• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Nixxuz....I have no experience with the Dayton's you are ordering,but several years ago,I ordered a pair of Dayton 10 inch woofers,and was totally pleased with their performance and build quality...I'm almost certain you will be happy,but give them some time to loosen up.

I used mine for/ in an older Estate sale d.i.y Transmission line build,the Dayton's gave such a great Bass,however,I finally gave up trying to get a mid that worked,so the T-lines made a nice bonfire one night....Some projects are best Not passed on!
.
I'm sure with what you have,you can dial them in to your taste,any new drivers I've tried are for the most part Very good value for the money!
Please keep us updated how they work for you,remember some of the best reviews are ones we get from members on AK.

EP concert Kenny,tonight's concert Shadowland Edge of Night...
 
Scan.jpg Buy a pair of pre-owned Bozak Concert Grand or symphony panels. Cut out the appropriated size and stiffen the wall studs. Mount the baffles to the studs. Make your own frame with grill cloth. to protect the drivers. The room or closet on the back side of the speakers should be as large as possible to insure bass extension below 20 Hz for Concert Grands. You can remove the covers on the midranges if you want but I wouldn't recommend it. You would truly have infinite baffles where the speakers could move freely with out loading and you would n't have rear reflection that would compromise your bass response and cause anomalies in the rest of the spectrum. One couple used a linen closet behind the left speaker and a entry closet behind the right speaker. Another couple the speakers radiated into a two car garage and he added mids and tweeters to have stereo full range in the Garage. One gentle man mounted his symphony panels in one end of his screened in porch which he later glassed in with the speakers radiating into his tool shed where he kept his riding Lawn mower and other tools. Bozaks were designed to work their best unloaded with infinite baffles, and they did. They didn't have the humps in the bass response like their enclosured cousins do to room loading. . Even with 16 cu ft wasn't large enough in my opinion. Symphonies and 305's sounded best with the tweeters centered at ear height. I installed 515 Altec pairs with 311 90's and 288C drivers on sides of stages with backs opened and protected by double chicken wire on either sides of performance stages with the off stage curtains absorbing unwanted mids produced by the woofers. Other times the baffles would be over 100 cu ft. vented back stage. Very little loading that way, too. It was much better sound than an A7 or A2 box. Yes the woofer projection in the mids wasn't as good but the over all sound was better. I wonder if the system I installed in the Scottish rite temple in the 70's still have the 515b's the 803 and 203 B horns on either side of the stage. Wonder if the 2100 and two 250's are still there.
 
Last edited:
I currently am using a variation of the MJ King flat OB project. In my untreated (sadly won't happen) room, bass is slightly boomy. If I were to build an H-frame, would this be an improvement? I realize as stated by MJ King, I would be giving up some sensitivity but achieving lower frequency response. Worth the effort or not? What I would be hoping for is less boomy bass. Attached is a pic of current version. No measuring capability and probably no chance of room treatment. Thanks.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0498.JPG
    IMG_0498.JPG
    105.9 KB · Views: 26
Last edited:
twiii,awhile back, I owned a pr of Bozak 12 in Coaxials,the cabs baffle board had a marked cutout for adding future 6 in mid....They were assembled c/w components,in Canada by some forgotten Furniture Co.,were Beautiful,big cubes,and up on low stands,tilted back sounded great with my Fisher tube Integrated,till the Fisher got taken out by a Racoon cross phasing himself in a storm/hydro re-closure,so sold Bozaks.

There was a site called hi-fi-lit,that had pictures of Concert Grand's,but as far as I know I've never ever spotted a pair in Canada,Super rare here & very pricey back in their day, like Jensen Imperials,I keep looking,stuff occasionally turns up,was flabbergasted yesterday when I was gifted 4-Burhoe Blues by a former co-worker,they're very rare too,only saw one set on Canuck a few years back,in fact I'm thoroughly enjoying Listening to 2 of them now,and even considering double stacking the four(?)....Never Underestimate a Vintage speaker,the Blues's are Crazy-rocking some Boogie-Woogie Piano,man,these are sounding Exceptionally Nice,especially on this Van Morrison Live at Montreux concert.

Of course they'll need a re-cap,and I'm thinking these could well end up being my vinyl speakers..Crazy what Canadians have Squirreled away in their basements!

I read a thread on AVS Forum,about somebody mounting 18 in subs in a closet,similar to what you mentioned about Bozaks between the studs..I bet those folks,really enjoyed their Music!

I remember,as a mid teen,getting into playing drums,a good friends older brother,an Electrician,had a similar(Bozaks in walls) system set up in 1/2 the basement(his bedroom).
I looked behind walls once,and saw he had build one wall like 3 ft out from the concrete all across the whole width of the room/house,with a top all the way across.Wood was cheap back then..

He ran,4-15's(likley JBL) vertically placed/mounted securely into a solid hardwood reinforced/braced door that was the entrance to their cold storage under their front porch.
...And Horizontally out from there were several 12's on each side,of the door &smaller speakers outboard of them,a sideways Wall of Sound.It worked.

...His younger Brother my friend was allowed to use it with permission,but only till 7'oclock' on the Master Volume.

It was certainly different when his older Brother was Home,he 'Rocked the Casba',we loved it,and as he was a Huge Elvis/Music fan,and he invited us over to hear the first drop on every new record!

..He had totally rewired the House panel,and had diy transformers/amps plus I remember seeing glowing tubes.

I still,distinctly remember him telling us......What ever you do....'Don't go in that corner,or you'll get Electrocuted'!!!!!,holy S**t........ahhhhhh....lucky we Listened back then,those were the days,ha,ha....

When it got too loud for his Dad upstairs he would pound his foot on the floor,too funny....the Brother would drop the volume down abruptly,and spend the next hour creeping it back up..11 o'clock was my favorite Volume
.
I remember nearly getting pasted against the door,when we both walked in UN-expectedly,right when he dropped the needle on some Do-wop,Sha Na na/Rock a Billy comes to mind.

..I thought about trying it once,but decided against it after I quickly became the scourge of my family when I was restoring/playing around flipping/auditioning Drum sets.

I don't know about you guys in Texas,but if I lived there, I'd be hauling ass down to the Scottish Rite Temple,see if any of those old drivers are still there and for sale?
EP 4.8 Concert Kenny....Tonight's Concert Van Morrison Live at Montreux 1980/1974
.
 
Last edited:
I currently am using a variation of the MJ King flat OB project. In my untreated (sadly won't happen) room, bass is slightly boomy. If I were to build an H-frame, would this be an improvement? I realize as stated by MJ King, I would be giving up some sensitivity but achieving lower frequency response. Worth the effort or not? What I would be hoping for is less boomy bass. Attached is a pic of current version. No measuring capability and probably no chance of room treatment. Thanks.

Adding and H frame to this design will produce significantly deeper bass. You can experimenter by adding a cardboard tube 7.5" deep to both the front and back of the baffle. This could be as simple as a strip of thin cardboard fitted around the driver frame in front and inside the baffle hole in back and then taped in place. Simple, quick, and an easily reversible change to see if it helps with your slight booming problem. With the Fostex FF85WK full range driver having the bass drop 1 to 2 dB will also help re-balance the sound if the bass is a little overwhelming.

My suspicion is that either your room is responding or you amp is adding some series resistance, the design itself should not produce an overly resonant bass response. If you are using a tube amp I would strongly urge you to try a SS amp, it will produce a dryer bass sound which might help in your room.
 
Adding and H frame to this design will produce significantly deeper bass. You can experimenter by adding a cardboard tube 7.5" deep to both the front and back of the baffle. This could be as simple as a strip of thin cardboard fitted around the driver frame in front and inside the baffle hole in back and then taped in place. Simple, quick, and an easily reversible change to see if it helps with your slight booming problem. With the Fostex FF85WK full range driver having the bass drop 1 to 2 dB will also help re-balance the sound if the bass is a little overwhelming.

My suspicion is that either your room is responding or you amp is adding some series resistance, the design itself should not produce an overly resonant bass response. If you are using a tube amp I would strongly urge you to try a SS amp, it will produce a dryer bass sound which might help in your room.
Thanks so much for your response and suggestions. I will give that a try. I am using a SS amp like you suggested on your website. Thanks again for a well thought out and documented contribution to the DIY community.
 
I have not read all 144 pages of this thread but .....

Have not seen mention of Audio Nirvana drivers/designs

Not well thought of?

I had some Classic 8s but hadn't discovered open baffle and ended up selling the Classic 8s before going to OBs. I wish I still had a pair to try now. I still might some day.

They are very good full range speakers and I think some people are using them... or have some experience to share.

Check out ebay... you might be able to score a used pair for a good price.
 
Well after a very short run in, I'm very impressed with the Dayton PS220-8's, for the price. It could be that it's just going to take some getting used to either FR speakers, OB's, or a combination of the 2, but they were indeed kind of "shouty" at first. Looking at the FR measurements, I decided to EQ the 500hz-1khz down around 2-3dB and that helped a LOT. If you love your mids, these drivers excel in that arena. The highs are quite nice. You kind of know there isn't a true tweeter going on, but it's far less of a sticking point than I had first assumed. What I assume OB lovers are getting at is indeed a sort of "airyness" or presence that I think comes from the dipole natuer of getting that reflected sound. Even being point source, these drivers are no more or less forgiving when it comes to placement than my Jamo C-109 towers. They obviously lack in the midbass department, as I assumed they would. Anyone telling you these speakers perform to their stated Fs of 47hz is being ridiculous. About 100hz is where I am crossing over my sub as they just sound REALLY thin at those frequencies, which is fine for me, but I assume anyone getting into this is going to know a decent EQ and additional drivers capable of authority under 70hz or so are a must. The tonality of these are quite nice. I have heard they require a significant burn in time, and I can only assume 10-20 hours should be the norm.

Are they beating out my 109's? Of course not. Not considering they cost 10 times less including baffles. But are they actually keeping up? Honestly, yes! I knew DIY gives you more for your money, but with a tiny bit of elbow grease and a decent sub, I honestly can't see why, at least as far as sound goes, a person would look to some of the budget brands out there. Not when you can get this sort of performance for much less. Obviously the finish isn't going to be nearly as nice, unless you have the time and skills for that sort of thing. But it's not an issue for me. No WAF in my music dungeon.

In short, if you're into the FR OB sound and have an EQ and a decent subwoofer, or the equivalent, these drivers are a treat for right around $200 a pair.
 
Well after a very short run in, I'm very impressed with the Dayton PS220-8's, for the price. It could be that it's just going to take some getting used to either FR speakers, OB's, or a combination of the 2, but they were indeed kind of "shouty" at first. Looking at the FR measurements, I decided to EQ the 500hz-1khz down around 2-3dB and that helped a LOT. If you love your mids, these drivers excel in that arena. The highs are quite nice. You kind of know there isn't a true tweeter going on, but it's far less of a sticking point than I had first assumed. What I assume OB lovers are getting at is indeed a sort of "airyness" or presence that I think comes from the dipole natuer of getting that reflected sound. Even being point source, these drivers are no more or less forgiving when it comes to placement than my Jamo C-109 towers. They obviously lack in the midbass department, as I assumed they would. Anyone telling you these speakers perform to their stated Fs of 47hz is being ridiculous. About 100hz is where I am crossing over my sub as they just sound REALLY thin at those frequencies, which is fine for me, but I assume anyone getting into this is going to know a decent EQ and additional drivers capable of authority under 70hz or so are a must. The tonality of these are quite nice. I have heard they require a significant burn in time, and I can only assume 10-20 hours should be the norm.

Are they beating out my 109's? Of course not. Not considering they cost 10 times less including baffles. But are they actually keeping up? Honestly, yes! I knew DIY gives you more for your money, but with a tiny bit of elbow grease and a decent sub, I honestly can't see why, at least as far as sound goes, a person would look to some of the budget brands out there. Not when you can get this sort of performance for much less. Obviously the finish isn't going to be nearly as nice, unless you have the time and skills for that sort of thing. But it's not an issue for me. No WAF in my music dungeon.

In short, if you're into the FR OB sound and have an EQ and a decent subwoofer, or the equivalent, these drivers are a treat for right around $200 a pair.


Pictures?
 
Pictures?
Not quite yet. I only rigged the baffles to get a sense of the sound when listening to them as, roughly, intended. I let them play just sitting free on their backs for about 3-4 hours last night, just to flex a little bit. I'm sure the sound will change further yet, when I have them properly positioned and toed in to my liking.

Edit: Oh fine, but remember! These are just mock ups! I fully intend to get some really good baffles built when I have more time and money. And when I'm not trapped in a full basement with no decent working area! And yes, they will have a base. And yes, they will replace the Jamos in the same position.

20190301_222529.jpg
20190301_222646.jpg
 
Last edited:
i've had good experiences w AN drivers. used 12" drivers in vintage cabinets for a long time. then used them as "bass bins" (actually crossed at 3,000hz) with horns -- that sounded really nice. then stumbled on Altec 604s so the ANs are boxed up right now. also have 8" that i've used in a bass-assisted OB. using visaton b200s in that set-up right now but plan to dig out the ANs to see how the whizzer cone sound compares.
 
Not quite yet. I only rigged the baffles to get a sense of the sound when listening to them as, roughly, intended. I let them play just sitting free on their backs for about 3-4 hours last night, just to flex a little bit. I'm sure the sound will change further yet, when I have them properly positioned and toed in to my liking.

Edit: Oh fine, but remember! These are just mock ups! I fully intend to get some really good baffles built when I have more time and money. And when I'm not trapped in a full basement with no decent working area! And yes, they will have a base. And yes, they will replace the Jamos in the same position.

View attachment 1436432
View attachment 1436434

Do you plan to add OB woofers?
 
Man that's certainly a sweet looking driver,Wow,there is a lot of reasonably priced drivers out there,looks like Great Value for the Money,and you can make it work for you!....Have Fun,take your time,Looking Good!......Enjoy the break in......I like to Listen to them break in,its amazing when they start to open up!

EP Concert Kenny,tonight's concert :Joe Cocker Live.........Across from Midnight Tour......an oldie but goodie!
 
Back
Top Bottom