• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Wharfedale Owners Thread

Thanks for all your help on this. I will continue to experiment with crossovers for the Rosedales, one thing I want to try is taking the bass feed from a Dovedale to the bass unit on the Rosedales. Though much improved to my ears by being ported, they are not yet giving me the wondrous low of the Dovedale. However, the 15" drivers are half the impedance of the dovedale 12"'s. How much difference will that make?
Huge. The crossovers are designed with DC resistance in mind. Not sure what the issue is on your Rosedales. Mine shake the floor pretty well - better than any 12 inch speaker would. How soft is the rubber surround on yours?They should be very pliable.
 
Huge. The crossovers are designed with DC resistance in mind.
I thought as much. Just reading up on it now.

Not sure what the issue is on your Rosedales. Mine shake the floor pretty well - better than any 12 inch speaker would. How soft is the rubber surround on yours?They should be very pliable.
Don't get me wrong. That 15" driver is awesome at producing bass in spadefuls. As you say, it can rattle the windows easily! And the surround is as soft and pliable as any of my other units. If I hadn't heard my W2/Dovedales (W2B's), I would be very, very happy with these. But it is the presentation of the overall sound that is lacking in comparison with my W2B's. Existing wisdom would say that a 15" driver is going to have a different ability through the freq response than a 12" unit. I get that. But this is different in the same way the 12" driver with the round ceramic magnet array is different from the 12" driver with the square magnet array. The first is MUCH better than the second (with the examples I have), but it shouldn't be. They are passed off as being identical, swap-around replacements. I don't understand why they swapped. The round came before the square, yet is not as good (to me). The 15" has a square magnet array too. I wanted to eliminate that as being the difference. I have yet to hear a 15" with a round magnet.
I must admit this has become a bit of a holy grail issue with me now. Maybe I should just accept they are different and appreciate them for the amazing speakers they are, but different.
 
the presentation of the overall sound that is lacking in comparison with my W2B's
I wish I could listen to your Dovedales to hear this for myself. Do the Dovedales have Alnico magnets? That will make a difference in the sound. Do a little experiment for me. If you don't have a function generator, you can test your speakers response with this web site https://www.szynalski.com/tone-generator/ . Be careful not to have your volume up too high when using it or you could blow a mid-range or tweeter. My modified Rosedales are relatively flat down to 35Hz, then they fall off but are still detectable at 25Hz (probably down by 8-10db).
 
Just picked up a pair of W70Ds to match my main speakers which are also W70Ds. They were on the auction site and about an hour and a half away with local pickup only (for obvious reasons.) Couldn't pass up getting a set to match my existing main speakers. Haven't had a chance to test them, but they look very good.

I haven't decided whether these go into the main room as rear speakers for the home theater and stereo listening or if they should be the main speakers in the setup that is going into an alternate room.

About to have too many Wharfedales in the house. I have a pair of W20Ds that are destined for the bedroom (but they need the purple tweeters repaired, that is another thread.) Also have an empty pair of W60E(?) cases (purchased from someone who parted out the drivers and then sold the cases empty) that is probably destined to hold the drivers from a Wharfedale Unit Kit 5. Plus I have quite a collection of drivers some of which may be destined for sub-woofer duty or maybe a home theater center channel speaker build. At some point though, I may need to cull the herd a bit.
 
Just picked up a pair of W70Ds to match my main speakers which are also W70Ds. They were on the auction site and about an hour and a half away with local pickup only (for obvious reasons.) Couldn't pass up getting a set to match my existing main speakers. Haven't had a chance to test them, but they look very good.

I haven't decided whether these go into the main room as rear speakers for the home theater and stereo listening or if they should be the main speakers in the setup that is going into an alternate room.

About to have too many Wharfedales in the house. I have a pair of W20Ds that are destined for the bedroom (but they need the purple tweeters repaired, that is another thread.) Also have an empty pair of W60E(?) cases (purchased from someone who parted out the drivers and then sold the cases empty) that is probably destined to hold the drivers from a Wharfedale Unit Kit 5. Plus I have quite a collection of drivers some of which may be destined for sub-woofer duty or maybe a home theater center channel speaker build. At some point though, I may need to cull the herd a bit.
The W20D was replaced by the W25. A speaker I very much like. Size wise they compare to the AR-7 but I think they sound better and are certainly a much better-looking speaker.

AR-7
1825D50C-2F1D-4B8D-9F74-EC436AADDFC2.jpeg

W-25
119B1D67-CEA2-4833-BAFB-030596804A46.jpeg
6E29F52D-B815-4FB7-9BBC-1B102BC0B2C0.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Regarding the W20Ds per the specs at http://stereo.toups.info/Wharfedale/index.html I believe of all the Wharfedales, this one is probably the candidate for replacing the purple tweeters with a soft dome tweeter. The cross-over point is 1.6 kHz which is probably well below the sweet spot of the purple tweeter. In models with mid-ranges, these are crossed at 3.5 kHz. Even the W30D two-way uses a 2.0 kHz cross over point.

I think the W25 proves this point, that one uses a tweeter that stands a better chance of having a response into the mid-range. Cross over point seems to be similar. I found a review of the W25 at https://worldradiohistory.com/hd2/I.../HiFi-Stereo-Review-1971-03-OCR-Page-0038.pdf and continued at https://worldradiohistory.com/hd2/I.../HiFi-Stereo-Review-1971-03-OCR-Page-0042.pdf The box size seems to be approximately the same as the W20D and I assume the 8 inch driver is probably the same.

The first step is to repair the purple tweeters and then listen to them. Of course, I could use the "Speaker Workshop" program and get a real measurement. Hopefully that wouldn't spoil the magic. LOL

In spite of being a fan of my W70Ds, I have always been partial to a well executed two-way system from a simplicity and minimalist stand point from both a hardware, size, and price perspective. However one needs a 3+-way if one really wants a very low response.

My first speakers were a pair of Synergistic S23s that were 2-ways with a passive radiator. They used a 2 1/2 inch cone tweeter that had a response into the mid-range. These were also used on the S12 that i talked my sister into buying. (Still have the Synergistic S23s but I had to replace the surrounds since they were the foam type that disintegrates. While replacing the surrounds on the main speakers and the passive radiators, I found that the passive radiators were a simple piece of cardboard covered by an adhesive foam cover. Plus if I remember correctly, the crossover was a simple capacitor. In spite of that, they served me well and are about to be passed along to one of my children to make way for a Wharfedale. Details on these speakers can be found at http://stereo.toups.info/
 
Let me put that last post in better perspective. I trotted out my latest speaker acquisition, a pair of ADS L8e’s. Hooked one up to replace the left W70e and it sounded pretty damned good - or so I thought. Then removed the right W70e and hooked up both ADS speakers. Very disappointing to say the least. Tan and forward with hardly any bass. Once agin I reaffirmed what good speakers are supposed to sound like. The ADS pair are back in the closet where they belong.
 
Let me put that last post in better perspective. I trotted out my latest speaker acquisition, a pair of ADS L8e’s. Hooked one up to replace the left W70e and it sounded pretty damned good - or so I thought. Then removed the right W70e and hooked up both ADS speakers. Very disappointing to say the least. Tan and forward with hardly any bass. Once agin I reaffirmed what good speakers are supposed to sound like. The ADS pair are back in the closet where they belong.
You should have seen My face back in 1972 when I first powered up my W35s. I was an AR snob at the time. The only reason why I got the W35s was no one in Key West, Florida sold AR speakers. These Wharfedales were the only acoustic suspended speakers I could get. When I got them back to my room at The Naval Air Station at Key Largo and powered them up I was stunned. These were not counterfeit AR’s they were in a different league. This was my introduction to the “English Sound” and I have never looked back.

Presently my sights are on a nice set of W60Es that are reasonably close. I will eventually get a set of W70Es. Maybe I can finish things out with the ultra-rare W80A Veriflex, Wharfedales answer to the Bose 901. Unlike the Bose you could adjust it to the acoustics of the room not the other way around like the 901. Plus it does not need an electronic equalizer to make mediocre speakers sound better.
 
Last edited:
Presently my sights are on a nice set of W60Es that are reasonably close.
Good luck procuring those W60e's @transmaster! Placement will be key to getting the best bass these have to offer. I know it sounds like I rave about these speakers, but in fact I do. There is something different about them. I've had KLH 5's, Advents, ADC's (local NE speaker brand), and host of Radio Shack stuff including the "Optomistic" line, and none of them stack up. The Paradigm Phantom V1's with a 15 inch sub came close, but was still missing that percussive hit you get from a kick drum that you feel in your chest.
 
I've had Klipsh KG4,s Saunsui SP1500's, CF3', Vandersteen 1C and 2Ce's, Infinity RSe's, Boston A150's

And my W70C's are still my daily drivers. They not only sound great but were made to look great too. Most box speakers with black grills are, well lets face it, ugly...not mine! :D At some point I'm going to have to find out how close @infullview lives to me because I'd like to hear the e's in comparison.

Sadly my HH Scott receiver has had some issues with the left channel, could just need a replacement tube in the pre-amp. But that 30 tube watts really makes my W70C's shine in a way my current HK ss doesn't.
 
I've had Klipsh KG4,s Saunsui SP1500's, CF3', Vandersteen 1C and 2Ce's, Infinity RSe's, Boston A150's

And my W70C's are still my daily drivers. They not only sound great but were made to look great too. Most box speakers with black grills are, well lets face it, ugly...not mine! :D At some point I'm going to have to find out how close @infullview lives to me because I'd like to hear the e's in comparison.

Sadly my HH Scott receiver has had some issues with the left channel, could just need a replacement tube in the pre-amp. But that 30 tube watts really makes my W70C's shine in a way my current HK ss doesn't.
I'm located in York county, PM if you're close enough for a visit. I'd love to compare notes on the W70C vs E.
 
Hi all,

Found a pair of W70Ds fairly close to me (only 2.5 hours away!) and will be checking them out and possibly buying them on Friday. I'd appreciate any tips you have on inspecting them. I'll audition them for sure. The front grills have never been removed so I won't be able to inspect the drivers for their condition. I might be able to have the rear panel removed to inspect crossovers and such. Based on the owner's info, I think these are unmolested originals.

thanks,

Mike
 
Hello Mike.

If you do get around to removing the front, be careful as the tweeter wires may be short, resulting in severely damaging the tweeter.

Robert
 
Last edited:
Hello Mike.

If you do get around to removing the front, be careful as the tweeter wires may be short, resulting in severely damaging the tweeter.

Robert
Is the tweeter mounted to the grill? or is it a case of mechanical interference? What is the correct way to remove the front grill? Or are all the drivers mounted to the back of the baffle and no grill removal required to access them?
 
The "D" models drivers are all mounted from the back so to get to them you have to remove the back panel of the cabinet. The tweeter and mid-range are mounted inside their own enclosure box inside. This is the one the the reasons I like the "E" model they are all mounted from the front.
 
The "D" models drivers are all mounted from the back so to get to them you have to remove the back panel of the cabinet. The tweeter and mid-range are mounted inside their own enclosure box inside..
Thanks for the additional info. Is the crossover mounted to the rear panel or further inside the cabinet?
 
Really the only trouble area the Wharfedale's of this series have is the tweeters. They are so often bad that you go into a deal expecting it. There are a bunch of modern replacements so bad tweeters are not a deal breaker.
 
Back
Top Bottom