Whatever the reason is that some people prefer the sound of very efficient speakers, and I can think of various possibilities... it probably isn't low distortion. Unless you need to create very high SPL's in large rooms, it is easier to obtain low distortion if you are willing to sacrifice efficiency.
Of course I cannot speak for others, but for me, high efficiency brings great dynamic range and more of a "live" feeling. I definitely am not looking for high SPL.
Clearly, all loudspeaker designs are trade off decisions. Unfortunately, physics or knowledge have limited our ability to recreate the live sound experience in an acceptable size and price for audio enthusiasts. In my mind, priority is too often set on the lifestyle choice of small size. While it is very often a good commercial choice from the manufacturers perspective, it is likely not as significant a priority to the audio enthusiast.
Further, it is evident to me that often too much priority is set on frequency response. While smooth/flat FR curves are very important, FR is difficult for most people to clearly perceive. It is but one characteristic measurement and perhaps not the most important. For instance, I am fairly confident that flat FR below 35 or 37 hz as well as above 15 Khz is achieved more to meet a specification than it is to satisfy listener satisfaction. Unfortunately, I doubt many of us can hear much above 15Khz.
Just think about it from a designer's point of view: we all know how to build very efficient systems. This technology was conquered in the 50's and 60's. Any educated speaker engineer has studied these designs in great detail. As one tries to push the envelope in other directions... smaller size, lower distortion, deeper bass, wider dispersion, lower cost, etc. ...efficiency is bound to drop. I'm not saying, at all or in any way, that one approach is inherently better than the other. Just that taking things to the max in any one direction means settling for less in other areas.
-k
I agree completely. Technology to build efficient speakers exists and has for many years. It is clearly evident in pro sound. The trade offs may not be acceptable in a home system for a audio enthusiast.
I agree completely that achieving a reasonably accurate, extended FR, that is well dispersed, in a acceptable size for home use while maintaining ultimate efficiency is probably exceeding the limit.
I agree completely, it is all about trade offs. I have several systems. Each of them, basically, is a different set of priorities.
What I am trying to achieve in this system, sacrificing much of the size limitation, is as much of the good stuff above that I can get with an efficiency
approaching 100 db/w/m
That's all I want... for today anyway... :yes: