. The long answer involves levels of activity in a situation where pH is not optimized and salts (ions) required for activity and stability are lacking (since tank solutions are typically made with DI water). Furthermore, I would suspect some denaturation of enzymes (killing their activity) in a solution of cavitation bubbles, but I have never looked into this. Maybe give it a try and see what happens?

Hello Phantomrebel
Thank you for clarifying ion requirement for enzyme solution. Unfortunately, I have cleaned many records using DI water with Nexazyme, already. Our tap water here is very hard. Do you see a problem using hard water to make enzyme solution? Would there be a problem scrubbing the record while using hard water enzyme solution, due to the minerals and other stuff in the water? Of course, I rinse again with DI water after enzyme application.
 
Hello Phantomrebel
Thank you for clarifying ion requirement for enzyme solution. Unfortunately, I have cleaned many records using DI water with Nexazyme, already. Our tap water here is very hard. Do you see a problem using hard water to make enzyme solution? Would there be a problem scrubbing the record while using hard water enzyme solution, due to the minerals and other stuff in the water? Of course, I rinse again with DI water after enzyme application.
Using distilled water is not a huge deal if you are using an enzyme mix like Nexazyme as this contains a variety of each enzyme type (six different proteases, for example) that have a range of pH optimums and ionic requirements. Some work fine in dH2O, others need a little Mg2+, etc. 100% activity is not essential, but you don't want alkaline pH and no ions around as a good number of the enzymes aren't active under those conditions. I would never use very hard water or highly chlorinated water straight from the tap on records. Always charcoal filter or use bottled.
 
Using distilled water is not a huge deal if you are using an enzyme mix like Nexazyme as this contains a variety of each enzyme type (six different proteases, for example) that have a range of pH optimums and ionic requirements. Some work fine in dH2O, others need a little Mg2+, etc. 100% activity is not essential, but you don't want alkaline pH and no ions around as a good number of the enzymes aren't active under those conditions. I would never use very hard water or highly chlorinated water straight from the tap on records. Always charcoal filter or use bottled.

Thanks. When you say bottled water, do you mean bottled drinking (not distilled) water?
 
Hey, I am new to the vinyl world, been reading and researching about this topic, but so much stuff, i just get confused on which way to go. I wish i could afford a machine but can not.

Can someone please list the EXACT materials needed to do the process about that the historical records uses, I will use that one.

Also, I might spend $30 for the vinyl vac? Or just make it?

Will also get microfiber towels, an audioquest brush, and another soft brush for cleaning.

Would like a nice tidy list of what i need, doin it as cheap as possible. I do think its smarter to go this way than the spin clean way?
 
Can I just throw something in here, in my experience it doesn't matter what you do to clean your records, if you can't get every last little bit of your cleaning solution off your records before it dries on then it's never going to be a completely effective process, (on the basis that any residue that's left is by definition not only going to contain whatever dissolved ingredients the solution originally contained but also any dirt the cleaning process has picked up).
 
Can I just throw something in here, in my experience it doesn't matter what you do to clean your records, if you can't get every last little bit of your cleaning solution off your records before it dries on then it's never going to be a completely effective process, (on the basis that any residue that's left is by definition not only going to contain whatever dissolved ingredients the solution originally contained but also any dirt the cleaning process has picked up).
Partially true, which is why the dH2O rinse is critical. That said, it is impossible to avoid the fact that a molecular layer of detergent remains on the record surface, regardless of the extent of rinsing (unless you rinse with something non-polar). Which is why the choice of detergent actually does matter.
 
Thanks. When you say bottled water, do you mean bottled drinking (not distilled) water?
Either charcoal filtered tap or bottled spring water. Not critical, but certainly better than distilled for optimal enzymatic activity (given the short incubation times and the sub-optimal temperature and pHs typically employed in record cleaning protocols).
 
Can someone please list the EXACT materials needed to do the process about that the historical records uses, I will use that one.

Many seem to be based on the formula here:

http://cool.conservation-us.org/byauth/st-laurent/care.html

  • The Canadian Conservation Institute (CCI) recommends the use of nonionic, ethelyne oxide condensates surfactants to clean sound recordings. The CCI does not foresee long-term problems associated with the use of nonionic surfactants such as Tergitol. Tergitol 15-S-3 is an oil soluble surfactant and 15-S-9 is a water soluble surfactant. Combined they remove a wide range of dirt and greases and can safely be used on sound recordings. Use 0.25 part of Tergitol 15-S-3 and 0.25 parts of Tergitol 15-S-9 per 100 parts of distilled water. (These products are available in small quantities from TALAS (Division of Technical Library Service Inc) 213 West 35th Street, New York, N.Y. (212) 465-8722.) The recording must then be rinsed thoroughly with distilled water to eliminate any trace of detergent residue.
This mix works with non ultrasonic methods in which the fluid is applied with a brush, allowed to soak a bit and then rinsed completely from the vinyl record. Several folks substitute Triton x-100 for the Tergitols because the Triton is easier to source.

Hope this helps...
 
Has anyone looked at the DOW Ecosurf line of products as a substitute for Triton or Tergitol? TALAS sells the ecosurf EH-3 product and it looks interesting. I'm not a chemist, though.
Thanks.
Tom Connell
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom