• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Man that's certainly a sweet looking driver,Wow,there is a lot of reasonably priced drivers out there,looks like Great Value for the Money,and you can make it work for you!....Have Fun,take your time,Looking Good!......Enjoy the break in......I like to Listen to them break in,its amazing when they start to open up!

EP Concert Kenny,tonight's concert :Joe Cocker Live.........Across from Midnight Tour......an oldie but goodie!
They certainly surprised me for the price! They absolutely need a sub or some woofers to fill in the low end, but I'm almost pissed at the fact that $250 wort of drivers and plywood can roughly equal the sound of my $3200 80lb. Jamo towers. And the Jamos are no slouches.
 
These are awesome but cost a few $$.View attachment 1440562
Yeah, I'm not sure I am in a position to be looking at $1000 worth of drivers just yet. Thinking about a couple of these;
https://www.parts-express.com/dayto...h_zzXcIN8PzEFU0lDzepCZKTGtVNH8LBQRI7xTr8owlRw
I already have one Skar EVL18 D2, but 2 of the Daytons are cheaper than another single Skar, and much more efficient. I could conceivably run the whole thing with the 40wpc of my Yaqin MC13S amp. I used a crossover rcalculator and it seems I only need a pair of 10.6mH inductors to limit the 18"s to 120hz? Forgive the ignorance, as I have no idea what I am doing when it comes to building crossovers, hence one of the reasons for going FR.
Edit; Now I'm actually looking at these instead for cheaper...
https://www.parts-express.com/b-52-18-180l-18-cast-frame-professional-subwoofer-8-ohm--299-2300
 
Last edited:
I would look for woofers with higher Qts like the Eminence Alpha 15a.
Advice heeded. Now about that crossover... can I use a couple of single inductors to keep them below 120hz? What's that going to do to the efficiency?

Or...yeah I'll just do what this guy did. It's practically the same thing anyway.
BAA8D15EA0A912DAC0BF7D05AC37721D.app1_1488508750744_L1800.jpeg
 
Advice heeded. Now about that crossover... can I use a couple of single inductors to keep them below 120hz? What's that going to do to the efficiency?

Or...yeah I'll just do what this guy did. It's practically the same thing anyway.

My experience is that the H-frame subwoofers do bass a lot better than a flat baffle. I mounted four (two per side) Alpha 15a’s on a flat baffle that was 24” wide and that configuration was not able to produce the deep and satisfying bass I was able to get with a pair of 15a’s in h-frames and at roughly 18” wide the H-frames were less imposing and cumbersome. Granted, it doesn’t get much cheaper or easier than cutting a hole in a piece of plywood, but the H-frame is very easy and inexpensive to construct. Using an active crossover (Ashly, Rane, Behringer, etc) or inexpensive plate amp from PE works great for tailoring xover point. With an active xover you can create a low cut for the full range driver that integrates seamlesless with the high cut of the subwoofer if you find the H-frame does mid bass better than the Dayton driver...which I think you will.
 
Last edited:
I think I'm just going to slap an inductor on the Alpha's and run full signal to the Dayton's. There is no scenario where I would be running enough wattage to the Dayton's to get them to distort badly. My sealed sub will handle the under 70hz, Alpha's for the 60-ish-120hz, and the Daytons everything else. I honestly have no other possible place to use these than my main system, so the sub is going to be there anyway. If I get adventurous the H-frames won't be hard to integrate into existing design. And yeah, the Dayton's do NOTHING for mid bass IMO. The drop from 100hz is so steep I have no idea why PE put out specs listing 40hz. I know that's with an enclosure, but it would have to be tuned like crazy and still be extremely weak that far down.
 
Ordered some 9.0mH inductors and the Alpha 15A's. Now the long process of cutting, gluing, veneering, staining, poly'ing, drilling, mounting, bracing, and breaking in, my new OB's.
 
So, no photos for a while yet, but running the PS220's with the Eminence Alpha 15A's, with the 9.0mH ferrite core inductors between the 15A's and the FR's. Running both drivers in parallel off my 4 ohm taps. The Eminence really filled in the area that was lacking in the 40-250hz range. Since ordering though, I do notice the dropoff for the PS220's seems closer to 300hz than the 150hz I had thought. Might have to either pull the core on the inductor and reduce the mH, or get a set of lower mH inductors. But, even without the baffle being completed...(The {S220's are in a 12"x48" baffle. I just propped the Alpha's up in front of them and clipped the inductors in the path.) They sound VERY good. I honestly can't believe that I could get sound this good out of around $400 in drivers and materials. I had a friend come over and hear just the PS220's and my sub filling in the low end.
He didn't say "Wow, they sound good."
He got a strange ratlike look on his face and asked me; "What brand of speakers are those again?"
 
So I'm gonna repost this from the DIY forum since I was told it might get more traction here.
"So as you might know, I built a very simple set of OB FR speakers. The driver used was the Dayton PS220-8. The mounting was a simple piece of faced plywood. I have an EQ and it's got an active crossover and sub out.
I ran the PS220's with my Yaqin MC13S amp. The EQ splits off the signal to the sub out and I have the crossover for the low pass set to around 100hz. Obviously this mean that the sub is getting 100hz and below, but the PS220's are getting the full signal.
I just received 2 Eminence Alpha 15A, per Poultrygeist's recommendation, to integrate with a new set of panels. The wiring for that is super simple. I run from the amp to the PS220's, and then run parallel to the Alpha. with a 9.0mH inductor in the positive path to the Alpha, limiting it's FR down to around 150hz @ -6dB. Shallow slope, but it seems to work really well.
Now, I've been discussing the process with a fellow enthusiast who owns the PS220's as well, but has not used them in this manner. I did state that the PS220 lacks a slight bit at the tippy top end, as I imagine almost all FR drivers do. This isn't even something I thought I'd notice, but there it is. Perhaps it's actually because I AM doing critical listening, that I notice it.
In any case, I have been discussing with him the possibility of adding a tweeter of some kind, just something to light up that last bit of sparkle. We discussed a few different contenders, but I was most interested in the HiVi RT2C planar tweeter;
https://www.parts-express.com/hivi-rt2c-a-planar-isodynamic-tweeter--297-406
The way my system is set up would alleviate the problems caused by what some have labeled a narrow horizontal field. It's One recliner set in "the triangle". It's meant for one person to really LISTEN to music. So there are no off axis worries.
I was perusing eBay while at work, (group home overnights, lots of downtime), and found a pair for a very good price. In casual conversation I mentioned that if they were still up for sale when I get paid in a couple weeks, (group home overnights, terrible pay), I'd be picking them up to give a 3 way design a whirl.
I apparently did not understand his enthusiasm for my experimentation, as he immediately offered to purchase them for me "in the interest of an affordable high quality design". His only requirement is I document the build for others.
I accepted. $160 worth of free planar drivers is nothing to sneeze at.

So now my conundrum. I know the values of the caps I need for the high pass to the HiVi planars. I have the inductors for the low pass to the Alphas. I want as much of the full range to go to the PS220's.
What I don't know is how to wire this whole mess for either a 4 or 8 ohm total load, (both have taps on my Yaqin).
My first instinct was to just go Alpha/PS220 parallel, and then to the RT2C serial. But I have been told this is bad for REASONS.

So what now? there are, in fact, 3 way speakers. I SEE'D EM'! How do I make mine do the thing?"

Since then, I have ordered an 8 ohm dummy load transistor. My engineering friend says this is sub-optimal, and I'm aware it just "wastes" 25% of my amps output. But I can't really afford another pair of drivers, at this time, and want to see how the design works with the HiVi in place. If I like it, I'm going to have to get different baffles cut and go with either 2 more 15", (which honestly aren't even needed), or 2 more 220's, (same situation), or 2 more HiVi's, (well, you get the picture). I could run the whole thing as a 12 ohm load, but it seems like that's going to put me in roughly the same situation as adding the resistor?

Anyway, any help would be appreciated.
 
I'm having trouble following this and maybe I'm answering a question you didn't ask but.

If you run tweeters with a cap off the Daytons from the same amp I'd look for a tweeter with higher sensitivity. In that situation you can pad a tweeter down but you can't increase it's efficiency and make it play louder to match the Daytons
 
I've got it covered now. I'm going with the resistor for now, and I'll entertain the thought of another set of Alpha's when funds permit. I've also gotten the opinion that, perhaps instead, a rear firing RT2C added would be more beneficial.
The RT2C tweeter is 94dB efficient vs the PS220 being 96.5, buuuuut, we all know that what the manufacturer lists as a spec, and what the actual spec translates to in real world situations, can be VERY different. The tweeter is from HiVi and the FR from Parts Express, so it honestly depends on their testing methodology. PE shows the FR graph for the PS220 doing VERY different things than what is being presented in my build and room. According to specs, the Alpha 15A's should be completely blotting out the PS220's with their 99dB efficiency, but in the real world, they are not. If an L-pad becomes needed down the road, I'll look into it then.
What I'm trying for, as of right now, is a pair of 3 way OB's with a lot of overlap between the tweeter and the FR. The tweeters aren't even really necessary, but I'm looking for the slight "sizzle" on the top end. And it's going to be a simple cap on the FR for 200hz and over, and another cap on the tweeter for around 4khz and up. Only first order, and only -6dB. I'm not looking at the overlap from an engineering viewpoint. While I respect Toole and Olive as much as anyone, I think their work provides a baseline, more than an a hard and fast rule, about how speakers should sound, and what sort of overlap is either beneficial, or unpleasant. This is in NO WAY, me going for a neutral or flat FR. I'm more in the Fletcher-Munson camp when it comes to desired FR. And this could all be down to my room modes as well. Hell, my floor is concrete, so I'm working against an almost totally non-transmitting surface in that respect.
Well now I'm rambling, so I'll just stop and build my damn crossovers.
 
Last edited:
First order components in...and WOW. For a little over $500 for the pair, these are AMAZING. I'm getting full strong bass down to 40hz with just one pair of Alpha's baffle mounted. The HiVi RT2C tweeters bring that top end sparkle that is supposed to smooth out over time, but I enjoy, and the PS220's are calmed a LOT in the "shouty" 1.5khz range as they are mounted lower than ear level. All in all, probably the best speakers I have heard so far.
Edit: I actually just wired them to 6 ohms per baffle. That's what my Jamo's were, and these seem to work fine at that impedance. But they are a LOT louder.
 
Last edited:
I have Zenith 49CZ903's in open baffles. Best speakers I've ever owned.

I joined the 49CZ club with a console I found locally. I paid about double what @Poultrygeist did, but I figure the transformer will be useful on future projects and the 5U4GB looks to be in good shape (will test it later after I get my tube tester working again)

I wasn't expecting much because I've tried RCA console 12"ers and Magnavox 12"ers and neither one impressed. These are the closed magnet type 49CZ860 & 49CZ861 (pics later). I cut the baffle from the console down the middle and have them sitting on the floor about 24" high. Bass is augmented with a pair of Cambridge Sound Works PSW-1 acoustic suspension subs. One in each corner, crossed at 140Hz (as high as they go....just a guess that the Z's don't put out much below 200??)

They sounded very hot upon first audition and I thought, "well, maybe they don't have the 852 / 802 magic" but maybe they just needed to loosen up. The next day, I realized that they had extreme detail and they seemed to smooth out a bit. The sensitivity is the notable thing about these to my ears. Yes, they disappear and have a tall sound stage and vocals hang in mid air between the speakers.....but I can hear jazz musicians breathing...even MOREso than on my horns. They sure seem to perform best on music from "their" era, like Louis Armstrong, Julie London, Chet Baker. Stuff that was recorded on tube gear maybe?

Like others have said, I don't feel any need for a tweeter at this point. I like the purity of a single driver, no XO in OB. Been wanting to test this for some time.
Not sure if I'm getting the "non-boxy" sensation yet, but I don't have a nice open area cleared for them and haven't allowed my brain to adjust to the sound yet. Still some experimentation to do.

Lastly, these things have been estimated to be 97dB sensitive....IMHO, I think more like 100. I say that because my Zen clone has a bit of a buzz that is easily ignored on my 95dB 3Pi's but can be annoying on the Zeniths. To quote another AK'er; " a gentle breeze will make music on these things". True.
 
Back
Top Bottom