• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

What is relative efficiency:

In the horizontal, it's a 100° horn, but the beamwidth effectively collapses to 50° above 13 kHz.

Not an issue insofar as the direct response is concerned, as long as the listener's within the 50° "window," but the sidewall reflections lack "sizzle."

Ok, so in general we have a 100 degree horn sitting in a 90 degree corner, right? Fair that it might have most of the coverage significantly taken care of? (up to about 12.9Khz)

Since these are going into corners, do I understand the next part of the graph correctly.... it's a 100 degree horn, falling to about 50 degrees at almost 13K hz but it's only down about 6db's at this junction and this 'hole' (for lack of better word) is only about maybe 4,000 wide) Does this explain why we might be adding some HF equalization to bump this back up? (using a +6db at 13,200 hi shelv)

Let me change my orientation a bit... I would have thought that a "beaming" speaker would have a floodlight type dispersion most everywhere HOWEVER it would have a part that is blazingly focused as a hot spot. What I think I'm inferring from how I see the graph (and I admit I know little about it) coupled to what you have indicated... it would seem that the horn is very well behaved up to about 13K hz and then there is a drop off of about 6db's in the outer (left and right) 20 degrees of the pattern? (90 degree corner less the 50 degrees of coverage, sitting in a corner means 20 degrees on left & 20 degrees on right are down 6 db's?) So, now at this specific area, we have a 50 degree pattern in a 90 degree corner which still covers typical sitting patterns which are ostensibly in the center of the room. Only the walls and inward some are missing this very HF info?

I think part of my confusion is, I interpret 'beaming' to be a focus of sound at a higher intensity. I'm beginning to wonder, given what you said, if beaming is merely relegated to the angle of dispersion and has nothing to do with intensity? Indeed, it seems the output at this level is LESS? I would have always thought focusing the output to a more narrow angle would have increased the output.

This is interesting. You've helped me learn something tonight...not sure exactly what yet but something is clicking in my head! :thmbsp:
 
1) Beamwidth is independent of frequency response. The graphs show the angle at which the response is down 6 dB from whatever it is on axis. We cannot correct directivity issues with EQ. If we bumped up the off-axis VHF response, the on-axis response would go up, too.

2) Intensity is a matter of reference. If you consider the light from the center of the flashlight as the standard, it is "beaming" relative to wherever the intensity is less off-axis. A flashlight beams more than a fluorescent fixture with a diffuser.

3) Toed-in 45°, there are still sidewall reflections in play. The dispersion does not fall off a cliff outside the -6 dB limit. If, however the listener is seated beyond the apex of listening triangle, i.e. outside the point where the left and right axes intersect, the first and strongest lateral reflection comes from the OPPOSITE sidewall, generating spaciousness cues with more on-axis spectral balance.

Draw out your room and plot the locus of the first reflection according to listener location; the rule is "Angle of incidence = angle of reflection...."
 
That is also my understanding. :thmbsp:

Whatever the reason is that some people prefer the sound of very efficient speakers, and I can think of various possibilities... it probably isn't low distortion. Unless you need to create very high SPL's in large rooms, it is easier to obtain low distortion if you are willing to sacrifice efficiency.

Just think about it from a designer's point of view: we all know how to build very efficient systems. This technology was conquered in the 50's and 60's. Any educated speaker engineer has studied these designs in great detail. As one tries to push the envelope in other directions... smaller size, lower distortion, deeper bass, wider dispersion, lower cost, etc. ...efficiency is bound to drop. I'm not saying, at all or in any way, that one approach is inherently better than the other. Just that taking things to the max in any one direction means settling for less in other areas.

-k
 
Whatever the reason is that some people prefer the sound of very efficient speakers, and I can think of various possibilities... it probably isn't low distortion. Unless you need to create very high SPL's in large rooms, it is easier to obtain low distortion if you are willing to sacrifice efficiency.
Of course I cannot speak for others, but for me, high efficiency brings great dynamic range and more of a "live" feeling. I definitely am not looking for high SPL.

Clearly, all loudspeaker designs are trade off decisions. Unfortunately, physics or knowledge have limited our ability to recreate the live sound experience in an acceptable size and price for audio enthusiasts. In my mind, priority is too often set on the lifestyle choice of small size. While it is very often a good commercial choice from the manufacturers perspective, it is likely not as significant a priority to the audio enthusiast.

Further, it is evident to me that often too much priority is set on frequency response. While smooth/flat FR curves are very important, FR is difficult for most people to clearly perceive. It is but one characteristic measurement and perhaps not the most important. For instance, I am fairly confident that flat FR below 35 or 37 hz as well as above 15 Khz is achieved more to meet a specification than it is to satisfy listener satisfaction. Unfortunately, I doubt many of us can hear much above 15Khz.

Just think about it from a designer's point of view: we all know how to build very efficient systems. This technology was conquered in the 50's and 60's. Any educated speaker engineer has studied these designs in great detail. As one tries to push the envelope in other directions... smaller size, lower distortion, deeper bass, wider dispersion, lower cost, etc. ...efficiency is bound to drop. I'm not saying, at all or in any way, that one approach is inherently better than the other. Just that taking things to the max in any one direction means settling for less in other areas.

-k
I agree completely. Technology to build efficient speakers exists and has for many years. It is clearly evident in pro sound. The trade offs may not be acceptable in a home system for a audio enthusiast.

I agree completely that achieving a reasonably accurate, extended FR, that is well dispersed, in a acceptable size for home use while maintaining ultimate efficiency is probably exceeding the limit.

I agree completely, it is all about trade offs. I have several systems. Each of them, basically, is a different set of priorities.

What I am trying to achieve in this system, sacrificing much of the size limitation, is as much of the good stuff above that I can get with an efficiency approaching 100 db/w/m :D

That's all I want... for today anyway... :yes:
 
Last edited:
Further, it is evident to me that often too much priority is set on frequency response. While smooth/flat FR curves are very important, FR is difficult for most people to clearly perceive. It is but one characteristic measurement and perhaps not the most important.
Get the Toole book and read up. It's "Job one," and no design even gets to the gate without it.

Sean Olive's blog:

http://seanolive.blogspot.com/
 
I would think that there are a lot of great-sounding speakers that fall into the "Low Efficiency" category. Especially in the '70's.

My speakers (8 ohms) - rated at 87db (in-room), and yet I can effectively-drive them with 50w each (Not the least bit what I would call "power-hungry"). And they're definitely-not lacking in bass. Oddly enough, their weak-link is the soundstage. They're fine if you're sitting in front of them (or wherever the sweet spot happens to be), but not so-good if you're wandering. The imaging is great though. These aren't Concert Grands or a Paragon system or anything crazy like that (They retailed for around $300 a pair back in '73), but they're certainly not rack speakers. They're just a relatively-simple, medium-sized, boxy pair of speakers from '73.

I would have thought that the huge speakers would have great soundstaging qualities - where you can hear it in the upstairs bathroom. Were you talking about a certain enclosure design, or did you mean in general?
 
Last edited:
"What I am trying to achieve in this system, sacrificing much of the size limitation, is as much of the good stuff above that I can get with an efficiency approaching 100 db/w/m."

Hmmm... I have an extra SPL meter around here, and I could mess around with the "Calibration" trimpot. I bet I could come up with at least 105 dB/W/m out of a 4.5" woofer....

-k


If you set up a pair of
 
Get the Toole book and read up. It's "Job one," and no design even gets to the gate without it.

Sean Olive's blog:

http://seanolive.blogspot.com/

Here's my take on it.. Perhaps I am misguided, but here is what I perceive to be relevant and truthful:

Perhaps, Frequency Response is "job one", but I have heard speakers with pretty flat response that don't sound all that good and ones that the FR wasn't that great that sounded pretty good.

I am not saying it isn't important, but tricks can be and typically are played in the measurement process as well, such as smoothing that can hide some resonances. In other words, +- 3db probably really isn't +-3db without smoothing.

Further, FR does not measure cymblance (sp?), any form of distortion, attack and decay.

In my mind, Frequency Response is but one measurement and it is averaged.. Further, it is the one charachteristic of a speaker that the user can easily address and modify with the use of a EQ of some sort.
 
"What I am trying to achieve in this system, sacrificing much of the size limitation, is as much of the good stuff above that I can get with an efficiency approaching 100 db/w/m."

Hmmm... I have an extra SPL meter around here, and I could mess around with the "Calibration" trimpot. I bet I could come up with at least 105 dB/W/m out of a 4.5" woofer....

-k


If you set up a pair of

Ken,

You are a brilliant designer. You know many times more than what I will ever know about the art and science of speaker design. However, I do know what I hear and what I want to hear.

Perhaps I am not understanding your point, but it seems to me that you are trying to say that all efficient speakers cheat on the specification. Even if they did, relative efficiency from one speaker to another is still very apparent even if the exact efficiency is misstated. It doesn't matter to me if I can get 100 db/w/m efficiency. Hell, I can't even measure it to assure I do. But they surely would be significantly more efficient than say a 85 db/w/m speaker.

For me, as I began this thread, I stated that I was looking for a setup that would not lose many of the good criteria, but could get high (not extreme) efficiency. I am willing to utilize large speakers to get there.

No, I don't want a "horn" or PA sound. I want a pretty "refined" sound, but I also want high relative efficiency and clarity.

I really don't care if it tests great.. I want it to sound great. I currently own many great speakers. Some of them are high, medium and low efficiency. They each have their trade offs.. I get all that. I may not be able to quantify it, but I can hear it..

Surely, you are not saying I cannot get relatively close to my target?

BTW, thank you for your input, even if I don't quite understand what you are trying to say, I do appreciate it.

Dan
 
Cosmos,

Well, really, thanks for the kind words. But, I feel a little guilty, because I was just kidding (mainly myself) with the last comment.

What I believe: the quest for audio bliss is extremely personal, and passionate seekers of it are the lifeblood of the audio world. Each and every time I jump in to a discussion like this, it is when I percieve the need to clarify a technical point that is being discussed. I don't ever argue with preference or goals, because I really have no feelings about them, other than being glad they exist.

So, I might state, as a random example: "The rise time of two woofers of different masses but the same frequency response is the same." But, I would never even think of saying: "Those two woofers sound identical."

My only issue is when listeners somehow become convinced of >physical causes< of what they are hearing, often in social waves and traceable to advertizing. Careful tests are done, a particular cause is ruled out over the years, but the group of listeners doggedly persists in repeating their explaination, instead of just discussing what they hear.

OK, back to your question: as far as I can tell, you are just trying to optimize your speakers for subjective pleasure, along some prioritized paths. That's about the best way to do this in life, so sure, go for it! The only downside to trying to push the envelope ever towards the impossible, is that it can lead to a bad case of serial monogamy: falling in love, but always rethinking the tradeoffs every few months. Good for the biz, though...

-k
 
Perhaps, Frequency Response is "job one", but I have heard speakers with pretty flat response that don't sound all that good and ones that the FR wasn't that great that sounded pretty good.
Of course. It's not the only parameter, merely the first order one. Smooth, flat response does not guarantee sonic quality, but lack of it is well established via controlled listening evaluations as clearly inferior, other factors being equal. See the Voecks interview.

Think how the "pretty good" one might be improved via improving its FR, and how the "pretty flat" one might benefit from identification and correction of its other issues, whatever they might be, responsible for it not sounding all that good. Alas, it's not just a matter of EQ; as example, we can't fix directivity issues with EQ, and there's a high likelihood of messing up other second-order parameters in the attempt, as well....
 
Last edited:
Of course. It's not the only parameter, merely the first order one. Smooth, flat response does not guarantee sonic quality, but lack of it is well established via controlled listening evaluations as clearly inferior, other factors being equal. See the Voecks interview.

Think how the "pretty good" one might be improved via addressing its FR, and how the "pretty flat" one might benefit from identification and correction of its other issues, whatever they might be, responsible for it not sounding all that good. Alas, it's not just a matter of EQ; as example, we can't fix directivity issues with EQ, and there's a high likelihood of messing up other second-order parameters in the attempt, as well....

To add to that Z, the room plays a huge part in all this as well. I have had many speakers in my room and know it fairly well. It was designed and built by an Audio Engineer working for Ford. That being said, I've had speakers that I was just sure that had an issue and then took them outside and poof! the issue is gone. My system has 93db tweets, 115db midhorns and 96db woof horns. I play hell trying to balance that all out but when it is balanced it really rocks. Dan has heard my system many times and can testify that if you move your head three inches either side of center, the image absolutly falls apart. I knew that going in, but didn't mind because I only sit in one spot and the imaging is worth it.
 
Thanks for your input folks. It helps immensely.. far more than you know.

So here is my planned sequence of experimentation:

1. Unity horns with mid-bass drivers. (blame Dave :yes:)
2. Edgarhorns (to establish an imaging baseline)
3. Gedlee Summa
3. CMCD Waveguides and drivers.

To run some tests, I am looking for software...
I already have:

1. True RTA
2. Behringer calibrated mic and pre-amp
3. Behringer DCX-2496

Looking for CLIO and Behringer DEQ-2496. Any other suggestions on measurement devices/software?
 
In the vertical, it's holding control at 50° out to 13 kHz, gets narrower, then briefly recovers.

In the horizontal, it's a 100° horn, but the beamwidth effectively collapses to 50° above 13 kHz.

You call that beaming?!? Yikes :O I certainly don't.

For what it's worth, on a 2" throat the polar response above ~7kHz is mostly dominated by the compression driver's phase plug. There is nothing stopping anyone from changing out the driver to achieve insane design goals.

So what do you recommend that should sound and measure better? I've heard all the JBL horns posted thus far in this thread and they don't come remotely close.
 
Last edited:
To run some tests, I am looking for software...
I already have:

1. True RTA
2. Behringer calibrated mic and pre-amp
3. Behringer DCX-2496

Looking for CLIO and Behringer DEQ-2496. Any other suggestions on measurement devices/software?

REW is free and a very powerful tool. I actually prefer it to Praxis and Smaart which are both very expensive, although sometimes you have to be creative to work around REW's limitations.
http://www.hometheatershack.com/roomeq/

Arta is another mostly free tool (the free version doesn't let you save):
http://www.fesb.hr/~mateljan/arta/index.htm

And then there is also Speaker Workshop:
http://www.speakerworkshop.com/
 
You call that beaming?!? Yikes :O I certainly don't.

For what it's worth, on a 2" throat the polar response above ~7kHz is mostly dominated by the compression driver's phase plug. There is nothing stopping anyone from changing out the driver to achieve insane design goals.

So what do you recommend that should sound and measure better? I've heard all the JBL horns posted thus far in this thread and they don't come remotely close.
The design is a 3-way. Take away the VHF horn and (1"?) driver and it's no surprise the directivity is compromised in the last octave.

If the objective (and claim) is constant directivity with concomitant uniform power response, then the horizontal beamwidth collapsing to 50% of spec at high frequencies is clearly "beaming;" we're back in Altec sectoral radial horn territory.

Indeed, you can't get there (directivity control in the top octave) with a 2" throat horn or waveguide.

JBL Pro routinely meets its beamwidth specs across the board with biradial horns and PT waveguides:

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/support/getfile.aspx?doctype=3&docid=1078

http://www.jblpro.com/catalog/support/getfile.aspx?doctype=3&docid=1384

There are plenty of enthusiasts who believe Tractrix is the bee's knees; seems like Cosmos isn't one of them, however.

If you want to talk about how stuff sounds, then we need to move up to JBL Synthesis for comparing apples.... ;)
 
Last edited:
The design is a 3-way.

I don't mean to butt in here but what is? (only asking because I don't know if you're referring to the JBL's which I know little about or the Jubilee which is being used as a 2-way but shown on the Klipsch site as a 3-way)
 
Back
Top Bottom