• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

if you push a little on the grill frame there on the bottom of the 12" driver hole, does the grill frame bend away from the box a little, or does it stay firm against it? If it does bend away I'm inclined to say they're velcro and just find a wide flat putty knife or somethin and try prying a corner
 
Well there are two options. One you won't like. My W70C's are Velcro, and if they haven't been taken off in a long time they do stick pretty hard.
the other is they're glued on the front and not meant to be taken off...hard to tell from your pic of the back side, but it does almost look like there are glue residue marks where the fiberboard frame meets the cloth grill. That said, it would mean the bolts for the driver would also have to be glued solid, because it would be impossible to service the speaker if they came loose...those are almost certainly flat head wood screw machine bolts.
If I'm not wrong the Rosedales are the W70E's in America and I think @infullview has a pair and might be able to tell you.

And you aren't kidding, that's a nice looking pair!
Thanks! I am pretty pleased with them. I won't tell you what I paid, but it wasn't much. It was a risk though, I bought them long distance unseen so I wasn't risking much in case they were dud, but no. All working as they should. It will be just a check over and new caps. And I might have the adventure of porting them as originally planned. They are seriously nice sounding, immensely rich, but I can tell there's something amiss, probably leaky caps.
 
I've solved the riddle, they were pinned on! Ive had this before with dovedales. Four lost-head 3/4 inch pins. They gave in eventually. Thanks for your help everyone!
 
Help! I have started to service my newly acquired Rosedales, and I'm struggling to get the front grill off! The woofer is rear mounted, but the other drivers are mounted from the front so it surely must come off. The grill seems welded in place, is it on velcro? I can easily move it in the centre of the bottom edge from inside, but the corners are not giving and the grill is only thin mdf, I dont want to break them, they are in beautiful condition. How are they attached?View attachment 2675403 View attachment 2675404 View attachment 2675405
I own Rosedale and the grills are attached with long finish nails. Use a thin knife and slide it down the side of the grill, then slowly pry up on the nails. Once you get the grill off, remove the nails out of the newly removed grill and replace with Velcro
 
I own Rosedale and the grills are attached with long finish nails. Use a thin knife and slide it down the side of the grill, then slowly pry up on the nails. Once you get the grill off, remove the nails out of the newly removed grill and replace with Velcro
You are absolutely right infullview. I have seen this on Wharfedales before, but due to the grill being rebated it is very difficult to see how they thought this was an appropriate way to affix the grills. You cannot get anything down behind the edge without damaging the woodwork. At first I thought they were screwed from behind like the earlier W2's and Early Dovedales, until I removed the back. The only really safe way I can see of removing a pinned grill in this situation is to remove the bass driver as I did.

I was reading Gilbert's 'Loudspeakers' book again last night and saw an interesting passage on longevity. He was saying that they will usually improve with use as the fundamental freq. reduces as things loosen up, and a speaker in really good conditions, kept dry and not abused might last as long as 10-15 years! How surprised he might be if he knew ours were still making people smile 55-60 years later! Just amazing.
 
So back to my very original question. These Rosedales are not ported. I personally much prefer the extended low end of ported cabs, and am considering experimenting with these. Does anyone know if there are any constructional differences between the 15" drivers specifically of this period (1967-1970 ish) with rubber surrounds used on ported cabinets, and those of the same period used in sealed cabinets. I can see from historic pictures that the early Rosedales and w/70's were ported, then the design changed to sealed. I summise this was to up the power handling capacity, but my reading tells me that the damping effect of the sealed cab meant the driver could be more compliant and such a driver would not survive in a ported cab due to excessive cone excursion. However, I can see no observable difference in them, and the compliance seems the same as drivers taken from ported examples. I do have some drivers from Wharfedales of a later period (late 70's) from sealed cabs, and the build is lighter and magnets smaller, but rated power is higher, with a caveat not to use them in unported cabs. Perhaps the company thought they could save money on later designs by taking advantage of the damping effect of sealed cabs, but early ones were not changed?
 
Last edited:
You are absolutely right infullview. I have seen this on Wharfedales before, but due to the grill being rebated it is very difficult to see how they thought this was an appropriate way to affix the grills. You cannot get anything down behind the edge without damaging the woodwork. At first I thought they were screwed from behind like the earlier W2's and Early Dovedales, until I removed the back. The only really safe way I can see of removing a pinned grill in this situation is to remove the bass driver as I did.

I was reading Gilbert's 'Loudspeakers' book again last night and saw an interesting passage on longevity. He was saying that they will usually improve with use as the fundamental freq. reduces as things loosen up, and a speaker in really good conditions, kept dry and not abused might last as long as 10-15 years! How surprised he might be if he knew ours were still making people smile 55-60 years later! Just amazing.

It is very interesting to compare the condition of AR speakers of c.1966, and Wharfedales of the same time. Even if reasonably well cared for the AR need work on the woofers. With Wharfedales of the same period it was the purple sunny side up tweeter that was problematic. Both marque’s crossovers need attention. The woofer is much more of an issue than the other drivers in a multi-driver system. The purple dome tweeter in the W40, W60C/D, and W70D have modern replacements, but not-so-woofers. The AR-branded Woofers have several outfits that can completely refurbish them, not so Wharfedales fortunately they have stood the test of time.
 
You are absolutely right infullview. I have seen this on Wharfedales before, but due to the grill being rebated it is very difficult to see how they thought this was an appropriate way to affix the grills. You cannot get anything down behind the edge without damaging the woodwork. At first I thought they were screwed from behind like the earlier W2's and Early Dovedales, until I removed the back. The only really safe way I can see of removing a pinned grill in this situation is to remove the bass driver as I did.

I was reading Gilbert's 'Loudspeakers' book again last night and saw an interesting passage on longevity. He was saying that they will usually improve with use as the fundamental freq. reduces as things loosen up, and a speaker in really good conditions, kept dry and not abused might last as long as 10-15 years! How surprised he might be if he knew ours were still making people smile 55-60 years later! Just amazing.
The trick to getting the grill off with a thin bladed knife is all about using surface area to your advantage. Slide the think knife between the fabric and the rabbit, then twist it to catch the edge of the cloth. Wedge another knife to preserve the progress you've made as you go until you have enough of the grill lifted to safely pry up with more force. I did this with my Rosedales and it didn't make any marks on the wood or hurt the grill.

I agree that it's amazing how well these speakers sound after all these years. BTW my x-wife thought the Rosedales sounded better than the W70E's. She could be right as the Rosedales have the original tweeters. Personally I like the W70e's because they have more interior volume for the woofer and a lower resonance point. Same cabinet but front mounted and they cut the size of the box on the mid in half witch adds a bit more space.
 
So back to my very original question. These Rosedales are not ported. I personally much prefer the extended low end of ported cabs, and am considering experimenting with these. Does anyone know if there are any constructional differences between the 15" drivers specifically of this period (1967-1970 ish) with rubber surrounds used on ported cabinets, and those of the same period used in sealed cabinets. I can see from historic pictures that the early Rosedales and w/70's were ported, then the design changed to sealed. I summise this was to up the power handling capacity, but my reading tells me that the damping effect of the sealed cab meant the driver could be more compliant and such a driver would not survive in a ported cab due to excessive cone excursion. However, I can see no observable difference in them, and the compliance seems the same as drivers taken from ported examples. I do have some drivers from Wharfedales of a later period (late 70's) from sealed cabs, and the build is lighter and magnets smaller, but rated power is higher, with a caveat not to use them in unported cabs. Perhaps the company thought they could save money on later designs by taking advantage of the damping effect of sealed cabs, but early ones were not changed?
If you port these boxes you may lower the power handling ability as they will bottom out much easier. I believe Wharfedale did make some adjustments on the speaker compliance. They were always tinkering...
 
I wouldn’t add an air port unless you’re already skilled at speaker design and also have testing equipment/software to see the Vs and impedance curve etc of the woofer. Even then I’d personally make a mock-up using MDF to test results. And then you have to know the math or find calculations on port size/depth/tuning. Just hacking and throwing some pvc in there without a background is more likely to ruin it and leave you trying to get what you had back
But that’s me
 
After a brief lack of activity I have been able to get on with the project. I appreciate the concerns re: porting the Rosedales, but after much research I decided to go ahead. I used a 2" ID pipe with an inner sleeve to allow for adjustments. After testing and retesting I arrived at my preferred sound. The pipe is 200mm or 8", which produces the wonderful open bass response I was looking for at quite low inputs, mimicking the Dovedales. They sound wonderful, however the mid and high response is still not as bright as the Dovedales which I prefer. That needs further research.
I was surprised to discover that the Rosedales are wired in a reverse configuration, the bass units are wired reverse polarity, as are the tweets, with only the mids in standard polarity. I know wiring the mid in reverse is common in three way speakers to iron out phase frequency issues, but can anyone suggest a reason for doing this? I have been experimenting with stacking the Dovedales on top of the Rosedales, but to drive them together I must wire the Rosedales backwards or the bass units cancel out. For the naysayers I should add, together they sound sublime, complimenting each other perfectly.
 
Rosedales are wired in a reverse configuration, the bass units are wired reverse polarity, as are the tweets
I think you'll find that only the bass is wired in reverse. I also wanted to stack my Rosedales with the W70e's so I built a copies of the W70e crossovers and installed them in place of the originals. Now they are both in phase and the new crossovers allow me to adjust the mid and high output for better tonal balance in my room.
 
I used a 2" ID pipe with an inner sleeve to allow for adjustments
Does this arrangement give you better low frequency extension? If so by how much? Did you do any response testing? If you don't own any equipment, there are a couple of web sites with waveform apps that you can use to do some subjective testing.
 
I think you'll find that only the bass is wired in reverse. I also wanted to stack my Rosedales with the W70e's so I built a copies of the W70e crossovers and installed them in place of the originals. Now they are both in phase and the new crossovers allow me to adjust the mid and high output for better tonal balance in my room.
Thanks. I must admit I am thinking of building new crossovers too, I double checked after your comments about the wiring, but I was correct, only the mid takes it's positive feed from the positive supply. The bass and the tweet are reverse wired. A little more reading tells me that it is common to 'flip' the polarity at each crossover point, so if the bass had been wired positive the mid would have been flipped (180 ) and the tweet would have been flipped again (to bring it back to 0 or 360). I suppose this is the same result in reverse, but what puzzles me is WHY? The existing crossovers have a 4.2mH coil on the bass, 0.57mH and 25uF on the mid, and 0.3mH, 6uF and a 3.3R resistor on the tweet. which may explain the lesser bright sound. Do you have a schematic of the crossover on the W70's? And what are the impedance of the drivers if you know?
 
Does this arrangement give you better low frequency extension? If so by how much? Did you do any response testing? If you don't own any equipment, there are a couple of web sites with waveform apps that you can use to do some subjective testing.

infullview, I know this is possibly bordering on sacrilege, to go in without any formal knowledge or equipment and just tweak, so perhaps I should mention that I am an instrument maker, I build guitars and stringed instruments (so I am a pretty accomplished woodcraft guy too). I tuned the bass response purely by ear, to reproduce the lower registers of a string bass around 40 - 60 Hz in a way which pleases me. I used a twin section pipe sliding it inside itself till I got the sound I liked, and then reproduced it in a single section. (just like tuning a pipe organ). I would be interested to run it through a waveform app, at some point to see what I ended up with, but it is more the timbre of the bass rather than just plain low end extension. If that makes sense.
 
Thanks. I must admit I am thinking of building new crossovers too, I double checked after your comments about the wiring, but I was correct, only the mid takes it's positive feed from the positive supply. The bass and the tweet are reverse wired. A little more reading tells me that it is common to 'flip' the polarity at each crossover point, so if the bass had been wired positive the mid would have been flipped (180 ) and the tweet would have been flipped again (to bring it back to 0 or 360). I suppose this is the same result in reverse, but what puzzles me is WHY? The existing crossovers have a 4.2mH coil on the bass, 0.57mH and 25uF on the mid, and 0.3mH, 6uF and a 3.3R resistor on the tweet. which may explain the lesser bright sound. Do you have a schematic of the crossover on the W70's? And what are the impedance of the drivers if you know?
Yes, look at page 55 on this thread for my W70E schematics. All of the drivers in the W70E look to be the same as the Rosedale. DC resistance of the woofer is 5.8 Ohms tweeter was close to four, etc. The only driver that looks a little different is the mid.
 
Thanks for all your help on this. I will continue to experiment with crossovers for the Rosedales, one thing I want to try is taking the bass feed from a Dovedale to the bass unit on the Rosedales. Though much improved to my ears by being ported, they are not yet giving me the wondrous low of the Dovedale. However, the 15" drivers are half the impedance of the dovedale 12"'s. How much difference will that make?
 
Back
Top Bottom