• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

This book does a good job of covering the “English” Whatedales. The whole back section lists speaker models and drivers. Sadly it has little to say about the American Wharfedales.

View attachment 2667380
Thanks for this, I have seen it before but not read it yet, though I have read two or three of Gilbert's own books. ( Sound Reproduction, Loudspeakers, the why and how of sound reproduction, and several of his articles). I have never come across any of the foam-surround drivers though. (at least not till the late 70's/early 80's. I had no idea there were alnico's with foam surrounds) What I don't understand is why the rubber surrounds were developed before acoustic suspension designs were introduced into the Wharfedale range. With a port, surely there is no need for airtight surrounds.

Those FSB's are clearly very early models, so they definitely predate the acoustic suspension patents expiry.

As for the empty chamber, is there perhaps some slots or holes in the separating baffle? Some sort of acoustic filter perhaps, as the port seems to be in that chamber.

It is my intention to build some cabinets of my own, to include a 15", a 12" an 8" and either a 3" or dome tweeter, but that will be a while away yet.

One point, wht does the super three (rated 10 - 15 impedance) show a resistance of 5 ohms? I understand the reading is from an d/c current not a/c, but I always thought the resistance was within an ohm or two?
 
A DC resistance of 5 ohms is indicative of an 8 ohms speaker. However, impedance is frequency dependent. Of the two I have on the shelf, the DC resistance of one is 6.38 ohms and the other is 6.21 ohms. Their nominal impedance is 7.5 ohms, between 1khz and 2khz. At 5khz, the impedance is 9.94 ohms; 10khz it's 12.64 ohms and at 15khz, it's 14.93 ohms. Since the Super 3 is typically used above 5khz, this may explain why it's rated as 10 to 15 ohms.
 
I have discussed this before. Before computerized speaker design speakers were voiced according to individuals. Gilbert Briggs, Rudy Bozak, Paul Klipsch, etc. The audio Engineers each had their own idea of audio reproduction. You can hear the distinctive voicing of these speakers. Modern computer designed speakers are very accurate but like Tube vis Sold State audio amps there is something missing.
 
I have discussed this before. Before computerized speaker design speakers were voiced according to individuals. Gilbert Briggs, Rudy Bozak, Paul Klipsch, etc. The audio Engineers each had their own idea of audio reproduction. You can hear the distinctive voicing of these speakers. Modern computer designed speakers are very accurate but like Tube vis Sold State audio amps there is something missing.

I know, and completely agree with you transmaster. And the particular voicing of that, ahem, W2B, is like nothing I've experienced before or since. I honestly must have tried 20 or more pairs of speakers, mostly similar in size, many far more expensive, and nothing, nothing comes anywhere near, and I go back to them with a huge smile on my face. The fact that I've had several pairs now which all sound exquisitely the same, shows it's in the family line. I've been trying to isolate the particular element which creates it, I now think it is that one variant of the 12" with the round ceramic magnet array and a very compliant motion, combined with those low and high pass filter frequencies, which creates the magic.
 
One of things I think makes the Wharfedale sound is the cast zinc alloy speaker frames. Zinc is easy to die cast and it is naturally non-resonate.
 
A DC resistance of 5 ohms is indicative of an 8 ohms speaker. However, impedance is frequency dependent. Of the two I have on the shelf, the DC resistance of one is 6.38 ohms and the other is 6.21 ohms. Their nominal impedance is 7.5 ohms, between 1khz and 2khz. At 5khz, the impedance is 9.94 ohms; 10khz it's 12.64 ohms and at 15khz, it's 14.93 ohms. Since the Super 3 is typically used above 5khz, this may explain why it's rated as 10 to 15 ohms.
Thanks, interesting. So is there not an industry standard for specifying impedance? In your example the nominal impedance does not at all reflect the impedance at it's target operating frequency. I have wharfedale tweeters on my shelf with marked nominal impedance of 6 - 8ohms. If the same rule applies as with the Super 3, that would make it's impedance at target operating frequency very high. It means the markings are meaningless really. How strange.
 
6-8 Ohms is the general range in a frequency sweep from 20-20kHtz, it’s basically a number to help you match to an appropriate amp and design your crossover. Amps in general aren’t usually rated below 4 Ohms (car audio and PA amps notwithstanding).

if you wire two 8 ohm (nominal) speakers together in parallel (both directly from the amp) the electrical resistance of the two will be in the 4 ohm range as seen by the amp. If you wire them in series (red to red one, then out of that speakers black to the next speakers red, then from speaker 2’s black back to the amp) the resistance is seen by the amp as double, or about 16 Ohms. This is important to know if you’re designing a crossover or connecting multiple speakers to one output on an amp. Also why some amps say 4-8 Ohms on speakers A or B, but only 8 Ohms for speakers A+B (because A+B is just wiring them in parallel within the amp, if you had two sets of 4 Ohm speakers in A+B the resistance would be around 2 Ohms and you could blow the amp)

The measurement you get from a multimeter is fairly irrelevant and only shows you the voice coil hasn’t burned out and there’s still a connection between the + and - connections
 
They make audio impedance meters. I have wanted one for a long time but they are just too expensive even used ones. They work by feeding a voice coil with a specific voltage at a specified audio frequency. What you end up with is an impedance graph for a given speaker. This is dead handy for matching up modern drivers to vintage speakers.
 
I know, and completely agree with you transmaster. And the particular voicing of that, ahem, W2B, is like nothing I've experienced before or since. I honestly must have tried 20 or more pairs of speakers, mostly similar in size, many far more expensive, and nothing, nothing comes anywhere near, and I go back to them with a huge smile on my face. The fact that I've had several pairs now which all sound exquisitely the same, shows it's in the family line. I've been trying to isolate the particular element which creates it, I now think it is that one variant of the 12" with the round ceramic magnet array and a very compliant motion, combined with those low and high pass filter frequencies, which creates the magic.
I was looking at e-pay.uk and was surprised how many Dovedale 3's there are for sale for around $150 US (mostly local pickup). The average price for the US equivalent model the W60E is about $300 in working condition. Is the lager size of these speakers an issue?
 
Wharfedales in the 1950’s and 1960’s were not nationally marketed in the US. They were mostly marketed in New England, and to a lesser extent down the East coast. I was introduced to the marque in Key West Florida in 1971. Because of this Wharfedales of this vintage are not that common across the country. It is the “E” line I am primarily interested in, These are what I call the American Wharfedales, W25, W35, W45, W60E, W70E, and W80A Veriflex. There was never a “E” model W90. The “D” line were also acoustically suspended but they use the problematic purple domed tweeter. That is not a deal killer there are several modern replacements for it. The major difference between the “D” and “E” line of other than drivers is the speakers on the “D” model mount from the back.

F8C66711-481C-4504-B2A5-6A32F8975E72.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Finally had to pass on my 3way Wharfe DIY ported enclosures. The footprint of the two were going to be too big for a downsized situation in my imediate future.

Admittedly, the drivers were from the late 70's, but they could hold their own quite well against most of the modern offerings. This I have also been told by others as well. They did their job without a hitch, and I ran them hard at times!

So, in the next year, I will be asking for a suitable replacement for them. Floor standing models, probably under a $1000 if it is possible, and will consider going used if needed. The SO may back me in this regard. :-) In turn, I will be asking for advice in this respect.


Just realized that the above share reads like a eulogy:rolleyes:...but maybe in a way it is, eh?


Wharfedales rule!


Q
 
Finally had to pass on my 3way Wharfe DIY ported enclosures. The footprint of the two were going to be too big for a downsized situation in my imediate future.

Admittedly, the drivers were from the late 70's, but they could hold their own quite well against most of the modern offerings. This I have also been told by others as well. They did their job without a hitch, and I ran them hard at times!

So, in the next year, I will be asking for a suitable replacement for them. Floor standing models, probably under a $1000 if it is possible, and will consider going used if needed. The SO may back me in this regard. :) In turn, I will be asking for advice in this respect.


Just realized that the above share reads like a eulogy:rolleyes:...but maybe in a way it is, eh?


Wharfedales rule!


Q

Take a look at the W45, I love mine. Back in 1970 they were advertised as a bookshelf speaker. By modern standards they are a little large for that. They would fit nicely on elevated speaker stands. My brother always bragged about his AR-2AX’s a contemporary to the W45. My W45 not only look better, and are built better, they blow the 2AX’s out of the water sonically.
 
Wharedale W45:
The W45 is about the same size as the AR-2AX, and has a Wharfedale 10” woofer. Wharfedales of this vintage either used doped canvas or rubber surrounds. I have examples of both even after 50 years they are in perfect condition.

57E04E61-463C-47EF-84C0-DBD18FE60AE4.jpeg
 
I was looking at e-pay.uk and was surprised how many Dovedale 3's there are for sale for around $150 US (mostly local pickup). The average price for the US equivalent model the W60E is about $300 in working condition. Is the lager size of these speakers an issue?
If by that you mean are larger speakers not popular in the UK, you're right, they are not. There may be other psychosocial reasons too, but generally, UK properties are much smaller (island mentality) and large speakers take up too much floorspace for the average home (or so I'm told, I suppose it's about priorities too, they are very important to me so I make room!)

I look on with envy at the range of larger speakers readily available to those in the US. Tannoy, Celestion, Goodmans and a few others, including of course Wharfedale made large and very large cabinets up to the early 70's, but since then we've had no real choice of mainstream larger speakers, most Brits have forgotten what good bass sounds like. I live within a mile or two of the original Wharfedale factory site, so they sold well around here, I could pick up early Lintons and the like for next to nothing, it's criminal really.
 
Help! I have started to service my newly acquired Rosedales, and I'm struggling to get the front grill off! The woofer is rear mounted, but the other drivers are mounted from the front so it surely must come off. The grill seems welded in place, is it on velcro? I can easily move it in the centre of the bottom edge from inside, but the corners are not giving and the grill is only thin mdf, I dont want to break them, they are in beautiful condition. How are they attached?IMG-1141.jpg IMG-1144.jpg IMG-1147.jpg
 
Help! I have started to service my newly acquired Rosedales, and I'm struggling to get the front grill off! The woofer is rear mounted, but the other drivers are mounted from the front so it surely must come off. The grill seems welded in place, is it on velcro? I can easily move it in the centre of the bottom edge from inside, but the corners are not giving and the grill is only thin mdf, I dont want to break them, they are in beautiful condition. How are they attached?View attachment 2675403 View attachment 2675404 View attachment 2675405
Well there are two options. One you won't like. My W70C's are Velcro, and if they haven't been taken off in a long time they do stick pretty hard.
the other is they're glued on the front and not meant to be taken off...hard to tell from your pic of the back side, but it does almost look like there are glue residue marks where the fiberboard frame meets the cloth grill. That said, it would mean the bolts for the driver would also have to be glued solid, because it would be impossible to service the speaker if they came loose...those are almost certainly flat head wood screw machine bolts.
If I'm not wrong the Rosedales are the W70E's in America and I think @infullview has a pair and might be able to tell you.

And you aren't kidding, that's a nice looking pair!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom