• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

What is relative efficiency:

Cosmos

Speakerholic
Subscriber
Recently, I saw a post stating that a speaker of 90db was medium efficiency. This raises the question in my mind:

What efficiency defines relative efficiency level?


For many years, I have used the following:

Supreme efficiency: 100db+/w/m
High efficiency: 96 to 100 db
Medium efficiency: 92 to 95 db
Low efficiency: 85 to 91 db
Extremely low efficiency: <85 db

In the 50s 60s and early 70s, the above rules were probably too low. Efficiency was a design requirement for low powered tube gear.

Through the last 30+ years, with the advent of solid state gear, many designers have drastically lowered the priority for efficiency in the design process. This is especially evident with the small mini-monitors and sub-satellite systems, which often have efficiencies in the 80s. The availability of massive wattage allows this lowered priority.

My difficulty, with this process, is that I believe that medium to high efficiency systems, with or without high power amplifiers, just make a better sounding system. It seems to me that they are more dynamic and life like. They also allow use of any style amplifier you'd like, from SS through SET.

However, as a trade off, higher efficiency systems are also larger in size. In my experience, larger size speakers have more difficulty imaging. Further, I cannot name an extreme efficiency system (100+db that would fit into a normal room) that makes enough clean, tight, bass for me..

Without a doubt, it's all about trade offs.

The biggest question of this thread is:

What high efficiency (96 to 100 db/w/m) system images well, provides good deep tight bass while avoiding laser like sweet spot?

Again, the design must be:
1. 96 to 100 db/w/m effiiient.
2. Produce good, tight, deep bass.
3. Image well without "head in the vise" sweet spot.
 
Register to hide this ad
What high efficiency (96 to 100 db/w/m) system images well, provides good deep tight bass while avoiding laser like sweet spot?

Again, the design must be:
1. 96 to 100 db/w/m effiiient.
2. Produce good, tight, deep bass.
3. Image well without "head in the vise" sweet spot.

Are you truncating the list at 100db? Willing to go higher? What's your room size? What's your budget? What is your tolerance for asthetics? (willing to live with ugly to get better sound or do you need better asthetics at the expense of better sound?)

Given your constraints (without knowing your size/budget/WAF constraints) I'd say the Klipsch Jubilee knocks each one of those out of the ballpark.
 
I'd guess the vast majority of home audio speakers on the market are in the "low efficiency" range listed in the original post.
 
It's the law -- you can't get high-efficiency extended bass outta small boxes.

The answer is pro sound mid/high augmented with subwooferage.... :yes:
 
Are you truncating the list at 100db? Willing to go higher?

I have nothing against higher. However, I have heard alot of speakers and I have never heard anything 100+ db efficient that could create the bass response I want.

What's your room size? What's your budget? What is your tolerance for asthetics? (willing to live with ugly to get better sound or do you need better asthetics at the expense of better sound?)
Room size is 14 x 22 but I intend to build a larger committed listening room (22x35) so figure 14x22 to 22 x 35.

Asthetics are cool, but not the defining priority. Ugly, but great sounding can work..

Budget is under $20K, but I have alot of building blocks to work with. DIY is awesome!



Given your constraints (without knowing your size/budget/WAF constraints) I'd say the Klipsch Jubilee knocks each one of those out of the ballpark.

I have never heard a Klipsch I could live with, but I also have never heard a Jubilee. Further, I don't have any idea what it is. I will do some research on it.. Could be a Contenda! Wonder who carries them to listen to?
 
It's the law -- you can't get high-efficiency extended bass outta small boxes.

The answer is pro sound mid/high augmented with subwooferage.... :yes:

Zilch, I am with you.. but getting the big stuff to image well...

I have heard some great imaging speakers, such as Spica T-50 and Edgarhorns. Edgarhorns are highly efficient, but you better not turn your head or lean...

Ok, I want it all..:yes:
 
Gedlee Summa w/ three subs.

Just don't listen while laying on the floor or while standing really close to the speakers or you'll get bad sound.
 
Last edited:
Go for it! For me my speaker size and listening volume goes down every year. I guess it is a sign of old age. I would/am fully satisfied with an "under 50watt" amp and a nice set of speakers (Even though I have stronger)

P.S. Looking for Mrs. right!!! 10-35watt crown
 
Mid/high don't hafta be big. Can be small as Minimus, if desired.... :yes:

Could it be the next "Wave" project? "Mega-mini wave"?

So far, two suggestions:
1. Klipsch Jubilee
2. Gedlee Summa w/ three subs

and some big ass JBL pro stuff that's small.. :D
 
Could it be the next "Wave" project? "Mega-mini wave"?
Already in process over there, clones of these in stock PE cabs, 0.25, 0.38, and 0.5 cuft stock PE cabs. Not uber-efficient like you want, but they could be with other woofers:

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/General/ProductFamily.aspx?FId=63&MId=2

You can get to 100 dB/W easily with pro woofers like Eminence and "standard" waveguides.

At 108 dB/W, these'll get you to the upper limits of where you want to be in a modest package:

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/support/getfile.aspx?doctype=3&docid=653

[With max continuous 132 dB SPL as a bonus.... :tongue: ]
 
Klipsch Tangent 400s meet every one of those criteria. Boxes aren't too big, front firing ports, 97dB @ 1watt/1meter sensitivity, and can handle 125 watts RMS, or can sound amazing with a 10 watt EL84 tube amp, and DEEP with bass (38Hz-20kHz(+-)3dB). Trade off? Not in the heritage line, Only come in black, and have plastic horns that like the break if you screw them down too tight.
 
Already in process over there, clones of these in stock PE cabs, 0.25, 0.38, and 0.5 cuft stock PE cabs. Not uber-efficient like you want, but they could be with other woofers:

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/General/ProductFamily.aspx?FId=63&MId=2

You can get to 100 dB/W easily with pro woofers like Eminence and "standard" waveguides.

At 108 dB/W, these'll get you to the upper limits of where you want to be in a modest package:

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/support/getfile.aspx?doctype=3&docid=653

[With max continuous 132 dB SPL as a bonus.... :tongue: ]

Which of the AC series are you cloning?

Also, your second link isn't working for me and it isn't clear what you're pointing to..
 
Klipsch Tangent 400s meet every one of those criteria. Boxes aren't too big, front firing ports, 97dB @ 1watt/1meter sensitivity, and can handle 125 watts RMS, or can sound amazing with a 10 watt EL84 tube amp, and DEEP with bass (38Hz-20kHz(+-)3dB). Trade off? Not in the heritage line, Only come in black, and have plastic horns that like the break if you screw them down too tight.

To be honest, I don't think any of the klipsch lineup wiht the possible exception of the Jubilee would suit Dan's needs.
 
For home speakers, I would say that 89dB/2.83V is about average, and 91dB is higher than average. Mid-90's is very unusual and probably means coils wound with a lowish-impedance, a high cutoff, or a very large system.

Impedance is one of the games manufacturers play to make their specs look better. Measuring in non-anechoic environments or at frequency hot-spots are the others. As Zilch points out, it's all physics. No brand or box type has a magic advantage; it's all a matter of design decisions and tradeoffs.

-k
 
Last edited:
Asthetics are cool, but not the defining priority. Ugly, but great sounding can work..

Budget is under $20K, but I have alot of building blocks to work with. DIY is awesome!

I have never heard a Klipsch I could live with, but I also have never heard a Jubilee. Further, I don't have any idea what it is. I will do some research on it.. Could be a Contenda! Wonder who carries them to listen to?

Are you close enough where you could make a "jaunt" to either Knoxville, Indianapolis, Chicago or perhaps Buffalo?

Those are the only places that I'm aware of with Jubilees that are close to you. There are only maybe... 20 or so pair out there.

Go to the Klipsch site, do a search on "Chronicles" or hit this http://forums.klipsch.com/forums/p/77599/767705.aspx#767705

It will show you a pair being built and delivered. The delivery starts about page 11 (or maybe 14?). Once the pictures of delivery start, the next page has a picture of my old Khorns which occupied the same corner so you can get a clue as to the size. Also... that is a 50" tv between them.

Your budget would EASILY accomodate a pair that are not in black but nicely veneered. You could be the third person in the world to have a veneered pair.


My second choice for some kick hiney would be some LaScala bottoms, the Klipsch K402 horn on top and use it as a 2-way while adding in a killer subwoofer. The K402 horn is the behemouth horn you see atop the Jubilee. This LaScala version is being called a "JubeScala" and is also astounding in its sound.

Serious offer....if you are ever near Knoxville Tn, you are welcome to swing by for a jam session.

Something like this really should be heard first, in my opinion.
 
Back
Top Bottom