• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

June 3rd Led Zeppelin

There is no "volume war" , "loudness war", "dynamic range" issues with these remasters.....
These remasters have been extremely well done to retain the original "feel" of the album while bringing a bit of fidelity to it.
My vinyl sounds fat and dynamic......as do the HD versions, although I would say they have EQ'd the vinyl differently, the bass in general is more forward, but in a nice way....

I have the super deluxe issues, and the HD tracks, and it all sounds absolutely brilliant....

There is, and always will be "tape saturation" and "buss squash" on Led Zeppelin II, that is how they mixed the album back in 1969, it was the intention to mix it like that, its brings excitement and tension to the music....
If you guys are hearing this as distortion, then perhaps you don't really like Led Zeppelin, and maybe some Steely Dan might suit you better?

Al Stewart is bright and fluffy...:music:

To be fair maybe the $24.00 LP's are not the same as we have in the box sets.
The ones I have are first press and pressed in Germany.
 
Hopefully they didnt rush copies to meet demand. I have original copies of the LP and they sound thin, best sounding copy I have of II is an old cassette from the seventies although the songs that were redone for the 1990 boxset sound really nice. I guess I will try another copy just to be sure mine didnt come from a bad batch. (I have a copy the the orig CD from the 80s, that copy is just pathetic). If the next copy is the same way then I guess my only other option will be to bite the bullet and spend a Benjamin on a RL pressing next Christmas.
I just listened to a couple of tunes of LZ I remastered CD and that is a much better remaster. Maybe I should of just ordered CD copies of both. I will now download the MP3 versions that were included with my purchase and do a comparison.

What are your Matrix #s in the dead wax?
Also on the lable where was it manufactured?
Does it also have John D. in the dead wax?
 
What are your Matrix #s in the dead wax?
Also on the lable where was it manufactured?
Does it also have John D. in the dead wax?

I get where you're coming from, but to be hoenst I can't imagine there would be "that" much difference in quality and sound, it sounds pretty extreme.....
The Master is the Master.....
just like this damn RL nonsense......Bob Ludwig mastered Led Zeppelin II Period....
It doesn't matter if it had RL or not in the dead wax, it is still a Bob Ludwig master.....
What does matter is the generation of the master used to make the pressing.....and of course the plant it was pressed in and whether its a first pressing or a subsequent pressing later on.....
I have many Led Zeppelin pressings and there are good and bad on all accounts...
I have a locally pressed Led Zeppelin II which sounds better than a RL LZII pressing......
So its horses for courses, and of course people may have different opinions and theories, but I am basing my opinions on my own experiences...

Summary, I find it difficult to believe there can be that much difference..
 
Didnt meant to offend anyone

I think anyone who drops $50 on a couple of Zep reissues even though they already have dozens of copies of their stuff qualifies as a real Zeppelin fan. I understand perfectly the issue of dealing with the original recording, I was hoping for a vinyl pressing that brings out the best of that recording but my copy just didnt do it for me, I prefer the thin sounding old worn copies I have (ticks pops scratches and all) over the new pressing . I hope I have a bad copy but am starting to think I should send it back and get a CD remaster instead. The guys who handled the pressings after RL handed them over ruined one of the greatest sessions in rock history.
 
Last edited:
4-2-7 deadwax info

Mine has P.USA R1-535225 -27805- JD. Funny thing is on the lable it has Manfactured in Germany in print, but in dead was P.USA. Let me know if anyone else has a copy with simular dead wax info. Also the stamped info in the dead wax appear to be very hard to read and uneven even with magnifying glass(compared to other records I have looked at)., Maybe mine was made with some bad vinyl
 
Last edited:
There is no "volume war" , "loudness war", "dynamic range" issues with these remasters.....
These remasters have been extremely well done to retain the original "feel" of the album while bringing a bit of fidelity to it.
My vinyl sounds fat and dynamic......as do the HD versions, although I would say they have EQ'd the vinyl differently, the bass in general is more forward, but in a nice way....

I have the super deluxe issues, and the HD tracks, and it all sounds absolutely brilliant....

There is, and always will be "tape saturation" and "buss squash" on Led Zeppelin II, that is how they mixed the album back in 1969, it was the intention to mix it like that, its brings excitement and tension to the music....
If you guys are hearing this as distortion, then perhaps you don't really like Led Zeppelin, and maybe some Steely Dan might suit you better?

Or maybe we've not had decent gear for the last thirty years. Good gear tends to bring out flaws in source material.
I play junk records on my bedroom system so I don't have to listen to as much surface noise. It more closely relates to the stuff I've owned in the past.
Tell ya what, I have an early pressing of 2, I'll clean it up as best I can (grade, poor) and see if this same distortion is there. From a previous comparison I can tell ya this, the new one is much louder.
 
Or maybe we've not had decent gear for the last thirty years. Good gear tends to bring out flaws in source material.
I play junk records on my bedroom system so I don't have to listen to as much surface noise. It more closely relates to the stuff I've owned in the past.
Tell ya what, I have an early pressing of 2, I'll clean it up as best I can (grade, poor) and see if this same distortion is there. From a previous comparison I can tell ya this, the new one is much louder.

I don't think the remaster is that much louder, yeah sure it is louder, but it most most certainly not the source of the distortion being talked about.....

Yeah, be interested so see what you find.......
 
My old original mint LZ II I bought new has "RL" on side 1, "LH" (Lee Hulko) side 2. Supposedly there was a problem with the original side 2 RL (jumping groove on some players?) so LH re-did it. :scratch2:
 
My new LZII is much louder, it is as loud at 9 o'clock setting as my orig version plays at 10:30 on the dial. Onkyo TA-8700 currently is in rotation, for reference. I cant stay in the room with anything close to 11 o'clock on the dial as the room is only 9x11.
 
Mine has P.USA R1-535225 -27805- JD. Funny thing is on the lable it has Manfactured in Germany in print, but in dead was P.USA. Let me know if anyone else has a copy with simular dead wax info. Also the stamped info in the dead wax appear to be very hard to read and uneven even with magnifying glass(compared to other records I have looked at)., Maybe mine was made with some bad vinyl

LZ I Deluxe Print, 9,618/30,000

LZ I Remasterd Vinyl, German Pressing, Masterd by John D.
Side one R1-535224 - A1
Side two R1-535224 - B1
Ok that's a German First Press

LZ 1 Live Vinyl, German Pressing, Mastered by Jonh D
Side One R1-536123-A2
Side two R1-536123-B2
Side three R1-536123-C2
Side four R1-536123-D2
German second pressing?


LZ II Deluxe Print, 29,051 / 30,000

LZ II Remasterd Vinyl,German Pressing, Mastrered by John D

Side one R1-535225- A1
Side two R1- 535225- B1
First German Press

LZ II Companion Disc, German Pressing, Mastered by John D.
Side one Ri-536180- A1
Side two R1-536180- B1
First German Press

Box LZ III , I have not opend yet


Hi Dan I am in Australia

I believe you have the Super Deluxe set which has seperate original lp and companion lp as well as the cd's etc.

The Deluxe vinyl sets come in a tri-fold gatefold without limited pressing no.

Led Zep II - Deluxe vinyl - manfactured in Germany.

Barcode: 081227964368
label - R1-535341 - ORIGINAL LP
run out groove - BD-16358-01-A1 A1 JD
BD-16358-01-B1

label R1 536182 - COMPANION
run out groove - BE-40837-01-A1 A1
BE-40837-01-B1

there is talk on Hoffman that not all pressings were done at Pallas and some were done at Optimal in Germany as well. US release looks like Pallas and EU Optimal perhaps when you look at the run out grooves on each release.
 
Right off the bat I don't care for this bonus disc version of Whole Lotta Love.
I didn't listen to the rest of this clip as I don't care to hear different versions of the classics.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WI6pnOG67qg

I loved it and it actually sounded more real. I used to work a lot with bands and listen to the practis and live events. When their album would come out it sounded nothing like them. Too much studio manipulation of the real sound the band produces.

PS: go listen @ 28.30 of the vid and tell me you don't like that jam. It's like Zep meets Marshall Tucker lol.
 
Last edited:
^^^^^^^
No doubt Page and company picked the correct "version" for the original Led Zeppelin II.
Out takes and alternate versions are usually just that, curios.
Some find that stuff interesting:)
 
^^^^^^^
No doubt Page and company picked the correct "version" for the original Led Zeppelin II.
Out takes and alternate versions are usually just that, curios.
Some find that stuff interesting:)

Yeah none of the cuts are new it's just all an evolution. Lay tape down and pick bits a pieces of all to make something you hope others will like.

I love the last song I keep playing it over and over, like a kid lol.
 
I loved it and it actually sounded more real. I used to work a lot with bands and listen to the practis and live events. When their album would come out it sounded nothing like them. Too much studio manipulation of the real sound the band produces.

PS: go listen @ 28.30 of the vid and tell me you don't like that jam. It's like Zep meets Marshall Tucker lol.

Same situation here, I love the extras, a real insight into the workings of the songs, I love the LZII outtakes.....
I am a guitarist and as a musician, these cuts are really interesting to me....

I really like for instance Out on the Tiles from the LZIII outtakes, really nice just hearing the rhythm section pounding it out with no overdubs and vocals....
the guitar and bass growling away is the most incredible sound.......

My go to format is actually the HD Tracks downloads I have......they sound better than the vinyl by a long shot.....to me anyway....
 
As far as I know all the Pallas-pressed LPs have "P USA" in the deadwax. Apparently they are technically/officially made by Pallas USA, but the actual pressing plant is in Germany. That's what the Steve Hoffman folks are saying.

It also appears to be generally, though apparently not universally, true that the US is getting Pallas, and Canada and EU are getting Optimal. Four of the 7 LPs in my Super Deluxes are clearly marked Pallas. The other three (LZ I bonus LPs, and LZ II main LP) are not and therefore appear to be Optimal. I will have to double check, though.

All 7 of mine appear nice and flat.
 
As far as I know all the Pallas-pressed LPs have "P USA" in the deadwax. Apparently they are technically/officially made by Pallas USA, but the actual pressing plant is in Germany. That's what the Steve Hoffman folks are saying.

It also appears to be generally, though apparently not universally, true that the US is getting Pallas, and Canada and EU are getting Optimal. Four of the 7 LPs in my Super Deluxes are clearly marked Pallas. The other three (LZ I bonus LPs, and LZ II main LP) are not and therefore appear to be Optimal. I will have to double check, though.

All 7 of mine appear nice and flat.

I forgot to mention the Pallas-pressed LPs have "P USA" in the deadwax.

Mine are flat as well and I thought they where heavier than 180g but they are 180g.
 
Alright, I said I'd try out my old Zep II vs the new one. It's still a disaster post cleaning, but thru the surface noise I could hear some of the same distortion.
I gotta' wonder if by cleaning it up the way they did it just made it easier to hear any artifacts made in the original mix.

Judging by my "calibrated" volume knob, I'd say the new ones got approximately 3dB over the old, so that's not too much louder. May have been a issue with my spare table. That old copy's never gonna' see the good TT again.
 
So does anyone know which copies the radio stations play? Almost every song from II that is played on the radio sounds better than the copies I have.
 
OK. After reading this thread, and being a LZ fan, I had to finally try one of these out. Decided to start at the beginning so Led Zeppelin it is, the deluxe cd version. I was pleasantly surprised to find it for only €15. I'm listening to it right now. For the first listen I chose to rip to flac and use headphones, and to listen back to back song by song with the 1994 remaster.

I'm using Amarok as a player and it has a primitive spectrum analyzer to check out levels. My headphones aren't the best, just a pair of Sennheiser HD 280 Pro. Sound card is an Asus Xonar Essence STX with the original op-amps.

My biggest fear was overblown compression (like the 2011 DSOTM that I can't listen to without throwing up) and can immediately put that dog to rest. At first I thought that the new version was a little dull compared to the '92 till I flipped back and forth on Good Times/bad Times several times and realized that while a few peaks are higher than the '94 overall (to my ears) it's actually just a tad lower overall in volume, with the exception of Black Mountain Side, which to me is slightly louder.

I find it interesting that some are finding the new remaster to be louder on vinyl. I believe the cd to be overall a bit quieter in comparison to the '94 CD remaster. I don't have any older CDs to compare and gave all of my vinyl to my son.

The second thing that I notice is that the '94 remaster had just a bit more reverb overall than this new one. This new remaster is also cleaner overall, I can turn up the volume more without it becoming harsh or painfull for my old ears. I'll probably have to go out and buy the next 2 now.

I think that now it's time to go out front and fire up the Speakerlabs and see what they and the neighbors think. Beer should be cold by now.

Cheers,
James
 
Back
Top Bottom