• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

I personally would never even attempt to build a system that could approximate the experience of live concert organ performance. I'm speaking for myself, and not judging anyone that has attempted this or has plans to do so. For me, there can be no substitution for the real thing. Hearing and feeling an actual pipe organ is a visceral experience. You are hearing the actual instrument - overtones, harmonics, sub harmonics..... There is nothing quite like it
 
I personally would never even attempt to build a system that could approximate the experience of live concert organ performance. I'm speaking for myself, and not judging anyone that has attempted this or has plans to do so. For me, there can be no substitution for the real thing. Hearing and feeling an actual pipe organ is a visceral experience. You are hearing the actual instrument - overtones, harmonics, sub harmonics..... There is nothing quite like it
You are absolutely correct it is all
But impossible to mic’ a pipe organ to get that over powering sound. All you can do is try.

Think about this the first “Church” Organs appeared in the 12th century. In the 12th century there were not many “loud” sounds in a persons environment. Bring a person from that time forward to the present and they would go insane with the average noise level we have today. A church organ was the loudest sound the average person would have heard outside of environmental sounds back all of those centuries ago. To them a Church Organ was the voice of God thundering to them.
 
I personally would never even attempt to build a system that could approximate the experience of live concert organ performance. I'm speaking for myself, and not judging anyone that has attempted this or has plans to do so. For me, there can be no substitution for the real thing. Hearing and feeling an actual pipe organ is a visceral experience. You are hearing the actual instrument - overtones, harmonics, sub harmonics..... There is nothing quite like it
The link I provided comes very close to the real thing if you have a system that can reproduce it. There are two very large pipe organs in Portland, ME that I have heard, so I do know what they should sound like.
 
So I just started work on a pair of Rosedales which appear to be a very close relative of the W70E. All of the speakers are in pristine condition which includes the purple dome tweeters. Access is through the back, and the crossovers was scewed to the back. I pulled the crossover out and measured all the caps, and also measured the one inductor that was unmarked and made a schematic. This model has a simpler crossover that has no LPads, just a fixed 3.3 ohm resistor in the tweeter path. The woofer has a 4.0 mH inductor in series to roll off high end at 6 db/octave. Everything makes sense EXCEPT the phase of the woofer appears to be reversed!? I'm not sure if this was a mistake or if they did this intensionally. I am going to investigate further to see if perhaps they soldered the wrong color wires onto the woofer (I'll perform a battery test to determine the posive connection). One thing I know for sure, if these were intentionally out of phase that aren't going to stay that way. I want to run these with my W70Es, and they have to be in phase with them so they don't null out the bass. I'll post pictures of this restoration as I get further along.


the woofer came inverted from the factory, my rosedale came that way too.
 
Which begs the question....why!? I don't think they did this on the W70Es

I don't know why ... but if I can tell you the differences I could notice in the sound when he pushed air in or when he pushed out (I tried both polarities) ..... with the polarity reversed the bass response it is less present, the bass sounds a little tighter and the resonance decreases .... with the correct polarity the opposite effect occurs, the bass becomes more present, more resonant and also reaches higher in the frequencies (for example the sound from a box of drums is heard louder) .... a similar effect occurs when you compare a woofer in a reflex box with a sealed box .... a question, your w70E and Rosedale woofers have a square magnet or circular magnet ? Do they have rubber or cloth suspension?
 
I don't know why ... but if I can tell you the differences I could notice in the sound when he pushed air in or when he pushed out (I tried both polarities) ..... with the polarity reversed the bass response it is less present, the bass sounds a little tighter and the resonance decreases .... with the correct polarity the opposite effect occurs, the bass becomes more present, more resonant and also reaches higher in the frequencies (for example the sound from a box of drums is heard louder) .... a similar effect occurs when you compare a woofer in a reflex box with a sealed box .... a question, your w70E and Rosedale woofers have a square magnet or circular magnet ? Do they have rubber or cloth suspension?

Sorry for my English translated from Google, I'm from Chile.
 
I don't know why ... but if I can tell you the differences I could notice in the sound when he pushed air in or when he pushed out (I tried both polarities) ..... with the polarity reversed the bass response it is less present, the bass sounds a little tighter and the resonance decreases .... with the correct polarity the opposite effect occurs, the bass becomes more present, more resonant and also reaches higher in the frequencies (for example the sound from a box of drums is heard louder) .... a similar effect occurs when you compare a woofer in a reflex box with a sealed box .... a question, your w70E and Rosedale woofers have a square magnet or circular magnet ? Do they have rubber or cloth suspension?
Square and rubber - same drivers. My personal guess as to why they did this was to make the overall frequency response flatter with fewer crossover components. They didn't use a 3rd order Butterworth filter on the mid range or the woofer and it's crossed over at around 900Hz on the low side which overlaps the woofer's high end response - so by reversing the phase on the woofer they roll off the high end response of the woofer by bucking it with the mid thus creating a 'fake' 12 db/octave roll off for both. This works in theory as long as you don't have another set of speakers next to them operating in phase.
 
Square and rubber - same drivers. My personal guess as to why they did this was to make the overall frequency response flatter with fewer crossover components. They didn't use a 3rd order Butterworth filter on the mid range or the woofer and it's crossed over at around 900Hz on the low side which overlaps the woofer's high end response - so by reversing the phase on the woofer they roll off the high end response of the woofer by bucking it with the mid thus creating a 'fake' 12 db/octave roll off for both. This works in theory as long as you don't have another set of speakers next to them operating in phase.

Interesting your thinking. Have you ever tried woofer with circular magnet and cloth hanger? Those work between 10-15 ohms ..... I have a couple of those, I consider that they have a higher capacity than the square magnet woofer .... the supension is much softer, and the magnet is much heavier. It's bass sound is more detailed and less resonant.
 
gents. i'm going to start chunking my way through this thread. noob status here but studying up as quick as i can.

any info on fixing a wharfedale w60d mark II's "purple jellyfish" tweeter? one of mine does not appear to be working.

found this thread previously: https://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/refurbishing-wharfedale-w60d-mark-iis.702652/

is taking apart this pair of speakers straightforward? any threads on cleaning the potentiometers (?) and whatever else might be needed in here?

THANKS

<edit: links here:
http://audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=139198&highlight=W90
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=305872
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=152351 >
 

Attachments

  • 32985826-8659-4DE1-9CB1-A68058D7606D.jpeg
    32985826-8659-4DE1-9CB1-A68058D7606D.jpeg
    50 KB · Views: 14
  • 804AAA4A-2B9E-49C4-A48B-47B28DEDEBF6.jpeg
    804AAA4A-2B9E-49C4-A48B-47B28DEDEBF6.jpeg
    38.1 KB · Views: 11
  • C2986655-777E-4F4D-BC05-F71032B5BB30.jpeg
    C2986655-777E-4F4D-BC05-F71032B5BB30.jpeg
    74.5 KB · Views: 11
  • A06841BF-FBB4-442C-A365-14C4529AFD85.jpeg
    A06841BF-FBB4-442C-A365-14C4529AFD85.jpeg
    130.4 KB · Views: 12
Last edited:
gents. i'm going to start chunking my way through this thread. noob status here but studying up as quick as i can.
Good idea to read through entire thread as there's a lot of good info to be had. You can probably find a replacement tweeter on ePay as they show up from time to time. If all else fails, there's a company in Australia that sells replacement diaphragms to rebuild them.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom