• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

PoultrygeistI. That's good to know about the Magnovox amp. I have a pair of Dayton DT 250 P-8 compression drivers with the 5"X10"" waveguides I could use. I'm now using one with the Zenith speaker cabinet.The Dayton driver is really efficient so I used a L Pad to dial in the volume to match the Zenith. Also the Dayton plays down to around 1200 HZ. I used two 8uf caps to make a 16 uf cross over It sounds pretty good to me. There is no denying that the Zeniths have great mid range capabilities but I do think I'll miss the deep bass that the Advents provide. I'm not crazy about using a sub. Any opinions? Curt

This is what you need to pair with the Zeniths for bass augmentation: The efficient and high Qts Eminence Alpha 15A is no doubt the most popular OB woofer. They're priced around $59 and fill in the bass that a full range driver struggles with. OB speakers companies like Emerald Physics, PureAudio. Spatial etc have used them. The much loved Augie from Hawthorne ( RIP ) is a modified 15A.

290-407_ALT_0.jpg
 
The popular Alpair 12's are not cheap at over $300 for two. While I'd like to try them I would not swap my budget Zeniths for a pair. I once owned the expensive Tang Band 1808's as used in the gorgeous PureAudio OB's and loved their smoothness and refinement but they ended up being a bit too laid back for my tastes. At 93dbs they are slightly more efficient than the Alpair 12's but my 2a3 SET had barely enough power to drive them ( not so with the Zeniths ). The Eminence Beta 12LTA is a fine sounding HE wide band speaker but it played second fiddle to the Zeniths. I sold them to a friend in town who loves them. He also has my Tang Bands as well.

My OB full range driver journey so far:

Started with the Betsy's and they were impressive but sold them to another AK member who so far has done nothing with them. Should have probably kept them as they were lots of fun but less refined than the TB's. Loved the Tang Band W8-1808 for several years but sold them when I got a great deal on a pair of Lowther DX3's which are my Sunday drivers. Enjoyed the Eminence Beta 12LTA with phase plugs for a few years but sold them once I discovered the Zeniths, my daily go to drivers.
 
Poultry, your lowthers... how do they compare to the zenith? I would imagine they are detail monsters. Have you had any issues with their "shout" that everyone seems to say they have? Are they fatiguing?
 
This is what you need to pair with the Zeniths for bass augmentation: The efficient and high Qts Eminence Alpha 15A is no doubt the most popular OB woofer. They're priced around $59 and fill in the bass that a full range driver struggles with. OB speakers companies like Emerald Physics, PureAudio. Spatial etc have used them. The much loved Augie from Hawthorne ( RIP ) is a modified 15A.

If you've got the room for it, I've had much better luck with the Goldwood GW-1858. A bit more expensive, but well worth it in my opinion...

Roscoe
290-386_HR_0.jpg
 
This is what you need to pair with the Zeniths for bass augmentation: The efficient and high Qts Eminence Alpha 15A is no doubt the most popular OB woofer. They're priced around $59 and fill in the bass that a full range driver struggles with. OB speakers companies like Emerald Physics, PureAudio. Spatial etc have used them. The much loved Augie from Hawthorne ( RIP ) is a modified 15A.

290-407_ALT_0.jpg

I have a pair of the Alpha 15 A's that are occasionally used in my first open baffle project. They are paired with 8" Saba green cones and little cone tweeters. I guess I could use the Alphas with the Zeniths and the Dayton DT 250 P-8 , in a three way open baffle setup. I wonder if the little Zenith could drive them all. Another thought would be to power the Alphas with a separate amp. I could use a little T amp I'm not using at the moment
Any suggestion on how low of a frequency to cross the Zeniths
 
Last edited:
Poultry, your lowthers... how do they compare to the zenith? I would imagine they are detail monsters. Have you had any issues with their "shout" that everyone seems to say they have? Are they fatiguing?

They are very different. The Lowther DX3's are detail freaks. They sound very lit up. Not as polite as the Tang Bands or the Zeniths. They play very high so a tweeter is definitely not needed. Once the company rolled the edges of their whizzers a few years ago shout was no longer an issue. As efficient as the Zeniths are the Lowthers are even more so. According to the website Lowther drivers were designed to be run full range without correction.

The Zeniths have fine detail but not to the level of the DX3. What the Zeniths have in spades is an absolutely beautiful tone. They're less fatiguing than the in-your-face Lowthers. I wouldn't listen to the Lowthers all day but I would with the Zeniths. As you might expect the 12" Zenith produce a larger sound stage and a grander sense of scale. They won't pin point image like the smaller driver but that's less of an issue with OB's where the sound comes from all over.

You better have good sources with the Lowthers as they are far less forgiving than the Zeniths. Revealing to a fault they are. For the record my Zeniths are mint and I say that as I removed them from a console that looked almost new.

Thinking about this post it's pretty crazy to be comparing $30 speakers to $1500 speakers ( mine used were half that ) but it goes to show how highly regarded the Zeniths are IMO.
 
I have a pair of the Alpha 15 A's that are occasionally used in my first open baffle project. They are paired with 8" Saba green cones and little cone tweeters. I guess I could use the Alphas with the Zeniths and the Dayton DT 250 P-8 , in a three way open baffle setup. I wonder if the little Zenith could drive them all. Another thought would be to power the Alphas with a separate amp. I could use a little T amp I'm not using at the moment
Any suggestion on how low of a frequency to cross the Zeniths

You should definitely bi-amp using a tube amp on the Zeniths. Your t-amp may be fine with the Alphas. I drive my Zeniths and tweeters full range with the Alphas set at 100hz and sometimes a bit more.
 
You should definitely bi-amp using a tube amp on the Zeniths. Your t-amp may be fine with the Alphas. I drive my Zeniths and tweeters full range with the Alphas set at 100hz and sometimes a bit more.[/QUOTE

Thanks for your help. Yes definitely tubes for the Zeniths. I think if I try the Alphas, I'll try to filter out the 100 HZ and below frequencies to the Zeniths. I might try different frequency test tones on the Zeniths to try to determine their best frequency range. I know the Alphas will play well over 100 hz but I want to emphasize the Zeniths.Then I can order some inductors.
This could be a fun Fall project.
 
Just placed my order for a pair of the Alpair 12s. I just couldn't resist. I read too many reports on them sounding excellent in OBs so I have to give them a go. I'm hoping I can get them before the weekend, I'd love to get them broken in. We will see.

300 posts. Moving on up in the world. :)
 
If you've got the room for it, I've had much better luck with the Goldwood GW-1858. A bit more expensive, but well worth it in my opinion...
I have not ordered my bass drivers to go with my 12LTAs. I plan to build H-Frames for whatever I get. For a 16 x 14 x 8 foot room, would you go with the 18" Goldwood's or the 15A's in that size room? I do plan to bi-amp.

Roscoe
290-386_HR_0.jpg
 
I have not ordered my bass drivers to go with my 12LTAs. I plan to build H-Frames for whatever I get. For a 16 x 14 x 8 foot room, would you go with the 18" Goldwood's or the 15A's in that size room? I do plan to bi-amp

It's not the size of the room that I was thinking about, rather the larger H-Frames you'll need for the 18" driver. I've never heard these on an H-Frame, but they worked quite well for me on a JEL style baffle in a 15x17 room with a high ceiling.

Roscoe
 
15a in our room (26x17x9 crossed @ 80 and there more bass than needed for our tastes. I keep it dialed down.
 
I've had my pair of Mark Audio Alpair 12ps delivered today. I am following the recommended break in recipe that Mark Audio has for their drivers. I know some don't believe in it and others go to extremes. Opinions be damned, I've decided to be safe and just do it the recommended way. This recipe calls for playing 100 hours of music that's not bass heavy (think easy listening station) at low volumes for 20 hours and gradually increasing to normal levels. So It looks like they'll be playing some of my favorite jazz and acoustic material for a while.

FIRST IMPRESSIONS:
They are gorgeous drivers. They look very delicate while at the same time have heft and weight that lets you know they are very solid and over built where they need to be. The spider is massive for a driver this size. You can really tell they work hard to make sure that each driver is built to the highest standard. They also come with a sweet rubber gasket to mount the driver to the baffle. I've been using a pair of alnico Philips drivers for a few months now and they are so light and flimsy compared to the beefy Alpairs. But they sound remarkable... So the competition is stiff.

Anyway, I have them sitting on a shelf hooked up to my DAC, laptop, and cheap little Nobsound TPA 3116 (Love this thing). Right off the bat, they were VERY harsh. Vocals were just nasty to the point of not really being able to make out the lyrics. My wife actually said "you paid how much for those?". I wasn't worried but still made that awkward laugh we make while we try to think of a way to justify our purchase to our spouse. ;)

We left the house to go to my son's soccer game and returned a few hours later.

I walked into my listening room and started the same song we heard when I first fired them up. Even after only having 3 hours of low volume on them they had smoothed out A LOT. voices weren't grating but now crystal clear and the highs were much more open. chalk it up to me wanting to hear it, but I think they really did clean up a lot. I raised the volume just a touch and really liked what I heard.

I'll be back to report after I can turn up the volume more and get the baffles built. I have a few ideas on my baffles that I want to try and I hope to get my H-Frames solidified with some bracing while these finish breaking in.

To summarize: So far so good.
 
I received a pair of these B&C DE35 tweeters on Friday. These are well reviewed quality tweets with neodymium magnets. It only took a few minutes to Install them in the Zenith 49CZ802 OB's and with alligator clips I sampled them using a variety of caps. While they sounded pretty good they did not out perform the Eminence ASD 1001 compression tweets nor did they integrate quite as well. I boxed them up and will be returning them to PE.

de35-3.jpg
 
I don't plan to try any more tweeters with the Zeniths and will stick with these ASD 1001's with the small wave guide. A 1.5 uF cap gives just the right amount of top end. I don't hear as much rear ambient sound from the ASD's like I did with the Realistics and B&C's but the accuracy of the high hats is spot on. Love how well they blend with the Zeniths and I think they look better.

219633.jpg
 
I don't plan to try any more tweeters with the Zeniths and will stick with these ASD 1001's with the small wave guide. A 1.5 uF cap gives just the right amount of top end. I don't hear as much rear ambient sound from the ASD's like I did with the Realistics and B&C's but the accuracy of the high hats is spot on. Love how well they blend with the Zeniths and I think they look better.

219633.jpg
This is good news. I am selling some old audio gear that I am not using to get the rest of what I need to pretty much copy what you have done, while still keeping in good standing with all the rest of the family who don't care about listening to music (except in the car or on ear buds with smartphone). I started with the idea of going with the ASD 1001, but was considering the B&C DE35. I was even considering the B&C DE400TN-8 after reading an article by Mark Wheeler at www.tnt-audio.com. The DE400 looks interesting, but is even more money.

Lately, I have been playing with a plastic pair of old Radio Shack super tweeters I bought for four bucks at The Goodwill. I used to have a pair of Fostex T90A's that I used to use with my Fostex sigma 208 based back loaded horns. After a number of years I decided that I could live without them. More exciting with them, but more relaxing over time without them. However, the 12 LTA's do need a tweeter more than the 208's. I am hopeful that the ASD 1001's will sound better than the plastic radio shack tweeters. I feel I can hear the 12 LTA's and the RS tweeters playing separately.

A friend wanted my T90A's and I traded them for a pair of Paul Speltz Zero Autoformers. Those can be connected to double, triple or quadruple the impedance that the amplifier sees. Thus, I think I could try using an F-mod in series with the bass driver and could connect all three drivers to my 45 SET amp on each side. Probably I would be best to bi-amp though? I could sell the autoformers. Having never had an active crossover, I wonder if I will be better off to power the 15A's with a Yung sd100, sd200, or to get the $80 Berhinger and use my Cary Rocket 88 to power the 15A's? BTW, I liked the sound of my Fostex 208 best when played by my 45 SET amp much more. But recently I tried compared the Rocket 88 and the 45 SET playing the 12 LTA's. I thought it was a closer match, and more a question of flavor than really liking one over. But, it has been on a shelf for a long time and is something else that I could sell to buy other things audio to play with. I want to try those bucket subs someday too, but not until everything else is done.
 
Back
Top Bottom