Hello fellow Wharfedalers!
Over the last two or so years I have gone from complete novice to fairly well informed on the subject of vintage Wharfedales, that is the UK versions at least. I must admit to still being confused by the myriad of US models and how they relate to UK variants. It is interesting that the Wxx line with it’s suffix B, C, D etc does help when identifying variants, the UK never seems to have benefitted from that. My love began with the purchase of a pair of W2 Dovedales. (I have several now, all different). From this point on, I’m going to start referring to the different models with suffix’s too, so these, as far as I can tell, would be W2 Dovedale B’s.
I know there is a bit of supposition going on here, and that story of the fire which destroyed all the records at the factory is well known, but I believe the first W2’s were ported, (mine are ser no 8938, dated 1965) with a tygan covered baffle surrounded by a silk rope trim. The fronts were not removable. Cabinets are solid ply, veneered of course. The drivers are the iconic cast alloy framed alnico 12” units (polystyrene filled flat cone in this one, mesh roll surround) and a super 5 (5”) unit. The crossovers in all these early models of course are all simple, in this one it’s a huge tin box 10uF cap and 2.5mH inductor coil (measured). The cap incidentally is still within 5% tolerance after all these years. As to the sound, well… I can only imagine they must have amazed folk in 1965). However they lack the bass extension of a few years later.
Next in line and my first purchase, are nominated as W2/Dovedales, the first to have the newer, floating look fronts with silver trim surround. On these first updated versions (which I am going to call W2B’s unless anyone knows different) are still ported, the fronts are not detachable, but they look identical to the later ones with ‘pinned on’ fronts. They have the ser no. 5218 so clearly not contiguous with early models. The cloth, Tygan still, is wrapped over the baffle and screwed into the cabinet from the inside. The drivers in these are ceramic 12” round magnets with rubber roll surrounds (no poly filled cone here), with a 5” ceramic tweeter which still looks identical to the super 5 but has no identifying labels. The crossover consists of an 8.2 uF cap and 4mH inductor. It was these that began my love affair with Dovedales. The whole is so much more than the sum of its parts. Presentation is incredibly dynamic, fantastic mids and highs (though of course lacking any super high freqs, but unless you are 6 or a dog, you wouldn’t know). But it is the glorious acoustic quality to the bass these emit that makes them really special. It is not massively in-your-face, but resonant and physical (like a double bass being bowed). My hunch is that you can’t get that particular quality from an unported design, due to the difference in roll-off at the very low end.
Based on that experience I bought another identical looking pair, but I was disappointed to find they did not sound the same. The bass was good, very good in fact, but not as rewarding as my earlier models. On closer inspection they had the same cabinet, crossover and tweet, the 12” unit looked the same, still rubber roll, still cast allow frame, except it has a square magnet. And the baffles had removable fronts. For this reason I am going to call them W2C’s. I checked the compliance of the woofers, exactly the same. I measured the crossover components and the driver coils, exactly the same. The only difference was the square magnet. Could that really make such a difference and if so, why did Gilbert allow it? Perhaps he preferred it, I certainly didn’t.
So I went in search of another pair of W2B’s, (yes I know it’s entitled of me to come up with a naming strategy of my own but bear with me, I’m open to suggestions!). I eventually found a pair, and they confirmed my suspicions, they sounded wonderful and exactly the same, same acoustic bass quality.
For info, I have not yet encountered any vintage Wharfedale drivers with any detrimental hardening of the rubber or stiffness in compliance, they seem to age very well and if anything, loosen up with years of use. I have noticed that some of the driver units in the ‘kit form’ speakers known as Unit 3, Unit 4 etc had much smaller magnet arrays, and a warning that they should ONLY be used in sealed cabinets of specific dimensions, presumably they do require the dampening effect of a sealed enclosure. Not sure if these were also used in later production models like the Melton, but every picture I’ve seen of any later Dovedale’s seem to use the large magnet array used in the early ones.
I have since listened to some later models, the closed cab, unported, infinite baffle designs with three drivers, and for me they are a step backwards. Of course, they will handle a lot more power, but they sound strangled and boxy in comparison.
This leads me to a few ponderances, and I really appreciate any comments.
1. Why did Wharfedale change from ported to infinite baffle design? Perhaps it was necessary to get the power handling at the time, if driver design couldn’t damp the larger transients?
2. Has anyone else compared different models like this, and what did you find?
3. Does anyone appreciate the bass response I am talking about, or is it just me?
4. Most importantly to me, does anyone know if there was a change in the bass drivers internal design when the change was made to closed instead of vented cabinet. The reason I ask this is because it has always been a want of mine to try a 15” bass driver, and I have just bought a pair of Rosedale’s which haven’t arrived yet. I bought these on a whim, have very little info on them, but I believe they are slightly later and I don’t expect they will be ported. I would like to experiment with porting to see what happens (don’t worry, I’ll make sure anything I do is reversable) but is it ok to use the 15” driver designed for sealed cabs in a ported design? I know some early 15” cabs in the U.S. were ported. It is interesting that all the drivers in the ported and unported W2’s and Dovedale’s all have the rubber roll and appear the same, even though they were used in both ported and unported designs. Is there a difference I have missed?
My investigations continue, but if anyone has any comments or info on any of my pondering I would be very interested in them. Sorry for the long post.