• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

MC2505 catastrophe

Maybe someone can figure out the date code, they physically look like they are of recent manufacture--this pair was purchased maybe 2 years ago-- life has gotten in the way, and now am fired up about getting mine back into service.
I wonder what a difference the increase in capacitance will make....

MAC sold you new caps made the 3rd week of 2019.

Increasing from 9300uF to 15,000uF isn’t likely to make any difference, other than increasing inrush current. The MAC engineering dept factored this into the power supply design as capacitors had a wide tolerance back in the 1960s. The 2505 was a high end product of its era. Unless the original GE 9300uf caps were diminished in performance, you shouldn’t hear any difference vs the new 15,000uf CDEs. It would be interesting to see a scope reading of both caps for comparison.

The below video test is interesting but note the amp is a budget design:

 
Last edited:
Thanks Monk :)
3rd week of 2019...
So if I remember correctly-- I bought these sometime around mid 2021...
I

Now that Benz has seen what they look like, and seems date of manufacture is ok, that will help him with his decision....

I have a Siglent scope and AWG etc -- but nothing is set up ... right now, and my knowledge is limited...
Hopefully I can find some time to really devote to getting my bench set up semi workable etc ...

I just think it's pretty remarkable that McIntosh still supports products of this era.

Thanks again for your input.
 
I've reached out to the McIntosh Labs parts dept via the website and enquired about availability. Will see what they say!
 
I've reached out to the McIntosh Labs parts dept via the website and enquired about availability. Will see what they say!

Awesome-- didn't think of using their website -- I always just call.

And thanks Monk, for the link to the vid -- very interesting, smart guy for sure, watched him before.
A few times re-watching will instill some more insight for me. :)

Off to get some coffee --
Best to everyone - gotta make this a productive day.
 
MAC sold you new caps made the 3rd week of 2019.

Increasing from 9300uF to 15,000uF isn’t likely to make any difference, other than increasing inrush current. The MAC engineering dept factored this into the power supply design as capacitors had a wide tolerance back in the 1960s. The 2505 was a high end product of its era. Unless the original GE 9300uf caps were diminished in performance, you shouldn’t hear any difference vs the new 15,000uf CDEs. It would be interesting to see a scope reading of both caps for comparison.

The below video test is interesting but note the amp is a budget design:


I too have to believe that if McIntosh is recommending / selling these as replacements, they are compatible.

Most likely during the design the original 9300uF were "enough" filtering, anything higher would have taken even more space and wasn't necessary. If McIntosh says adding 60% to the original design is fine I'd go with it (and it's still not a crazy increase).
 
I too have to believe that if McIntosh is recommending / selling these as replacements, they are compatible.

Most likely during the design the original 9300uF were "enough" filtering, anything higher would have taken even more space and wasn't necessary. If McIntosh says adding 60% to the original design is fine I'd go with it (and it's still not a crazy increase).

Totally agree With the Saturation Point :) ---
In fact I think this was a special deal w/ cornell D -- to manufacture these caps specific, not available elsewhere. (thinking about what I've read, although many moons ago)
I tried to find these caps elsewhere -- No
If McIntosh is gonna sell it - they KNOW.

Input greatly appreciated...
Celadon
 
Note that most if not all MC2505 headphone jacks are wired right to tip, the opposite of modern headphones. The left tip industry standard didn't appear until 1975. I don't know if the MAC factory changed the headphone jack wiring in later production 2505s.

I rewired my 1972 2505 to make the headphone channels "correct" with the modern standard.

Here is a video that shows how to rewire the headphone jack on a 2105, the sister amp of the 2505.

 
Note that most if not all MC2505 headphone jacks are wired right to tip, the opposite of modern headphones. The left tip industry standard didn't appear until 1975. I don't know if the MAC factory changed the headphone jack wiring in later production 2505s.

I rewired my 1972 2505 to make the headphone channels "correct" with the modern standard.

Here is a video that shows how to rewire the headphone jack on a 2105, the sister amp of the 2505.

I didn't know that, very interesting. I don't generally use headphones but might just correct it on mine as well. It would bother me on an album like DSOTM...

EDIT: excellent vid, I actually started watching the series, part 2 covers the replacement of power supply caps in a MC2105. Very well presented and informative.
 
Last edited:
From October 1975 issue of High Fidelity Magazine, page 32.

"Headphones--At Last--To Be Standard

The Institute of High Fidelity has issued its standard IHF - 201, covering stereo and quadraphonic headphones. While much of the industry has been moving in the direction of the specifics laid down therein, a good many pieces of equipment in use in home systems today don't conform to it. Which is why we wish such a standard had been available long since.

The key provision is that the tip element of headphone plugs shall carry the left-channel signal. At one time manufacturers of headphones and of equipment with standard headphone jacks were divided about 50-50 on this point, meaning that you had only about an even chance that you could plug your set into your receiver without finding the channels reversed. Or having to wear the left earpiece on the right ear—unimportant when earpieces were symmetrical front-to-back, but many aren't today."


10806188-F12D-4EA0-9475-DBE6CB482C65.jpeg
 
Ok, so I heard back from McIntosh labs. They have a replacement cap for the old 9300uF, the new one is a Cornell Dubilier 06640500 15000uF / 75VDC, same as the ones being referred to here: https://audiokarma.org/forums/index...-capacitor-replacement-part-sub.915947/page-2 . They sell them for $120USD apiece. With conversion to CAD + shipping, they would run me about $360CAD. They are "recent" as per the response I got.

I also found this on Mouser: https://www.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Cornell-Dubilier-CDE/DCM932U050BH2A?qs=/ha2pyFadugnMBv44SuvFfKVxtZtdF5q%2BUhCcWkWIV4CYdcsdlMzKA== . Much cheaper at $35USD. The dimensions are correct and they are 9300uF / 50VDC (identical specs to the originals). 2 potential issues: they are rated at 1,000hrs only, and the leads are closer together, 22.23mm vs approx. 29mm (OEM) so would require drilling new holes in the chassis.
 
Tough call, but it's your call.

I'd prefer the ones McIntosh is selling with the correct spacing to avoid altering the chassis, but the additional $300? Woof! Still, what's your enjoyment and happiness worth and it should be a one-time purchase.
 
Ok, so I heard back from McIntosh labs. They have a replacement cap for the old 9300uF, the new one is a Cornell Dubilier 06640500 15000uF / 75VDC, same as the ones being referred to here: https://audiokarma.org/forums/index...-capacitor-replacement-part-sub.915947/page-2 . They sell them for $120USD apiece. With conversion to CAD + shipping, they would run me about $360CAD. They are "recent" as per the response I got.

I also found this on Mouser: https://www.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Cornell-Dubilier-CDE/DCM932U050BH2A?qs=/ha2pyFadugnMBv44SuvFfKVxtZtdF5q%2BUhCcWkWIV4CYdcsdlMzKA== . Much cheaper at $35USD. The dimensions are correct and they are 9300uF / 50VDC (identical specs to the originals). 2 potential issues: they are rated at 1,000hrs only, and the leads are closer together, 22.23mm vs approx. 29mm (OEM) so would require drilling new holes in the chassis.

The 1,000 hour at 85C rating of both those modern CDE DCM filter caps is really underwhelming. Compare them to this Vishay BC Components filter cap rated a 20,000 hours at 85C. MAL210618103E3 https://www.newark.com/vishay/mal210618103e3/electrolytic-capacitor-106-ped/dp/27T2831.

Of course the CDE can that MAC sells is the correct oddball physicall size which is really the only selling point. If you buy the Mouser version of the CDE cap, it's less expensive and probably chemically the same as the MAC version, but with different terminal spacing.

In reality those main filter caps probably never see more than 40C of radiated heat from the power transformer, even in a wood cabinet, so you likely can de-rate the 1,000 at 85C and end up with 16,000+ hours at 40C for the CDEs.

Still, it makes you wonder if the CDE filters will be as robust at the original 1960s GE cans. I wish MAC would contract out their next custom batch of filter cans with Vishay BC Components instead of CDE.

Does anyone have a vintage data sheet for the original GE 9300 uF filter cans that have proven to be very long-lasting?
 
Last edited:
Me -- I wouldn't be drilling or modifying or drilling my chassis -- yikes!
=-=-=-=-=

Came across the receipt for the filter caps -- purchased 3/23/2021.
SO -- I feel I have done well, although I did see the bill for all the lamps I bought.... ahem.... but -- you get what you pay for.

*** I also found the original filter caps today -- and was very surprized at what I found ---
the cap that had physically leaked, (which I had thought did the puke thing like most electrolytics), but upon closer inspection the actual "bakelite" black portion on the bottom has physically cracked --- in three directions from one of the screw connections! ****
Tried to get a pic, but need to find a grease pencil so the cracks show in a pic ---- definately will try
These caps had not been out of the amp-- since around 2006 -- I had pulled them, since then...
Overtightening on my part... maybe ? maybe not.

In any event-- I am kinda on a roll here with this amp -- and although, so many other unenjoyable things are taking my time now --- too bad, finding my tools...
So not as to muck up Benz thread -- I have a few things going on I will make my own post for -- hopefully soon.

Best - and the success stories roll on .

~C
 
Last edited:
Tough call, but it's your call.

I'd prefer the ones McIntosh is selling with the correct spacing to avoid altering the chassis, but the additional $300? Woof! Still, what's your enjoyment and happiness worth and it should be a one-time purchase.
Price is causing me to pause to an extent, but I’m not inclined to modify the chassis to save $$ either so I’m in a quandary at the moment.
The 1,000 hour at 85C rating of both those modern CDE DCM filter caps is really underwhelming. Compare them to this Vishay BC Components filter cap rated a 20,000 hours at 85C. MAL210618103E3 https://www.newark.com/vishay/mal210618103e3/electrolytic-capacitor-106-ped/dp/27T2831.

Of course the CDE can that MAC sells is the correct oddball physicall size which is really the only selling point. If you buy the Mouser version of the CDE cap, it's less expensive and probably chemically the same as the MAC version, but with different terminal spacing.

In reality those main filter caps probably never see more than 40C of radiated heat from the power transformer, even in a wood cabinet, so you likely can de-rate the 1,000 at 85C and end up with 16,000+ hours at 40C for the CDEs.

Still, it makes you wonder if the CDE filters will be as robust at the original 1960s GE cans. I wish MAC would contract out their next custom batch of filter cans with Vishay BC Components instead of CDE.

Does anyone have a vintage data sheet for the original GE 9300 uF filter cans that have proven to be very long-lasting?
The more I read, the less interested I become in these new caps. I found a few bits of info on re-stuffing the big caps and I’ve not (yet) discarded that possibility. This would allow me to select quality caps with good specs.
Me -- I wouldn't be drilling or modifying or drilling my chassis -- yikes!

=-=-=-=-=

Came across the receipt for the filter caps -- purchased 3/23/2021.

SO -- I feel I have done well, although I did see the bill for all the lamps I bought.... ahem.... but -- you get what you pay for.

*** I also found the original filter caps today -- and was very surprized at what I found ---

the cap that had physically leaked, (which I had thought did the puke thing like most electrolytics), but upon closer inspection the actual "bakelite" black portion on the bottom has physically cracked --- in three directions from one of the screw connections! ****

Tried to get a pic, but need to find a grease pencil so the cracks show in a pic ---- definately will try

These caps had not been out of the amp-- since around 2006 -- I had pulled them, since then...

Overtightening on my part... maybe ? maybe not.

In any event-- I am kinda on a roll here with this amp -- and although, so many other unenjoyable things are taking my time now --- too bad, finding my tools...

So not as to muck up Benz thread -- I have a few things going on I will make my own post for -- hopefully soon.

Best - and the success stories roll on .

~C
I’m also not keen on making modifications to the chassis as mentioned above…

I took another close look at the big caps with a magnifier and I see no cracks at all, nor any evidence of leaks. They also test good as mentioned previously. One option would be to keep them in and replace them down the road if they go bad since they’re extremely easy to replace. I haven’t decided yet and re-stuffing could be another option.
 
Update:

I received the first batch of parts; as indicated previously I kept the list short at this time as my primary focus is to fix the issue before ordering more. I’m fine if this project takes a little while as I’m in no rush.

For the time being, I got replacements for C11-12, C34, C 35-36. I tested them and capacitance ranges from -12.5% to -5%, which is within the +/-20% tolerance which I assume is fine. ESR looks good on all of them as expected. Note that I decided to get 3-post strips vs. the 2-posters that Monk suggested. My thinking is that I may be able to ground the caps via the middle posts as they will be attached via the C34 mounting bolts (which I assume can act as ground). I will draw up a basic schematic/mock-up and will post it here to get your thoughts before proceeding.

My first step will be to install the 2 caps for C34, and then test with a BDT which I will build. I don’t have a ton of free time this week so this will once again be a weekend project. If the issue is resolved (fingers crossed) then I will move on to C11-12 and C35-36, and test again. Next after that will be other caps (i.e. tropical fish, input board and likely the C33 multi can from CE).

20230510_052414.jpg

Digikey parts list A.jpg
 
Last edited:
Update:

I received the first batch of parts; as indicated previously I kept the list short at this time as my primary focus is to fix the issue before ordering more. I’m fine if this project takes a little while as I’m in no rush.

For the time being, I got replacements for C11-12, C34, C 35-36. I tested them and capacitance ranges from -12.5% to -5%, which is within the +/-20% tolerance which I assume is fine. ESR looks good on all of them as expected. Note that I decided to get 3-post strips vs. the 2-posters that Monk suggested. My thinking is that I may be able to ground the caps via the middle posts as they will be attached via the C34 mounting bolts (which I assume can act as ground). I will draw up a basic schematic/mock-up and will post it here to get your thoughts before proceeding.

My first step will be to install the 2 caps for C34, and then test with a BDT which I will build. I don’t have a ton of free time this week so this will once again be a weekend project. If the issue is resolved (fingers crossed) then I will move on to C11-12 and C35-36, and test again. Next after that will be other caps (i.e. tropical fish, input board and likely the C33 multi can from CE).

Very :)cool!
Looking forward to your progress
 
Getting ready for the weekend project. I have a variac on the way and will build a DBT. The plan is to mount the 3-post strips to the C34 mounting bolts as Monk had suggested. I screwed them on temporarily and it looks like there will be enough space (just!) to accommodate the 470uF and 220uF caps between the strips. I drew up a few mock-ups on my ipad (not pretty, but clear enough hopefully), and am very open to thoughts / suggestions. Note that the caps are positioned in opposite direction to each other in order to accommodate the existing wiring lengths in the amp. Also note that the white/black wire goes to a post that is bolted to the chassis.

Original configuration:
20230425_181014(zoom).jpg

IMG_0350.PNG

IMG_0351.PNG

IMG_0352.PNG
 
Getting ready for the weekend project. I have a variac on the way and will build a DBT. The plan is to mount the 3-post strips to the C34 mounting bolts as Monk had suggested. I screwed them on temporarily and it looks like there will be enough space (just!) to accommodate the 470uF and 220uF caps between the strips. I drew up a few mock-ups on my ipad (not pretty, but clear enough hopefully), and am very open to thoughts / suggestions. Note that the caps are positioned in opposite direction to each other in order to accommodate the existing wiring lengths in the amp. Also note that the white/black wire goes to a post that is bolted to the chassis.

Original configuration:
View attachment 2884241

View attachment 2884242

View attachment 2884243

View attachment 2884244


@Benz - I think your proposed wiring diagrams may be incorrect.

The marking on the outside of the C34 can (which I've outlined in yellow) appears to indicate the "nothing / dash" terminal (with the single white / black wire) is "Comm Pos." If so, that means this terminal is Common Positive.

Looking at the schematic below, I've highlighted C34 in red, and the half moon and triangle terminals appear to both be negative.

If my observations are correct, it appears to me that the positive leads of the new 470 uF and 220 uF axial capacitors would need to both connect with the single white / black "Comm Pos" wire. And the negative lead of the new 220 uF cap would connect to the white / green wire. And the negative lead of the new 470 uF cap would connect to the three purple wires.

We need to get some more Akers eyes on this. Am I right or wrong in this wiring analysis?

Also, I wouldn't use the center lug on the terminal strips as they are connected to the can bolts. By not using that center lug on the terminal strip you disarm the future (remote) chance the original can cap might degrade internally and a disconnected section shorts to the can (and thus to the center terminal strip lug). That's why I recommended Keystone 810 instead of 809. :)


common.jpg

8.jpg
 
Last edited:
@Benz - I've sketched out this diagram to show what I believe may be the correct approach for C34. Need to get other Akers to review and weigh in. Am I right or wrong in my analysis of the can markings and schematic?

IMG_9667.jpeg
 
Last edited:
OK ---
I mentioned polarity, because when I first bought this amp -- I listened to it at theguys house for a while -- everything seemed ok.
Went home and pulled the bottom. One of the 2 caps you are replacing had been bypassed with an axial underneath -- Looking like it was ready to explode!
Following the lead of whoever had done THAT work, I ordered a couple replacements -- installed the same polarity as previous rework and same thing good for a short time and swell up again.
That's when it went off to Dewickt -- and I think it was because the cap was installed backward.
Don't know if this helps -- but I wonder if I had known to reverse polarity on that cap, if I would have had to send it off .... I think it was the larger of the 2 values, if I remember.

And Monk's Thought on my cap being wired " term only" -- has prompted me to rewire w/ the cap completely out -- and clean up that ugly wire mess of mine...
 
Back
Top Bottom