• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

What is relative efficiency:

Are you close enough where you could make a "jaunt" to either Knoxville, Indianapolis, Chicago or perhaps Buffalo?

Those are the only places that I'm aware of with Jubilees that are close to you. There are only maybe... 20 or so pair out there.

Yes, Indianapolis, Chicago and Knoxville could be relatively convenient, in that order.

Go to the Klipsch site, do a search on "Chronicles" or hit this http://forums.klipsch.com/forums/p/77599/767705.aspx#767705

It will show you a pair being built and delivered. The delivery starts about page 11 (or maybe 14?). Once the pictures of delivery start, the next page has a picture of my old Khorns which occupied the same corner so you can get a clue as to the size. Also... that is a 50" tv between them.

Your budget would EASILY accomodate a pair that are not in black but nicely veneered. You could be the third person in the world to have a veneered pair.


My second choice for some kick hiney would be some LaScala bottoms, the Klipsch K402 horn on top and use it as a 2-way while adding in a killer subwoofer. The K402 horn is the behemouth horn you see atop the Jubilee. This LaScala version is being called a "JubeScala" and is also astounding in its sound.

Serious offer....if you are ever near Knoxville Tn, you are welcome to swing by for a jam session.

Something like this really should be heard first, in my opinion.

Pretty nice looking build... and yes, I wholeheartedly agree they should be heard prior to committing. Your offer is very appreciated. Now, whether or not I'd have room corners available is a huge question.

Thanks for the info and generous offer. One I'd like to take you up on when the time is right.. :yes:
 
AC15, 16, and 18/95.

AM6200/95, a member of the "normal-size" AE series:

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/general/ProductFamily.aspx?FId=25&MID=2

Also, AC2212/95 is 95 dB/W, for example.

[Some of those will be notably familiar to a defined group of AK DIYers.... ;) ]
Now this looks like some very interesting stuff.. Cone Midrange Compression Driver with Differential Drive Dual Voice Coil... 108 db efficiency.. Holy...

Are you using these modules down to 250 Hz?

Is there significant shelving/EQ required?

Price tag isn't exactly cheap, but.. they cover a very wide range of the spectrum.

Very interrresstink.
 
Cerwin Vega D9 is moderately sized and not short on bass. I believe 101db @ 1 watt.

Klipsch Forte has some serious bass, around 98db and a smallish cabinet.

I wouldn't mind finding a set of CV D7 woofers and building an econo-wave project around them.

I want high efficiency, don't mind big cabinets and want full range.

My current set of Bozaks don't seem to go below 50-60hz, but I've got some work to do on them. I have no idea what their efficiency rating is, but the cabinets are 12 cubic feet. They do have lots of mid-bass.
 
Now this looks like some very interesting stuff.. Cone Midrange Compression Driver with Differential Drive Dual Voice Coil... 108 db efficiency.. Holy...

Are you using these modules down to 250 Hz?

Is there significant shelving/EQ required?

Price tag isn't exactly cheap, but.. they cover a very wide range of the spectrum.

Very interrresstink.
I have only built prototypes; the components are relatively inexpensive, actually. Yes, the midbass is that efficient. Filters are in the .pdf:

http://www.jblproservice.com/pdf/AE Series/AM6200,95-WH.pdf

There's a less expensive version by JBL that doesn't play quite that low (350 Hz) and is "only" 106 dB/W:

http://www.jblproservice.com/pdf/AE Series/AM4200,95-WH.pdf

And one by QSC that's worth looking into DIY with non-CMCD waveguide midrange. Read up here:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1173647

JBL plays that, too, with a familiar HF waveguide, and a closed-back Eminence midrange:

http://www.jblproservice.com/pdf/PRX Series/PRX535.pdf

That midrange waveguide is just $16, as I recall.... :yes:
 
Last edited:
I suppose Klipsch are the mac daddy for klipsch fans. However, Dan is more than likely looking for a constant directivity horn if imaging is important to him. I think Klipsch uses a lot of Tractrix profile horns which would definitely not meet his requirements he listed in his first post.
 
Jubilee is Tractrix, and it does, indeed, beam. The data is here on AK.

[Somewhere.... ;) ]
 
Bear in mind,

Speaker efficiency is only part of the equation. Take a 10 watt amp, use 80db/watt/meter efficiency speakers and let's say you get a volume of "10," just to use an easy number for reference.

Take that same 10 watt amp, use 90db/watt/meter efficient speakers and you've just doubled your volume--now that volume is ""20" rather than "10."

Take that same 10 watt amp, use a 100db/watt/meter efficient speaker and your 10 watt amp has now tripled your volume to "30."

The human ear is very insensitive, and logarithmic in terms of volume. But this goes both ways, in terms of watts and speaker efficiency.

So in the end, it's a combination of factors. Got a 90db/watt/meter efficient speaker and a 10 watt amp? You'll get the exact same volume with a 100 watt amp and 80db/watt/meter efficient speakers.

Watts and speaker sensitivity are interrelated. It doesn't do much good to make generalizations about speaker sensitivity without specifying the watts driving it.

Best,

John
 
Bear in mind,

Speaker efficiency is only part of the equation. Take a 10 watt amp, use 80db/watt/meter efficiency speakers and let's say you get a volume of "10," just to use an easy number for reference.

Take that same 10 watt amp, use 90db/watt/meter efficient speakers and you've just doubled your volume--now that volume is ""20" rather than "10."

Take that same 10 watt amp, use a 100db/watt/meter efficient speaker and your 10 watt amp has now tripled your volume to "30."

The human ear is very insensitive, and logarithmic in terms of volume. But this goes both ways, in terms of watts and speaker efficiency.

So in the end, it's a combination of factors. Got a 90db/watt/meter efficient speaker and a 10 watt amp? You'll get the exact same volume with a 100 watt amp and 80db/watt/meter efficient speakers.

Watts and speaker sensitivity are interrelated. It doesn't do much good to make generalizations about speaker sensitivity without specifying the watts driving it.

Best,

John

John, Thank you sincerely for your thoughts and attempt to help.

However, when you go from 80 db to 100db/w/m efficiency, you quadruple volume, not triple it. But no matter...

I have expressed the fundamentals of my quest all for good reason. It is not volume that I am trying to achieve. It is greater dynamics and lower distortion. Those two do follow with greater efficiency. Higher efficiency speakers are said to couple with air better. Whatever the physics are, high efficiency speakers just plain sound much more "live". There are significant gains beyond just volume... Further, they allow a greater selection in amplification too..

Trust me, I already have a plethora of high watt amps and low efficiency speakers, several of which are in the category of "best ever" speakers. All are great sounding speakers in their own right.. like KLH Nines, JBL 250Ti, Ohm F, etc. This is not what I am currently looking to achieve. I already have (or had) that..
 
Jubilee is Tractrix, and it does, indeed, beam. The data is here on AK.

[Somewhere.... ;) ]

Edgarhorns are tractrix and they are awesome, but they beam... oh boy, do they beam.. In the zone... like a set of headphones :yes: If the Jubilees beam like Edgarhorns, then I would have to agree.. I'd likely love them, but they are not what I am looking for. Although I might just have to buy a pair to see.. :D

Now then, those CMCD thingamajobs seem really intriguing.. I must know more....

Are you using stock crossovers?

8" or 6.5" mid driver versions?
 
Last edited:
Now then, those CMCD thingamajobs seem really intriguing.. I must know more....

Are you using stock crossovers?

8" or 6.5" mid driver versions?
Here's the Tech Note:

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/support/getfile.aspx?docid=201&doctype=3

Jack and I both bought the combo waveguides about a year ago. I got the 8" CMCD components, and Jack began working with direct-mounting 104H mids (the midrange opening is small). I got as far as hooking them up with a CX3400 active crossover and getting some preliminary measurements and I believe Jack did similar. About that time, EconoWave took off, and recognizing that this approach would not be mainstream, we shelved the project for later pursuit.

I subsequently acquired the PRX midrange horn and driver, and did preliminary measurements on them, as well. More on that whenever I get back to it.

In the meantime, the QSC combo came available as documented in Chucky's AVS Forum thread. I believe that's what I'd be stacking on Jubliee corner horns, perhaps, or old school JBL 4507 bass bins with 2235H. There's plenty of newer JBL low frequency stuff to play with, as well, differential drive neodymium yada yada.

You can also see that many DIYers are giving up extended bass in favor of high-efficiency woofers and midwoofers combined with compression driver/waveguide HF/VHF for many of the sonic benefits you cite. It's a trend, really: let subs do the low bass and concentrate upon maximum midrange clarity and articulation across the higher bandwidth using modest size mid/high boxes such as Brandon's No Quarters:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1167816

Even for two-channel it makes good sense; the value of multi-subs is well documented from several sources now. Split off the VLF and the rest is more easily accomplished and managed.... :yes:
 
Last edited:
Here's the Tech Note:

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/support/getfile.aspx?docid=201&doctype=3

Jack and I both bought the combo waveguides about a year ago. I got the 8" CMCD components, and Jack began working with direct-mounting 104H mids (the midrange opening is small). I got as far as hooking them up with a CX3400 active crossover and getting some preliminary measurements and I believe Jack did similar. About that time, EconoWave took off, and recognizing that this approach would not be mainstream, we shelved the project for later pursuit.

I subsequently acquired the PRX midrange horn and driver, and did preliminary measurements on them, as well. More on that whenever I get back to it.

In the meantime, the QSC combo came available as documented in Chucky's AVS Forum thread. I believe that's what I'd be stacking on Jubliee corner horns, perhaps, or old school JBL 4507 bass bins with 2235H. There's plenty of newer JBL low frequency stuff to play with, as well, differential drive neodymium yada yada.

You can also see that many DIYers are giving up extended bass in favor of high-efficiency woofers and midwoofers combined with compression driver/waveguide HF/VHF for many of the sonic benefits you cite. It's a trend, really: let subs do the low bass and concentrate upon maximum midrange clarity and articulation across the higher bandwidth using modest size mid/high boxes such as Brandon's No Quarters:

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1167816

Even for two-channel it makes good sense; the value of multi-subs is well documented from several sources now. Split off the VLF and the rest is more easily accomplished and managed.... :yes:

This makes a lot of sense to me.

I have been playing with 2226h (98db) in 4507 boxes and really liking it. I topped that with 4612OK and it makes for a 98db setup that really has alot going for it.. To improve it, I'd mod the crossover for 2404H instead of 2404H-1... In any case, this setup has confirmed to me the direction I want to go..

Also, bought some 15" Tannoys.. nice, but not far enough along my path...

There's a pair of Edgar 350 Hz on their way for some trials as well.. I have never heard them in my system..

Going to try the 4Pi setup soon too..

Next up, following all of that, I have a set of Unity Horns in waiting.. very much along the lines of the QSC/JBL CMCD idea, in a sense..

Now add in the CMCD, add in another 5 db or so efficiency and this should be pretty special..

This perhaps added with a HE LF setup.. perhaps the Jubilee.. :yes:

I am in. Keep it coming...
 

Attachments

  • DSC02669.jpg
    DSC02669.jpg
    81.8 KB · Views: 28
  • DSC02668.jpg
    DSC02668.jpg
    88.5 KB · Views: 26
Last edited:
I have been playing with 2226h (98db) in 4507 boxes and really liking it. I topped that with 4612OK and it makes for a 98db setup that really has alot going for it..
When I was working on Hamilton's center channel and the Mini 4425s, I measured my 4612Bs. The data's posted somewhere on LHF, probably. Suffice it to say there's plenty of improvement to be made there reworking the filters. Nobody bit.

OTOH, it's 20 years later, and there's improved technology available, e.g., the $6, 6" square PT waveguide will likely fit right in there. Can we find modern woofers to sub for 2118Js with slipped magnets? Do we still need two? I wouldn't be surprised to find we could better the whole deal for less than the cost of a single D16R2405 diaphragm, $140 ea. MSRP, presently.... :yes:
 
When I was working on Hamilton's center channel and the Mini 4425s, I measured my 4612Bs. The data's posted somewhere on LHF, probably. Suffice it to say there's plenty of improvement to be made there reworking the filters. Nobody bit.

OTOH, it's 20 years later, and there's improved technology available, e.g., the $6, 6" square PT waveguide will likely fit right in there. Can we find modern woofers to sub for 2118Js with slipped magnets? Do we still need two? I wouldn't be surprised to find we could better the whole deal for less than the cost of a single D16R2405 diaphragm, $140 ea. MSRP, presently.... :yes:

I'd agree completely. I hear the rolled off highs and peaky midbass response and poor imaging. However, it's dynamic.. man, it's dynamic. Of course, two 8" woofers aren't needed in my use (one only to try to extend bass). I guess in the end, it's really only use is to confirm that in this system, I am trying to get dynamics and efficiency. It was a quickly thrown together system that got the wheels going. I don't seem to have any issues with any of the 2118J's and I have 16 of them (4 pair of 4612OK). The star in this system, without a doubt, is the 2226.

On to the next level... I was going to order the crossovers, waveguides and drivers for QSC SC-2150, but couldn't find the crossovers on-line. Are you using them?
 
Last edited:
Jubilee is Tractrix, and it does, indeed, beam. The data is here on AK.

[Somewhere.... ;) ]

Preface: I am not an engineer, I am not a speaker designer and I am not well versed in some of this technical talk so if I sound a little vague, realize it's similar to you trying to talk to Albert Einstein on the finer points of his theorys while you have only read the cliff notes :D You might get the BIG BIG picture, but that doesn't mean you can articulate a question very well to him directly.

Something about the Jubilee and beaming just wasn't sitting right with me so I asked some of the other guys who know more than I do.

Attached are the polars for the top horn. I'm told that it is a modified Tractrix and Roy (Delgado, who designed it) calls it a constant coverage design since (as I'm told) it is supposed to give good coverage not only in the horizontal but vertical planes.

Perhaps if you understand these graphs more than I do (which is NOT a great leap of faith, trust me :thmbsp:) maybe you can opine as to according to the graph, what makes the horn beamy or perhaps, not beamy?
 

Attachments

I don't know if it would matter to know but we're crossing over electronically at 450hz. I do not know what the acoustic crossover point is... some of this crossover talk is (to me) akin to voodo. :yes:
 
In the vertical, it's holding control at 50° out to 13 kHz, gets narrower, then briefly recovers.

In the horizontal, it's a 100° horn, but the beamwidth effectively collapses to 50° above 13 kHz.

Not an issue insofar as the direct response is concerned, as long as the listener's within the 50° "window," but the sidewall reflections lack "sizzle."

The solution is to damp the early sidewall reflections altogether, but that kills the spaciousness cues....
 
Back
Top Bottom