Never used a Red Ed but I have used many AT3600s. The cart body is very good, the stylus as delivered from AT is a conical. This can be good or bad depending on your perspective. I like that cartridge very much for casual listening and for 45 single listening. The replacement conical stylus is very inexpensive. There are some companies making elliptical and even Shibata styli for these so depending on what you want the cartridge is capable of a lot more than it would first appear. If that were mine I would get a new genuine ATN3600L stylus for it and try it out. You may like it.